The Pinkertons

The Pinkertons, also known as the Pinkerton National Detective Agency, are a major group of antagonists led by Agent Andrew Milton in Red Dead Redemption II.

They are based off of the real life detective agency of the same name.

Victims

Chapter One: Colter

Outlaws From the West

• Mac Callander - Bled to death after being shot by Agent Andrew Milton during the Blackwater Massacre off-screen, body shown.
  • Total - 1

Chapter Four: Saint Denis

Banking, The Old American Art

• Hosea Matthews - Shot in the chest by Agent Andrew Milton. (Cutscene)
• Leonard "Lenny" Summers - Shot to death by two unnamed Pinkerton agents.
  • Total - 2

Chapter Six: Beaver Hollow

Red Dead Redemption

• Arthur Morgan's Horse - Shot to death by several Pinkerton agents.
• John Marston's Horse - Shot to death by several Pinkerton agents.
  • Total - 2

Epilogue - Part 2

Bare Knuckle Friendships

• Leopold Strauss - Tortured to death by Pinkerton agents off-screen, mentioned.
  • Total - 1

Kill Count

Agency Kill Count

• Total - 6
  • 4 Humans
    • All Male
  • 2 Animals
    • All Horses

Character Kill Counts

1. Agent Andrew Milton - 2 (Deceased)

Deaths

Chapter Four: Saint Denis

Banking, The Old American Art

• 35 Unnamed Pinkerton Agents - Shot by either Arthur, John, Dutch, Bill, Lenny, Javier, Charles, or Micah. Shared kills. (Bank)
• Two Unnamed Pinkerton Agents - Shot to death by Arthur Morgan for killing Lenny. (Rooftops)
  • Total - 37

Chapter Five: Guarma

Dear Uncle Tacitus

• Agent Bunter - Shot to death by Arthur Morgan, optional.
• Agent Johns - Shot to death by Arthur Morgan, optional.
• Agent Orly - Shot to death by Arthur Morgan, optional.
• Unnamed Pinkerton Agent - Shot to death by Arthur Morgan, optional.
  • Total - 4

Fleeting Joy

• 33 Unnamed Pinkerton Agents - Shot by either Arthur, Sadie, Dutch, Javier, Bill, Micah, or Charles. Shared kills.
• Unnamed Pinkerton Agent - Stabbed in the neck by Micah Bell to prevent him from revealing he's a rat. (Cutscene)
  • Total - 34

Chapter Six: Beaver Hollow

Just a Social Call

• 15 Unnamed Pinkerton Agents - Shot by either Arthur or Dutch. Shared kills.
• Unnamed Pinkerton Agent - Thrown over the side of a staircase by Micah Bell.
• 23 Unnamed Pinkerton Agents - Shot by either Arthur, Dutch, or Micah. Shared kills. (Coal Building)
• 11 Unnamed Pinkerton Agents - Shot by either Arthur, Dutch, or Micah. Shared kills. (Chase)
  • Total - 50

Red Dead Redemption

• Agent Andrew Milton - Shot in the head by Abigail Marston. (Cutscene)
• Seven Unnamed Pinkerton Agents - Shot by either Arthur or Sadie. Shared kills. (Van Horn)
• 19 Unnamed Pinkerton Agents - Shot to death by Arthur Morgan to save Sadie and Abigail. (Van Horn)
• Six Unnamed Pinkerton Agents - Shot by either Arthur or Sadie after saving Abigail. Shared kills. (Van Horn)
• Nine Unnamed Pinkerton Agents - Shot to death by Arthur Morgan to defend Sadie and Abigail. (Chase)
• At Least 18 Unnamed Pinkerton Agents - Shot by either Arthur or John. Shared kills. (Camp)
• 14 Unnamed Pinkerton Agents - Shot by either Arthur or John. Shared kills. (Chase #2)
• 14 Unnamed Pinkerton Agents - Shot to death by Arthur Morgan. (Get The Money)
  • Total - 87

Death Count

Agency Death Count

• Total - 212

Character Kill Counts

1. Arthur Morgan - 212 (Deceased)
2. Dutch Van der Linde - 117 (Deceased)
3. Micah Bell - 104 (Deceased)
4. John Marston - 81 (Deceased)
5. Charles Smith - 68 (Alive)
6. Bill Williamson - 68 (Deceased)
7. Javier Escuela - 68 (Deceased)
8. Sadie Adler - 46 (Alive)
9. Leonard "Lenny" Summers - 35 (Deceased)
10. Abigail Marston - 1 (Deceased)