List of Deaths Wiki
List of Deaths Wiki
List of Deaths Wiki
15,420
pages
in: Video Games, Western, Action,
and 31 more

Red Dead Redemption II

View source
RDR2 poster

Red Dead Redemption II is a western action-adventure video game created by Rockstar, serving as a prequel to Red Dead Redemption and an interquel to Red Dead Revolver. It is the second game in the Rockstar Universe and the third game in the Red Dead Series.

The game stars Arthur Morgan coming to terms with the consequences of being an outlaw, the collapse of the Van der Linde Gang, and the rise of John Marston and his family.

This list includes all 124 main story missions, 27 side quests, 14 companion activities, 12 Bounty Hunts, 90 challenges, 50 points of interest, 240 random encounters, 14 newspapers, three homesteads, 16 graveyards, 22 camp item requests, three store robberies, nine gang hideouts, 21 documents, 34 single player achievements, 15 Easter Eggs, and deaths only revealed through dialogue.

Victims

Main Story Missions

Chapter One: Colter

Outlaws From the West
Named Characters
  • Jenny Kirk - Shot to death by an unknown person during the Blackwater Massacre off-screen, mentioned.
  • Davey Callander - Shot to death by an unknown person during the Blackwater Massacre off-screen, body shown.
  • Mac Callander - Bled to death after being shot by Agent Andrew Milton during the Blackwater Massacre off-screen, body shown.
  • Jake Adler - Murdered by Billy, Declan, Tom, and several other O'Driscoll gang members off-screen, body shown.
  • Billy (O'Driscoll) - Shot to death by Arthur Morgan, Dutch Van der Linde, and Micah Bell III. Shared kill.
  • Declan (O'Driscoll) - Shot to death by Arthur Morgan, Dutch Van der Linde, and Micah Bell III. Shared kill.
    • Total - 6
Enemies
  • Seven Unnamed O'Driscoll Gang Members - Shot to death by Arthur Morgan, Dutch Van der Linde, and Micah Bell III. Shared kills.
  • Unnamed O'Driscoll Gang Member - Strangled to death by Arthur Morgan after interrogating him, optional.
    • Total - 8
Animals
  • Three O'Driscoll Horses - Shot to death by Arthur Morgan, optional.
    • Total - 3
Overall
  • Total - 17
    • 14 Humans
      • 13 Men
      • 1 Woman
    • 3 Animals
      • 3 Horses
Enter, Pursued by a Memory
Animals
  • Three Crows - Shot to death by Arthur Morgan, optional.
  • Three Wolves - Shot to death by Arthur Morgan to defend John Marston and Javier Escuella.
  • Four Wolves - Shot to death by either Arthur Morgan or Javier Escuella. Shared kills.
  • John Marston's Horse - Mauled and then eaten by wolves off-screen, body shown.
    • Total - 11
Other
  • Unknown Man - Bit by a dog and died of an infection off-screen, mentioned.
    • Total - 1
Overall
  • Total - 12
    • 11 Animals
      • 7 Wolves
      • 3 Birds
      • 1 Horse
    • 1 Human
      • 1 Man
Old Friends
Named Characters
  • Annabelle - Murdered by Colm O'Driscoll off-screen, mentioned.
    • Total - 1
Enemies
  • 16 Unnamed O'Driscoll Gang Members - Shot to death by either Arthur Morgan, Dutch Van der Linde, Lenny Summers, Javier Escuella, Bill Williamson, or Micah Bell III. Shared kills. (First Wave)
  • 13 Unnamed O'Driscoll Gang Members - Shot to death by either Arthur Morgan, Dutch Van der Linde, Lenny Summers, Javier Escuella, Bill Williamson, or Micah Bell III. Shared kills. (Second Wave)
    • Total - 29
Animals
  • Three O'Driscoll Horses - Shot to death by Arthur Morgan, optional.
    • Total - 3
Other
  • Colm O'Driscoll's Brother - Murdered by Dutch Van der Linde off-screen, mentioned.
    • Total - 1
Overall
  • Total - 34
    • 31 Humans
      • 30 Men
      • 1 Woman
    • 3 Animals
      • 3 Horses
The Aftermath of Genesis
Animals
  • Rabbit - Killed by Simon Pearson off-screen, mentioned.
  • Two Deer - Shot to death by Arthur Morgan with a bow and arrows.
  • Deer - Shot by Arthur Morgan with a bow and arrows, optional.
    • Total - 4
Overall
  • Total - 4
    • 4 Animals
      • 3 Deer
      • 1 Rabbit
Who The Hell Is Leviticus Cornwall?
Enemies
  • Unnamed Cornwall Guard - Stabbed in the neck by Lenny Summers.
  • Seven Unnamed Cornwall Guards - Shot to death by either Arthur Morgan or Lenny Summers to stop the train. Shared kills.
  • Unnamed Cornwall Guard - Either shot to death by Arthur Morgan to save Lenny Summers or thrown over the side of the train tracks by Arthur to fall to his death.
  • 18 Unnamed Cornwall Guards - Shot to death by either Arthur Morgan, Dutch Van der Linde, Bill Williamson, Lenny Summers, Micah Bell III, Javier Escuella, or Charles Smith after the train is stopped. Shared kills.
  • Three Unnamed Cornwall Employees - Shot to death by Arthur Morgan, optional.
    • Total - 30
Overall
  • Total - 30
    • 30 Humans
      • 30 Men
Eastward Bound
Other
  • Charles Smith's Mother - Killed by several United States soldiers off-screen, mentioned. (Debatable)
    • Total - 1
Overall
  • Total - 1 (1 Debatable)
    • 1 Human
      • 1 Woman

Chapter Two: Horseshoe Overlook

Polite Society, Valentine Style
Named Characters
  • Jimmy Brooks - Either fell to his death from a cliff after eventually slipping or after his hand was stomped on by Arthur Morgan, optional.
    • Total - 1
Animals
  • Horse - Shot to death by Arthur Morgan, optional.
    • Total - 1
Other
  • Unnamed Man - Beaten to death by Arthur Morgan for assaulting Karen Jones, optional.
  • Unnamed Man - Shot to death by Arthur Morgan after returning his horse, optional.
    • Total - 2
Overall
  • Total - 4
    • 3 Humans
      • 3 Men
    • 1 Animal
      • 1 Horse
Americans at Rest
Other
  • Nine Unnamed Men - Beaten to death by Arthur Morgan, Bill Williamson, Charles Smith, and Javier Escuella in a bar fight. Shared kills.
    • Total - 9
Overall
  • Total - 9
    • 9 Humans
      • 9 Men
Who is Not Without Sin
Animals
  • Eight Sheep - Shot to death by Arthur Morgan, optional.
    • Total - 8
Other
  • Unnamed Man - Killed by Arthur Morgan for beating up Reverend Swanson, optional.
  • Unnamed Sheepherder - Killed by Arthur Morgan to prevent reporting either an assault or murder, optional.
    • Total - 2
Overall
  • Total - 10
    • 8 Animals
      • 8 Sheep
    • 2 Humans
      • 2 Men
Exit, Pursued by a Bruised Ego
Named Characters
  • Bessie Matthews - Died of unspecified causes off-screen somewhere between 1883 and 1899, mentioned.
    • Total - 1
Animals
  • Boadicea (Horse) - Killed by an unknown person during the Blackwater Massacre off-screen, mentioned.
  • Rabbit - Shot to death by Arthur Morgan so he and Hosea Matthews could eat it.
  • Two Fish - Eaten by the legendary bear off-screen, remains shown.
  • Legendary Bear - Shot and stabbed to death by Arthur Morgan, optional.
    • Total - 5
Other
  • Unnamed Man - Killed by Hosea Matthews for his horse off-screen, mentioned.
    • Total - 1
Overall
  • Total - 7
    • 5 Animals
      • 2 Fish
      • 1 Horse
      • 1 Rabbit
      • 1 Bear
    • 2 Humans
      • 1 Man
      • 1 Woman
The First Shall Be Last
Enemies
  • Unnamed Ike Skelding's Boys Member - Stabbed in the neck by Arthur Morgan.
  • Unnamed Ike Skelding's Boys Member - Strangled to death by Javier Escuella.
  • 11 Unnamed Ike Skelding's Boys Members - Shot to death by either Arthur Morgan, Charles Smith, or Javier Escuella to rescue Sean MacGuire. Shared kills. (Canyon)
  • Two Unnamed Ike Skelding's Boys Members - Shot to death by either Arthur Morgan or Javier Escuella while rushing to help Charles Smith. Shared kills.
  • Unnamed Ike Skelding's Boys Member - Either stabbed to death by Charles Smith with a machete or shot to death by Arthur Morgan to save Charles. Shared kill.
  • Ten Unnamed Ike Skelding's Boys Members - Shot to death by either Arthur Morgan, Charles Smith, or Javier Escuella to rescue Sean MacGuire. Shared kills. (Camp)
    • Total - 26
Animals
  • Two Horses - Shot to death by Arthur Morgan, optional.
    • Total - 2
Overall
  • Total - 28
    • 26 Humans
      • 26 Men
    • 2 Animals
      • 2 Horses
Paying a Social Call
Enemies
  • Unnamed O'Driscoll Gang Member - Stabbed in the neck by either Arthur Morgan or Bill Williamson. Shared kill.
  • Two Unnamed O'Driscoll Gang Members - Either both stabbed to death by Arthur Morgan and Bill Williamson or stabbed with knives thrown by Arthur and Bill. Shared kills.
  • Unnamed O'Driscoll Gang Member - Stabbed in the neck by either Arthur Morgan or John Marston. Shared kill.
  • 14 Unnamed O'Driscoll Gang Members - Shot to death by either Arthur Morgan, John Marston, or Bill Williamson. Shared kills.
  • Unnamed O'Driscoll Gang Member - Shot in the stomach by Kieran Duffy to save Arthur Morgan. (Cut-Scene)
    • Total - 19
Other
  • Three Unnamed Women - Shot to death by Arthur Morgan, optional.
    • Total - 3
Overall
  • Total - 22
    • 22 Humans
      • 19 Men
      • 3 Women
A Quiet Time
Other
  • Two Unnamed O'Driscoll Gang Members - Killed by Micah Bell III off-screen in Strawberry, mentioned.
    • Total - 2
Overall
  • Total - 2
    • 2 Humans
      • 2 Men
Blessed are the Meek?
Named Characters
  • Sheriff Hanley - Shot to death by either Arthur Morgan or Micah Bell III. Shared kill.
  • Norman - Shot to death by Micah Bell III for stealing his dual revolvers.
  • Maddy - Shot to death by Micah Bell III off-camera, gun flash seen.
    • Total - 3
Enemies
  • 22 Unnamed Strawberry Lawmen - Shot to death by either Arthur Morgan or Micah Bell III. Shared kills. (Strawberry)
  • Eight Unnamed Strawberry Lawmen - Shot to death by either Arthur Morgan or Micah Bell III. Shared kills. (Chase)
    • Total - 30
Animals
  • Horse - Shot to death by Arthur Morgan, optional. (Strawberry)
  • Eight Horses - Shot to death by Arthur Morgan, optional. (Chase)
    • Total - 9
Other
  • Unnamed O'Driscoll Gang Member - Shot in the head by Micah Bell III. (Cut-Scene)
    • Total - 1
Overall
  • Total - 43
    • 34 Humans
      • 33 Men
      • 1 Woman
    • 9 Animals
      • 9 Horses
Good, Honest, Snake Oil
Animals
  • Benedict Allbright's Horse - Shot to death by Arthur Morgan, optional.
    • Total - 1
Other
  • At Least Three Unknown People - Killed by Benedict Allbright with his fake medicine off-screen, mentioned.
    • Total - 3
Overall
  • Total - 4
    • 3 Humans
      • 3 Victims of Unknown Gender
    • 1 Animal
      • 1 Horse
We Loved Once and True I
  • None
We Loved Once and True II
Named Characters
  • Barry Linton - Died of pneumonia off-screen, mentioned.
    • Total - 1
Overall
  • Total - 1
    • 1 Human
      • 1 Man
We Loved Once and True III
Animals
  • 11 Cows - Shot to death by Arthur Morgan, optional.
  • Two Wagon Horses - Shot to death by Arthur Morgan, optional.
  • Two Horses - Shot to death by Arthur Morgan, optional.
  • Jamie's Horse - Shot to death by Arthur Morgan, optional.
    • Total - 16
Other
  • Unnamed Chelonian Master - Strangled to death by Arthur Morgan, optional.
  • Nine Unnamed Men - Shot to death by Arthur Morgan, optional.
    • Total - 10
Overall
  • Total - 26
    • 16 Animals
      • 11 Cows
      • 5 Horses
    • 10 Humans
      • 10 Men
Money Lending and Other Sins I
  • None
Money Lending and Other Sins II
Named Characters
  • Cooper - Killed by Arthur Morgan, optional.
  • Lilly Millet - Killed by Arthur Morgan, optional.
  • Chick Matthews - Killed by Arthur Morgan, optional.
    • Total - 3
Animals
  • Chick Matthews' Horse - Shot to death by Arthur Morgan, optional.
    • Total - 1
Other
  • Unnamed Man - Killed by Arthur Morgan for witnessing Cooper's beating, optional.
    • Total - 1
Overall
  • Total - 5
    • 4 Humans
      • 3 Men
      • 1 Woman
    • 1 Animal
      • 1 Horse
Money Lending and Other Sins III
  • None
The Spines of America
Named Characters
  • Bob Crawford Sr. - Killed by Arthur Morgan, optional. (Only during the night robbery)
  • Bob Crawford Jr. - Killed by Arthur Morgan, optional. (Only during the night robbery)
    • Total - 2
Other
  • Unnamed Man - Killed by Arthur Morgan for witnessing the robbery and possible murders, optional.
    • Total - 1
Overall
  • Total - 3
    • 3 Humans
      • 3 Men
Pouring Forth Oil I
  • None
Pouring Forth Oil II
Animals
  • Cornwall Guard Dog - Killed by Arthur Morgan, optional. (Oil Refinery)
    • Total - 1
Other
  • Unnamed Cornwall Guard - Shot to death by Arthur Morgan, optional. (Valentine)
    • Total - 1
Overall
  • Total - 2
    • 1 Human
      • 1 Man
    • 1 Animal
      • 1 Dog
Pouring Forth Oil III
  • None
Pouring Forth Oil IV
Enemies
  • Unnamed Train Guard - Killed by Arthur Morgan, optional.
  • Four Unnamed Train Guards - Shot to death by Arthur Morgan to save Sean MacGuire.
  • 12 Unnamed Lawmen - Shot to death by either Arthur Morgan, John Marston, Charles Smith, or Sean MacGuire. Shared kills.
    • Total - 17
Animals
  • 25 Horses - Shot to death by Arthur Morgan, optional.
    • Total - 25
Other
  • Unnamed Train Engineer - Killed by Arthur Morgan, optional.
    • Total - 1
Overall
  • Total - 43
    • 25 Animals
      • 25 Horses
    • 18 Humans
      • 18 Men
A Fisher of Men
Animals
  • Three Fish - Caught by Arthur Morgan and presumably eaten off-screen, optional.
    • Total - 3
Overall
  • Total - 3
    • 3 Animals
      • 3 Fish
An American Pastoral Scene
Enemies
  • Unnamed Stagecoach Driver - Shot to death by either Arthur Morgan or Micah Bell III. Shared kill.
  • Five Unnamed Stagecoach Guards - Shot to death by either Arthur Morgan or Micah Bell III. Shared kills.
  • 17 Unnamed O'Driscoll Gang Members - Shot to death by either Arthur Morgan or Micah Bell III. Shared kills.
    • Total - 23
Animals
  • Four Stagecoach Guard Horses - Shot to death by Arthur Morgan, optional.
  • Two O'Driscoll Horses - Shot to death by Arthur Morgan, optional.
  • Two O'Driscoll Wagon Horses - Shot to death by Arthur Morgan, optional.
    • Total - 8
Overall
  • Total - 31
    • 23 Humans
      • 23 Men
    • 8 Animals
      • 8 Horses
The Sheep and the Goats
Enemies
  • Four Unnamed Cornwall Henchmen - Shot to death by either Arthur Morgan or Dutch Van der Linde to save John Marston and Leopold Strauss. Shared kills.
  • Unnamed Cornwall Henchman - Shot in the head by either Arthur Morgan or John Marston to save Leopold Strauss. Shared kill. (If the player only kills the guard holding John.)
  • 32 Unnamed Valentine Lawmen - Shot to death by either Arthur Morgan, John Marston, or Dutch Van der Linde. Shared kills.
  • Four Unnamed Valentine Lawmen - Shot to death by Arthur Morgan after rescuing Leopold.
    • Total - 41
Animals
  • Three Horses - Shot to death by Arthur Morgan, optional.
    • Total - 3
Other
  • Three Unnamed Ranch Hands - Shot to death by Arthur Morgan, optional.
    • Total - 3
Overall
  • Total - 47
    • 44 Humans
      • 44 Men
    • 3 Animals
      • 3 Horses
A Strange Kindness
Enemies
  • Six Unknown Gang Members - Shot to death by either Arthur Morgan or Charles Smith. Shared kills.
    • Total - 6
Animals
  • Three Vultures - Shot to death by Arthur Morgan, optional.
  • Two Horses - Shot to death by Arthur Morgan, optional.
    • Total - 5
Other
  • Unnamed Man - Shot to death by gangsters off-screen, body shown.
    • Total - 1
Overall
  • Total - 12
    • 7 Humans
      • 7 Men
    • 5 Animals
      • 3 Birds
      • 2 Horses

Chapter Three: Clemens Point

The New South
Named Characters
  • Copper (Dog) - Died of unspecified causes off-screen, mentioned.
  • Greta Van der Linde - Died of unspecified causes off-screen in 1881, grave shown.
    • Total - 2
Enemies
  • Unnamed Anderson Boys' Gang Member - Accidentally hit in the head by a passing bar and then fell off a speeding train.
    • Total - 1
Animals
  • At Least Four Fish - Caught by Arthur Morgan and presumably eaten off-screen, optional.
  • Three Bass - Caught by an unnamed fishmonger off-screen 15 years prior with Arthur Morgan pretending to have caught them, mentioned.
    • Total - 7
Other
  • Dutch Van der Linde's Father - Killed by an unknown person during the Battle of Gettysburg in the Civil War off-screen, mentioned.
  • Wesley's Ex-Wife - Died of unknown causes off-screen, funeral mentioned.
    • Total - 2
Overall
  • Total - 12
    • 8 Animals
      • 7 Fish
      • 1 Dog
    • 4 Humans
      • 2 Men
      • 2 Women
Further Questions of Female Suffrage
Enemies
  • Unnamed Lemoyne Raider - Ran over by Sadie Adler with a wagon.
  • Two Unnamed Lemoyne's Raiders Gang Members - Shot to death by either Arthur Morgan or Sadie Adler. Shared kills.
  • Five Unnamed Lemoyne's Raiders Gang Members - Shot to death by either Arthur Morgan or Sadie Adler. Shared kills. (Ambush)
    • Total - 8
Animals
  • Five Lemoyne Raiders Horses - Shot to death by Arthur Morgan, optional.
    • Total - 5
Other
  • Sadie Adler's Nephew - Died during childbirth off-screen, mentioned.
    • Total - 1
Overall
  • Total - 14
    • 9 Humans
      • 9 Men
    • 5 Animals
      • 5 Horses
Money Lending and Other Sins IV
Named Characters
  • Winton Holmes - Mauled to death by the White Cougar off-camera, body shown.
  • Mrs. Claypole - Died of unspecified causes off-screen several years prior, grave shown.
    • Total - 2
Animals
  • White Cougar - Shot to death by Arthur Morgan.
    • Total - 1
Other
  • Unnamed Man's Aunt - Died of unspecified causes off-screen several years prior, mentioned.
  • Three Unknown People - Killed by the White Cougar off-screen, bodies shown.
    • Total - 4
Overall
  • Total - 7
    • 6 Humans
      • 3 Victims of Unknown Gender
      • 2 Women
      • 1 Man
    • 1 Animal
      • 1 Cougar
American Distillation
Named Characters
  • State Legislator Fredrick Mitchell - Shot in the head by Lemoyne Raiders off-screen, body shown.
  • Reginald - Died of unspecified causes off-screen, mentioned.
    • Total - 2
Enemies
  • 16 Unnamed Lemoyne Raider Gang Members - Shot to death by either Arthur Morgan or Bill Williamson. Shared kills.
    • Total - 16
Animals
  • Two Lemoyne Raiders Wagon Horses - Shot to death by Arthur Morgan, optional.
    • Total - 2
Other
  • Six Unnamed State Legislators - Killed by the Lemoyne Raiders off-screen, seven mentioned not including the already counted Frederick Mitchell.
  • Unnamed Man - Shot to death by Lemoyne Raiders off-screen, body shown.
    • Total - 7
Overall
  • Total - 27
    • 25 Humans
      • 25 Men
    • 2 Animals
      • 2 Horses
The Course of True Love I
  • None
The Course of True Love II
  • None
The Course of True Love III
Other
  • At Least One Unnamed Woman - Killed by Anti-Women's Suffrage protestors off-screen in Rhodes, mentioned.
    • Total - 1
Overall
  • Total - 1
    • 1 Human
      • 1 Woman
Advertising, The New American Art
Enemies
  • Ten Unnamed Lemoyne Raider Gang Members - Shot to death by either Arthur Morgan or Hosea Matthews. Shared kills. (Saloon)
  • Unnamed Lemoyne Raider Gang Member - Shot to death by Arthur Morgan to save Hosea Matthews. (Saloon)
  • Two Unnamed Lemoyne Raider Gang Members - Shot to death by Arthur Morgan. (Saloon)
  • Unnamed Lemoyne Raider Gang Member - Shot in the chest by Hosea Matthews during the escape. (Saloon)
  • 13 Unnamed Lemoyne Raider Gang Members - Shot to death by Arthur Morgan. (Chase)
  • Two Unnamed Lemoyne Raider Gang Members - Either shot to death by Arthur Morgan or blown up after he shot the dynamite filled wagon.
    • Total - 29
Animals
  • Ten Lemoyne Raiders Horses - Shot to death by Arthur Morgan, optional. (Chase)
  • Two Lemoyne Raiders Wagon Horses - Either shot to death by Arthur Morgan or blown up after shooting the dynamite in the back of the wagon, optional.
    • Total - 12
Other
  • Three Unnamed Men - Shot to death by Arthur Morgan, optional. (Saloon)
    • Total - 3
Overall
  • Total - 44
    • 32 Humans
      • 32 Men
    • 12 Animals
      • 12 Horses
Horse Flesh for Dinner
Enemies
  • 16 Unnamed Braithwaite Family Guards - Shot to death by either Arthur Morgan, John Marston, or Javier Escuella. Shared kills. (Manor)
  • Three Unnamed Braithwaite Family Guards - Shot to death by either Arthur, John Marston, or Javier Escuella. Shared kills. (Chase)
    • Total - 19
Animals
  • Four Braithwaite Horses - Shot to death by Arthur Morgan, optional.
  • Four Braithwaite Wagon Horses - Shot to death by Arthur Morgan, optional.
    • Total - 8
Other
  • Tavish Gray's Uncle - Killed by an unspecified member of the Braithwaite family off-screen, mentioned.
  • Unnamed Braithwaite Stablehand - Killed by either Arthur Morgan, John Marston, or Javier Escuella. Shared kill.
    • Total - 2
Overall
  • Total - 29
    • 21 Humans
      • 21 Men
    • 8 Animals
      • 8 Horses
The Fine Joys of Tobacco
Named Characters
  • Hamish - Killed by either Arthur Morgan or Sean MacGuire. Shared kill.
    • Total - 1
Enemies
  • Unnamed Gray Family Guard - Stabbed in the neck by Sean MacGuire.
  • Unnamed Gray Family Guard - Stabbed to death by either Arthur Morgan or Sean MacGuire. Shared kill.
  • Two Unnamed Gray Family Guards - Shot to death by Sean MacGuire while Arthur Morgan burned the tobacco crops.
  • 21 Unnamed Gray Family Guards - Shot to death by either Arthur Morgan or Sean MacGuire. Shared kills.
    • Total - 25
Animals
  • Two Gray Family Horses - Shot to death by Arthur Morgan, optional.
    • Total - 2
Overall
  • Total - 28
    • 26 Humans
      • 26 Men
    • 2 Animals
      • 2 Horses
Magicians for Sport
Named Characters
  • Jeb - Shot to death by either Arthur Morgan or Charles Smith. Shared kill.
    • Total - 1
Enemies
  • Unnamed Bounty Hunter - Beaten to death by either Arthur Morgan or Charles Smith. Shared kill.
  • Four Unnamed Bounty Hunters - Shot to death by either Arthur Morgan or Charles Smith. Shared kills.
  • Unnamed Bounty Hunter - Either stabbed in the chest with a knife thrown by Charles Smith to save Arthur Morgan or shot in the head by Arthur to save Charles. Shared kill.
    • Total - 6
Animals
  • Jeb's Horse - Shot to death by Arthur Morgan, optional.
  • Unnamed Bounty Hunter's Horse - Shot to death by Arthur Morgan, optional.
    • Total - 2
Overall
  • Total - 9
    • 7 Humans
      • 7 Men
    • 2 Animals
      • 2 Horses
Friends in Very Low Places
Named Characters
  • Chester Damsen - Shot to death by Arthur Morgan, optional.
    • Total - 1
Enemies
  • Unnamed Stagecoach Guard - Shot to death by Arthur Morgan, optional.
    • Total - 1
Animals
  • Two Stagecoach Horses - Shot to death by Arthur Morgan, optional.
    • Total - 2
Other
  • Unnamed Stagecoach Driver - Shot to death by Arthur Morgan, optional.
  • Unnamed Stagecoach Passenger - Shot to death by Arthur Morgan, optional.
    • Total - 2
Overall
  • Total - 6
    • 4 Humans
      • 3 Men
      • 1 Woman
    • 2 Animals
      • 2 Horses
An Honest Mistake
Named Characters
  • Lowe - Shot to death by Charles Smith.
  • Cooperforth - Shot to death by either Arthur Morgan or Uncle. Shared kill.
    • Total - 2
Enemies
  • Unnamed Cornwall Guard - Shot to death by Arthur Morgan. (Chase)
  • 17 Unnamed Cornwall Guards - Shot to death by either Arthur Morgan, Charles Smith, Bill Williamson, or Uncle. Shared kills. (Outhouse)
  • Unnamed Cornwall Guard - Stabbed to death by Arthur Morgan. (Woods)
  • Unnamed Cornwall Guard - Shot to death by Uncle. (Woods)
  • Five Unnamed Cornwall Guards - Shot to death by either Arthur Morgan, Charles Smith, Bill Williamson, or Uncle. Shared kills. (Woods)
    • Total - 25
Animals
  • Two Wagon Horses - Shot to death by Arthur Morgan, optional. (Chase)
  • Two Lawmen Horses - Shot to death by Arthur Morgan, optional. (Outhouse)
  • Three Lawmen Horses - Shot to death by Arthur Morgan, optional. (Woods)
    • Total - 7
Other
  • Unnamed Man - Shot to death by Arthur Morgan, optional. (Chase)
    • Total - 1
Overall
  • Total - 35
    • 28 Humans
      • 28 Men
    • 7 Animals
      • 7 Horses
Preaching Forgiveness as he Went
Enemies
  • 16 Unnamed Lemoyne Raiders Gang Members - Shot to death by either Arthur Morgan or Lenny Summers. Shared kills. (Plantation)
  • Three Unnamed Lemoyne Raiders Gang Members - Shot to death by either Arthur Morgan or Lenny Summers. Shared kills. (Chase)
    • Total - 19
Animals
  • Two Lemoyne Raiders Wagon Horses - Either shot to death by Arthur Morgan or blown up after shooting the dynamite in the back of the wagon, optional. (Shady Belle)
  • Three Lemoyne Raiders Horses - Shot to death by Arthur Morgan, optional. (Ambush)
    • Total - 5
Overall
  • Total - 24
    • 19 Humans
      • 19 Men
    • 5 Animals
      • 5 Horses
Sodom? Back to Gomorrah
Named Characters
  • Thomas Downes - Succumbed to his Tuberculosis off-screen, mentioned.
    • Total - 1
Enemies
  • 15 Unnamed Valentine Lawmen - Shot to death by either Arthur Morgan, Bill Williamson, Lenny Summers, or Karen Jones. Shared kills. (Valentine)
  • Eight Unnamed Valentine Lawmen - Shot to death by either Arthur Morgan, Bill Williamson, Lenny Summers, or Karen Jones. Shared kills. (Chase)
    • Total - 23
Animals
  • Ten Lawmen Horses - Shot to death by Arthur Morgan, optional.
    • Total - 10
Other
  • Unnamed Bank Teller - Beaten to death by Bill Williamson with his rifle.
    • Total - 1
Overall
  • Total - 35
    • 25 Humans
      • 25 Men
    • 10 Animals
      • 10 Horses
Blessed are the Peacemakers
Named Characters
  • Seamus (O'Driscoll) - Killed by an unspecified member of the Van der Linde gang off-screen, mentioned.
    • Total - 1
Enemies
  • Unnamed O'Driscoll Gang Member - Neck snapped by Arthur Morgan.
  • Six Unnamed O'Driscoll Gang Members - Either stealthily killed or shot to death by Arthur Morgan for kidnapping, shooting, and torturing him. (Camp)
  • Eight Unnamed O'Driscoll Gang Members - Shot to death by Arthur Morgan. (Patrolling)
    • Total - 15
Animals
  • Seven O'Driscoll Horses - Shot to death by Arthur Morgan, optional. (Camp)
  • Five O'Driscoll Horses - Shot to death by Arthur Morgan, optional. (Patrolling)
    • Total - 12
Overall
  • Total - 28
    • 16 Humans
      • 16 Men
    • 12 Animals
      • 12 Horses
A Short Walk in a Pretty Town
Named Characters
  • Sean MacGuire - Shot in the head by a Gray Family hired sniper.
  • Sheriff Leigh Gray - Shot in the head by Arthur Morgan to save Bill Williamson.
  • Deputy Archibald MacGregor - Shot to death by either Arthur Morgan or Micah Bell III. Shared kill.
  • Jock Gray - Shot to death by either Arthur Morgan or Micah Bell III. Shared kill.
    • Total - 4
Enemies
  • Unnamed Gray Family Sniper - Shot in the head by Micah Bell III. (Cut-Scene)
  • Two Unnamed Rhodes Lawmen/Gray Family Hired Guns - Shot to death by Micah Bell III. (Cut-Scene)
  • 31 Unnamed Rhodes Lawmen/Gray Family Hired Guns - Shot to death by either Arthur Morgan, Bill Williamson, or Micah Bell III. Shared kills.
  • Unnamed Rhodes Lawman/Gray Family Hired Gun - Shot to death by either Arthur Morgan or Micah Bell III to save Bill Williamson. Shared kill.
    • Total - 35
Animals
  • Five Rhodes Lawmen/Gray Family Hired Gun Horses - Shot to death by Arthur Morgan, optional.
    • Total - 5
Overall
  • Total - 44
    • 39 Humans
      • 39 Men
    • 5 Animals
      • 5 Horses
Blood Feuds, Ancient and Modern
Named Characters
  • Catherine Braithwaite - Committed suicide by running into her burning house after the Van der Linde gang killed her entire family. (Cut-Scene)
  • Gerald Braithwaite - Shot to death by Arthur Morgan.
  • Gareth Braithwaite - Shot to death by Arthur Morgan.
  • Bartholomew Braithwaite - Shot in the head by Dutch Van der Linde. (Cut-Scene)
    • Total - 4
Enemies
  • 11 Unnamed Braithwaite Family Guards - Shot to death by either Arthur Morgan, John Marston, Dutch Van der Linde, Hosea Matthews, Charles Smith, Bill Williamson, Lenny Summers, or Javier Escuella. Shared kills. (First Wave)
  • Unnamed Braithwaite Family Guard - Shot to death by either Arthur Morgan or John Marston. (Manor)
  • 21 Unnamed Braithwaite Family Guards - Shot to death by either Arthur Morgan, John Marston, Charles Smith, Bill Williamson, Lenny Summers, or Javier Escuella. Shared kills. (Second Wave)
  • Unnamed Braithwaite Family Guard - Set on fire with a molotov cocktail thrown onto him by Hosea Matthews off-camera.
    • Total - 34
Animals
  • Three Braithwaite Horses - Shot to death by Arthur Morgan, optional.
  • Four Braithwaite Wagon Horses - Shot to death by Arthur Morgan, optional.
    • Total - 7
Overall
  • Total - 45
    • 38 Humans
      • 37 Men
      • 1 Woman
    • 7 Animals
      • 7 Horses
The Battle of Shady Belle
Enemies
  • Unnamed Lemoyne Raiders Gang Leader - Either shot to death by Arthur Morgan or committed suicide by shooting himself in the head.
  • Unnamed Lemoyne Raiders Member - Either shot to death by Arthur Morgan or by John Marston as he escapes if Arthur spares him. Shared kill.
  • Unnamed Lemoyne Raiders Member - Either shot to death by Arthur Morgan or beaten to death by him on his request.
  • Two Unnamed Lemoyne Raider Gang Members - Shot to death by either Arthur Morgan or John Marston. Shared kills.
    • Total - 5
Overall
  • Total - 5
    • 5 Humans
      • 5 Men

Chapter Four: Saint Denis

The Joys of Civilization
  • None
Angelo Bronte, A Man of Honor
Enemies
  • Five Unnamed Grave Robbers - Shot to death by either Arthur Morgan or John Marston. Shared kills.
  • At Least Seven Unnamed Saint Denis Lawmen - Shot to death by either Arthur Morgan or John Marston, optional. Shared kills.
    • Total - 12
Other
  • Unnamed Man's Friend - Died of unspecified causes off-screen, mentioned.
    • Total - 1
Overall
  • Total - 13
    • 12 Humans
      • 12 Men
      • 1 Victim of Unknown Gender
Money Lending and Other Sins V
Named Characters
  • Algie Davison - Shot to death by Arthur Morgan, optional.
  • Nate Davison - Shot to death by Arthur Morgan, optional.
    • Total - 2
Overall
  • Total - 2
    • 2 Humans
      • 2 Men
Help a Brother Out
Enemies
  • Unnamed Human Trafficker - Shot to death by Arthur Morgan, optional.
    • Total - 1
Overall
  • Total - 1
    • 1 Human
      • 1 Man
Brothers and Sisters, One and All
Enemies
  • Unnamed Saint Denis Lawman - Shot to death by Arthur Morgan, optional.
    • Total - 1
Other
  • Sister Calderón's Mother - Died of unspecified causes off-screen, mentioned.
    • Total - 1
Overall
  • Total - 2
    • 2 Humans
      • 1 Man
      • 1 Woman
Fatherhood and Other Dreams
Named Characters
  • Ashton - Either beaten, strangled, or shot to death by Arthur Morgan, optional.
    • Total - 1
Animals
  • Four Wagon Horses - Shot to death by Arthur Morgan, optional.
    • Total - 4
Other
  • Mary Linton's Mother - Died of unspecified causes off-screen, mentioned.
    • Total - 1
Overall
  • Total - 6
    • 4 Animals
      • 4 Horses
    • 2 Humans
      • 1 Man
      • 1 Woman
No, No, and Thrice, No
Named Characters
  • Anthony Foreman - Stabbed in the stomach by Arthur Morgan, optional.
  • Malcolm Foreman - Killed by Tilly Jackson in self defense off-screen, mentioned.
    • Total - 2
Enemies
  • Unnamed Foreman Brother - Stabbed in the neck by Susan Grimshaw.
  • Two Unnamed Foreman Brothers - Shot to death by Arthur Morgan. (House)
  • Two Unnamed Foreman Brothers - Shot to death by either Arthur Morgan or Susan Grimshaw. Shared kills. (Chase)
    • Total - 5
Animals
  • Two Foreman Brothers Horses - Shot to death by Arthur Morgan, optional.
  • Anthony Foreman's Horse - Shot to death by Arthur Morgan, optional.
    • Total - 3
Other
  • Mary-Beth Gaskill's Mother - Died of Typhoid Fever off-screen, mentioned.
    • Total - 1
Overall
  • Total - 11
    • 8 Humans
      • 7 Men
      • 1 Woman
    • 3 Animals
      • 3 Horses
The Gilded Cage
  • None
A Fine Night of Debauchery
Enemies
  • Unnamed Grand Korrigan Pit Boss - Shot to death by Arthur Morgan in a duel.
  • Unnamed Grand Korrigan Guard - Hit in the head by Javier Escuella with the butt of his rifle.
  • Unnamed Grand Korrigan Guard - Shot in the chest by Javier Escuella. (Cut-Scene)
  • Unnamed Grand Korrigan Guard - Either shot to death by Arthur Morgan or hit in the head by Leopold Strauss with a wine bottle. Shared kill. (Poker Room)
  • 17 Unnamed Grand Korrigan Guards - Shot to death by either Arthur Morgan or Javier Escuella. Shared kills. (Poker Room)
    • Total - 21
Overall
  • Total - 21
    • 21 Humans
      • 21 Men
American Fathers I
  • None
American Fathers II
Named Characters
  • Danbury - Shot to death by Arthur Morgan, optional.
    • Total - 1
Enemies
  • 17 Unnamed Cornwall Company Guards - Shot to death by Arthur Morgan. (Refinery)
  • Three Unnamed Cornwall Company Guards - Shot to death by either Arthur Morgan or Eagle Flies. (Chase)
    • Total - 20
Animals
  • Three Cornwall Horses - Shot to death by Arthur Morgan, optional. (Refinery)
  • Three Cornwall Horses - Shot to death by Arthur Morgan, optional. (Chase)
    • Total - 6
Overall
  • Total - 27
    • 21 Humans
      • 21 Men
    • 6 Animals
      • 6 Horses
High and Low Finance
Enemies
  • Unnamed Patrolman - Neck snapped by Arthur Morgan.
  • At Least Seven Unnamed Rhodes Lawmen - Shot to death by either Arthur Morgan or Charles Smith, optional.
    • Total - 8
Animals
  • Four Rhodes Lawmen Horses - Shot to death by Arthur Morgan, optional. (Chase)
    • Total - 4
Overall
  • Total - 12
    • 8 Humans
      • 8 Men
    • 4 Animals
      • 4 Horses
Horsemen, Apocalypses
Named Characters
  • Kieran Duffy - Decapitated by the O'Driscoll Gang on the orders of Colm O'Driscoll off-screen, body shown.
    • Total - 1
Enemies
  • Three Unnamed O'Driscoll Gang Members - Stabbed to death by Sadie Adler.
  • Unnamed O'Driscoll Gang Member - Throat slashed by Charles Smith with a machete.
  • 36 Unnamed O'Driscoll Gang Members - Shot to death by either Arthur Morgan, John Marston, Sadie Adler, Dutch Van der Linde, or Charles Smith. Shared kills.
    • Total - 40
Animals
  • Two O'Driscoll Horses - Shot to death by Arthur Morgan, optional.
  • Two O'Driscoll Wagon Horses - Shot to death by Arthur Morgan, optional.
    • Total - 4
Overall
  • Total - 45
    • 41 Humans
      • 41 Men
    • 4 Animals
      • 4 Horses
Urban Pleasures
Enemies
  • 20 Unnamed Saint Denis Lawmen - Shot to death by either Arthur Morgan, Dutch Van der Linde, or Lenny Summers. Shared kills. (Trolley)
  • 11 Unnamed Saint Denis Lawmen - Shot to death by either Arthur Morgan, Dutch Van der Linde, or Lenny Summers. Shared kills. (Crash Site)
  • 20 Unnamed Saint Denis Lawmen - Shot to death by either Arthur Morgan, Dutch Van der Linde, or Lenny Summers. Shared kills. (Alleyways/Streets)
  • 11 Unnamed Saint Denis Lawmen - Shot to death by either Arthur Morgan, Dutch Van der Linde, or Lenny Summers. Shared kills. (Wagon Chase)
  • Two of Angel Bronte's Men - Shot to death by Arthur Morgan. (Manor)
  • Two Unnamed Saint Denis Lawmen - Either shot to death by Arthur Morgan or blown up with dynamite thrown by Lenny Summers that is shot by Arthur. Shared kills. (Bridge)
    • Total - 66
Animals
  • 17 Saint Denis Lawmen Horses - Shot to death by Arthur Morgan, optional.
  • Four Saint Denis Lawmen Wagon Horses - Shot to death by Arthur Morgan, optional.
  • Two Horses - Blown up with dynamite thrown by Lenny Summers that is shot by Arthur Morgan. Shared kills. (Bridge)
    • Total - 23
Other
  • Unnamed Male Civilian - Fell to his death after his wagon was destroyed by the broken trolley.
    • Total - 1
Overall
  • Total - 90
    • 67 Humans
      • 67 Men
    • 23 Animals
      • 23 Horses
Country Pursuits
Animals
  • At Least One Catfish - Caught by either Dutch Van der Linde or Thomas and presumably eaten off-screen, mentioned. Shared kill.
  • Two Crayfish - Caught in traps set up by Thomas off-screen.
    • Total - 3
Overall
  • Total - 3
    • 3 Animals
      • 3 Fish
Revenge is a Dish Best Eaten
Named Characters
  • Angelo Bronte - Drowned in a swamp and then fed to an alligator by Dutch Van der Linde.
    • Total - 1
Enemies
  • 29 Unnamed Angelo Bronte Henchmen - Shot to death by either Arthur Morgan, John Marston, Dutch Van der Linde, Bill Williamson, or Lenny Summers. Shared kills.
  • 18 Unnamed Saint Denis Lawmen - Shot to death by either Arthur Morgan, John Marston, Dutch Van der Linde, Bill Williamson, or Lenny Summers. Shared kills.
    • Total - 47
Overall
  • Total - 48
    • 48 Humans
      • 48 Men
Banking, The Old American Art
Named Characters
  • Hosea Matthews - Shot in the chest by Agent Andrew Milton. (Cut-Scene)
  • Leonard "Lenny" Summers - Shot to death by two unnamed Pinkerton agents.
    • Total - 2
Enemies
  • 35 Unnamed Pinkerton Agents - Shot to death by either Arthur Morgan, John Marston, Dutch Van der Linde, Bill Williamson, Lenny Summers, Javier Escuella, Charles Smith, or Micah Bell III. Shared kills. (Bank)
  • Two Unnamed Pinkerton Agents - Shot to death by Arthur Morgan for killing Lenny Summers. (Rooftops)
    • Total - 37
Animals
  • Two Saint Denis Lawmen Horses - Shot to death by Arthur Morgan, optional.
  • Six Saint Denis Lawmen Wagon Horses - Shot to death by Arthur Morgan, optional.
    • Total - 8
Other
  • Unnamed Bank Guard - Hit in the head by Bill Williamson with the butt of a rifle.
    • Total - 1
Overall
  • Total - 48
    • 40 Humans
      • 40 Men
    • 8 Animals
      • 8 Horses

Chapter Five: Guarma

Welcome to the New World
Enemies
  • Unnamed Guarma Guard - Shot to death by either Hercule Fontaine or his rebels. (Cut-Scene)
  • Unnamed Guarma Guard - Beaten to death by Leon Fuentes with a rifle. (Cut-Scene)
  • Five Unnamed Guarma Guards - Shot to death by either Arthur Morgan or Hercule Fontaine and his rebels. Shared kills. (Beach)
  • 11 Unnamed Guarma Guards - Shot to death by either Arthur Morgan, Dutch Van der Linde, Bill Williamson, Micah Bell III, Leon, Hercule, or his rebels. (Rebel Camp)
    • Total - 18
Other
  • Unnamed Man's Grandfather - Died of unspecified causes off-screen, implied.
  • Two Unnamed Men - Shot to death by Guarma guards.
    • Total - 3
Overall
  • Total - 21
    • 21 Humans
      • 21 Men
Savagery Unleashed
Named Characters
  • Angel - Either stabbed or shot to death by Arthur Morgan after choking him unconscious, optional.
    • Total - 1
Enemies
  • Unnamed Hangman - Shot to death by Arthur Morgan.
  • Seven Unnamed Guarma Guards - Shot to death by Arthur Morgan.
    • Total - 8
Other
  • Unnamed Man - Hanged by Angel with a noose in a trap to capture Arthur Morgan.
    • Total - 1
Overall
  • Total - 10
    • 10 Humans
      • 10 Men
A Kind and Benevolent Despot
Named Characters
  • Gloria - Strangled and head smashed against a ladder by Dutch Van der Linde for attempting to rob him.
    • Total - 1
Enemies
  • Unnamed Guarma Guard - Stabbed in the throat by Arthur Morgan. (Sugar Mill)
  • Unnamed Guarma Guard - Stabbed in the throat by Dutch Van der Linde. (Sugar Mill)
  • Unnamed Guarma Guard - Stabbed in the back by Arthur Morgan. (Sugar Mill)
  • Unnamed Guarma Guard - Stabbed to death by Dutch Van der Linde off-camera, body shown. (Sugar Mill)
  • 20 Unnamed Guarma Guards - Shot to death by either Arthur Morgan or Dutch Van der Linde to save Javier Escuella. Shared kills. (Sugar Mill)
  • 15 Unnamed Guarma Guards - Shot to death by Arthur Morgan while Dutch Van der Linde escaped with Javier Escuella. (Woods)
    • Total - 39
Overall
  • Total - 40
    • 40 Humans
      • 39 Men
      • 1 Woman
Hell Hath No Fury
Enemies
  • 13 Unnamed Cuban Soldiers - Shot to death by either Arthur Morgan, Dutch Van der Linde, Bill Williamson, Micah Bell III, Hercule, or an unnamed rebel. Shared kills. (Wave One)
  • 20 Unnamed Cuban Soldiers - Shot to death by either Arthur Morgan, Dutch Van der Linde, or Hercule. Shared kills. (Bridge/Beach)
  • Unnamed Cuban Soldier - Shot to death by Hercule Fontaine to save Dutch Van der Linde.
  • At Least 800 Unnamed Cuban Soldiers - Blown up with a cannon fired by Arthur Morgan and Hercule. Shared kills. (Warship) (See Notes)
    • Total - 834
Overall
  • Total - 834
    • 834 Humans
      • 834 Men
Paradise Mercifully Departed
Named Characters
  • Colonel Alberto Fussar - Blown up with a cannon fired by Arthur Morgan.
  • Levi Simon - Shot in the chest by an unnamed ship captain.
    • Total - 2
Enemies
  • Unnamed Cuban Soldier - Stabbed in the neck by Arthur Morgan.
  • Unnamed Cuban Soldier - Stabbed in the back with a knife thrown by Micah Bell III.
  • 24 Unnamed Cuban Soldiers - Shot to death by either Arthur Morgan, Dutch Van der Linde, Hercule, or Micah Bell III. Shared kills. (Guard Camp)
  • 15 Unnamed Cuban Soldiers - Shot to death by either Arthur Morgan, Dutch Van der Linde, Hercule, or Micah Bell III. Shared kills. (Ruins)
    • Total - 41
Overall
  • Total - 43
    • 43 Humans
      • 43 Men
Dear Uncle Tacitus
Named Characters
  • Agent Bunter - Shot to death by Arthur Morgan, optional.
  • Agent Johns - Shot to death by Arthur Morgan, optional.
  • Agent Orly - Shot to death by Arthur Morgan, optional.
    • Total - 3
Enemies
  • Unnamed Pinkerton Agent - Shot to death by Arthur Morgan, optional.
    • Total - 1
Animals
  • Four Pinkerton Horses - Shot to death by Arthur Morgan, optional.
    • Total - 4
Overall
  • Total - 8
    • 4 Humans
      • 4 Men
    • 4 Animals
      • 4 Horses
Fleeting Joy
Enemies
  • 33 Unnamed Pinkerton Agents - Shot to death by either Arthur Morgan, Sadie Adler, Dutch Van der Linde, Javier Escuella, Bill Williamson, Micah Bell III, or Charles Smith. Shared kills.
  • Unnamed Pinkerton Agent - Stabbed in the neck by Micah Bell III to prevent him from revealing he's a rat. (Cut-Scene)
    • Total - 34
Overall
  • Total - 34
    • 34 Humans
      • 34 Men
A Fork in the Road
  • None
That's Murfree Country
Named Characters
  • Molly O'Shea - Shot in the stomach by Susan Grimshaw for allegedly betraying the Van der Linde gang.
    • Total - 1
Enemies
  • Unnamed Murfree Brood Gang Member - Stealthily killed by Arthur Morgan with any weapon of his choice.
  • Unnamed Murfree Brood Gang Member - Stabbed with a hatchet thrown by Charles Smith.
  • 18 Unnamed Murfree Brood Gang Members - Shot to death by either Arthur Morgan or Charles Smith. Shared kills. (Cave)
    • Total - 20
Other
  • Unknown Man - Killed by two unnamed Murfree Brood gang members off-screen, body shown.
  • Unknown Man - Killed by an unnamed Murfree Brood gang member off-screen, body shown.
  • Unknown Man - Stabbed to death by an unnamed Murfree Brood gang member with a machete unless he's saved by Arthur Morgan.
  • Unknown Man - Tortured to death by several unnamed Murfree Brood gang members.
    • Total - 4
Overall
  • Total - 25
    • 25 Humans
      • 24 Men
      • 1 Woman

Chapter Six: Beaver Hollow

Icarus and Friends
Named Characters
  • Arturo Bullard - Shot to death by an unknown O'Driscoll gang member.
    • Total - 1
Enemies
  • 19 Unnamed O'Driscoll Gang Members - Shot to death by either Arthur Morgan or Sadie Adler. Shared kills. (Balloon)
  • 20 Unnamed O'Driscoll Gang Members - Shot to death by either Arthur Morgan or Sadie Adler. Shared kills. (Crash Site)
    • Total - 39
Animals
  • 19 O'Driscoll Horses - Shot to death by Arthur Morgan, optional. (Balloon)
  • Seven O'Driscoll Horses - Shot to death by Arthur Morgan, optional. (Crash Site)
    • Total - 26
Other
  • Two Unnamed O'Driscoll Gang Members - Killed by Sadie Adler off-screen a week prior, mentioned.
  • At Least Two Unknown People - Murdered by Colm O'Driscoll off-screen, mentioned.
    • Total - 4
Overall
  • Total - 70
    • 44 Humans
      • 42 Men
      • 2 Victims of Unknown Gender
    • 26 Animals
      • 26 Horses
Visiting Hours
Named Characters
  • Milliken - Shot to death by Arthur Morgan, optional.
    • Total - 1
Enemies
  • Unnamed Sisika Prison Watchtower Guard - Stabbed in the neck by Arthur Morgan.
  • Two Unnamed Sisika Prison Guards - Shot to death by Arthur Morgan who were guarding John Marston.
  • Four Unnamed Sisika Prison Guards - Beaten to death by Sadie Adler.
  • At Least 27 Unnamed Sisika Prison Guards - Shot to death by either Arthur Morgan, John Marston, or Sadie Adler to escape the prison. Shared kills. (Gate/Bridge)
  • Seven Unnamed Sisika Prison Guards - Shot to death by either Arthur Morgan, John Marston, or Sadie Adler to escape the prison. Shared kills. (Fields)
  • Seven Unnamed Sisika Prison Guards - Shot to death by either Arthur Morgan, John Marston, or Sadie Adler to escape the prison. Shared kills. (Beach)
  • Seven Unnamed Sisika Prison Guards - Shot to death by Arthur Morgan. (Boat)
    • Total - 55
Animals
  • 13 Sisika Prison Guard Horses - Shot to death by Arthur Morgan, optional.
    • Total - 13
Overall
  • Total - 69
    • 56 Humans
      • 56 Men
    • 13 Animals
      • 13 Horses
Just a Social Call
Named Characters
  • Leviticus Cornwall - Shot in the chest by Dutch Van der Linde. (Cut-Scene)
    • Total - 1
Enemies
  • Three Unnamed Cornwall Guards - Shot to death by either Arthur Morgan or Dutch Van der Linde. Shared kills.
  • 15 Unnamed Pinkerton Agents - Shot to death by either Arthur Morgan or Dutch Van der Linde. Shared kills.
  • Unnamed Pinkerton Agent - Thrown over the side of a staircase by Micah Bell III.
  • 23 Unnamed Pinkerton Agents - Shot to death by either Arthur Morgan, Dutch Van der Linde, or Micah Bell III. Shared kills. (Coal Building)
  • 11 Unnamed Pinkerton Agents - Shot to death by either Arthur Morgan, Dutch Van der Linde, or Micah Bell III. Shared kills. (Chase)
    • Total - 53
Animals
  • Stagecoach Horse - Shot to death by Arthur Morgan, optional.
  • 11 Pinkerton Horses - Shot to death by Arthur Morgan, optional.
    • Total - 12
Overall
  • Total - 66
    • 54 Humans
      • 54 Men
    • 12 Animals
      • 12 Horses
Do Not Seek Absolution I
  • None
Do Not Seek Absolution II
  • None
Of Men and Angels
  • None
The Course of True Love IV
  • None
The Course of True Love V
Named Characters
  • Iain Gray - Shot to death by Arthur Morgan after knocking him out in a fight, optional.
  • Scott Gray - Shot to death by Arthur Morgan after knocking him out in a fight, optional.
  • Olive Calhoon - Killed by anti-women's suffrage protestors off-screen, mentioned.
    • Total - 3
Enemies
  • Penelope Braithwaite's Second Cousin - Shot to death by Arthur Morgan.
  • 11 Unnamed Braithwaite Guards - Shot to death by Arthur Morgan.
    • Total - 12
Animals
  • 12 Braithwaite Guard Horses - Shot to death by Arthur Morgan, optional.
    • Total - 12
Overall
  • Total - 27
    • 15 Humans
      • 14 Men
      • 1 Woman
    • 12 Animals
      • 12 Horses
Money Lending and Other Sins VI
  • None
Money Lending and Other Sins VII
Named Characters
  • Arthur Londonderry - Died of unspecified causes off-screen, mentioned.
    • Total - 1
Enemies
  • Six Unnamed United States Soldiers - Shot to death by either Arthur Morgan or J. John Weathers. Shared kills.
    • Total - 6
Animals
  • Three United States Soldier Horses - Shot to death by Arthur Morgan, optional.
    • Total - 3
Other
  • Unnamed Foreman - Shot to death by Arthur Morgan, optional.
    • Total - 1
Overall
  • Total - 11
    • 8 Humans
      • 8 Men
    • 3 Animals
      • 3 Horses
The Delights of Van Horn
Named Characters
  • Eric - Shot to death by Bill Williamson.
    • Total - 1
Enemies
  • Five Unnamed Stagecoach Guards - Shot to death by either Arthur Morgan or Bill Williamson. Shared kills. (Van Horn)
  • 12 Unnamed Van Horn Lawmen - Shot to death by Arthur Morgan to defend Bill Williamson and the wagon. Shared kills. (Chase)
    • Total - 17
Animals
  • Two Stagecoach Horses - Shot to death by Arthur Morgan, optional.
  • Four Van Horn Lawmen Horses - Shot to death by Arthur Morgan, optional.
  • 12 Pinkerton Horses - Shot to death by Arthur Morgan, optional.
    • Total - 18
Overall
  • Total - 36
    • 18 Humans
      • 18 Men
    • 18 Animals
      • 18 Horses
The Bridge to Nowhere
  • None
A Rage Unleashed
Named Characters
  • Pennington - Either shot to death by Arthur Morgan or drowned in the river.
    • Total - 1
Enemies
  • Six Unnamed United States Soldiers - Shot to death by either Arthur Morgan, Dutch Van der Linde, Charles Smith, or Eagle Flies. Shared kills. (Boat)
    • Total - 6
Overall
  • Total - 7
    • 7 Humans
      • 7 Men
Archeology for Beginners
Named Characters
  • Isaac Morgan - Shot to death by a gang of thieves off-screen, mentioned.
  • Eliza - Shot to death by a gang of thieves off-screen, mentioned.
    • Total - 2
Enemies
  • Six Unnamed United States Soldiers - Shot to death by Arthur Morgan for robbing Rains Falls and burning down his sacred site, optional.
    • Total - 6
Animals
  • Horse - Killed and eaten by two wolves off-screen, remains shown.
  • Two Wolves - Shot to death by Arthur Morgan, optional.
  • Six United States Soldier Horses - Shot to death by Arthur Morgan, optional.
    • Total - 9
Overall
  • Total - 17
    • 9 Animals
      • 7 Horses
      • 2 Wolves
    • 8 Humans
      • 7 Men
      • 1 Woman
Honor, Amongst Thieves
Enemies
  • Two Unnamed United States Soldiers - Shot to death by Arthur Morgan, optional.
    • Total - 2
Animals
  • Two United States Wagon Horses - Shot to death by Arthur Morgan, optional.
    • Total - 2
Overall
  • Total - 4
    • 2 Humans
      • 2 Men
    • 2 Animals
      • 2 Horses
The Fine Art of Conversation
Named Characters
  • Jackson - Shot to death by Arthur Morgan, optional. (Later appears in the mission The King's Son if he's spared, but he won't be counted twice)
    • Total - 1
Enemies
  • Nine Unnamed United States Soldiers - Shot to death by Arthur Morgan. (Army Camp)
  • Nine Unnamed United States Soldiers - Shot to death by either Arthur Morgan or Charles Smith. Shared kills. (Chase)
  • 20 Unnamed United States Soldiers - Shot to death by either Arthur Morgan or Charles Smith. Shared kills. (Woods)
  • Three Unnamed United States Soldiers - Shot to death by either Arthur Morgan or Charles Smith. Shared kills. (Chase #2)
    • Total - 41
Animals
  • Nine United States Soldier Horses - Shot to death by Arthur Morgan, optional.
  • Two United States Soldier Wagon Horses - Shot to death by Arthur Morgan, optional.
  • Captain Lyndon Monroe's Horse - Shot to death by an unnamed United States soldier during the escape.
    • Total - 12
Other
  • Sister Calderón's Husband - Died of unspecified causes off-screen, mentioned.
    • Total - 1
Overall
  • Total - 55
    • 43 Humans
      • 43 Men
    • 12 Animals
      • 12 Horses
Goodbye, Dear Friend
Named Characters
  • Colm O'Driscoll - Hanged by the city of Saint Denis with a noose.
  • Paul (O'Driscoll) - Stabbed to death by Arthur Morgan, optional.
    • Total - 2
Enemies
  • Unnamed O'Driscoll Gang Member - Throat slashed by Sadie Adler with a knife. (Cut-Scene)
  • Unnamed O'Driscoll Gang Member - Shot in the head by Sadie Adler. (Cut-Scene)
  • Ten Unnamed O'Driscoll Gang Members - Shot to death by either Arthur Morgan, Sadie Adler, Dutch Van der Linde, or Saint Denis lawmen. Shared kills. (Execution Site)
  • Five Unnamed Saint Denis Lawmen - Shot to death by either Arthur Morgan, Sadie Adler, Dutch Van der Linde, or O'Driscoll gang members. Shared kills. (Execution Site)
    • Total - 17
Other
  • Two Unknown Saint Denis Lawmen - Killed by Dutch Van der Linde off-screen to steal their uniforms. (Debatable)
    • Total - 2
Overall
  • Total - 21 (2 Debatable)
    • 21 Humans
      • 21 Men
Mrs. Sadie Adler, Widow I
  • None
Mrs. Sadie Adler, Widow II
Named Characters
  • Tom (O'Driscoll) - Stabbed to death by Sadie Adler. (Cut-Scene)
    • Total - 1
Enemies
  • Unnamed O'Driscoll Gang Member - Set on fire with a molotov cocktail thrown by Sadie Adler.
  • Unnamed O'Driscoll Gang Member Sniper - Shot to death by Arthur Morgan.
  • 14 Unnamed O'Driscoll Gang Members - Shot to death by either Arthur Morgan or Sadie Adler. Shared kills. (Outside)
  • Four Unnamed O'Driscoll Gang Members - Shot to death by Arthur Morgan. (Barn)
  • Two Unnamed O'Driscoll Gang Members - Shot to death by Sadie Adler. (House)
    • Total - 22
Overall
  • Total - 23
    • 23 Humans
      • 23 Men
Favored Sons
Named Characters
  • Martin - Shot to death by either Arthur Morgan, Dutch Van der Linde, Eagle Flies, Paytah, or three unnamed Wapiti Native Americans. Shared kill.
    • Total - 1
Enemies
  • 11 Unnamed United States Soldiers - Shot to death by either Arthur Morgan, Dutch Van der Linde, Eagle Flies, Paytah, or three unnamed Wapiti Native Americans. Shared kills. (Tree trap)
  • Eight Unnamed United States Soldiers - Shot to death by either Arthur Morgan, Dutch Van der Linde, Eagle Flies, Paytah, or three unnamed Wapiti Native Americans. Shared kills. (Reinforcements)
  • Unnamed United States Artilleryman - Shot to death by Arthur Morgan. (Ambush)
  • 11 Unnamed United States Soldiers - Shot to death by either Arthur Morgan, Dutch Van der Linde, Eagle Flies, Paytah, or one unnamed Wapiti Native American. Shared kills. (Ambush)
  • 25 Unnamed United States Soldiers - Shot to death by either Arthur Morgan or Dutch Van der Linde. (Chase)
    • Total - 56
Animals
  • Five United States Soldier Horses - Shot to death by Arthur Morgan, optional.
    • Total - 5
Other
  • Two Unnamed Wapiti Native Americans - Blown up with a cannon fired by an unnamed United States soldier.
    • Total - 2
Overall
  • Total - 64
    • 59 Humans
      • 59 Men
    • 5 Animals
      • 5 Horses
The King's Son
Named Characters
  • Lyle Morgan - Executed by an unknown person via hanging off-screen in 1874, mentioned.
    • Total - 1
Enemies
  • Two Unnamed United States Soldiers - Stealthily killed by Arthur Morgan with any weapon of his choice. (Fort Wallace)
  • Two Unnamed United States Soldiers - Shot in the head by Charles Smith with a bow and arrows. (Fort Wallace)
  • Five Unnamed United States Soldiers - Shot to death by either Arthur Morgan or Charles Smith with bows and arrows. Shared kills. (Fort Wallace)
  • Unnamed United States Soldier - Stealthily killed by Arthur Morgan with any weapon of his choice to start a lantern fire. (Fort Wallace)
  • Unnamed United States Soldier - Shot in the head by Charles Smith with a bow off-camera, body shown. (Fort Wallace)
  • 15 Unnamed United States Soldiers - Shot to death by either Arthur Morgan or Charles Smith to rescue Eagle Flies. Shared kills. (Fort Wallace)
  • 12 Unnamed United States Soldiers - Shot to death by either Arthur Morgan or Charles Smith. (Chase)
  • 15 Unnamed United States Soldiers - Shot to death by either Arthur Morgan or Charles Smith. (Canoes)
    • Total - 53
Animals
  • Six United States Soldier Horses - Shot to death by Arthur Morgan, optional. (Fort Wallace)
  • 11 United States Soldier Horses - Shot to death by Arthur Morgan, optional. (Chase)
  • Seven United States Soldier Horses - Shot to death by Arthur Morgan, optional. (Canoes)
    • Total - 24
Overall
  • Total - 78
    • 54 Humans
      • 54 Men
    • 24 Animals
      • 24 Horses
My Last Boy
Named Characters
  • Colonel Henry Favours - Shot to death by Arthur Morgan.
  • Eagle Flies - Bled out after being shot in the stomach by Colonel Henry Favours.
    • Total - 2
Enemies
  • Two Unnamed United States Soldiers - Shot to death by Eagle Flies. (Cut-Scene)
  • 31 Unnamed United States Soldiers - Shot to death by either Arthur Morgan, Sadie Adler, Charles Smith, or the six remaining unnamed Wapiti Native Americans. Shared kills. (Wave One)
  • Unnamed United States Soldier - Shot to death by either Arthur Morgan or Sadie Adler to save Eagle Flies. Shared kill.
  • 63 Unnamed United States Soldiers - Shot to death by either Arthur Morgan, John Marston, Sadie Adler, Charles Smith, Bill Williamson, Javier Escuella, Dutch Van der Linde, Eagle Flies, Paytah, or the six remaining unnamed Wapiti Native Americans. Shared kills. (Wave Two)
  • Five Unnamed United States Soldiers - Shot to death by either Arthur Morgan or Dutch Van der Linde. (Factory)
  • Two Unnamed United States Soldiers - Shot to death by Eagle Flies to save Arthur Morgan. (Cut-Scene)
  • Unnamed United States Soldier - Hit in the head by Eagle flies with the butt of his rifle to save Arthur Morgan. (Cut-Scene)
    • Total - 105
Animals
  • Ten Wapiti Tribe Horses - Shot to death by United States soldiers off-screen, bodies shown.
  • Four United States Soldier Horses - Shot to death by Arthur Morgan, optional.
    • Total - 14
Other
  • Ten Unnamed Wapiti Native Americans - Killed by United States soldiers during the battle.
  • Unnamed Wapiti Native American - Bled out after being shot by an American soldier off-screen. (Debatable)
  • At Least One Unknown Man - Killed by Chief Rains Fall off-screen, mentioned.
  • Chief Rains Fall's Wife - Throat slashed by an unknown United States soldier off-screen, mentioned.
  • Eagle Flies' Brother - Beaten to death by an unnamed United States soldier off-screen, mentioned.
    • Total - 14
Overall
  • Total - 135 (1 Debatable)
    • 121 Humans
      • 120 Men
      • 1 Woman
    • 14 Animals
      • 14 Horses
Our Best Selves
Enemies
  • Unnamed United States Soldier - Thrown into a river to drown by Sadie Adler and Cleet. Shared kill.
  • 25 Unnamed United States Soldiers - Shot to death by either Arthur Morgan or John Marston. Shared kills. (Wave One)
  • Unnamed United States Soldier - Shot to death by Arthur Morgan for shooting John Marston.
  • 20 Unnamed United States Soldiers - Shot to death by either Arthur Morgan, Sadie Adler, Bill Williamson, or Cleet. Shared kills. (Minigun)
    • Total - 47
Animals
  • 20 United States Soldier Horses - Shot to death by Arthur Morgan, optional.
    • Total - 20
Other
  • Unnamed Train Driver - Killed by Bill Williamson off-screen, mentioned.
    • Total - 1
Overall
  • Total - 68
    • 48 Humans
      • 48 Men
    • 20 Animals
      • 20 Horses
Red Dead Redemption
Named Characters
  • Arthur Morgan - Either succumbed to his tuberculosis or killed by Micah Bell III. (Cut-Scene)
  • Agent Andrew Milton - Shot in the head by Abigail Marston. (Cut-Scene)
  • Susan Grimshaw - Shot in the stomach by Micah Bell III. (Cut-Scene)
    • Total - 3
Enemies
  • Seven Unnamed Pinkerton Agents - Shot to death by either Arthur Morgan or Sadie Adler. Shared kills. (Van Horn)
  • 19 Unnamed Pinkerton Agents - Shot to death by Arthur Morgan to save Sadie Adler and Abigail Marston. (Van Horn)
  • Six Unnamed Pinkerton Agents - Shot to death by either Arthur Morgan or Sadie Adler after saving Abigail Marston. Shared kills. (Van Horn)
  • Nine Unnamed Pinkerton Agents - Shot to death by Arthur Morgan to defend Sadie Adler and Abigail Marston. (Chase)
  • At Least 18 Unnamed Pinkerton Agents - Shot to death by either Arthur Morgan or John Marston. Shared kills. (Camp)
  • 14 Unnamed Pinkerton Agents - Shot to death by either Arthur Morgan or John Marston. Shared kills. (Chase #2)
  • 14 Unnamed Pinkerton Agents - Shot to death by Arthur Morgan. (Get The Money)
    • Total - 87
Animals
  • 40 Pinkerton Horses - Shot to death by Arthur Morgan, optional.
  • Arthur Morgan's Horse - Shot to death by several Pinkerton agents.
  • John Marston's Horse - Shot to death by several Pinkerton agents.
    • Total - 42
Overall
  • Total - 132
    • 90 Humans
      • 89 Men
      • 1 Woman
    • 42 Animals
      • 42 Horses

Epilogue - Part One

The Wheel
Enemies
  • Two Unnamed Laramie Gang Members - Beaten to death by John Marston, optional.
    • Total - 2
Other
  • Unnamed Man - Shot to death by John Marston off-screen for trying to rob him, mentioned.
    • Total - 1
Overall
  • Total - 3
    • 3 Humans
      • 3 Men
Simple Pleasures
  • None
Farming, For Beginners
  • None
Fatherhood, For Beginners
  • None
Old Habits
  • None
Jim Milton Rides, Again?
Named Characters
  • Mr. Tolbert - Killed by an unnamed Laramie gang member off-screen, mentioned.
    • Total - 1
Enemies
  • Two Unnamed Laramie Gang Members - Beaten to death by John Marston. (Pronghorn Ranch)
  • 18 Unnamed Laramie Gang Members - Shot to death by either John Marston, Tom Dickens, or Abe. Shared kills. (Hanging Dog Ranch)
  • Unnamed Laramie Gang Leader - Shot in the head by John Marston with a double barrel shotgun. (Hanging Dog Ranch)
    • Total - 21
Overall
  • Total - 22
    • 22 Humans
      • 22 Men
Fatherhood, For Idiots
Enemies
  • Three Unnamed Men - Shot to death by John Marston in self defense.
    • Total - 3
Animals
  • Three Horses - Shot to death by John Marston, optional.
    • Total - 3
Overall
  • Total - 6
    • 3 Humans
      • 3 Men
    • 3 Animals
      • 3 Horses
Motherhood
  • None
Gainful Employment
Animals
  • Nathan Kirk's Horse - Shot to death by John Marston, optional.
    • Total - 1
Overall
  • Total - 1
    • 1 Animal
      • 1 Horse
The Landowning Classes
  • None (Cut-Scene Only)
Home of the Gentry?
Other
  • Three Unnamed Squatters - Shot to death by John Marston, optional.
    • Total - 3
Overall
  • Total - 3
    • 3 Humans
      • 3 Men

Epilogue - Part Two

Bare Knuckle Friendships
Named Characters
  • Leopold Strauss - Tortured to death by Pinkerton agents off-screen, mentioned.
    • Total - 1
Enemies
  • Four Unnamed Guido Martelli Henchmen - Shot to death by either John Marston or Charles Smith. Shared kills.
    • Total - 4
Overall
  • Total - 5
    • 5 Humans
      • 5 Men
Home Improvement for Beginners
  • None
An Honest Day's Labors
Named Characters
  • James Langton - Shot to death by either John Marston or Sadie Adler. Shared kill.
  • Shane Finley - Either optionally shot to death by John Marston or eventually hanged by the town of Blackwater.
    • Total - 2
Enemies
  • 23 Unnamed James Langton's Men - Shot or stealthily killed by either John Marston or Sadie Adler. Shared kills. (Canyon)
  • 13 Unnamed James Langton's Men - Shot to death by either John Marston or Sadie Adler. (Chase)
    • Total - 36
Animals
  • 13 Horses - Shot to death by John Marston, optional.
    • Total - 13
Other
  • Unnamed Child - Murdered by Shane Finley off-screen, mentioned.
    • Total - 1
Overall
  • Total - 52
    • 39 Humans
      • 38 Men
      • 1 Victim of Unknown Gender
    • 13 Animals
      • 13 Horses
The Tool Box
Named Characters
  • Willard Wayne - Shot in the shoulder by an unnamed member of the Skinner Brothers with an arrow and then stabbed through the eye with a dagger off-screen, body found.
    • Total - 1
Enemies
  • 14 Unnamed Skinner Brothers - Shot to death by either John Marston, Charles Smith, or Mr. Devon. Shared kills. (Wave One)
  • 21 Unnamed Skinner Brothers - Shot to death by either John Marston or Charles Smith. Shared kills. (Wave Two)
    • Total - 35
Overall
  • Total - 36
    • 36 Humans
      • 36 Men
A New Jerusalem
  • None
A Quick Favor for an Old Friend
Named Characters
  • Ramón Cortez - Eventually hanged by the city of Saint Denis off-screen.
    • Total - 1
Enemies
  • Ten Unnamed Del Lobo Gang Members - Shot to death by either John Marston or Sadie Adler. Shared kills. (Rhodes)
  • 28 Unnamed Del Lobo Gang Members - Shot to death by either John Marston or Sadie Adler. Shared kills. (Bridge Camp Wave One)
  • Four Unnamed Del Lobo Gang Members - Shot to death by either John Marston or Sadie Adler. Shared kills. (Bridge Camp Wave Two)
    • Total - 42
Animals
  • Two Del Lobo Horses - Shot to death by John Marston, optional.
    • Total - 2
Overall
  • Total - 45
    • 43 Humans
      • 43 Men
    • 2 Animals
      • 2 Horses
Uncle's Bad Day
Enemies
  • Unnamed Skinner Brother - Shot to death by John Marston with a bow.
  • Unnamed Skinner Brother - Shot in the head by Charles Smith with a bow.
  • Three Unnamed Skinner Brothers - Shot to death by John Marston with a bow and arrows, optional.
  • Unnamed Skinner Brother Stagecoach Driver - Shot to death by John Marston with a bow, optional.
  • Unnamed Skinner Brother - Stabbed in the back with a knife thrown by Charles Smith to save John Marston. (Cut-Scene)
  • Unnamed Skinner Brother - Shot in the head by John Marston to save Charles Smith. (Cut-Scene)
  • Six Unnamed Skinner Brothers - Shot to death by either John Marston or Charles Smith to save Uncle. Shared kills.
  • 22 Unnamed Skinner Brothers - Shot to death by John Marston to protect Charles Smith and Uncle.
  • Three Unnamed Skinner Brothers - Shot to death by either John Marston or Charles Smith while escaping the woods. (Chase)
    • Total - 39
Animals
  • Two Skinner Brothers Wagon Horses - Shot to death by John Marston, optional.
    • Total - 2
Other
  • Unknown Man - Dragged by an unnamed Skinner Brother with a stagecoach.
  • Two Unknown Men - Hanged by the Skinner Brothers off-screen, bodies shown.
  • Three Unknown People - Killed by the Skinner Brothers off-screen, bodies shown.
    • Total - 6
Overall
  • Total - 47
    • 45 Humans
      • 42 Men
      • 3 Victims of Unknown Gender
    • 2 Animals
      • 2 Horses
The Best of Women
  • None (Cut-Scene Only)
Trying Again
Animals
  • At Least Two Fish - Caught by John Marston and presumably eaten off-screen, optional.
  • At Least One Fish - Caught by Jack Marston and presumably eaten off-screen.
    • Total - 3
Overall
  • Total - 3
    • 3 Animals
      • 3 Fish
A Really Big Bastard
Enemies
  • Two Unnamed Bounty Hunters - Shot to death by either John Marston or Sadie Adler. Shared kills.
    • Total - 2
Animals
  • Two Bounty Hunter Horses - Shot to death by John Marston, optional.
    • Total - 2
Other
  • Unnamed Man - Killed by the legendary bear off-screen, body shown.
    • Total - 1
Overall
  • Total - 5
    • 3 Humans
      • 3 Men
    • 2 Animals
      • 2 Horses
A New Future Imagined
  • None
American Venom
Named Characters
  • Micah Bell III - Shot to death by John Marston and Dutch Van der Linde. Shared kill.
  • Cleet - Either hanged by John Marston with a noose or shot to death by Sadie Adler if he was spared by John. Shared kill.
  • Joe - Shot to death by John Marston.
    • Total - 3
Enemies
  • Unnamed Sniper of Micah's Gang - Shot to death by John Marston.
  • 15 Unnamed Members of Micah's Gang - Shot to death by either John Marston or Sadie Adler. (Wave One)
  • Unnamed Member of Micah's Gang - Shot in the back by Charles Smith to save Sadie Adler. (Cut-Scene)
  • Unnamed Member of Micah's Gang - Beaten to death by John Marston. (Cut-Scene)
  • 34 Unnamed Members of Micah's Gang - Shot to death by John Marston. (Wave Two)
    • Total - 52
Animals
  • Rat - Killed by John Marston, optional.
    • Total - 1
Other
  • Unnamed Woman - Murdered by Cleet off-screen, mentioned.
  • Unnamed Little Girl - Killed by Micah Bell III off-screen after previously killing her entire family, mentioned.
    • Total - 2
Overall
  • Total - 58
    • 57 Humans
      • 55 Men
      • 2 Women
    • 1 Animal
      • 1 Rat

Side Missions

A Better World, A New Friend

Animals
  • Squirrel - Shot to death by John Marston on the request of Ms. L. Hobbs. Shared kill.
  • Rabbit - Shot to death by John Marston on the request of Ms. L. Hobbs. Shared kill.
  • Cardinal - Shot to death by John Marston on the request of Ms. L. Hobbs. Shared kill.
  • Rat - Shot to death by John Marston on the request of Ms. L. Hobbs. Shared kill.
  • Woodpecker - Shot to death by John Marston on the request of Ms. L. Hobbs. Shared kill.
  • Chipmunk - Shot to death by John Marston on the request of Ms. L. Hobbs. Shared kill.
  • Oriole - Shot to death by John Marston on the request of Ms. L. Hobbs. Shared kill.
  • Robin - Shot to death by John Marston on the request of Ms. L. Hobbs. Shared kill.
  • Opossum - Shot to death by John Marston on the request of Ms. L. Hobbs. Shared kill.
  • Sparrow - Shot to death by John Marston on the request of Ms. L. Hobbs. Shared kill.
  • Songbird - Shot to death by John Marston on the request of Ms. L. Hobbs. Shared kill.
  • Toad - Shot to death by John Marston on the request of Ms. L. Hobbs. Shared kill.
  • Bullfrog - Shot to death by John Marston on the request of Ms. L. Hobbs. Shared kill.
  • Skunk - Shot to death by John Marston on the request of Ms. L. Hobbs. Shared kill.
  • Waxwing - Shot to death by John Marston on the request of Ms. L. Hobbs. Shared kill.
  • Bat - Shot to death by John Marston on the request of Ms. L. Hobbs. Shared kill.
  • Blue Jay - Shot to death by John Marston on the request of Ms. L. Hobbs. Shared kill.
  • Crow - Shot to death by John Marston on the request of Ms. L. Hobbs. Shared kill.
  • Beaver - Shot to death by John Marston on the request of Ms. L. Hobbs. Shared kill.
    • Total - 19
Overall
  • Total - 19
    • 19 Animals
      • 9 Birds
      • 2 Frogs
      • 1 Squirrel
      • 1 Rabbit
      • 1 Rat
      • 1 Chipmunk
      • 1 Opossum
      • 1 Skunk
      • 1 Bat
      • 1 Beaver

A Bright Bouncing Boy

Named Characters
  • Professor Marko Dragic - Murdered by "969" off-screen, body shown.
  • "969" - Shot to death by either Arthur Morgan or John Marston, optional. Shared kill.
    • Total - 2
Animals
  • Seagull - Blown up with a toy mine set up by Marko Dragic.
    • Total - 1
Other
  • Eight Unnamed Men - Either blown up or drowned when the ship they were on was hit by a sea mine off-screen, mentioned.
  • Unnamed Lab Assistant - Died of unspecified causes off-screen, mentioned.
    • Total - 9
Overall
  • Total - 12
    • 10 Humans
      • 9 Men
      • 1 Victim of Unknown Gender
    • 1 Animal
      • 1 Bird
    • 1 Robot
      • 1 Man

A Fine Night For It

Enemies
  • Nine Unnamed Night Folk - Shot to death by either Arthur Morgan, John Marston, or an unnamed man. Shared kills.
    • Total - 9
Other
  • Five Unknown People - Killed by the Night Folk off-screen, bodies shown.
    • Total - 4
Overall
  • Total - 13
    • 13 Humans
      • 9 Men
      • 4 Victims of Unknown Gender

A Fisher of Fish

Named Characters
  • Jeremy Gill - Pulled underwater by a catfish and drowned.
    • Total - 1
Animals
  • Legendary Bluegill - Captured by either Arthur Morgan or John Marston on the request of Jeremy Gill. Shared kill.
  • Legendary Bullhead Catfish - Captured by either Arthur Morgan or John Marston on the request of Jeremy Gill. Shared kill.
  • Legendary Chain Pickerel - Captured by either Arthur Morgan or John Marston on the request of Jeremy Gill. Shared kill.
  • Legendary Lake Sturgeon - Captured by either Arthur Morgan or John Marston on the request of Jeremy Gill. Shared kill.
  • Legendary Longnose Gar - Captured by either Arthur Morgan or John Marston on the request of Jeremy Gill. Shared kill.
  • Legendary Muskie - Captured by either Arthur Morgan or John Marston on the request of Jeremy Gill. Shared kill.
  • Legendary Perch - Captured by either Arthur Morgan or John Marston on the request of Jeremy Gill. Shared kill.
  • Legendary Smallmouth Bass - Captured by either Arthur Morgan or John Marston on the request of Jeremy Gill. Shared kill.
  • Legendary Sockeye Salmon - Captured by either Arthur Morgan or John Marston on the request of Jeremy Gill. Shared kill.
  • Legendary Steelhead Trout - Captured by either Arthur Morgan or John Marston on the request of Jeremy Gill. Shared kill.
  • Legendary Largemouth Bass - Captured by John Marston on the request of Jeremy Gill.
  • Legendary Redfin Pickerel - Captured by John Marston on the request of Jeremy Gill.
  • Legendary Rock Bass - Captured by John Marston on the request of Jeremy Gill.
    • Total - 13
Overall
  • Total - 14
    • 13 Animals
      • 13 Fish
    • 1 Human
      • 1 Man

A Test of Faith

Other
  • Deborah MacGuiness' Sister - Died of unspecified causes off-screen, mentioned.
    • Total - 1
Overall
  • Total - 1
    • 1 Human
      • 1 Woman

All that Glitters

Named Characters
  • Máximo Cristóbal Valdespino - Shot to death by either Arthur Morgan or John Marston, optional.
    • Total - 1
Animals
  • Máximo Cristóbal Valdespino's Horse - Shot to death by either Arthur Morgan or John Marston, optional.
    • Total - 1
Overall
  • Total - 2
    • 1 Human
      • 1 Man
    • 1 Animal
      • 1 Horse

American Dreams

Named Characters
  • Eliza Bloom - Murdered by Edmund Lowry Jr. off-screen, implied by her missing poster in his basement.
  • Edmund Lowry Jr. - Shot to death by either Arthur Morgan or John Marston to save Sheriff Malloy or by Sheriff Malloy himself. Shared kill.
    • Total - 2
Other
  • Three Unnamed Men - Murdered by Edmund Lowry Jr. off-screen, bodies shown. (Clues)
  • 37 Unknown People - Murdered by Edmund Lowry Jr. off-screen, bodies shown. (Basement)
    • Total - 40
Overall
  • Total - 42
    • 42 Humans
      • 37 Victims of Unknown Gender
      • 4 Men
      • 1 Woman

Arcadia for Amateurs

Animals
  • Coyote - Shot to death by either Arthur Morgan or John Marston, optional. (Encounter #1)
  • Five Wolves - Shot to death by either Arthur Morgan or John Marston, optional. (Encounter #2)
  • Boar - Eaten alive by an alligator. (Encounter #4)
  • 10,000 Alligators - Killed by poachers off-screen in 1898, mentioned. (Encounter #4)
    • Total - 10,007
Overall
  • Total - 10,007
    • 10,007 Animals
      • 10,000 Alligators
      • 5 Wolves
      • 1 Coyote
      • 1 Boar

Duchesses and other Animals

Animals
  • 15 Egrets - Shot to death by either Arthur Morgan or John Marston on the request of Algernon Wasp. Shared kills. (Part 2)
  • 20 Herons - Shot to death by either Arthur Morgan or John Marston on the request of Algernon Wasp. Shared kills. (Part 3)
  • 30 Spoonbills - Shot to death by either Arthur Morgan or John Marston on the request of Algernon Wasp. Shared kills. (Part 4)
    • Total - 65
Overall
  • Total - 65
    • 65 Animals
      • 65 Birds

Fundraiser

Other
  • Unnamed Woman - Shot to death by either Arthur Morgan or John Marston.
    • Total - 1
Overall
  • Total - 1
    • 1 Human
      • 1 Woman

Geology for Beginners

Named Characters
  • Tom Sinclair - Died of unspecified causes off-screen in 1897, mentioned.
    • Total - 1
Overall
  • Total - 1
    • 1 Human
      • 1 Man

He's British, of Course

Animals
  • King (Dog) - Killed by Stripey off-screen, body shown.
  • Two Horses - Mauled to death by a lion off-screen, body shown.
  • Lion - Shot to death by either Arthur Morgan or John Marston.
    • Total - 4
Other
  • Unnamed Man - Mauled to death by a lion off-camera, body shown.
    • Total - 1
Overall
  • Total - 5
    • 4 Animals
      • 2 Horses
      • 1 Dog
      • 1 Lion
    • 1 Human
      • 1 Man

Idealism and Pragmatism for Beginners

Named Characters
  • Jean-Marc Mercier - Shot to death by Arthur Morgan on the orders of Henri Lemieux, optional.
    • Total - 1
Overall
  • Total - 1
    • 1 Human
      • 1 Man

No Good Deed

Enemies
  • Six Unnamed Gangsters - Shot to death by either Arthur Morgan or John Marston. (Camp)
  • Three Unnamed Gangsters - Shot to death by either Arthur Morgan or John Marston. (Ambush)
    • Total - 9
Animals
  • Three Horses - Shot to death by either Arthur Morgan or John Marston. (Ambush)
    • Total - 3
Overall
  • Total - 12
    • 9 Humans
      • 9 Men
    • 3 Animals
      • 3 Horses

Oh, Brother

  • None

Smoking and other Hobbies

  • None

The American Inferno, Burnt Out

Named Characters
  • Evelyn Miller - Died of starvation off-screen sometime between 1899 and 1907, body shown.
    • Total - 1
Animals
  • Deer - Shot to death by either Arthur Morgan or John Marston to put it out of it's misery after being caught in a trap, optional.
    • Total - 1
Enemies
  • Three Unnamed Poachers - Shot to death by either Arthur Morgan or John Marston, optional. Shared kills.
    • Total - 3
Overall
  • Total - 5
    • 4 Humans
      • 4 Men
    • 1 Animal
      • 1 Deer

The Artist's Way

Enemies
  • Unnamed Man - Shot to death by either Arthur Morgan or John Marston to save Charles Smith. (Encounter #1)
  • Three Unnamed Men - Shot to death by either Arthur Morgan or John Marston to save Charles Smith. (Encounter #4)
    • Total - 4
Other
  • Two Unnamed Saint Denis Lawmen - Shot to death by either Arthur Morgan or John Marston, optional. (Encounter #4)
    • Total - 2
Overall
  • Total - 6
    • 6 Humans
      • 6 Men

The Iniquities of History

Named Characters
  • Jeremiah Compson - Shot to death by either Arthur Morgan or John Marston, optional.
  • Betsy Compson - Died of unspecified causes off-screen sometime between 1855 and 1899, mentioned.
    • Total - 2
Enemies
  • Two Unnamed Squatters - Shot to death by either Arthur Morgan or John Marston.
    • Total - 2
Animals
  • Jeremiah Compson's Horse - Shot to death by either Arthur Morgan or John Marston, optional.
    • Total - 1
Other
  • Jeremiah Compson's Grandfather - Died of unknown causes off-screen several years prior, implied.
  • Jeremiah Compson's Father - Died of unknown causes off-screen several years prior, implied.
    • Total - 2
Overall
  • Total - 7
    • 6 Humans
      • 5 Men
      • 1 Woman
    • 1 Animal
      • 1 Horse

The Mercies of Knowledge

Named Characters
  • Wilson J. McDaniels - Sentenced to death via the electric chair.
  • Professor Andrew Bell III - Accidentally electrocuted to death by his electric chair.
    • Total - 2
Enemies
  • Four Unnamed Stagecoach Guards - Shot to death by Arthur Morgan. (Bridge)
  • Five of McDaniels' Men - Shot to death by Arthur Morgan. (Bridge)
  • Three Unnamed Moonshiners - Shot to death by Arthur Morgan. (Ambush)
    • Total - 12
Animals
  • Two Stagecoach Guard Horses - Shot to death by Arthur Morgan, optional. (Bridge)
  • Three McDaniels' Gang Horses - Shot to death by Arthur Morgan, optional. (Bridge)
  • Three Moonshiner Horses - Shot to death by Arthur Morgan, optional. (Ambush)
    • Total - 8
Other
  • Unknown Person - Murdered by Wilson J. McDaniels off-screen, mentioned.
    • Total - 1
Overall
  • Total - 23
    • 15 Humans
      • 14 Men
      • 1 Victim of Unknown Gender
    • 8 Animals
      • 8 Horses

The Noblest of Men, and a Woman

Named Characters
  • "Rabbit" Matthews - Shot to death by Billy Midnight off-screen several years prior, mentioned.
  • Gonzalo (Del Lobo) - Shot to death by either Arthur Morgan or John Marston. Shared kill.
  • Anselmo (Del Lobo) - Shot to death by either Arthur Morgan or John Marston. Shared kill.
  • Eliso (Del Lobo) - Shot to death by either Arthur Morgan or John Marston. Shared kill.
  • Flaco Hernández - Shot to death by either Arthur Morgan or John Marston. Shared kill.
  • Emmet Granger - Shot to death by either Arthur Morgan or John Marston. Shared kill.
  • Billy Midnight - Either shot to death by either Arthur Morgan or John Marston or committed suicide by shooting himself in the head. Shared kill.
  • Ged Calloway - Shot to death by Slim Grant off-screen in 1882, mentioned.
  • State Marshall Slim Grant - Shot in the back by Jim "Boy" Calloway. (Cut-Scene)
  • Jim "Boy" Calloway - Shot to death by either Arthur Morgan or John Marston. Shared kill.
    • Total - 10
Enemies
  • Three Unnamed Bounty Hunters - Blown up by either Arthur Morgan or John Marston with dynamite on the orders of Black Belle. Shared kills.
  • 13 Unnamed Bounty Hunters - Shot to death by either Arthur Morgan, John Marston, or Black Belle. Shared kills.
  • Two Unnamed Del Lobo Gang Members - Shot to death by either Arthur Morgan or John Marston. Shared kills.
  • Four Unnamed Gangsters - Shot to death by either Arthur Morgan or John Marston to save Jim "Boy" Calloway. Shared kills.
    • Total - 22
Animals
  • 16 Horses - Shot to death by either Arthur Morgan or John Marston, optional. (Black Belle)
  • Four Chickens - Shot to death by either Arthur Morgan or John Marston, optional. (Emmet Granger)
  • Three Pigs - Shot to death by either Arthur Morgan or John Marston, optional. (Emmet Granger)
  • Deer - Shot to death by Black Belle off-screen, picture shown.
    • Total - 24
Other
  • 14 Unnamed Men - Shot to death by Jim "Boy" Calloway off-screen several years prior, mentioned.
    • Total - 14
Overall
  • Total - 70
    • 46 Humans
      • 45 Men
      • 1 Victim of Unknown Gender
    • 24 Animals
      • 16 Horses
      • 4 Chickens
      • 3 Pigs
      • 1 Deer

The Smell of the Grease Paint

  • None

The Ties That Bind Us

Named Characters
  • Jimmy Holdacre - Succumbed to a heart attack while attacking Sampson Black and Wendell White off-screen, mentioned.
    • Total - 1
Animals
  • Unnamed Bounty Hunter's Horse - Shot to death by either Arthur Morgan or John Marston, optional.
    • Total - 1
Other
  • Unnamed Elderly Man - Shot to death by either Arthur Morgan or John Marston, optional.
  • Unnamed Bounty Hunter - Shot to death by either Arthur Morgan or John Marston, optional.
    • Total - 2
Overall
  • Total - 4
    • 3 Humans
      • 3 Men
    • 1 Animal
      • 1 Horse

The Veteran

Named Characters
  • Hamish Sinclair - Mauled to death by a boar.
    • Total - 1
Animals
  • Tyrant (Legendary Northern Pike) - Captured by either Arthur Morgan or John Marston with the help of Hamish Sinclair. Shared kill.
  • Deer - Killed by a wolf off-screen, body shown.
  • Four Wolves - Shot to death by either Arthur Morgan, John Marston, or Hamish. Shared kills.
  • Alpha Wolf - Shot to death by either Arthur Morgan or John Marston. Shared kill.
  • At Least One Cow - Mauled to death by a boar off-screen, mentioned.
  • Wolf - Mauled to death by a boar off-screen, body shown.
  • Boar - Shot to death by either Arthur Morgan or John Marston. Shared kill.
  • Buell (Horse) - Shot to death by either Arthur Morgan or John Marston, optional. Shared kill.
    • Total - 11
Other
  • Unnamed Man - Cut in half after being shot by an unknown person with a cannonball off-screen during the Civil War, mentioned.
    • Total - 1
Overall
  • Total - 13
    • 11 Animals
      • 6 Wolves
      • 1 Fish
      • 1 Deer
      • 1 Cow
      • 1 Pig
      • 1 Horse
    • 2 Humans
      • 2 Men

The Wisdom of the Elders

Animals
  • Three Pigs - Mauled to death by two dogs off-camera, bodies shown.
  • Two Sick Dogs - Shot to death by either Arthur Morgan or John Marston to save a woman's pigs. Shared kills.
  • Three Sick Dogs - Shot to death by either Arthur Morgan or John Marston to save an unnamed man. Shared kills.
  • Two Sick Dogs - Shot to death by either Arthur Morgan or John Marston to save Kain. Shared kills.
  • Four Sick Dogs - Shot to death by either Arthur Morgan or John Marston to protect Butcher Creek.
    • Total - 14
Other
  • Two Unnamed Men - Poisoned in a mine off-screen, bodies shown.
  • "Shaman" - Shot to death by either Arthur Morgan or John Marston, optional.
    • Total - 3
Overall
  • Total - 17
    • 14 Animals
      • 11 Dogs
      • 3 Pigs
    • 3 Humans
      • 3 Men

To the Ends of the Earth

Named Characters
  • William - Shot to death by either Arthur Morgan or John Marston, optional.
    • Total - 1
Overall
  • Total - 1
    • 1 Human
      • 1 Man

Charlotte Balfour

Named Characters
  • Cal Balfour - Mauled to death by a bear off-screen one week prior, grave shown.
  • Charlotte Balfour - Shot to death by either Arthur Morgan or John Marston, optional. Shared kill.
    • Total - 2
Animals
  • Rabbit - Shot to death by either Arthur Morgan or John Marston. Shared kill. (Encounter #1)
  • Two Wolves - Shot to death by either Arthur Morgan or John Marston to protect Charlotte. Shared kills. (Encounter #1)
  • Rat - Shot to death by Arthur Morgan. (Encounter #2)
    • Total - 4
Overall
  • Total - 6
    • 4 Animals
      • 2 Wolves
      • 1 Rabbit
      • 1 Rat
    • 2 Humans
      • 1 Man
      • 1 Woman

Companion Activities

Lenny Summers

Five Finger Fillet
  • None
Rob a Stagecoach
Enemies
  • Unnamed Stagecoach Guard - Shot to death by either Arthur Morgan or Lenny Summers. Shared kill.
  • Five Unnamed United States Marshals - Shot to death by either Arthur Morgan or Lenny Summers. Shared kills.
    • Total - 6
Animals
  • Four Stagecoach Horses - Shot to death by Arthur Morgan, optional.
  • Three United States Marshal Horses - Shot to death by Arthur Morgan, optional.
    • Total - 7
Other
  • Two Unknown Men - Killed by Lenny Summers for murdering his father off-screen, mentioned.
  • Mr. Summers - Beaten to death by two unknown men while they were drunk off-screen, mentioned.
  • Two Unnamed Stagecoach Drivers - Shot to death by either Arthur Morgan or Lenny Summers. Shared kills.
    • Total - 5
Overall
  • Total - 18
    • 11 Humans
      • 11 Men
    • 7 Animals
      • 7 Horses

Charles Smith

Go Hunting
Enemies
  • Unnamed Poacher - Strangled to death by Arthur Morgan, optional.
    • Total - 1
Animals
  • Bison - Shot to death by Arthur Morgan.
  • Five Bison - Shot to death by Arthur Morgan, optional.
  • Six Bison - Shot to death by poachers off-screen, bodies shown.
  • Two Poacher Horses - Shot to death by Arthur Morgan, optional.
    • Total - 14
Other
  • Unnamed Poacher - Shot in the chest by Charles Smith with a double barreled shotgun.
    • Total - 1
Overall
  • Total - 16
    • 14 Animals
      • 12 Bison
      • 2 Horses
    • 2 Human
      • 2 Men

Javier Escuella

Rob a Homestead
Named Characters
  • Pappy Porter - Shot to death by either Arthur Morgan or Javier Escuella. Shared kill.
  • Newt Porter - Shot to death by either Arthur Morgan or Javier Escuella. Shared kill.
  • Finney Porter - Shot to death by either Arthur Morgan or Javier Escuella. Shared kill.
  • Mal Porter - Shot to death by either Arthur Morgan or Javier Escuella. Shared kill.
  • Edie Porter - Shot to death by either Arthur Morgan or Javier Escuella. Shared kill.
    • Total - 5
Enemies
  • Two Unnamed Porter Family Members - Shot to death by either Arthur Morgan or Javier Escuella. Shared kills.
    • Total - 2
Animals
  • Two Horses - Shot to death by Arthur Morgan, optional.
    • Total - 2
Overall
  • Total - 9
    • 7 Humans
      • 6 Men
      • 1 Woman
    • 2 Animals
      • 2 Horses
Go Fishing
Animals
  • Steelhead Trout - Captured by Javier Escuella while fishing off-screen, mentioned.
  • At Least One Fish - Captured by Arthur Morgan.
    • Total - 2
Overall
  • Total - 2
    • 2 Animals
      • 2 Fish

Micah Bell

Five Finger Fillet
  • None
Rob a Stagecoach
Enemies
  • Four Unnamed Boles Overland Stagecoach Guards - Shot to death by either Arthur Morgan, Bill Williamson, or Micah Bell III. Shared kills.
    • Total - 4
Animals
  • Four Horses - Blown up with a stick of dynamite planted by Micah Bell III that was shot by Arthur Morgan. Shared kills.
    • Total - 4
Other
  • Unnamed Boles Overland Guard - Killed by Micah Bell III off-screen in a "boating accident", mentioned.
  • Two Unnamed Stagecoach Drivers - Blown up with a stick of dynamite planted by Micah Bell III that was shot by Arthur Morgan. Shared kills.
    • Total - 3
Overall
  • Total - 11
    • 7 Humans
      • 7 Men
    • 4 Animals
      • 4 Horses

Tilly Jackson

Dominoes
  • None

Sean MacGuire

Social Calls with Mr. MacGuire
Enemies
  • Unnamed Gang Member - Shot to death by Sean MacGuire.
  • Four Unknown Gang Members - Shot to death by either Arthur Morgan or Sean MacGuire. Shared kills.
  • Unnamed Gang Member - Shot to death by Arthur Morgan, optional.
    • Total - 6
Overall
  • Total - 6
    • 6 Humans
      • 6 Men
Rob a Stagecoach
Named Characters
  • Laurence - Shot to death by either Arthur Morgan or Sean MacGuire. Shared kill.
  • Harry - Shot to death by either Arthur Morgan or Sean MacGuire. Shared kill.
    • Total - 2
Enemies
  • Four Unnamed Boles Overland Guards - Shot to death by either Arthur Morgan or Sean MacGuire. Shared kills.
    • Total - 4
Overall
  • Total - 6
    • 6 Humans
      • 6 Men

Kieran Duffy

Go Fishing
Animals
  • At Least One Fish - Captured by Arthur Morgan and presumably eaten off-screen, optional. (Area One)
  • At Least Two Fish - Captured by Arthur Morgan and presumably eaten off-screen, optional. (Area Two)
  • Legendary Bluegill - Captured by Arthur Morgan and presumably eaten or stuffed off-screen.
    • Total - 4
Other
  • Both of Kieran Duffy's Parents - Died of Cholera off-screen, mentioned.
    • Total - 2
Overall
  • Total - 6
    • 4 Animals
      • 4 Fish
    • 2 Humans
      • 1 Man
      • 1 Woman

Bill Williamson

Rob a Stagecoach
Enemies
  • Six Unnamed Stagecoach Guards - Shot to death by either Arthur Morgan or Bill Williamson. Shared kills.
    • Total - 6
Overall
  • Total - 6
    • 6 Humans
      • 6 Men

Simon Pearson

Go Hunting
Animals
  • Five Crawfish - Captured by Arthur Morgan and Simon Pearson. Shared kills.
  • Three Alligators - Shot to death by Arthur Morgan, optional.
    • Total - 8
Overall
  • Total - 8
    • 8 Animals
      • 8 Fish
      • 3 Alligators

Uncle

Go Rustling
Named Characters
  • Squears - Shot to death by Arthur Morgan, optional.
    • Total - 1
Enemies
  • Two Unnamed Cow Rustlers - Shot to death by Arthur Morgan, optional.
    • Total - 2
Overall
  • Total - 3
    • 3 Humans
      • 3 Men

Bounty Hunting

Ellie Anne Swan

Named Characters
  • Frank Swan - Murdered by Ellie Anne Swan off-screen, mentioned.
  • Henry Swan - Murdered by Ellie Anne Swan off-screen, mentioned.
  • Howie Swan - Murdered by Ellie Anne Swan off-screen, mentioned.
  • Willie Swan - Murdered by Ellie Anne Swan off-screen, mentioned.
    • Total - 4
Other
  • Unnamed Man - Either shot to death by Arthur Morgan or John Marston or stabbed in the throat by Ellie Anne Swan.
  • Ellie Anne Swan's Mother - Murdered by Ellie Anne Swan off-screen, mentioned.
    • Total - 2
Overall
  • Total - 6
    • 6 Humans
      • 5 Men
      • 1 Woman

Joshua Brown

Enemies
  • Four Unnamed Bounty Hunters - Shot to death by either Arthur Morgan or John Marston. Shared kills.
    • Total - 4
Animals
  • Three Horses - Shot to death by either Arthur Morgan or John Marston, optional. Shared kills.
    • Total - 3
Overall
  • Total - 7
    • 4 Humans
      • 4 Men
    • 3 Animals
      • 3 Horses

Bart Cavanaugh

Named Characters
  • Bart Cavanaugh - Shot to death by John Marston, optional.
    • Total - 1
Enemies
  • Three Unnamed Laramie Gang Members - Shot to death by John Marston, optional.
    • Total - 3
Animals
  • Four Laramie Gang Horses - Shot to death by John Marston, optional.
    • Total - 4
Overall
  • Total - 8
    • 4 Humans
      • 4 Men
    • 4 Animals
      • 4 Horses

Mark Johnson

Named Characters
  • Mark Johnson - Eventually hanged by the town of Rhodes.
    • Total - 1
Enemies
  • Three of Mark Johnson's Friends - Shot to death by either Arthur Morgan or John Marston. Shared kills.
    • Total - 3
Animals
  • Mark Johnson's Horse - Shot to death by either Arthur Morgan or John Marston, optional. Shared kill.
  • Three Horses - Shot to death by either Arthur Morgan or John Marston, optional. Shared kills.
    • Total - 4
Other
  • Mark Johnson's Wife - Shot to death by either Arthur Morgan or John Marston, optional. Shared kill.
    • Total - 1
Overall
  • Total - 9
    • 5 Humans
      • 4 Men
      • 1 Woman
    • 4 Animals
      • 4 Horses

Robbie LaidLaw

Named Characters
  • Robbie LaidLaw - Shot to death by John Marston, optional.
    • Total - 1
Enemies
  • One of Robbie's Men - Shot to death by John Marston, optional.
    • Total - 1
Overall
  • Total - 2
    • 2 Humans
      • 2 Men

Camille de Millemont

Named Characters
  • Camille de Millemont - Either shot to death by either Arthur Morgan or John Marston or eventually hanged by the town of Rhodes. Shared kill.
    • Total - 1
Enemies
  • Three Unnamed Lemoyne Raiders Gang Members - Shot to death by either Arthur Morgan or John Marston. Shared kills. (Camp)
  • Three Unnamed Lemoyne Raiders Gang Members - Shot to death by either Arthur Morgan or John Marston. Shared kills. (Ambush)
    • Total - 6
Animals
  • Seven Lemoyne Raiders Horses - Shot to death by either Arthur Morgan or John Marston. Shared kills.
    • Total - 7
Other
  • Unnamed Mail Carrier - Murdered by Camille de Millemont off-screen, mentioned.
    • Total - 1
Overall
  • Total - 15
    • 8 Humans
      • 8 Men
    • 7 Animals
      • 7 Horses

Lindsey Wofford

Named Characters
  • Lindsey Wofford - Shot to death by either Arthur Morgan or John Marston, optional.
    • Total - 1
Enemies
  • Ten Unnamed Lemoyne Raiders Gang Members - Shot to death by either Arthur Morgan or John Marston, optional. (Fort)
  • Three Unnamed Bounty Hunters - Shot to death by either Arthur Morgan or John Marston. (Ambush)
    • Total - 13
Animals
  • Three Bounty Hunter Horses - Shot to death by either Arthur Morgan or John Marston, optional. (Ambush)
    • Total - 3
Overall
  • Total - 17
    • 14 Humans
      • 14 Men
    • 3 Animals
      • 3 Horses

Elias Green

Named Characters
  • Elias Green - Either shot to death by John Marston or eventually hanged by the town of Blackwater.
    • Total - 1
Enemies
  • Four Unnamed Skinner Brothers Gang Members - Shot to death by John Marston.
    • Total - 4
Other
  • Six Unknown People - Murdered by Elias Green off-screen, mentioned.
  • Nine Unknown People - Murdered by Elias Green off-screen, bodies shown.
    • Total - 15
Overall
  • Total - 20
    • 15 Humans
      • 15 Victims of Unknown Gender
      • 5 Men

Otis Skinner

Named Characters
  • Otis Skinner - Either shot to death by John Marston or eventually hanged by the town of Blackwater.
    • Total - 1
Enemies
  • Seven Unnamed Skinner Brothers Gang Members - Shot to death by John Marston. (Camp)
  • Three Unnamed Skinner Brothers Gang Members - Shot to death by John Marston. (Ambush)
    • Total - 10
Animals
  • Three Skinner Brothers Horses - Shot to death by John Marston, optional. (Ambush)
  • Skinner Brothers Dog - Shot to death by John Marston. (Camp)
    • Total - 4
Other
  • Unnamed Pelt Hunter - Skinned alive by Otis Skinner off-screen, mentioned.
    • Total - 1
Overall
  • Total - 16
    • 12 Humans
      • 12 Men
    • 4 Animals
      • 3 Horses
      • 1 Dog

Herman Zizendorf

  • None

Esteban Cortez

Named Characters
  • Esteban Cortez - Either shot to death by John Marston or executed by Sheriff Sam Freeman off-screen.
    • Total - 1
Enemies
  • Ten Unnamed Del Lobo Gang Members - Shot to death by John Marston.
    • Total - 10
Animals
  • Three Del Lobo Horses - Shot to death by John Marston, optional.
    • Total - 3
Overall
  • Total - 14
    • 11 Humans
      • 11 Men
    • 3 Animals
      • 3 Horses

Joaquín Arroyo

Named Characters
  • Joaquín Arroyo - Executed by Sheriff Sam Freeman off-screen.
    • Total - 1
Enemies
  • Two Unnamed Del Lobo Gang Members - Shot to death by John Marston. (Solomon's Frolly)
  • Unnamed Del Lobo Gang Member - Shot to death by John Marston, optional. (Solomon's Frolly)
  • Two Unnamed Del Lobo Gang Members - Shot to death by John Marston. (Train)
    • Total - 5
Animals
  • Two Del Lobo Horses - Shot to death by John Marston, optional. (Solomon's Frolly)
  • Two Del Lobo Horses - Shot to death by John Marston, optional. (Train)
  • Joaquín Arroyo's Horse - Shot to death by John Marston, optional. (Train)
    • Total - 5
Other
  • Unknown Person - Murdered by Joaquín Arroyo off-screen, mentioned.
    • Total - 1
Overall
  • Total - 12
    • 7 Humans
      • 6 Men
      • 1 Victim of Unknown Gender
    • 5 Animals
      • 5 Horses

Challenges

Banditry

Rank 1
Other
  • Five Unknown People - Shot to death by either Arthur Morgan or John Marston after robbing them. Shared kills.
    • Total - 5
Overall
  • Total - 5
    • 5 Humans
      • 5 Victims of Unknown Gender
Rank 2
  • None (Victims are entirely random)
Rank 3
Other
  • Four Unknown Shop Owners - Shot to death by either Arthur Morgan or John Marston after robbing them. Shared kills.
    • Total - 4
Overall
  • Total - 4
    • 4 Humans
      • 4 Victims of Unknown Gender
Rank 4
  • None (Victims are entirely random)
Rank 5
  • None (Murders are not required to receive a bounty and victims are random)
Rank 6
Other
  • Five Unknown People - Shot to death by either Arthur Morgan or John Marston to steal their horses. Shared kills.
    • Total - 5
Overall
  • Total - 5
    • 5 Humans
      • 5 Victims of Unknown Gender
Rank 7
  • None (The amount of money each person has is too random to count)
Rank 8
  • None (Victims are entirely random)
Rank 9
Other
  • Three Unknown People - Hogtied and left on the tracks by either Arthur Morgan or John Marston to eventually be run over by a train. Shared kills.
    • Total - 3
Overall
  • Total - 3
    • 3 Humans
      • 3 Victims of Unknown Gender
Rank 10
  • None (Victims are entirely random)

Explorer

Rank 1
  • None (No Kills Required)
Rank 2
  • None (No Kills Required)
Rank 3
  • None (No Kills Required)
Rank 4
  • None (No Kills Required)
Rank 5
  • None (No Kills Required)
Rank 6
  • None (No Kills Required)
Rank 7
  • None (No Kills Required)
Rank 8
  • None (No Kills Required)
Rank 9
  • None (No Kills Required)
Rank 10
  • None (No Kills Required)

Gambler

Rank 1
  • None (Victims are Entirely Random)
Rank 2
  • None (Victims are Entirely Random)
Rank 3
  • None (Victims are Entirely Random)
Rank 4
  • None (Victims are Entirely Random)
Rank 5
  • None (Victims are Entirely Random)
Rank 6
  • None (Victims are Entirely Random)
Rank 7
  • None (Victims are Entirely Random)
Rank 8
  • None (Victims are Entirely Random)
Rank 9
  • None (Victims are Entirely Random)
Rank 10
  • None (Victims are Entirely Random)

Herbalist

Rank 1
  • None (No Kills Required)
Rank 2
  • None (No Kills Required)
Rank 3
  • None (No Kills Required)
Rank 4
  • None (No Kills Required)
Rank 5
  • None (No Kills Required)
Rank 6
  • None (No Kills Required)
Rank 7
  • None (No Kills Required)
Rank 8
  • None (No Kills Required)
Rank 9
  • None (No Kills Required)
Rank 10
  • None (No Kills Required)

Horseman

Rank 1
Animals
  • Five Rabbits - Shot to death by either Arthur Morgan or John Marston. Shared kills.
    • Total - 5
Overall
  • Total - 5
    • 5 Animals
      • 5 Rabbits
Rank 2
  • None (No Kills Required)
Rank 3
  • None (No Kills Required)
Rank 4
Other
  • Unknown Person - Dragged to death by either Arthur Morgan or John Marston while riding their horse. Shared kill.
    • Total - 1
Overall
  • Total - 1
    • 1 Human
      • 1 Victim of Unknown Gender
Rank 5
Animals
  • Five Unknown Animals - Ran over by either Arthur Morgan or John Marston while riding their horse. Shared kills.
    • Total - 5
Overall
  • Total - 5
    • 5 Animals
      • 5 Animals of Unknown Species
Rank 6
  • None (No Kills Required)
Rank 7
Enemies
  • Seven Unknown People - Shot to death by either Arthur Morgan or John Marston while riding their horse. Shared kills.
    • Total - 7
Other
  • Total - 7
    • 7 Humans
      • 7 Victims of Unknown Gender
Rank 8
Animals
  • Nine Unknown Animals - Shot to death by either Arthur Morgan or John Marston while riding their horse. Shared kills.
    • Total - 9
Overall
  • Total - 9
    • 9 Animals
      • 9 Animals of Unknown Species
Rank 9
  • None (No Kills Required)
Rank 10
Animals
  • Nine Horses - Shot to death by either Arthur Morgan or John Marston after taming them, optional. Shared kills.
    • Total - 9
Overall
  • Total - 9
    • 9 Animals
      • 9 Horses

Master Hunter

Rank 1
Animals
  • Three Deer - Shot to death by either Arthur Morgan or John Marston for their skins. Shared kills.
    • Total - 3
Overall
  • Total - 3
    • 3 Animals
      • 3 Deer
Rank 2
Animals
  • Three Rabbits - Shot to death by either Arthur Morgan or John Marston for their skins. Shared kills.
    • Total - 3
Overall
  • Total - 3
    • 3 Animals
      • 3 Rabbits
Rank 3
  • None (No Kills Required)
Rank 4
Animals
  • Five Unknown Animals - Shot to death by either Arthur Morgan or John Marston. Shared kills.
    • Total - 5
Overall
  • Total - 5
    • 5 Animals
      • 5 Animals of Unknown Species
Rank 5
Animals
  • Three Bears - Shot to death by either Arthur Morgan or John Marston for their skins. Shared kills.
    • Total - 3
Overall
  • Total - 3
    • 3 Animals
      • 3 Bears
Rank 6
Animals
  • Five Cougars - Shot to death by either Arthur Morgan or John Marston with a bow and arrows. Shared kills.
    • Total - 5
Overall
  • Total - 5
    • 5 Animals
      • 5 Cougars
Rank 7
Animals
  • Two Unknown Animals - Shot to death by either Arthur Morgan or John Marston. Shared kills.
    • Total - 2
Overall
  • Total - 2
    • 2 Animals
      • 2 Animals of Unknown Species
Rank 8
Animals
  • Three Fish - Captured by either Arthur Morgan or John Marston. Shared kills.
    • Total - 3
Overall
  • Total - 3
    • 3 Animals
      • 3 Fish
Rank 9
Animals
  • Opossum - Shot to death by either Arthur Morgan or John Marston while it was playing dead. Shared kill.
    • Total - 1
Overall
  • Total - 1
    • 1 Animal
      • 1 Opossum
Rank 10
Named Characters
  • Giaguaro (Panther) - Shot to death by either Arthur Morgan or John Marston. Shared kill.
    • Total - 1
Overall
  • Total - 1
    • 1 Animal
      • 1 Panther

Sharpshooter

Rank 1
Animals
  • Three Birds - Shot to death by either Arthur Morgan or John Marston while they were flying. Shared kills.
    • Total - 3
Overall
  • Total - 3
    • 3 Animals
      • 3 Birds
Rank 2
Animals
  • Two Unknown Animals - Shot to death by either Arthur Morgan or John Marston. Shared kills.
    • Total - 2
Overall
  • Total - 2
    • 2 Animals
      • 2 Animals of Unknown Species
Rank 3
Animals
  • Five Birds - Shot to death by either Arthur Morgan or John Marston while they were flying. Shared kills.
    • Total - 5
Overall
  • Total - 5
    • 5 Animals
      • 5 Birds
Rank 4
Enemies
  • Unknown Person - Stabbed with an axe thrown by either Arthur Morgan or John Marston. Shared kill.
    • Total - 1
Overall
  • Total - 1
    • 1 Human
      • 1 Victim of Unknown Gender
Rank 5
Animals
  • Six Unknown Animals - Shot to death by either Arthur Morgan or John Marston. Shared kills.
    • Total - 6
Overall
  • Total - 6
    • 6 Animals
      • 6 Animals of Unknown Species
Rank 6
Other
  • Unknown Person - Shot to death by either Arthur Morgan or John Marston with a sniper rifle. Shared kill.
    • Total - 1
Overall
  • Total - 1
    • 1 Human
      • 1 Victim of Unknown Gender
Rank 7
Other
  • Seven Unknown People - Shot in the head by either Arthur Morgan or John Marston. Shared kills.
    • Total - 7
Overall
  • Total - 7
    • 7 Humans
      • 7 Victims of Unknown Gender
Rank 8
Enemies
  • Three Unknown People - Shot to death by either Arthur Morgan or John Marston after disarming them.
    • Total - 3
Overall
  • Total - 3
    • 3 Humans
      • 3 Victims of Unknown Gender
Rank 9
Enemies
  • Three Unknown People - Shot to death by either Arthur Morgan or John Marston after shooting their hats off their heads.
    • Total - 3
Overall
  • Total - 3
    • 3 Humans
      • 3 Victims of Unknown Gender
Rank 10
Animals
  • Three Birds - Shot to death by either Arthur Morgan or John Marston with a sniper rifle. Shared kills.
    • Total - 3
Overall
  • Total - 3
    • 3 Animals
      • 3 Birds

Survivalist

Rank 1
Animals
  • Three Bluegill Fish - Captured by either Arthur Morgan or John Marston. Shared kills.
    • Total - 3
Overall
  • Total - 3
    • 3 Animals
      • 3 Fish
Rank 2
Animals
  • Five Unknown Animals - Shot to death by either Arthur Morgan or John Marston. Shared kills.
    • Total - 5
Overall
  • Total - 5
    • 5 Animals
      • 5 Animals of Unknown Species
Rank 3
Animals
  • Five Unknown Animals - Shot to death by either Arthur Morgan or John Marston with a varmint rifle. Shared kills.
    • Total - 5
Overall
  • Total - 5
    • 5 Animals
      • 5 Animals of Unknown Species
Rank 4
  • None (No kills required)
Rank 5
Animals
  • Fish - Captured by either Arthur Morgan or John Marston. Shared kills.
    • Total - 1
Overall
  • Total - 1
    • 1 Animal
      • 1 Fish
Rank 6
Animals
  • Five Unknown Animals - Shot to death by either Arthur Morgan or John Marston. Shared kills.
  • Five Unknown Animals - Killed by other animals off-screen, bodies shown.
    • Total - 10
Overall
  • Total - 10
    • 10 Animals
      • 10 Animals of Unknown Species
Rank 7
Animals
  • Eight Unknown Animals - Shot to death by either Arthur Morgan or John Marston with a bow and arrows. Shared kills.
    • Total - 8
Overall
  • Total - 8
    • 8 Animals
      • 8 Animals of Unknown Species
Rank 8
  • None (No kills required)
Rank 9
Animals
  • Fish - Captured by either Arthur Morgan or John Marston. Shared kills.
    • Total - 1
Overall
  • Total - 1
    • 1 Animal
      • 1 Fish
Rank 10
Animals
  • 15 Fish - Captured by either Arthur Morgan or John Marston. Shared kills.
    • Total - 15
Overall
  • Total - 15
    • 15 Animals
      • 15 Fish

Weapons Expert

Rank 1
Enemies
  • Three Unknown People - Stabbed to death by either Arthur Morgan or John Marston with a knife. Shared kills.
    • Total - 3
Overall
  • Total - 3
    • 3 Humans
      • 3 Victims of Unknown Gender
Rank 2
Enemies
  • Three Unknown People - Stabbed with knives thrown by either Arthur Morgan or John Marston. Shared kills.
    • Total - 3
Overall
  • Total - 3
    • 3 Humans
      • 3 Victims of Unknown Gender
Rank 3
Animals
  • Three Birds - Stabbed with a tomahawk thrown by either Arthur Morgan or John Marston. Shared kills.
    • Total - 3
Overall
  • Total - 3
    • 3 Animals
      • 3 Birds
Rank 4
Enemies
  • Ten Unknown People - Shot to death by either Arthur Morgan or John Marston with a shotgun. Shared kills.
    • Total - 10
Overall
  • Total - 10
    • 10 Humans
      • 10 Victims of Unknown Gender
Rank 5
Enemies
  • Five Unknown People - Stabbed with knives thrown by either Arthur Morgan or John Marston. Shared kills.
    • Total - 5
Overall
  • Total - 5
    • 5 Humans
      • 5 Victims of Unknown Gender
Rank 6
Enemies
  • Four Unknown People - Blown up with dynamite thrown by either Arthur Morgan or John Marston. Shared kills.
    • Total - 4
Overall
  • Total - 4
    • 4 Humans
      • 4 Victims of Unknown Gender
Rank 7
Enemies
  • Four Unknown People - Stabbed with a tomahawk thrown by either Arthur Morgan or John Marston. Shared kills.
    • Total - 4
Overall
  • Total - 4
    • 4 Humans
      • 4 Victims of Unknown Gender
Rank 8
Enemies
  • 15 Unknown People - Shot to death by either Arthur Morgan or John Marston with a long-barreled sidearm. Shared kills.
    • Total - 15
Overall
  • Total - 15
    • 15 Humans
      • 15 Victims of Unknown Gender
Rank 9
Enemies
  • Nine Unknown People - Shot to death by either Arthur Morgan or John Marston with a bow and arrows. Shared kills.
    • Total - 9
Overall
  • Total - 9
    • 9 Humans
      • 9 Victims of Unknown Gender
Rank 10
Animals
  • Bear - Stabbed with knives thrown by either Arthur Morgan or John Marston. Shared kills.
    • Total - 1
Overall
  • Total - 1
    • 1 Animal
      • 1 Bear

Points of Interest

Lemoyne

Abandoned Church
Enemies
  • Five Unnamed Lemoyne Raiders Gang Members - Shot to death by either Arthur Morgan or John Marston. Shared kills.
    • Total - 5
Other
  • At Least One Unnamed Lemoyne Raider Gang Member - Accidentally blown up when he dropped a match onto gunpowder off-screen several years prior, mentioned.
    • Total - 1
Overall
  • Total - 6
    • 6 Humans
      • 6 Men
Bolger Glad
Named Characters
  • Major Wilkinson - Killed by an unknown person during an unknown battle of the Civil War off-screen, mentioned.
  • Major Smith - Killed by an unknown person during an unknown battle of the Civil War off-screen, mentioned.
    • Total - 2
Overall
  • Total - 2
    • 2 Humans
      • 2 Men
Braithewaites' Secret
Named Characters
  • Gertrude Braithewaite - Died of starvation off-screen somewhere between 1899 and 1907, skeleton shown.
    • Total - 1
Overall
  • Total - 1
    • 1 Human
      • 1 Woman
Gray's Secret
Named Characters
  • Tavish Gray - Died of a heart attack off-screen in 1895, body shown.
    • Total - 1
Overall
  • Total - 1
    • 1 Human
      • 1 Man
Painting in Cabin
Animals
  • Alligator - Died of unknown causes off-screen, body shown.
    • Total - 1
Overall
  • Total - 1
    • 1 Animal
      • 1 Alligator
Phonograph
  • None
Pleasance
Named Characters
  • Leora Yeatman - Shot to death by an unknown person off-screen in 1883, grave shown.
  • Jessie Yeatman - Either shot or stabbed to death by an unknown person off-screen in 1883, grave shown.
  • Asa Hawson - Either shot or stabbed to death by an unknown person off-screen in 1883, grave shown.
  • Amelia Curle - Shot in the head by an unknown person off-screen in 1883, grave shown.
  • Reginald Yeatman - Shot to death by an unknown person off-screen in 1883, grave shown.
  • Jimmy Hawson - Stabbed to death by an unknown person off-screen in 1883, grave shown.
  • Daniel Curley - Either shot or stabbed to death by an unknown person off-screen in 1883, grave shown.
  • Glen Yeatman - Stabbed to death by an unknown person off-screen in 1883, grave shown.
  • Curtis Baines - Either shot or stabbed to death by an unknown person off-screen in 1883, grave shown.
  • Edmund Tobin - Shot to death by an unknown person off-screen in 1883, grave shown.
    • Total - 10
Animals
  • Snake - Died of unknown causes off-screen, body shown.
    • Total - 1
Overall
  • Total - 11
    • 10 Humans
      • 6 Men
      • 4 Women
    • 1 Animal
      • 1 Snake
Tiny Church
  • None
Withered Arm
  • None (This man is most likely Deputy Archibald's uncle Reginald, so he won't be counted twice)

New Hanover

Abandoned Trading Post
  • None
Brush Fire
  • None
Fossilized Man
Other
  • Unnamed Man - Died of unknown causes off-screen several years prior, skeleton shown.
    • Total - 1
Overall
  • Total - 1
    • 1 Human
      • 1 Man
Manmade Mutant
Animals
  • At Least One Pig - Killed by an unknown person off-screen, severed head shown.
  • At Least One Vulture - Killed by an unknown person off-screen, wings shown.
  • At Least One Bear - Killed by an unknown person off-screen, heart mentioned in a note.
    • Total - 3
Other
  • Unnamed Man - Killed by an unknown person off-screen, body parts shown.
    • Total - 1
Overall
  • Total - 4
    • 3 Animals
      • 1 Pig
      • 1 Bird
      • 1 Bear
    • 1 Human
      • 1 Man
Meteor House
Other
  • Three Unnamed Men - Blown up when a meteorite struck their house off-screen, bodies shown.
    • Total - 3
Overall
  • Total - 3
    • 3 Humans
      • 3 Men
Meteorite
  • None
Oil Derrick
Named Characters
  • Mr. Varley - Burned alive with oil after the oil derrick exploded and then hit in the head with a falling log.
    • Total - 1
Overall
  • Total - 1
    • 1 Human
      • 1 Man
Old Tomb
  • None
Old World Scripts
  • None
Register Rock
  • None
Serpent Mound
  • None
Cave Painting
  • None
Trading Post
  • None
Trail Trees I
  • None
Trail Trees II
  • None
Trail Trees III
  • None
Trail Trees IV
  • None
Warped Tree
Other
  • Unnamed Man's Wife - Died of unknown causes off-screen, grave shown.
    • Total - 1
Overall
  • Total - 1
    • 1 Human
      • 1 Woman

Ambarino

Barrel Rider
Other
  • Unnamed Woman - Either drowned or succumbed to her injuries after riding in a barrel down a waterfall off-screen, body shown.
    • Total - 1
Overall
  • Total - 1
    • 1 Human
      • 1 Woman
Defaced Grave
Named Characters
  • Felix Hawley - Died of unknown causes off-screen in 1888, skeleton shown.
    • Total - 1
Overall
  • Total - 1
    • 1 Human
      • 1 Man
Face in Cliff
Other
  • Unnamed Man - Committed suicide by hanging himself off-screen, body shown.
    • Total - 1
Overall
  • Total - 1
    • 1 Human
      • 1 Man
Frozen Settler
Other
  • Unnamed Man - Frozen to death off-screen, body shown.
    • Total - 1
Overall
  • Total - 1
    • 1 Human
      • 1 Man
Mammoth
Animals
  • Mammoth - Died of unknown causes off-screen, skeleton shown.
    • Total - 1
Overall
  • Total - 1
    • 1 Animal
      • 1 Mammoth
Meditating Monk
Other
  • Unnamed Man - Shot to death by either Arthur Morgan or John Marston. Shared kill.
    • Total - 1
Overall
  • Total - 1
    • 1 Human
      • 1 Man
Mysterious Hill Home
  • None
Strange Statues
  • None

West Elizabeth

Circus Wagons
Other
  • Unnamed Female Conjoined Twins - Died of unknown causes off-screen, bodies shown.
    • Total - 2
Overall
  • Total - 2
    • 2 Humans
      • 2 Women
Faces in Trees
  • None
Flying Machine
Other
  • Unnamed Man - Fell to his death after trying to fly in a custom machine off-screen.
    • Total - 1
Overall
  • Total - 1
    • 1 Human
      • 1 Man
Giant Remains
Other
  • Unnamed Giant - Died of unknown causes off-screen, skeleton shown.
    • Total - 1
Overall
  • Total - 1
    • 1 Monster
      • 1 Giant
        • 1 Victims of Unknown Gender
Hermit Woman
Animals
  • Four Dogs - Shot to death by either Arthur Morgan or John Marston. Shared kills.
    • Total - 4
Other
  • Unnamed Witch - Shot to death by either Arthur Morgan or John Marston. Shared kill.
    • Total - 1
Overall
  • Total - 5
    • 4 Animals
      • 4 Dogs
    • 1 Monster
      • 1 Witch
        • 1 Woman
Hidden Tunnel
Other
  • Unnamed Man - Shot to death by either Arthur Morgan or John Marston. Shared kill.
    • Total - 1
Overall
  • Total - 1
    • 1 Human
      • 1 Man
Native Burial
Other
  • Three Unknown People - Died of unknown causes off-screen, skulls shown.
    • Total - 3
Overall
  • Total - 3
    • 3 Humans
      • 3 Victims of Unknown Gender
Obelisk
  • None
Pagan Ritual
Other
  • Unnamed Man - Killed by an unknown person off-screen, body shown.
    • Total - 1
Overall
  • Total - 1
    • 1 Human
      • 1 Man
Whale Bones
Animals
  • Whale - Died of unknown causes off-screen, skeleton shown.
    • Total - 1
Overall
  • Total - 1
    • 1 Animal
      • 1 Whale
Wickiup
  • None

New Austin

Crashed Airship
  • None
Donkey Lady
Other
  • Unnamed Woman - Died of unknown causes off-screen, skeleton shown.
    • Total - 1
Overall
  • Total - 1
    • 1 Human
      • 1 Woman
Jesuit Missionary
Named Characters
  • Rodolfo - Died of unknown causes off-screen, skeleton shown.
    • Total - 1
Overall
  • Total - 1
    • 1 Human
      • 1 Man
Sperm Whale Bones
Animals
  • Whale - Died of unknown causes off-screen, skeleton shown.
    • Total - 1
Overall
  • Total - 1
    • 1 Animal
      • 1 Whale

Random Encounters

O'Driscoll Boys

Prison Wagon Break
Enemies
  • Three Unnamed O'Driscoll Gang Members - Shot to death by either Arthur Morgan or John Marston. Shared kills.
  • Unnamed O'Driscoll Prisoner - Shot to death by either Arthur Morgan or John Marston, optional. Shared kill.
    • Total - 4
Animals
  • Two Horses - Shot to death by the three O'Driscoll gang members.
  • Three O'Driscoll Horses - Shot to death by either Arthur Morgan or John Marston, optional. Shared kills.
    • Total - 5
Other
  • Two Unnamed Lawmen - Shot to death by three unnamed O'Driscoll gang members, or optionally killed by either Arthur Morgan or John Marston. Shared kill.
    • Total - 2
Overall
  • Total - 11
    • 6 Humans
      • 6 Men
    • 5 Animals
      • 5 Horses
Stagecoach Robbery
Enemies
  • Two Unnamed O'Driscoll Gang Members - Shot to death by either Arthur Morgan or John Marston. Shared kills.
    • Total - 2
Animals
  • Four Stagecoach Horses - Shot to death by either Arthur Morgan or John Marston, optional. Shared kills.
  • Two O'Driscoll Horses - Shot to death by either Arthur Morgan or John Marston, optional. Shared kills.
    • Total - 6
Other
  • Unnamed Stagecoach Driver - Shot to death by either Arthur Morgan or John Marston, optional. Shared kill.
    • Total - 1
Overall
  • Total - 9
    • 6 Animals
      • 6 Horses
    • 3 Humans
      • 3 Men
Extortion
Enemies
  • Two Unnamed O'Driscoll Gang Members - Killed by either Arthur Morgan or John Marston. Shared kills.
    • Total - 2
Animals
  • Two O'Driscoll Horses - Shot to death by either Arthur Morgan or John Marston, optional. Shared kills.
    • Total - 2
Other
  • Unnamed Man - Optionally killed by either Arthur Morgan or John Marston or beaten to death by two unnamed O'Driscoll gang members if he's not saved by either Arthur or John.
    • Total - 1
Overall
  • Total - 5
    • 3 Humans
      • 3 Men
    • 2 Animals
      • 2 Horses
Train Robbery
Enemies
  • Three Unnamed O'Driscoll Gang Members - Shot to death by either Arthur Morgan or John Marston. Shared kills.
    • Total - 3
Animals
  • Three O'Driscoll Horses - Shot to death by either Arthur Morgan or John Marston, optional. Shared kills.
    • Total - 3
Other
  • Four Unnamed Train Passengers - Shot to death by either three O'Driscoll gang members if Arthur Morgan or John Marston does not save them in time or optionally shot to death by Arthur or John. Shared kills.
  • Four Unnamed Train Guards - Shot to death by three O'Driscoll gang members off-screen, bodies shown.
  • Unnamed Train Conductor - Shot to death by three O'Driscoll gang members off-screen, body shown.
    • Total - 9
Overall
  • Total - 15
    • 12 Humans
      • 12 Men
    • 3 Animals
      • 3 Horses
Road Ambush I
Enemies
  • Four Unnamed O'Driscoll Gang Members - Shot to death by either Arthur Morgan or John Marston. Shared kills.
    • Total - 4
Animals
  • Four O'Driscoll Horses - Shot to death by either Arthur Morgan or John Marston, optional. Shared kills.
    • Total - 4
Overall
  • Total - 8
    • 4 Humans
      • 4 Men
    • 4 Animals
      • 4 Horses
Road Ambush II
Enemies
  • Three Unnamed O'Driscoll Gang Members - Shot to death by either Arthur Morgan or John Marston. Shared kills.
    • Total - 3
Animals
  • Two O'Driscoll Stagecoach Horses - Shot to death by either Arthur Morgan or John Marston, optional. Shared kills.
    • Total - 2
Overall
  • Total - 5
    • 3 Humans
      • 3 Men
    • 2 Animals
      • 2 Horses
Bridge Ambush I
Enemies
  • Three Unnamed O'Driscoll Gang Members - Shot to death by either Arthur Morgan or John Marston. Shared kills.
    • Total - 3
Animals
  • Three O'Driscoll Horses - Shot to death by either Arthur Morgan or John Marston, optional. Shared kills.
    • Total - 3
Overall
  • Total - 6
    • 3 Humans
      • 3 Men
    • 3 Animals
      • 3 Horses
Bridge Ambush II
Enemies
  • Four Unnamed O'Driscoll Gang Members - Shot to death by either Arthur Morgan or John Marston. Shared kills.
    • Total - 4
Animals
  • Two O'Driscoll Horses - Shot to death by either Arthur Morgan or John Marston, optional. Shared kills.
    • Total - 2
Overall
  • Total - 6
    • 4 Humans
      • 4 Men
    • 2 Animals
      • 2 Horses
Bridge Barricade
Enemies
  • Five Unnamed O'Driscoll Gang Members - Shot to death by either Arthur Morgan or John Marston. Shared kills.
    • Total - 5
Animals
  • Three O'Driscoll Horses - Shot to death by either Arthur Morgan or John Marston, optional. Shared kills.
  • Two O'Driscoll Stagecoach Horses - Shot to death by either Arthur Morgan or John Marston, optional. Shared kills.
    • Total - 5
Overall
  • Total - 10
    • 5 Humans
      • 5 Men
    • 5 Animals
      • 5 Horses
Brawl at Keane's Saloon
Enemies
  • Three Unnamed O'Driscoll Gang Members - Shot to death by either Arthur Morgan or John Marston. Shared kills.
    • Total - 3
Animals
  • Three O'Driscoll Horses - Shot to death by either Arthur Morgan or John Marston, optional. Shared kills.
    • Total - 3
Overall
  • Total - 6
    • 3 Humans
      • 3 Men
    • 3 Animals
      • 3 Horses

Del Lobo Gang

Del Lobo Breakout
Named Characters
  • Sheriff Palmer - Either shot to death by an unnamed Del Lobo gang member if he's not saved by either Arthur Morgan or John Marston, or optionally shot to death by either Arthur or John. Shared kill.
    • Total - 1
Enemies
  • Three Unnamed Del Lobo Gang Members - Shot to death by either Arthur Morgan, John Marston, or the unnamed Armadillo sheriff. Shared kills.
  • Unnamed Del Lobo Prisoner - Shot to death by either Arthur Morgan, John Marston, or the unnamed Armadillo sheriff. Shared kills.
    • Total - 4
Animals
  • Four Del Lobo Horses - Shot to death by either Arthur Morgan or John Marston, optional. Shared kills.
    • Total - 4
Overall
  • Total - 9
    • 5 Humans
      • 5 Men
    • 4 Animals
      • 4 Horses
Town Terror
Enemies
  • Three Unnamed Del Lobo Gang Members - Shot to death by either Arthur Morgan or John Marston. Shared kills.
    • Total - 3
Animals
  • Three Del Lobo Horses - Shot to death by either Arthur Morgan or John Marston, optional. Shared kills.
    • Total - 3
Overall
  • Total - 6
    • 3 Animals
      • 3 Men
    • 3 animals
      • 3 Horses
Bar Fight
Enemies
  • Two Unnamed Del Lobo Gang Members - Shot to death by either Arthur Morgan or John Marston. Shared kills.
    • Total - 2
Animals
  • Two Del Lobo Horses - Shot to death by either Arthur Morgan or John Marston, optional. Shared kills.
    • Total - 2
Overall
  • Total - 4
    • 2 Humans
      • 2 Men
    • 2 Animals
      • 2 Horses
Ambush I
Enemies
  • Five Unnamed Del Lobo Gang Members - Shot to death by either Arthur Morgan or John Marston. Shared kills. (Between Riley's Charge and Two Crows)
    • Total - 5
Animals
  • Five Del Lobo Horses - Shot to death by either Arthur Morgan or John Marston, optional.
    • Total - 5
Overall
  • Total - 10
    • 5 Humans
      • 5 Men
    • 5 Animals
      • 5 Horses
Ambush II
Enemies
  • Five Unnamed Del Lobo Gang Members - Shot to death by either Arthur Morgan or John Marston. Shared kills. (Between Pleasance House and Twin Rocks)
    • Total - 5
Animals
  • Five Del Lobo Horses - Shot to death by either Arthur Morgan or John Marston, optional.
    • Total - 5
Overall
  • Total - 10
    • 5 Humans
      • 5 Men
    • 5 Animals
      • 5 Horses
Ambush III
Enemies
  • Five Unnamed Del Lobo Gang Members - Shot to death by either Arthur Morgan or John Marston. Shared kills. (Sea of Coronado Bridge)
    • Total - 5
Animals
  • Five Del Lobo Horses - Shot to death by either Arthur Morgan or John Marston, optional.
    • Total - 5
Overall
  • Total - 10
    • 5 Humans
      • 5 Men
    • 5 Animals
      • 5 Horses
Del Lobo Posse
Enemies
  • Five Unnamed Del Lobo Gang Members - Shot to death by either Arthur Morgan or John Marston. Shared kills.
    • Total - 5
Animals
  • Five Del Lobo Horses - Shot to death by either Arthur Morgan or John Marston, optional. Shared kills.
    • Total - 5
Overall
  • Total - 5
    • 5 Humans
      • 5 Men
    • 5 Animals
      • 5 Horses
Venter's Place Party
Named Characters
  • Jorge (Del Lobo) - Shot to death by either Arthur Morgan or John Marston. Shared kill.
  • Marco (Del Lobo) - Shot to death by either Arthur Morgan or John Marston. Shared kill.
    • Total - 2
Enemies
  • Unnamed Del Lobo Gang Member - Shot to death by either Arthur Morgan or John Marston. Shared kill.
    • Total - 1
Animals
  • Three Del Lobo Horses - Shot to death by either Arthur Morgan or John Marston, optional. Shared kills.
    • Total - 3
Other
  • Unnamed Prostitute - Shot to death by either Arthur Morgan or John Marston, optional. Shared kill.
    • Total - 1
Overall
  • Total - 7
    • 4 Humans
      • 3 Men
      • 1 Woman
    • 3 Animals
      • 3 Horses
Train Holdup
Enemies
  • Three Unnamed Del Lobo Gang Members - Shot to death by either Arthur Morgan or John Marston. Shared kills.
    • Total - 3
Animals
  • Three Del Lobo Horses - Shot to death by either Arthur Morgan or John Marston, optional. Shared kills.
    • Total - 3
Other
  • Four Unnamed Men - Shot to death by either three Del Lobo gang members if Arthur Morgan or John Marston does not save them in time or optionally shot to death by Arthur or John. Shared kills.
    • Total - 4
Overall
  • Total - 10
    • 7 Humans
      • 7 Men
    • 3 Animals
      • 3 Horses
Del Lobo Execution
Named Characters
  • Sheriff Samuel "Sam" Freeman - Shot to death by either Arthur Morgan or John Marston. (Player's Choice, Optional)
    • Total - 1
Enemies
  • Unnamed Del Lobo Gang Member - Executed by Sheriff Sam Freeman by shooting him in the chest or optionally by Arthur Morgan or John Marston.
    • Total - 1
Other
  • Unnamed Deputy - Shot to death by either Arthur Morgan or John Marston. (Player's Choice, Optional)
    • Total - 1
Overall
  • Total - 3
    • 3 Humans
      • 3 Men

Laramie Gang

Ambush I
Enemies
  • Three Unnamed Laramie Gang Members - Shot to death by John Marston for trying to steal his horse.
    • Total - 3
Animals
  • Two Laramie Horses - Shot to death by John Marston, optional.
    • Total - 2
Overall
  • Total - 5
    • 3 Humans
      • 3 Men
    • 2 Animals
      • 2 Horses
Ambush II
Enemies
  • Two Unnamed Laramie Gang Members - Shot to death by John Marston.
    • Total - 2
Animals
  • Two Laramie Horses - Shot to death by John Marston, optional.
    • Total - 2
Overall
  • Total - 4
    • 2 Humans
      • 2 Men
    • 2 Animals
      • 2 Horses
Hostage Situation
Enemies
  • Two Unnamed Laramie Gang Members - Shot to death by John Marston to save the unnamed woman's husband.
    • Total - 2
Animals
  • Two Laramie Horses - Shot to death by John Marston, optional.
    • Total - 2
Other
  • Unnamed Man - Shot to death by John Marston. (Player's Choice, Optional)
  • Unnamed Woman - Shot to death by John Marston. (Player's Choice, Optional)
    • Total - 2
Overall
  • Total - 6
    • 4 Humans
      • 3 Men
      • 1 Woman
    • 2 Animals
      • 2 Horses
Wagon Holdup
Enemies
  • Two Unnamed Laramie Gang Members - Shot to death by John Marston to save a settler couple.
    • Total - 2
Animals
  • Two Laramie Horses - Shot to death by John Marston, optional.
  • Two Stagecoach Horses - Shot to death by John Marston, optional.
    • Total - 4
Other
  • Unnamed Man - Shot to death by John Marston. (Player's Choice, Optional)
  • Unnamed Woman - Shot to death by John Marston. (Player's Choice, Optional)
    • Total - 2
Overall
  • Total - 8
    • 4 Humans
      • 3 Men
      • 1 Woman
    • 4 Animals
      • 4 Horses
Cattle Killing
Enemies
  • Two Unnamed Laramie Gang Members - Shot to death by John Marston to save a settler couple.
    • Total - 2
Animals
  • Two Laramie Horses - Shot to death by John Marston.
  • Cow - Shot to death by one of the Laramie gang members off-screen, body shown.
    • Total - 3
Other
  • Two Unnamed Geddes Farm Workers - Shot to death by John Marston. (Player's Choice, Optional)
    • Total - 2
Overall
  • Total - 7
    • 4 Humans
      • 4 Men
    • 3 Animals
      • 2 Horses
      • 1 Cow

Lemoyne Raiders

Cavalry Charge
Enemies
  • 12 Unnamed Lemoyne Raiders Gang Members - Shot to death by either Arthur Morgan or John Marston. Shared kills.
    • Total - 12
Animals
  • 12 Lemoyne Raiders Horses - Shot to death by either Arthur Morgan or John Marston, optional. Shared kills.
    • Total - 12
Overall
  • Total - 24
    • 12 Humans
      • 12 Men
    • 12 Animals
      • 12 Horses
Gatling Gun Ambush
Enemies
  • Six Unnamed Lemoyne Raiders Gang Members - Shot to death by either Arthur Morgan or John Marston. Shared kills.
    • Total - 6
Animals
  • Three Lemoyne Raiders Horses - Shot to death by either Arthur Morgan or John Marston, optional. Shared kills.
    • Total - 3
Overall
  • Total - 9
    • 6 Humans
      • 6 Men
    • 3 Animals
      • 3 Horses
Exploding Wagon Ambush
Enemies
  • Five Unnamed Lemoyne Raiders Gang Members - Shot to death by either Arthur Morgan or John Marston. Shared kills.
    • Total - 5
Overall
  • Total - 5
    • All Men
Bridge Ambush
Enemies
  • Six Unnamed Lemoyne Raiders Gang Members - Shot to death by either Arthur Morgan or John Marston. Shared kills.
    • Total - 6
Animals
  • Two Lemoyne Raider Horses - Shot to death by either Arthur Morgan or John Marston, optional. Shared kills.
    • Total - 2
Overall
  • Total - 8
    • 6 Humans
      • 6 Men
    • 2 Animals
      • 2 Horses
Lone Lemoyne Raider
Enemies
  • Unnamed Lemoyne Raider - Shot to death by either Arthur Morgan or John Marston. Shared kill.
    • Total - 1
Animals
  • Lemoyne Raider's Horse - Shot to death by either Arthur Morgan or John Marston, optional. Shared kill.
    • Total - 1
Overall
  • Total - 2
    • 1 Human
      • 1 Man
    • 1 Animal
      • 1 Horse
Arson and Vandalism at Saint Denis City Hall
Enemies
  • Three Unnamed Lemoyne Raiders Gang Members - Shot to death by either Arthur Morgan or John Marston. Shared kills.
    • Total - 3
Animals
  • Three Lemoyne Raiders Horses - Shot to death by either Arthur Morgan or John Marston, optional. Shared kills.
    • Total - 3
Overall
  • Total - 6
    • 3 Humans
      • 3 Men
    • 3 Animals
      • 3 Horses
Abducted Policeman
Enemies
  • Four Unnamed Lemoyne Raiders Gang Members - Shot to death by either Arthur Morgan or John Marston Marston. Shared kills.
    • Total - 4
Animals
  • Two Lemoyne Raider Horses - Shot to death by either Arthur Morgan or John, optional. Shared kills.
    • Total - 2
Other
  • Unnamed Deputy - Either shot to death by an unnamed Lemoyne Raider if he is not saved by either Arthur Morgan or John Marston in time, or optionally killed by either Arthur or John. Shared kill.
    • Total - 1
Overall
  • Total - 7
    • 5 Humans
      • 5 Men
    • 2 Animals
      • 2 Horses
Abducted Tax Collectors I
Enemies
  • Four Unnamed Lemoyne Raiders Gang Members - Shot to death by either Arthur Morgan or John Marston. Shared kills.
    • Total - 4
Animals
  • Two Lemoyne Raider Horses - Shot to death by either Arthur Morgan or John Marston, optional. Shared kills.
    • Total - 2
Other
  • Unnamed Tax Collector - Either stabbed to death by an unnamed Lemoyne Raider if he is not saved by either Arthur Morgan or John Marston in time, or optionally killed by either Arthur or John. Shared kill.
    • Total - 1
Overall
  • Total - 7
    • 5 Humans
      • 5 Men
    • 2 Animals
      • 2 Horses
Abducted Tax Collectors II
Enemies
  • Two Unnamed Lemoyne Raiders Gang Members - Shot to death by either Arthur Morgan or John Marston. Shared kills.
    • Total - 2
Animals
  • Two Lemoyne Raider Horses - Shot to death by either Arthur Morgan or John Marston, optional. Shared kills.
    • Total - 2
Other
  • Unnamed Tax Collector - Shot in the head by an unnamed Lemoyne Raider.
  • Unnamed Tax Collector - Either shot in the head by an unnamed Lemoyne Raider if he is not saved by either Arthur Morgan or John Marston in time, or optionally killed by either Arthur or John. Shared kill.
    • Total - 2
Overall
  • Total - 6
    • 4 Humans
      • 4 Men
    • 2 Animals
      • 2 Horses
Prison Wagon Break
Enemies
  • Three Unnamed Lemoyne Raiders Gang Members - Shot to death by either Arthur Morgan or John Marston. Shared kills.
  • Unnamed Lemoyne Raider Prisoner - Shot to death by either Arthur Morgan or John Marston, optional. Shared kill.
    • Total - 4
Animals
  • Three Lemoyne Raider Horses - Shot to death by either Arthur Morgan or John Marston, optional. Shared kills.
  • Two Stagecoach Horses - Shot to death by either Arthur Morgan or John Marston, optional. Shared kills.
    • Total - 5
Other
  • Two Unnamed Lawmen - Either shot to death by three Lemoyne Raiders gang members, or optionally killed by either Arthur Morgan or John Marston. Shared kill.
    • Total - 2
Overall
  • Total - 11
    • 6 Humans
      • 6 Men
    • 5 Animals
      • 5 Horses
Brawls at Rhodes Parlour House I
Enemies
  • Two Unnamed Lemoyne Raiders Gang Members - Beaten to death by either Arthur Morgan or John Marston inside the bar. Shared kills.
    • Total - 2
Overall
  • Total - 2
    • 2 Humans
      • 2 Men
Brawls at Rhodes Parlour House II
Enemies
  • Unnamed Lemoyne Raider Gang Member - Beaten to death by either Arthur Morgan or John Marston outside the bar. Shared kill.
    • Total - 1
Overall
  • Total - 1
    • 1 Human
      • 1 Men
Lemoyne Raiders duo beat man outside Rhodes Parlour House
Enemies
  • Two Unnamed Lemoyne Raiders Gang Members - Beaten to death by either Arthur Morgan or John Marston. Shared kills.
    • Total - 2
Animals
  • Two Lemoyne Raider Horses - Shot to death by either Arthur Morgan or John Marston, optional. Shared kills.
    • Total - 2
Other
  • Unnamed Man - Beaten to death by two Lemoyne Raiders gang members if they are not stopped in time by either Arthur Morgan or John Marston, or optionally killed by either Arthur or John. Shared kill.
    • Total - 1
Overall
  • Total - 5
    • 3 Humans
      • 3 Men
    • 2 Animals
      • 2 Horses
Train Robbery
Enemies
  • Five Unnamed Lemoyne Raiders Gang Members - Shot to death by either Arthur Morgan or John Marston. Shared kills.
    • Total - 5
Animals
  • Five Lemoyne Raider Horses - Shot to death by either Arthur Morgan or John Marston, optional. Shared kills.
    • Total - 5
Other
  • Three Unnamed Train Guards - Shot to death by five Lemoyne Raiders gang members off-screen, bodies shown.
  • Five Unnamed Men - Shot to death by either five Lemoyne Raiders gang members if Arthur Morgan or John Marston does not save them in time or optionally shot to death by Arthur or John. Shared kills.
    • Total - 8
Overall
  • Total - 18
    • 13 Humans
      • 13 Men
    • 5 Animals
      • 5 Horses
Gun Deal Gone Wrong
Enemies
  • Two Unnamed Lemoyne Raiders Gang Members - Shot to death by either Arthur Morgan or John Marston. Shared kills.
  • Two Unnamed Gun Smugglers - Shot to death by either Arthur Morgan or John Marston, or possibly by two Lemoyne Raiders gang members. Shared kills.
    • Total - 4
Animals
  • Two Lemoyne Raiders Horses - Shot to death by either Arthur Morgan or John Marston, optional. Shared kills.
  • Two Gun Smuggler Horses - Shot to death by either Arthur Morgan or John Marston, optional. Shared kills.
    • Total - 4
Overall
  • Total - 8
    • 4 Humans
      • 4 Men
    • 4 Animals
      • 4 Horses
Successful Gun Deal
Enemies
  • Two Unnamed Lemoyne Raiders Gang Members - Shot to death by either Arthur Morgan or John Marston. Shared kills.
  • Two Unnamed Gun Smugglers - Shot to death by either Arthur Morgan or John Marston.
    • Total - 4
Animals
  • Two Lemoyne Raiders Horses - Shot to death by either Arthur Morgan or John Marston, optional. Shared kills.
  • Two Gun Smuggler Horses - Shot to death by either Arthur Morgan or John Marston, optional. Shared kills.
    • Total - 4
Overall
  • Total - 8
    • 4 Humans
      • 4 Men
    • 4 Animals
      • 4 Horses
Gang Intimidation I
Enemies
  • Three Unnamed Lemoyne Raiders Gang Members - Shot to death by either Arthur Morgan or John Marston. Shared kills. (Rhodes)
    • Total - 3
Overall
  • Total - 3
    • 3 Humans
      • 3 Men
Gang Intimidation II
Enemies
  • Three Unnamed Lemoyne Raiders Gang Members - Shot to death by either Arthur Morgan or John Marston. Shared kills. (Scarlett Meadows)
    • Total - 3
Overall
  • Total - 3
    • 3 Humans
      • 3 Men
Wagon Holdup I
Enemies
  • Two Unnamed Lemoyne Raiders Gang Members - Shot to death by either Arthur Morgan or John Marston. Shared kills.
    • Total - 2
Animals
  • Two Lemoyne Raiders Horses - Shot to death by either Arthur Morgan or John Marston, optional. Shared kills.
  • Two Stagecoach Horses - Shot to death by either Arthur Morgan or John Marston, optional. Shared kills.
    • Total - 4
Other
  • Two Unnamed Men - Shot to death by Lemoyne Raiders.
    • Total - 2
Overall
  • Total - 8
    • 4 Humans
      • 4 Men
    • 2 Animals
      • 2 Horses
Wagon Holdup II
Enemies
  • Three Unnamed Lemoyne Raiders Gang Members - Shot to death by either Arthur Morgan or John Marston. Shared kills.
    • Total - 3
Animals
  • Stagecoach Horse - Shot to death by either Arthur Morgan or John Marston, optional. Shared kill.
    • Total - 1
Other
  • Unnamed Man - Optionally shot to death by either Arthur Morgan or John Marston, or possibly by three Lemoyne Raiders gang members. Shared kills.
    • Total - 1
Overall
  • Total - 5
    • 4 Humans
      • 4 Men
    • 1 Animal
      • 1 Horse
Target Practice
Enemies
  • Three Unnamed Lemoyne Raiders Gang Members - Shot to death by either Arthur Morgan or John Marston. Shared kills.
    • Total - 3
Animals
  • Three Lemoyne Raider Horses - Shot to death by either Arthur Morgan or John Marston, optional. Shared kills.
    • Total - 3
Overall
  • Total - 6
    • 3 Humans
      • 3 Men
    • 3 Animals
      • 3 Horses
Vengeful Raiders
Enemies
  • Three Unnamed Lemoyne Raiders Gang Members - Shot to death by either Arthur Morgan or John Marston. Shared kills.
    • Total - 3
Overall
  • Total - 3
    • 3 Humans
      • 3 Men

Murfree Brood

Camp Intimidation
Enemies
  • Two Unnamed Murfree Brood Gang Members - Shot to death by either Arthur Morgan or John Marston. Shared kills.
    • Total - 2
Animals
  • Two Murfree Brood Horses - Shot to death by either Arthur Morgan or John Marston, optional. Shared kills.
    • Total - 2
Overall
  • Total - 4
    • 2 Humans
      • 2 Men
    • 2 Animals
      • 2 Horses
Camp Attack
Enemies
  • Two Unnamed Murfree Brood Gang Members - Shot to death by either Arthur Morgan or John Marston. Shared kills.
    • Total - 2
Overall
  • Total - 2
    • 2 Humans
      • 2 Men
Camp Robbery
Enemies
  • Four Unnamed Murfree Brood Gang Members - Shot to death by either Arthur Morgan or John Marston. Shared kills.
    • Total - 4
Other
  • Two Unnamed Men - Killed by two unnamed Murfree Brood gang members off-screen, bodies shown.
    • Total - 2
Overall
  • Total - 6
    • 6 Humans
      • 6 Men
Road Ambush
Enemies
  • At Least Two Unnamed Murfree Brood Gang Members - Shot to death by either Arthur Morgan or John Marston. Shared kills.
    • Total - 2
Overall
  • Total - 2
    • 2 Humans
      • 2 Men
Burning Wagon Attack
Enemies
  • Five Unnamed Murfree Brood Brood Gang Members - Shot to death by either Arthur Morgan or John Marston. Shared kills.
    • Total - 5
Overall
  • Total - 5
    • 5 Humans
      • 5 Men
Pox Tent Trap
Enemies
  • Unnamed Sick Murfree Brood Gang Member - Shot to death by either Arthur Morgan or John Marston. Shared kill.
  • Unnamed Murfree Brood Gang Member - Shot to death by either Arthur Morgan or John Marston. Shared kill.
    • Total - 2
Overall
  • Total - 2
    • 2 Humans
      • 2 Men
Man Tied To a Tree
Enemies
  • Two Unnamed Murfree Brood Gang Members - Shot to death by either Arthur Morgan or John Marston. Shared kills.
    • Total - 2
Other
  • Unnamed Man - Set on fire by the Murfree Brood gang members if he's not saved in time by either Arthur Morgan or John Marston, or optionally killed by either Arthur or John. Shared kill.
    • Total - 1
Overall
  • Total - 3
    • 3 Humans
      • 3 Men
Pit Trap
Enemies
  • Three Unnamed Murfree Brood Gang Members - Shot to death by either Arthur Morgan or John Marston. Shared kills.
    • Total - 3
Overall
  • Total - 3
    • 3 Humans
      • 3 Men
Kidnapping (Traumatized Victim)
Enemies
  • Two Unnamed Murfree Brood Gang Members - Shot to death by either Arthur Morgan or John Marston. Shared kills.
    • Total - 2
Animals
  • Stagecoach Horse - Shot to death by either Arthur Morgan or John Marston, optional. Shared kill.
    • Total - 1
Other
  • Two Unknown People - Murdered by two Murfree Brood gang members off-screen, bodies shown.
  • Unnamed Woman - Shot to death by either Arthur Morgan or John Marston, optional. Shared kill.
    • Total - 3
Overall
  • Total - 6
    • 5 Humans
      • 2 Victims of Unknown Gender
      • 2 Men
      • 1 Woman
    • 1 Animal
      • 1 Horse
Kidnapping (Grateful Victim)
Enemies
  • Two Unnamed Murfree Brood Gang Members - Shot to death by either Arthur Morgan or John Marston. Shared kills.
    • Total - 2
Animals
  • Two Murfree Brood Horses - Shot to death by either Arthur Morgan or John Marston, optional. Shared kills.
  • Two Horses - Killed by two Murfree Brood gang members off-screen, bodies shown.
    • Total - 4
Other
  • Unnamed Man - Shot to death by one of the Murfree Brood gang members.
  • Unnamed Woman - Killed by the Murfree Brood gang off-screen if Arthur Morgan or John Marston choose to not intervene, or optionally killed by either Arthur or John. Shared kill.
    • Total - 2
Overall
  • Total - 8
    • 4 Humans
      • 3 Men
      • 1 Woman
    • 4 Animals
      • 4 Horses
Murfree Brood dumping bodies from boat into the Elysian Pool
Enemies
  • Three Unnamed Murfree Brood Gang Members - Shot to death by either Arthur Morgan or John Marston. Shared kills.
    • Total - 3
Other
  • Two Unknown People - Murdered by one of the Murfree Brood gang members off-screen, bodies shown.
    • Total - 2
Overall
  • Total - 5
    • 5 Humans
      • 3 Men
      • 2 Victims of Unknown Gender
Murfree Brood Corpse Trap
Enemies
  • Three Unnamed Murfree Brood Gang Members - Shot to death by either Arthur Morgan or John Marston. Shared kills.
    • Total - 3
Other
  • Unnamed Man - Hanged by the three Murfree Brood gang members with a noose off-screen, body shown.
    • Total - 1
Overall
  • Total - 4
    • 4 Humans
      • 4 Men

Skinner Brothers

Camp Intimidation
Enemies
  • Two Unnamed Skinner Brothers Gang Members - Shot to death by John Marston.
    • Total - 2
Animals
  • Two Skinner Brothers Horses - Shot to death by John Marston, optional.
    • Total - 2
Overall
  • Total - 4
    • 2 Humans
      • 2 Men
    • 2 Animals
      • 2 Horses
Camp Attack
Enemies
  • Two Unnamed Skinner Brothers Gang Members - Shot to death by John Marston.
    • Total - 2
Overall
  • Total - 2
    • 2 Humans
      • 2 Men
Couple Hostage
Enemies
  • Three Unnamed Skinner Brothers Gang Members - Shot to death by John Marston.
    • Total - 3
Animals
  • Three Skinner Brothers Horses - Shot to death by John Marston, optional.
    • Total - 3
Other
  • Unnamed Man - Stabbed to death by one of the Skinner Brothers gang members if he's not saved in time by John Marston or optionally killed by John himself.
  • Unnamed Woman - Stabbed to death by one of the Skinner Brothers gang members if she's not saved in time by John Marston or optionally killed by John himself.
    • Total - 2
Overall
  • Total - 8
    • 5 Humans
      • 4 Men
      • 1 Woman
    • 3 Animals
      • 3 Horses
Ruined Camp
Other
  • Five Unknown People - Murdered by the Skinner Brothers gang off-screen, bodies shown.
  • Unnamed Man - Scalped by one of the Skinner Brothers gang members and either bled to death or is mercifully killed by John Marston.
    • Total - 6
Overall
  • Total - 6
    • 6 Humans
      • 5 Victims of Unknown Gender
      • 1 Man
Ruined Camp 2
Animals
  • Dog - Shot to death by John Marston, optional.
    • Total - 1
Other
  • Six Unknown People - Murdered by the Skinner Brothers gang off-screen, bodies shown.
    • Total - 6
Overall
  • Total - 7
    • 6 Humans
      • All Victims of Unknown Gender
    • 1 Animal
      • All Dogs

Night Folk

Night Folk Corpse Trap
Enemies
  • Three Unnamed Male Night Folk - Shot to death by either Arthur Morgan or John Marston. Shared kills.
    • Total - 3
Other
  • Unnamed Man - Hanged by the Night Folk with a noose off-screen, body shown.
    • Total - 1
Overall
  • Total - 4
    • 4 Humans
      • 4 Men
Woman in White Trap
Enemies
  • "Woman in White" (Night Folk) - Shot to death by either Arthur Morgan or John Marston. Shared kill.
  • Three Unnamed Male Night Folk - Shot to death by either Arthur Morgan or John Marston. Shared kills.
    • Total - 4
Overall
  • Total - 4
    • 4 Humans
      • 3 Men
      • 1 Woman
Night Folk Carrying a Corpse
Enemies
  • Two Unnamed Male Night Folk - Shot to death by either Arthur Morgan or John Marston. Shared kills.
    • Total - 2
Other
  • Unknown Person - Murdered by one of the Night Folk off-screen, body shown.
    • Total - 1
Overall
  • Total - 3
    • 3 Humans
      • 2 Men
      • 1 Victim of Unknown Gender
Night Folk Horse Murder Trap (Lure)
Enemies
  • Three Unnamed Male Night Folk - Shot to death by either Arthur Morgan or John Marston. Shared kills.
    • Total - 3
Animals
  • Either Arthur or John's Horse - Killed by one of the Night Folk if they fall for their trap.
    • Total - 1
Overall
  • Total - 4
    • 3 Humans
      • 3 Men
    • 1 Animal
      • 1 Horse
Night Folk Horse Murder Trap (Cart)
Enemies
  • Five Unnamed Male Night Folk - Shot to death by either Arthur Morgan or John Marston. Shared kills.
    • Total - 5
Animals
  • Horse - Killed by the Night Folk off-screen, body shown.
  • Either Arthur or John's Horse - Killed by one of the Night Folk if it is not saved in time.
    • Total - 2
Overall
  • Total - 7
    • 5 Humans
      • 5 Men
    • 2 Animals
      • 2 Horses

Angelo Bronte's Mob

Bridge Watch
Enemies
  • Four Unnamed Angelo Bronte Henchmen - Shot to death by Arthur Morgan.
    • Total - 4
Overall
  • Total - 4
    • 4 Humans
      • 4 Men
Doyle's Tavern Setup
Enemies
  • Three Unnamed Angelo Bronte Henchmen - Beaten to death by Arthur Morgan.
    • Total - 3
Overall
  • Total - 3
    • 3 Humans
      • 3 Men
Mobsters' Bullying
Enemies
  • Two Unnamed Angel Bronte Henchmen - Shot to death by Arthur Morgan.
    • Total - 2
Overall
  • Total - 2
    • 2 Humans
      • 2 Men

Guido Martelli's Mob

Mobsters' Bullying
Enemies
  • Two Unnamed Guido Martelli Henchmen - Shot to death by John Marston.
    • Total - 2
Overall
  • Total - 2
    • 2 Humans
      • 2 Men

Ku Klux Klan

KKK Meeting
Enemies
  • Two Unnamed KKK Members - Either optionally shot to death by either Arthur Morgan or John Marston or accidentally burned to death when a lit torch touched their robes. Shared kills.
  • Two Unnamed KKK Members - Shot to death either Arthur Morgan or John Marston. Shared kills. (Player's Choice, Optional)
    • Total - 4
Overall
  • Total - 4
    • 4 Humans
      • 4 Men
KKK Initiation
Enemies
  • Unnamed KKK Leader - Shot to death either Arthur Morgan or John Marston. Shared kill. (Player's Choice, Optional)
  • Two Unnamed KKK Members - Either optionally shot to death either Arthur Morgan or John Marston or burned to death after setting a giant cross on fire. Shared kills.
  • Seven Unnamed KKK Members - Shot to death by either Arthur Morgan or John Marston. Shared kills. (Player's Choice, Optional)
    • Total - 10
Animals
  • Four KKK Horses - Shot to death either Arthur Morgan or John Marston, optional. Shared kills.
    • Total - 4
Overall
  • Total - 14
    • 10 Humans
      • 10 Men
    • 4 Animals
      • 4 Horses
Cross Accident
Enemies
  • Unnamed KKK Leader - Shot to death by either Arthur Morgan or John Marston. Shared kill. (Player's Choice, Optional)
  • Two Unnamed KKK Members - Either optionally shot to death by either Arthur Morgan or John Marston or accidentally crushed after dropping a giant cross on themselves. Shared kills.
    • Total - 3
Animals
  • KKK Leader's Horse - Shot to death by Arthur Morgan. (Player's Choice, Optional)
    • Total - 1
Overall
  • Total - 4
    • 3 Humans
      • 3 Men
    • 1 Animal
      • 1 Horse

Nature

Man Bitten by Snake I
Named Characters
  • Norbert - Bitten on the leg by a snake and succumbed to its venom if either Arthur Morgan or John Marston choose to not help, or optionally killed by either Arthur or John. Shared kill.
    • Total - 1
Overall
  • Total - 1
    • 1 Human
      • 1 Man
Man Bitten by Snake II
Other
  • Unnamed Man - Bitten on the leg by a snake and succumbed to its venom if either Arthur Morgan or John Marston choose to not help, or optionally killed by either Arthur or John. Shared kill.
    • Total - 1
Overall
  • Total - 1
    • 1 Human
      • 1 Man
Man Poisoned by Plant
Other
  • Unnamed Man - Accidentally succumbed to a plant's poison after eating it if he's not saved in time by either Arthur Morgan or John Marston, or optionally killed by either Arthur or John. Shared kill.
    • Total - 1
Overall
  • Total - 1
    • 1 Human
      • 1 Man
Trapper Steps on a Trap I
Other
  • Unnamed Man - Accidentally stepped on a bear trap and bled to death if Arthur Morgan or John Marston don't save him in time, or optionally killed by either Arthur or John. Shared kill. (Strawberry)
    • Total - 1
Overall
  • Total - 1
    • 1 Human
      • 1 Man
Trapper Steps on a Trap II
Other
  • Unnamed Man - Accidentally stepped on a bear trap and bled to death if Arthur Morgan or John Marston don't save him in time, or optionally killed by either Arthur or John. Shared kill. (Roanoke Ridge)
    • Total - 1
Overall
  • Total - 1
    • 1 Human
      • 1 Man
Cougar Attack
Animals
  • Cougar - Shot to death by either Arthur Morgan or John Marston to save an unnamed man. (Player's Choice, Optional)
  • Unnamed Man's Horse - Shot to death by either Arthur Morgan or John Marston. (Player's Choice, Optional)
    • Total - 2
Other
  • Unnamed Man - Either optionally shot to death by either Arthur Morgan or John Marston or mauled to death by a cougar.
    • Total - 1
Overall
  • Total - 3
    • 2 Animals
      • 1 Cougar
      • 1 Horse
    • 1 Human
      • 1 Man
Wolf Attack I
Animals
  • Wolf - Shot to death by either Arthur Morgan or John Marston. Shared kill.
    • Total - 1
Other
  • Unnamed Man - Either eventually bled to death after being attacked by a wolf or mercifully shot to death by either Arthur Morgan or John Marston on his request. Shared kill.
    • Total - 1
Overall
  • Total - 2
    • 1 Human
      • 1 Man
    • 1 Animal
      • 1 Wolf
Wolf Attack II
Animals
  • Two Wolves - Shot to death by either Arthur Morgan or John Marston. Shared kill.
    • Total - 2
Other
  • Unnamed Man - Either mauled to death by wolves if he's not saved in time or optionally shot to death by either Arthur Morgan or John Marston. Shared kill.
    • Total - 1
Overall
  • Total - 3
    • 2 Animals
      • 2 Wolves
    • 1 Human
      • 1 Man
Prospector I
Animals
  • Prospector's Horse - Shot to death by either Arthur Morgan or John Marston, optional. Shared kill.
    • Total - 1
Other
  • Unnamed Man - Shot to death by either Arthur Morgan or John Marston to steal his gold. Shared kill.
    • Total - 1
Overall
  • Total - 2
    • 1 Human
      • 1 Man
    • 1 Animal
      • 1 Horse
Prospector II
Animals
  • Prospector's Horse - Shot to death by either Arthur Morgan or John Marston, optional. Shared kill.
    • Total - 1
Other
  • Unnamed Man - Shot to death by either Arthur Morgan or John Marston. Shared kill.
    • Total - 1
Overall
  • Total - 2
    • 1 Human
      • 1 Man
    • 1 Animal
      • 1 Horse
Shooting Competition I
Other
  • Unnamed Man - Shot to death by either Arthur Morgan or John Marston. Shared kill. (The Heartlands)
    • Total - 1
Overall
  • Total - 1
    • 1 Human
      • 1 Man
Shooting Competition II
Other
  • Unnamed Man - Shot to death by either Arthur Morgan or John Marston. Shared kill. (Rio Bravo)
    • Total - 1
Overall
  • Total - 1
    • 1 Human
      • 1 Man
Shooting Competition III
Other
  • Unnamed Man - Shot to death by either Arthur Morgan or John Marston. Shared kill. (Big Valley)
    • Total - 1
Overall
  • Total - 1
    • 1 Human
      • 1 Man
Shooting Competition IV
Other
  • Unnamed Man - Shot to death by either Arthur Morgan or John Marston. Shared kill. (Ringneck Creek)
    • Total - 1
Overall
  • Total - 1
    • 1 Human
      • 1 Man
Shooting Competition V
Other
  • Unnamed Man - Shot to death by either Arthur Morgan or John Marston. Shared kill. (Scarlett Meadows)
    • Total - 1
Overall
  • Total - 1
    • 1 Human
      • 1 Man
Bear Hunter I
Animals
  • Bear - Shot to death by either Arthur Morgan, John Marston, or the unnamed hunter. Shared kill. (Big Valley)
    • Total - 1
Other
  • Unnamed Man - Either mauled to death by a bear or optionally shot to death by either Arthur Morgan or John Marston. Shared kill. (Big Valley)
    • Total - 1
Overall
  • Total - 2
    • 1 Human
      • 1 Man
    • 1 Animal
      • 1 Bear
Bear Hunter II
Animals
  • Bear - Shot to death by either Arthur Morgan, John Marston, or the unnamed hunter. Shared kill. (Grizzlies East)
    • Total - 1
Other
  • Unnamed Man - Either mauled to death by a bear or optionally shot to death by either Arthur Morgan or John Marston. Shared kill. (Grizzlies East)
    • Total - 1
Overall
  • Total - 2
    • 1 Human
      • 1 Man
    • 1 Animal
      • 1 Bear
Coyote Hunter
Animals
  • Coyote - Shot to death by either Arthur Morgan, John Marston, or the unnamed hunter. Shared kill.
  • Hunter's Horse - Shot to death by either Arthur Morgan or John Marston, optional. Shared kill.
    • Total - 2
Other
  • Unnamed Hunter - Optionally shot to death by either Arthur Morgan or John Marston. Shared kill.
    • Total - 1
Overall
  • Total - 3
    • 2 Animals
      • 1 Coyote
      • 1 Horse
    • 1 Human
      • 1 Man
Hunter Needs Help Looking For His Friend
Named Characters
  • Tucker - Mauled to death by a bear off-screen, body shown.
    • Total - 1
Animals
  • Bear - Shot to death by either Arthur Morgan, John Marston, or the unnamed man. Shared kill.
  • Hunter's Horse - Shot to death by either Arthur Morgan or John Marston, optional. Shared kill.
    • Total - 2
Other
  • Unnamed Man - Either mauled to death by a bear or optionally shot to death by either Arthur Morgan or John Marston. Shared kill.
    • Total - 1
Overall
  • Total - 4
    • 2 Humans
      • 2 Men
    • 2 Animals
      • 1 Horse
      • 1 Bear
Herb Collector I
Animals
  • Herbalist's Horse - Shot to death by either Arthur Morgan or John Marston, optional. Shared kill. (New Hanover)
    • Total - 1
Other
  • Unnamed Herbalist - Shot to death by either Arthur Morgan or John Marston, optional. Shared kill.
    • Total - 1
Overall
  • Total - 2
    • 1 Human
      • 1 Man
    • 1 Animal
      • 1 Horse
Herb Collector II
Animals
  • Herbalist's Horse - Shot to death by either Arthur Morgan or John Marston, optional. Shared kill. (Big Valley)
    • Total - 1
Other
  • Unnamed Herbalist - Shot to death by either Arthur Morgan or John Marston, optional. Shared kill.
    • Total - 1
Overall
  • Total - 2
    • 1 Human
      • 1 Man
    • 1 Animal
      • 1 Horse
Herb Collector III
Animals
  • Herbalist's Horse - Shot to death by either Arthur Morgan or John Marston, optional. Shared kill. (Scarlett Meadows)
    • Total - 1
Other
  • Unnamed Herbalist - Shot to death by either Arthur Morgan or John Marston, optional. Shared kill.
    • Total - 1
Overall
  • Total - 2
    • 1 Human
      • 1 Man
    • 1 Animal
      • 1 Horse
Drunk Duelist I
Other
  • Unnamed Man - Shot to death by either Arthur Morgan or John Marston in a duel. (Valentine)
    • Total - 1
Overall
  • Total - 1
    • 1 Human
      • 1 Man
Drunk Duelist II
Other
  • Unnamed Man - Shot to death by either Arthur Morgan or John Marston in a duel. (Van Horn Trading Post)
    • Total - 1
Overall
  • Total - 1
    • 1 Human
      • 1 Man
Duelist Takes on Challenger I
Other
  • Unnamed Man - Shot to death by another man in a duel. (Valentine)
  • Unnamed Man - Shot to death by either Arthur Morgan or John Marston in a duel.
    • Total - 2
Overall
  • Total - 2
    • 2 Humans
      • 2 Men
Duelist Takes on Challenger II
Other
  • Unnamed Man - Shot to death by another man in a duel. (Van Horn Trading Post)
  • Unnamed Man - Shot to death by either Arthur Morgan or John Marston in a duel.
    • Total - 2
Overall
  • Total - 2
    • 2 Humans
      • 2 Men
Boastful Duelist
Named Characters
  • Willy Curlls - Shot to death by either Arthur Morgan or John Marston in a duel. (Player's Choice, Optional)
  • "Donkey" Daniels - Shot to death by Willy Curlls in a duel off-screen several years prior, mentioned. (Debatable)
    • Total - 2
Other
  • Willy Curlls' Friend - Shot to death by either Arthur Morgan or John Marston, optional.
    • Total - 1
Overall
  • Total - 3 (1 Debatable)
    • 3 Humans
      • 3 Men
Man Shoots Himself in the Leg I
Other
  • Two Unnamed Men - Shot to death by either Arthur Morgan or John Marston, optional. Shared kills. (Annesburg)
    • Total - 2
Overall
  • Total - 2
    • 2 Humans
      • 2 Men
Man Shoots Himself in the Leg II
Other
  • Two Unnamed Men - Shot to death by either Arthur Morgan or John Marston, optional. Shared kills. (Strawberry)
    • Total - 2
Overall
  • Total - 2
    • 2 Humans
      • 2 Men
Man Accidentally Shoots and Kills His Friend
Other
  • Unnamed Man - Accidentally shot to death by his friend.
  • Unnamed Man - Shot to death by either Arthur Morgan or John Marston, optional. Shared kill.
    • Total - 2
Overall
  • Total - 2
    • 2 Humans
      • 2 Men
Horse Race I
  • None (Big Valley)
Horse Race II
Animals
  • Horse - Either shot in the head by its owner for losing the race for a second time or optionally by either Arthur Morgan or John Marston. (Big Valley)
    • Total - 1
Other
  • Unnamed Man - Shot to death by either Arthur Morgan or John Marston for killing his horse, optional.
    • Total - 1
Overall
  • Total - 2
    • 1 Human
      • 1 Man
    • 1 Animal
      • 1 Horse
Horse Race III
  • None (Scarlett Meadows)
Horse Race IV
Animals
  • Horse - Shot to death by either Arthur Morgan or John Marston, optional. (Scarlett Meadows)
    • Total - 1
Other
  • Unnamed Woman - Shot to death by either Arthur Morgan or John Marston, optional.
    • Total - 1
Overall
  • Total - 2
    • 1 Human
      • 1 Woman
    • 1 Animal
      • 1 Horse
Horse Race V
Animals
  • Ariel (Horse) - Shot to death by either Arthur Morgan or John Marston, optional. (Grizzlies East)
    • Total - 1
Other
  • Unnamed Man - Shot to death by either Arthur Morgan or John Marston, optional.
    • Total - 1
Overall
  • Total - 2
    • 1 Human
      • 1 Man
    • 1 Animal
      • 1 Horse
Horse Race VI
Animals
  • Horse - Shot to death by either Arthur Morgan or John Marston, optional. (Ambarino)
    • Total - 1
Other
  • Unnamed Man - Shot to death by either Arthur Morgan or John Marston, optional.
    • Total - 1
Overall
  • Total - 2
    • 1 Human
      • 1 Man
    • 1 Animal
      • 1 Horse
Horse Race VII
Animals
  • Horse - Shot to death by either Arthur Morgan or John Marston, optional. (Ambarino)
    • Total - 1
Other
  • Unnamed Man - Shot to death by either Arthur Morgan or John Marston, optional.
    • Total - 1
Overall
  • Total - 2
    • 1 Human
      • 1 Man
    • 1 Animal
      • 1 Horse
Horse Kicks and Kills Its Owner
Animals
  • Horse - Shot to death by either Arthur Morgan or John Marston, optional.
    • Total - 1
Other
  • Unnamed Man - Kicked in the head by his own horse.
    • Total - 1
Overall
  • Total - 2
    • 1 Human
      • 1 Man
    • 1 Animal
      • 1 Horse
Runaway Horse
Animals
  • Horse - Shot to death by either Arthur Morgan or John Marston, optional.
    • Total - 1
Other
  • Unnamed Man - Shot to death by either Arthur Morgan or John Marston, optional.
    • Total - 1
Overall
  • Total - 2
    • 1 Human
      • 1 Man
    • 1 Animal
      • 1 Horse
Man Falls off Horse
Animals
  • Horse - Shot to death by either Arthur Morgan or John Marston, optional.
    • Total - 1
Other
  • Unnamed Man - Died of unknown causes.
    • Total - 1
Overall
  • Total - 2
    • 1 Human
      • 1 Man
    • 1 Animal
      • 1 Horse
Woman Trapped Under Her Horse I
Animals
  • Mildred's Horse - Died of unknown causes off-screen, body shown. (Valentine)
    • Total - 1
Other
  • Unnamed Woman's Husband - Died of unspecified causes off-screen, mentioned.
  • Unnamed Woman - Shot to death by either Arthur Morgan or John Marston, optional.
    • Total - 2
Overall
  • Total - 3
    • 2 Humans
      • 1 Man
      • 1 Woman
    • 1 Animal
      • 1 Horse
Woman Trapped Under Her Horse II
Animals
  • Moses (Horse) - Died of unknown causes off-screen, body shown. (Saint Denis)
    • Total - 1
Other
  • Unnamed Woman - Shot to death by either Arthur Morgan or John Marston, optional.
    • Total - 1
Overall
  • Total - 2
    • 1 Human
      • 1 Woman
    • 1 Animal
      • 1 Horse
Woman Trapped Under Her Horse III
Animals
  • Biscuit (Horse) - Died of unknown causes off-screen, body shown. (Emerald Ranch)
    • Total - 1
Other
  • Unnamed Woman - Shot to death by either Arthur Morgan or John Marston, optional.
    • Total - 1
Overall
  • Total - 2
    • 1 Human
      • 1 Woman
    • 1 Animal
      • 1 Horse
Woman Trapped Under Her Horse IV
Animals
  • Horse - Died of unknown causes off-screen, body shown. (Lagras)
  • Horse - Legs ripped off by two alligators off-screen several years prior, mentioned.
    • Total - 2
Other
  • Unnamed Woman - Shot to death by either Arthur Morgan or John Marston, optional.
    • Total - 1
Overall
  • Total - 3
    • 2 Animals
      • 2 Horses
    • 1 Human
      • 1 Woman
Crashed Wagon
Animals
  • Horse - Died when its owner crashed his wagon into a boulder while drunk off-screen, body shown.
    • Total - 1
Other
  • Unnamed Man - Shot to death by either Arthur Morgan or John Marston, optional.
    • Total - 1
Overall
  • Total - 2
    • 1 Human
      • 1 Man
    • 1 Animal
      • 1 Horse
Lenora View Wagon Crash
Named Characters
  • James Peyton - Fell to his death after his horses ran off of a cliff off-screen, body shown.
    • Total - 1
Animals
  • Two Horses - Fell to their deaths after running off of a cliff off-screen, bodies shown.
    • Total - 2
Other
  • Unnamed Man - Shot to death by either Arthur Morgan or John Marston, optional.
    • Total - 1
Overall
  • Total - 4
    • 2 Humans
      • 2 Men
    • 2 Animals
      • 2 Horses
Crazy Woman Lost in The Woods For Two Days
Other
  • Unnamed Woman - Shot to death by either Arthur Morgan or John Marston, optional.
    • Total - 1
Overall
  • Total - 1
    • 1 Human
      • 1 Woman
Peaceful Camper I
Animals
  • Horse - Shot to death by either Arthur Morgan or John Marston, optional.
    • Total - 1
Other
  • Unnamed Man - Shot to death by either Arthur Morgan or John Marston, optional.
    • Total - 1
Overall
  • Total - 2
    • 1 Human
      • 1 Man
    • 1 Animal
      • 1 Horse
Peaceful Camper II
Animals
  • Horse - Shot to death by either Arthur Morgan or John Marston, optional.
    • Total - 1
Other
  • Unnamed Man - Shot to death by either Arthur Morgan or John Marston, optional.
    • Total - 1
Overall
  • Total - 2
    • 1 Human
      • 1 Man
    • 1 Animal
      • 1 Horse
Peaceful Camper III
Animals
  • Horse - Shot to death by either Arthur Morgan or John Marston, optional.
    • Total - 1
Other
  • Unnamed Man - Shot to death by either Arthur Morgan or John Marston, optional.
    • Total - 1
Overall
  • Total - 2
    • 1 Human
      • 1 Man
    • 1 Animal
      • 1 Horse
Peaceful Camper IV
Animals
  • Horse - Shot to death by either Arthur Morgan or John Marston, optional.
    • Total - 1
Other
  • Unnamed Man - Shot to death by either Arthur Morgan or John Marston, optional.
    • Total - 1
Overall
  • Total - 2
    • 1 Human
      • 1 Man
    • 1 Animal
      • 1 Horse
Peaceful Camper V
Animals
  • Horse - Shot to death by either Arthur Morgan or John Marston, optional.
    • Total - 1
Other
  • Unnamed Man - Shot to death by either Arthur Morgan or John Marston, optional.
    • Total - 1
Overall
  • Total - 2
    • 1 Human
      • 1 Man
    • 1 Animal
      • 1 Horse
Peaceful Camper VI
Animals
  • Horse - Shot to death by either Arthur Morgan or John Marston, optional.
    • Total - 1
Other
  • Unnamed Man - Shot to death by either Arthur Morgan or John Marston, optional.
  • Unnamed Man's Brother - Died of unspecified causes off-screen a few years prior, mentioned.
    • Total - 2
Overall
  • Total - 3
    • 2 Humans
      • 2 Men
    • 1 Animal
      • 1 Horse
Peaceful Camper VII
Animals
  • Horse - Shot to death by either Arthur Morgan or John Marston, optional.
    • Total - 1
Other
  • Four Unnamed Bounty Hunters - Shot to death by Black Belle off-screen several years prior, mentioned.
  • Unnamed Woman - Shot to death by either Arthur Morgan or John Marston, optional.
    • Total - 5
Overall
  • Total - 6
    • 5 Humans
      • 4 Men
      • 1 Woman
    • 1 Animal
      • 1 Horse
Perverted Stalker
Animals
  • Horse - Shot to death by either Arthur Morgan or John Marston, optional.
    • Total - 1
Other
  • Unnamed Man - Shot to death by either Arthur Morgan or John Marston, optional.
    • Total - 1
Overall
  • Total - 2
    • 1 Human
      • 1 Man
    • 1 Animal
      • 1 Horse

Outlaws and Lawmen

Bill Williamson Captured
Enemies
  • Four Unnamed Bounty Hunters - Shot to death by either Arthur Morgan or Javier Escuella. Shared kills.
    • Total - 4
Animals
  • Bounty Hunter Horse - Shot to death by Arthur Morgan, optional.
    • Total - 1
Overall
  • Total - 5
    • 4 Humans
      • 4 Men
    • 1 Animal
      • 1 Horse
Prisoners at Crawdad Willies Shack
Other
  • Unnamed Man - Killed by one of the prisoners off-screen, body shown.
  • Unnamed Male Prisoner - Bled out after being stabbed by the unnamed man off-screen, body shown.
  • Unnamed Male Prisoner - Shot to death by either Arthur Morgan or John Marston, optional.
    • Total - 3
Overall
  • Total - 3
    • 3 Humans
      • 3 Men
Killer Prostitute
Other
  • Unnamed Man - Stabbed to death by the unnamed prostitute off-screen.
  • Unnamed Prostitute - Either hanged by the town of Valentine or optionally killed by either Arthur Morgan or John Marston.
    • Total - 2
Overall
  • Total - 2
    • 2 Humans
      • 1 Man
      • 1 Woman
Outlaw Attack
Animals
  • Four Horses - Shot to death by either Arthur Morgan or John Marston, optional. Shared kills.
    • Total - 4
Other
  • Four Unnamed Men - Shot to death by either Arthur Morgan or John Marston. Shared kills.
    • Total - 4
Overall
  • Total - 8
    • 4 Humans
      • 4 Men
    • 4 Animals
      • 4 Horses
Pickpocket I
Enemies
  • Unnamed Thief - Beaten to death by either Arthur Morgan or John Marston. Shared kill.
    • Total - 1
Overall
  • Total - 1
    • 1 Human
      • 1 Man
Pickpocket II
Enemies
  • Unnamed Thief - Beaten to death by either Arthur Morgan or John Marston. Shared kill.
    • Total - 1
Overall
  • Total - 1
    • 1 Human
      • 1 Man
Pickpocket III
Enemies
  • Unnamed Thief - Beaten to death by either Arthur Morgan or John Marston. Shared kill.
    • Total - 1
Overall
  • Total - 1
    • 1 Human
      • 1 Man
Fugitive Prisoner
Other
  • Unnamed Prisoner - Shot to death by either Arthur Morgan or John Marston, optional. Shared kill.
    • Total - 1
Overall
  • Total - 1
    • 1 Human
      • 1 Man
Chain Gang Escape Attempt
Enemies
  • Two Unnamed Prisoners - Shot to death by either Arthur Morgan or John Marston. Shared kills.
    • Total - 2
Animals
  • Two Stagecoach Horses - Shot to death by either Arthur Morgan or John Marston, optional. Shared kills.
    • Total - 2
Other
  • Two Unnamed Prison Guards - Either stabbed to death by three prisoners or shot to death by either Arthur Morgan or John Marston. Shared kills.
  • Unnamed Prisoner - Shot to death by either one of the prison guards or by either Arthur Morgan or John Marston. Shared kill.
    • Total - 3
Overall
  • Total - 7
    • 5 Humans
      • 5 Men
    • 2 Animals
      • 2 Horses
Criminal Being Transported by Lawmen I
Animals
  • Two Stagecoach Horses - Shot to death by either Arthur Morgan or John Marston, optional. Shared kills.
    • Total - 2
Other
  • Two Unnamed Lawmen - Shot to death by either Arthur Morgan or John Marston, optional. Shared kills.
  • Unnamed Female Prisoner - Shot to death by either Arthur Morgan or John Marston, optional. Shared kill.
  • Unnamed Woman's Husband - Murdered by the unnamed woman off-screen, mentioned.
    • Total - 4
Overall
  • Total - 6
    • 4 Humans
      • 3 Men
      • 1 Woman
    • 2 Animals
      • 2 Horses
Criminal Being Transported by Lawmen II
Animals
  • Two Stagecoach Horses - Shot to death by either Arthur Morgan or John Marston, optional. Shared kills.
    • Total - 2
Other
  • Two Unnamed Lawmen - Shot to death by either Arthur Morgan or John Marston, optional. Shared kills.
  • Unnamed Male Prisoner - Shot to death by either Arthur Morgan or John Marston, optional. Shared kill.
    • Total - 3
Overall
  • Total - 5
    • 3 Humans
      • 3 Men
    • 2 Animals
      • 2 Horses
Criminal Being Transported by Lawmen III
Animals
  • Two Stagecoach Horses - Shot to death by either Arthur Morgan or John Marston, optional. Shared kills.
    • Total - 2
Other
  • Two Unnamed Lawmen - Shot to death by either Arthur Morgan or John Marston, optional. Shared kills.
  • Unnamed Male Prisoner - Shot to death by either Arthur Morgan or John Marston, optional. Shared kill.
    • Total - 3
Overall
  • Total - 5
    • 3 Humans
      • 3 Men
    • 2 Animals
      • 2 Horses
Criminal Being Transported by Bounty Hunters I
Enemies
  • Two Unnamed Bounty Hunters - Shot to death by either Arthur Morgan or John Marston, optional. Shared kills.
    • Total - 2
Animals
  • Two Horses - Shot to death by either Arthur Morgan or John Marston, optional. Shared kills.
    • Total - 2
Other
  • Unnamed Man - Shot to death by either Arthur Morgan or John Marston, optional. Shared kill.
    • Total - 1
Overall
  • Total - 5
    • 3 Humans
      • 3 Men
    • 2 Animals
      • 2 Horses
Criminal Being Transported by Bounty Hunters II
Enemies
  • Two Unnamed Bounty Hunters - Shot to death by either Arthur Morgan or John Marston, optional. Shared kills.
    • Total - 2
Animals
  • Two Horses - Shot to death by either Arthur Morgan or John Marston, optional. Shared kills.
    • Total - 2
Other
  • Unnamed Man - Shot to death by either Arthur Morgan or John Marston, optional. Shared kill.
    • Total - 1
Overall
  • Total - 5
    • 3 Humans
      • 3 Men
    • 2 Animals
      • 2 Horses
Kidnapping I
Enemies
  • Unnamed Man - Shot to death by either Arthur Morgan or John Marston. Shared kill.
    • Total - 1
Animals
  • Horse - Shot to death by either Arthur Morgan or John Marston, optional. Shared kill.
    • Total - 1
Other
  • Unnamed Woman - Shot to death by either Arthur Morgan or John Marston, optional. Shared kill.
    • Total - 1
Overall
  • Total - 3
    • 2 Humans
      • 1 Man
      • 1 Woman
    • 1 Animal
      • 1 Horse
Kidnapping II
Enemies
  • Unnamed Man - Shot to death by either Arthur Morgan or John Marston. Shared kill.
    • Total - 1
Animals
  • Horse - Shot to death by either Arthur Morgan or John Marston, optional. Shared kill.
    • Total - 1
Other
  • Unnamed Woman - Shot to death by either Arthur Morgan or John Marston, optional. Shared kill.
    • Total - 1
Overall
  • Total - 3
    • 2 Humans
      • 1 Man
      • 1 Woman
    • 1 Animal
      • 1 Horse
Two Outlaws Trying to Break Open a Safe
Enemies
  • Two Unnamed Men - Either accidentally blown up with dynamite or shot to death by either Arthur Morgan or John Marston. Shared kills.
    • Total - 2
Animals
  • Two Stagecoach Horses - Shot to death by either Arthur Morgan or John Marston, optional. Shared kills.
    • Total - 2
Overall
  • Total - 4
    • 2 Humans
      • 2 Men
    • 2 Animals
      • 2 Horses
Two Outlaws With a Crashed Wagon
Enemies
  • Unnamed Man - Knocked out by the other outlaw and then optionally shot to death by either Arthur Morgan or John Marston. Shared kill.
  • Unnamed Man - Shot to death by either Arthur Morgan or John Marston, optional. Shared kills.
    • Total - 2
Animals
  • Horse - Shot to death by either Arthur Morgan or John Marston, optional. Shared kill.
    • Total - 1
Overall
  • Total - 3
    • 2 Humans
      • 2 Men
    • 1 Animal
      • 1 Horse
Injured Woman Robbery Ambush (Lydie)
Named Characters
  • Lydie - Shot to death by either Arthur Morgan or John Marston, optional. Shared kill.
  • Bobbie - Shot to death by either Arthur Morgan or John Marston, optional. Shared kill.
  • Earl - Shot to death by either Arthur Morgan or John Marston, optional. Shared kill.
    • Total - 3
Animals
  • Two Horses - Shot to death by either Arthur Morgan or John Marston, optional. Shared kills.
    • Total - 2
Overall
  • Total - 5
    • 3 Humans
      • 2 Men
      • 1 Woman
    • 2 Animals
      • 2 Horses
Horse Thief I
Enemies
  • Unnamed Man - Shot to death by either Arthur Morgan or John Marston for stealing their horse. Shared kill. (New Hanover)
    • Total - 1
Overall
  • Total - 1
    • 1 Human
      • 1 Man
Horse Thief II
Enemies
  • Unnamed Man - Shot to death by either Arthur Morgan or John Marston for stealing their horse. Shared kill. (Van Horn Trading Post)
    • Total - 1
Overall
  • Total - 1
    • 1 Human
      • 1 Man
Robbery
Enemies
  • Unnamed Man - Shot to death by either Arthur Morgan or John Marston. Shared kill.
    • Total - 1
Overall
  • Total - 1
    • 1 Human
      • 1 Man
Bridge Holdup
Enemies
  • Four Unnamed Men - Shot to death by either Arthur Morgan or John Marston. Shared kills.
    • Total - 4
Animals
  • Two Horses - Shot to death by either Arthur Morgan or John Marston, optional. Shared kills.
    • Total - 2
Overall
  • Total - 6
    • 4 Humans
      • 4 Men
    • 2 Animals
      • 2 Horses
Uncle's Saloon Debacle I
Other
  • Unnamed Man - Shot to death by either Arthur Morgan or John Marston for bullying Uncle, optional. (Blackwater)
    • Total - 1
Overall
  • Total - 1
    • 1 Human
      • 1 Man
Uncle's Saloon Debacle II
Other
  • Unnamed Man - Shot to death by either Arthur Morgan or John Marston for bullying Uncle, optional. (Valentine)
    • Total - 1
Overall
  • Total - 1
    • 1 Human
      • 1 Man
Attempted Murder
Named Characters
  • Horace - Shot to death by either Arthur Morgan or John Marston, optional. Shared kill.
    • Total - 1
Enemies
  • Two Unnamed Men - Shot to death by either Arthur Morgan or John Marston. Shared kills.
    • Total - 2
Animals
  • Two Horses - Shot to death by either Arthur Morgan or John Marston, optional. Shared kills.
    • Total - 2
Other
  • Horace's Wife - Either stabbed to death by one of the two kidnappers or optionally shot to death by either Arthur Morgan or John Marston. Shared kill.
    • Total - 1
Overall
  • Total - 6
    • 4 Humans
      • 3 Men
      • 1 Woman
    • 2 Animals
      • 2 Horses
Brutal Death
Animals
  • Horse - Shot to death by either Arthur Morgan or John Marston, optional. Shared kill.
    • Total - 1
Other
  • Unnamed Man - Tortured to death by an unknown person off-screen, body shown.
    • Total - 1
Overall
  • Total - 2
    • 1 Human
      • 1 Man
    • 1 Animal
      • 1 Horse

Random People

Blind Man Cassidy
Named Characters
  • "Blind Man" Cassidy - Shot to death by either Arthur Morgan or John Marston, optional. Shared kill.
    • Total - 1
Overall
  • Total - 1
    • 1 Human
      • 1 Man
Nigel (Gavin's Friend)
Named Characters
  • Nigel - Shot to death by either Arthur Morgan or John Marston, optional. Shared kill.
    • Total - 1
Overall
  • Total - 1
    • 1 Human
      • 1 Man
Agnes Dowd
Named Characters
  • Agnes Dowd - Committed suicide by hanging herself off-screen in 1883, grave shown. Revived as a ghost.
  • Agnes Dowd (Ghost) - Stabbed with a tomahawk thrown by either Arthur Morgan or John Marston, optional. Shared kill.
    • Total - 2
Other
  • Agnes Dowd's Lover - Shot to death by her father off-screen sometime before 1883, mentioned.
  • Agnes Dowd's Father - Murdered by Agnes Dowd in an unknown manner off-screen sometime before 1883, implied on her grave stone.
  • Agnes Dowd's Mother - Murdered by Agnes Dowd in an unknown manner off-screen sometime before 1883, implied on her grave stone.
    • Total - 3
Overall
  • Total - 5
    • 4 Humans
      • 2 Men
      • 2 Women
    • 1 Ghost
      • All Women
Mad Preacher
Named Characters
  • John/The Mad Preacher - Shot to death by either Arthur Morgan or John Marston, optional. Shared kill.
    • Total - 1
Overall
  • Total - 1
    • 1 Human
      • 1 Man
Peeping Toms I
Other
  • Two Unnamed Men - Shot to death by either Arthur Morgan or John Marston, optional. Shared kills.
  • Unnamed Man - Shot to death by either Arthur Morgan or John Marston, optional. Shared kill.
  • Unnamed Woman - Shot to death by either Arthur Morgan or John Marston, optional. Shared kill.
    • Total - 4
Overall
  • Total - 4
    • 4 Humans
      • 3 Men
      • 1 Woman
Peeping Toms II
Named Characters
  • Hank - Shot to death by either Arthur Morgan or John Marston, optional. Shared kill.
    • Total - 1
Other
  • Two Unnamed Men - Shot to death by either Arthur Morgan or John Marston, optional. Shared kills.
  • Hank's Wife - Shot to death by either Arthur Morgan or John Marston, optional. Shared kill.
Overall
  • Total - 4
    • 4 Humans
      • 3 Men
      • 1 Woman
Peeping Toms III
Other
  • Two Unnamed Men - Shot to death by either Arthur Morgan or John Marston, optional. Shared kills.
  • Unnamed Woman - Shot to death by either Arthur Morgan or John Marston, optional. Shared kill.
    • Total - 3
Overall
  • Total - 3
    • 3 Humans
      • 2 Men
      • 1 Woman
Soothsayer
Other
  • Unnamed Woman - Shot to death by either Arthur Morgan or John Marston, optional. Shared kill.
    • Total - 1
Overall
  • Total - 1
    • 1 Human
      • 1 Woman
Lost Dog I
Animals
  • Dog - Shot to death by either Arthur Morgan or John Marston, optional. Shared kill. (Emerald Ranch)
    • Total - 1
Overall
  • Total - 1
    • 1 Animal
      • 1 Dog
Lost Dog II
Animals
  • Dog - Shot to death by either Arthur Morgan or John Marston, optional. Shared kill. (Strawberry)
    • Total - 1
Overall
  • Total - 1
    • 1 Animal
      • 1 Dog
Hayden Russell
Named Characters
  • Captain Hayden Russell - Shot to death by either Arthur Morgan or John Marston, optional. Shared kill.
    • Total - 1
Overall
  • Total - 1
    • 1 Human
      • 1 Man
Poor Joe
Named Characters
  • "Poor" Joe/King Joe - Shot to death by either Arthur Morgan or John Marston, optional. Shared kill.
    • Total - 1
Overall
  • Total - 1
    • 1 Human
      • 1 Man
Lost Tourist
Other
  • Unnamed Man - Shot to death by either Arthur Morgan or John Marston, optional. Shared kill.
    • Total - 1
Overall
  • Total - 1
    • 1 Human
      • 1 Man
Directionally-Challenged Drunk I
Animals
  • Horse - Shot to death by either Arthur Morgan or John Marston, optional. Shared kill.
    • Total - 1
Other
  • Unnamed Man - Either kicked in the head by a horse after spooking it or optionally shot to death by either Arthur Morgan or John Marston. Shared kill.
    • Total - 1
Overall
  • Total - 2
    • 1 Human
      • 1 Man
    • 1 Animal
      • 1 Horse
Directionally-Challenged Drunk II
Other
  • Unnamed Man - Either drowned after walking off a dock into a river or optionally shot to death by either Arthur Morgan or John Marston.
    • Total - 1
Overall
  • Total - 1
    • 1 Human
      • 1 Man
Mickey
Named Characters
  • Mickey - Shot to death by either Arthur Morgan or John Marston, optional. Shared kill.
    • Total - 1
Animals
  • Mickey's Puppy - Accidentally smothered to death by Mickey when he fell asleep on top of it.
    • Total - 1
Other
  • Mickey's Friend - Died of unspecified causes off-screen, mentioned.
  • Mickey's Uncle Arthur - Died of unspecified causes off-screen several years prior, mentioned.
    • Total - 2
Overall
  • Total - 4
    • 3 Humans
      • 3 Men
    • 1 Animal
      • 1 Dog
Joe Butler
Named Characters
  • Joe Butler - Shot to death by either Arthur Morgan or John Marston, optional. Shared kill.
    • Total - 1
Other
  • All Five of Joe Butler's Brothers - Died of unknown causes during the American Civil War off-screen, mentioned.
  • Joe Butler's Wife - Died of Cholera off-screen, mentioned.
    • Total - 6
Overall
  • Total - 7
    • 7 Humans
      • 6 Men
      • 1 Woman
Drunk Camp Veteran
Other
  • Unnamed Man - Shot to death by either Arthur Morgan or John Marston, optional. Shared kill.
    • Total - 1
Overall
  • Total - 1
    • 1 Human
      • 1 Man
Moonshiner I
Animals
  • Two Horses - Shot to death by either Arthur Morgan or John Marston, optional. Shared kills.
    • Total - 2
Other
  • Two Unnamed Men - Shot to death by either Arthur Morgan or John Marston, optional. Shared kills. (Big Valley)
    • Total - 2
Overall
  • Total - 4
    • 2 Humans
      • 2 Men
    • 2 Animals
      • 2 Horses
Moonshiner II
Animals
  • Two Horses - Shot to death by either Arthur Morgan or John Marston, optional. Shared kills.
    • Total - 2
Other
  • Two Unnamed Men - Shot to death by either Arthur Morgan or John Marston, optional. Shared kills. (Southfield Flats)
    • Total - 2
Overall
  • Total - 4
    • 2 Humans
      • 2 Men
    • 2 Animals
      • 2 Horses
Moonshiner III
Animals
  • Two Horses - Shot to death by either Arthur Morgan or John Marston, optional. Shared kills.
    • Total - 2
Other
  • Two Unnamed Men - Shot to death by either Arthur Morgan or John Marston, optional. Shared kills. (Blue Water Marsh)
    • Total - 2
Overall
  • Total - 4
    • 2 Humans
      • 2 Men
    • 2 Animals
      • 2 Horses
Moonshiners IV
Enemies
  • Unnamed Man - Shot to death by either Arthur Morgan or John Marston. Shared kill.
    • Total - 1
Animals
  • Two Horses - Shot to death by either Arthur Morgan or John Marston, optional. Shared kills.
    • Total - 2
Other
  • Unnamed Man - Either accidentally poisoned when either Arthur Morgan or John Marston added Oleander Sage to his moonshine or shot to death by either Arthur or John. Shared kill.
    • Total - 1
Overall
  • Total - 4
    • 2 Humans
      • 2 Men
    • 2 Animals
      • 2 Horses
Treasure Hunter with High Stakes Treasure Map
Animals
  • Horse - Shot to death by either Arthur Morgan or John Marston. Shared kill.
    • Total - 1
Other
  • Unnamed Man - Shot to death by either Arthur Morgan or John Marston. Shared kill.
    • Total - 1
Overall
  • Total - 2
    • 1 Human
      • 1 Man
    • 1 Animal
      • 1 Horse
Heartbroken Stone-Thrower
Other
  • Unnamed Man - Shot to death by John Marston. (Only killable during/after the epilogue)
    • Total - 1
Overall
  • Total - 1
    • 1 Human
      • 1 Man
Conman in Hiding in Strawberry
Other
  • Unnamed Conman - Either drowned in sewage by an unnamed man or optionally shot to death by either Arthur Morgan or John Marston. Shared kill.
  • Unnamed Man - Shot to death by either Arthur Morgan or John Marston. Shared kill.
    • Total - 2
Overall
  • Total - 2
    • 2 Humans
      • 2 Men
Braithwaite Trespasses on Caliga Hall
Other
  • Two Unnamed Gray Family Guards - Shot to death by Arthur Morgan, optional.
  • Unnamed Braithwaite Family Spy - Either executed by one of the Gray Family guards or optionally shot to death by Arthur Morgan.
    • Total - 3
Overall
  • Total - 3
    • 3 Humans
      • 3 Men
Shipwreck
Other
  • Unnamed Man - Died of his injuries after drowning and washing ashore.
    • Total - 1
Overall
  • Total - 1
    • 1 Human
      • 1 Man
Fistfight Challenge
Other
  • Unnamed Man - Knocked out by an unnamed man and then optionally shot to death by either Arthur Morgan or John Marston. Shared kill.
  • Unnamed Man - Shot to death by either Arthur Morgan or John Marston. Shared kill.
    • Total - 2
Overall
  • Total - 2
    • 2 Humans
      • 2 Men
Reverend Peter Fotheringham
Named Characters
  • Reverend Peter Fotheringham - Shot to death by either Arthur Morgan or John Marston. Shared kill.
    • Total - 1
Overall
  • Total - 1
    • 1 Human
      • 1 Man
Unlucky Man
Other
  • Unnamed Man - Either eventually hanged by the city of Saint Denis or optionally shot to death by either Arthur Morgan or John Marston. Shared kill.
  • Unnamed Woman - Murdered by the unnamed man off-screen, mentioned.
    • Total - 2
Overall
  • Total - 2
    • 2 Humans
      • 1 Man
      • 1 Woman
Timothy A. Donahue
Named Characters
  • Timothy A. Donahue - Shot to death by either Arthur Morgan or John Marston. Shared kill.
    • Total - 1
Overall
  • Total - 1
    • 1 Human
      • 1 Man
Norris Forsythe
Named Characters
  • Norris Forsythe - Shot to death by either Arthur Morgan or John Marston. Shared kill.
    • Total - 1
Overall
  • Total - 1
    • 1 Human
      • 1 Man
Skinny Dipper
Other
  • Unnamed Man - Shot to death by either Arthur Morgan or John Marston. Shared kill.
    • Total - 1
Overall
  • Total - 1
    • 1 Human
      • 1 Man
Feral Man
Animals
  • Four Deer - Shot to death by the unnamed man's father with a shotgun off-screen in 1881, mentioned.
  • Three Wolves - Shot to death by either Arthur Morgan or John Marston. Shared kills.
  • Two Trout - Captured and eaten by the unnamed man off-screen in 1881, mentioned.
  • Rabbit - Killed and eaten by the unnamed man off-screen, body shown.
  • Quail - Shot in the throat by the unnamed man off-screen in 1881, mentioned.
    • Total - 11
Other
  • Unnamed Man - Shot to death by either Arthur Morgan or John Marston. Shared kill.
    • Total - 1
Overall
  • Total - 12
    • 11 Animals
      • 4 Deer
      • 3 Wolves
      • 2 Fish
      • 1 Rabbit
      • 1 Bird
    • 1 Human
      • 1 Man
Captive in the Rhodes Gunsmith Store
Named Characters
  • Sammy - Accidentally drowned in a river after firing a rifle and being knocked back by the recoil off-screen several years prior, mentioned.
    • Total - 1
Other
  • Sammy's Father - Shot to death by either Arthur Morgan or John Marston, optional.
  • Unnamed Man - Shot to death by either Arthur Morgan or John Marston, optional.
    • Total - 2
Overall
  • Total - 3
    • 3 Humans
      • 3 Men
Manito Glade Hermit
Enemies
  • Unnamed Man - Shot to death by either Arthur Morgan or John Marston. Shared kill.
    • Total - 1
Overall
  • Total - 1
    • 1 Human
      • 1 Man
Domestic Violence I
Enemies
  • Unnamed Man - Shot to death by either Arthur Morgan or John Marston, optional. Shared kill. (Valentine)
    • Total - 1
Other
  • Unnamed Woman - Either drowned by her husband in a water trough or optionally shot to death by either Arthur Morgan or John Marston. Shared kill.
    • Total - 1
Overall
  • Total - 2
    • 2 Humans
      • 1 Man
      • 1 Woman
Domestic Violence II
Enemies
  • Unnamed Man - Shot to death by either Arthur Morgan or John Marston, optional. Shared kill. (Rhodes)
    • Total - 1
Other
  • Unnamed Woman - Either drowned by her husband in a water trough or optionally shot to death by either Arthur Morgan or John Marston. Shared kill.
    • Total - 1
Overall
  • Total - 2
    • 2 Humans
      • 1 Man
      • 1 Woman
Sonny the Rapist
Named Characters
  • Sonny - Shot to death by either Arthur Morgan or John Marston. Shared kill.
    • Total - 1
Overall
  • Total - 1
    • 1 Human
      • 1 Man

Saint Denis City Life

Back Alley Mugging I
Enemies
  • Three Unnamed Men - Shot to death by either Arthur Morgan or John Marston. Shared kills.
    • Total - 3
Overall
  • Total - 3
    • 3 Humans
      • 3 Men
Back Alley Mugging II
Enemies
  • Unnamed Man - Shot to death by either Arthur Morgan or John Marston. Shared kill.
    • Total - 1
Other
  • Unnamed Man - Either shot to death by an unnamed mugger or optionally shot by either Arthur Morgan or John Marston. Shared kill.
    • Total - 1
Overall
  • Total - 2
    • 2 Humans
      • 2 Men
French Couple Robbed
Enemies
  • Unnamed Man - Shot to death by either Arthur Morgan or John Marston. Shared kill.
    • Total - 1
Other
  • Unnamed Woman - Either shot to death by an unnamed mugger or optionally shot by either Arthur Morgan or John Marston. Shared kill.
  • Unnamed Man - Shot to death by either Arthur Morgan or John Marston, optional.
    • Total - 2
Overall
  • Total - 3
    • 3 Humans
      • 2 Men
      • 1 Woman
Beggar I
Other
  • Unnamed Man - Shot to death by either Arthur Morgan or John Marston for pretending to be blind, optional.
    • Total - 1
Overall
  • Total - 1
    • 1 Human
      • 1 Man
Beggar II
  • Unnamed Man - Shot to death by either Arthur Morgan or John Marston for pretending to be blind, optional.
    • Total - 1
Overall
  • Total - 1
    • 1 Human
      • 1 Man
Beggar III
  • Unnamed Man - Shot to death by either Arthur Morgan or John Marston for pretending to be blind, optional.
    • Total - 1
Overall
  • Total - 1
    • 1 Human
      • 1 Man
Street Urchin Ambush
Enemies
  • Three Unnamed Men - Shot to death by either Arthur Morgan or John Marston. Shared kills.
    • Total - 3
Overall
  • Total - 3
    • 3 Humans
      • 3 Men
Doyle's Tavern Rat Infestation
Named Characters
  • Doyle - Shot to death by either Arthur Morgan or John Marston, optional. Shared kill.
    • Total - 1
Animals
  • Seven Rats - Shot to death by either Arthur Morgan or John Marston. Shared kills.
    • Total - 7
Overall
  • Total - 8
    • 7 Animals
      • 7 Rats
    • 1 Human
      • 1 Man
Police Brutality I
Other
  • Unnamed Saint Denis Lawman - Shot to death by either Arthur Morgan or John Marston, optional. Shared kill.
  • Unnamed Man - Shot to death by either Arthur Morgan or John Marston, optional. Shared kill.
    • Total - 2
Overall
  • Total - 2
    • 2 Humans
      • 2 Men
Police Brutality II
Other
  • Unnamed Saint Denis Lawman - Shot to death by either Arthur Morgan or John Marston, optional. Shared kill.
  • Unnamed Man - Shot to death by either Arthur Morgan or John Marston, optional. Shared kill.
    • Total - 2
Overall
  • Total - 2
    • 2 Humans
      • 2 Men
Jeering Men
Enemies
  • Two Unnamed Men - Shot to death by either Arthur Morgan or John Marston, optional. Shared kills.
    • Total - 2
Overall
  • Total - 2
    • 2 Humans
      • 2 Men
Dorothea Wicklow
Named Characters
  • Dorothea Wicklow - Shot to death by either Arthur Morgan or John Marston, optional. Shared kill.
    • Total - 1
Overall
  • Total - 1
    • 1 Human
      • 1 Woman
Man Splashed by Passing Wagon
Animals
  • Wagon Horse - Shot to death by either Arthur Morgan or John Marston, optional. Shared kill.
    • Total - 1
Other
  • Two Unnamed Men - Shot to death by either Arthur Morgan or John Marston, optional. Shared kills.
  • Unnamed Person - Shot to death by either Arthur Morgan or John Marston, optional. Shared kill.
    • Total - 3
Overall
  • Total - 4
    • 3 Humans
      • 2 Men
      • 1 Victim of Unknown Gender
    • 1 Animal
      • 1 Horse
An Abrupt End to An Argument
Other
  • Two Unnamed Men - Shot to death by either Arthur Morgan or John Marston, optional. Shared kills.
  • Unnamed Woman - Shot to death by either Arthur Morgan or John Marston, optional. Shared kill.
    • Total - 3
Overall
  • Total - 3
    • 3 Humans
      • 2 Men
      • 1 Woman
Man Splashed By Woman Dumping a Chamberpot
Other
  • Unnamed Man - Shot to death by either Arthur Morgan or John Marston, optional. Shared kill.
  • Unnamed Woman - Shot to death by either Arthur Morgan or John Marston, optional. Shared kill.
    • Total - 2
Overall
  • Total - 2
    • 2 Humans
      • 1 Man
      • 1 Woman
Chelonian Spokesman
Other
  • Unnamed Male Chelonia Member - Shot to death by either Arthur Morgan or John Marston, optional. Shared kill.
    • Total - 1
Overall
  • Total - 1
    • 1 Human
      • 1 Man
Man Recognizes Arthur From "A Fine Night of Debauchery"
Other
  • Unnamed Man - Shot to death by Arthur Morgan.
    • Total - 1
Overall
  • Total - 1
    • 1 Human
      • 1 Man
Vampire
Enemies
  • Nosferatu/The Saint Denis Vampire - Shot to death by either Arthur Morgan or John Marston. Shared kill.
    • Total - 1
Other
  • Unnamed Man - Blood drained by the Saint Denis Vampire off-screen, body shown.
    • Total - 1
Overall
  • Total - 2
    • 1 Human
      • 1 Man
    • 1 Monster
      • 1 Vampire
        • 1 Man

Valentine

Smithfield's Saloon Fight
Other
  • Unnamed Man - Knocked unconscious during a fight with another man and then optionally killed by either Arthur Morgan or John Marston. Shared kill.
  • Unnamed Man - Shot to death by either Arthur Morgan or John Marston, optional. Shared kill.
    • Total - 2
Overall
  • Total - 2
    • 2 Humans
      • 2 Men
Man Asks The Protagonist to Help Him Rob His Friend
Other
  • Unnamed Man - Shot to death by either Arthur Morgan or John Marston, optional. Shared kill.
  • Unnamed Female Hotel Worker - Shot to death by either Arthur Morgan or John Marston, optional. Shared kill.
  • Unnamed Man - Knocked unconscious by either Arthur Morgan or John Marston and then optionally killed. Shared kill.
    • Total - 3
Overall
  • Total - 3
    • 3 Humans
      • 2 Men
      • 1 Woman
Man Confronts Arthur About Beating up Tommy
Other
  • Unnamed Man - Shot to death by Arthur Morgan, optional.
    • Total - 1
Overall
  • Total - 1
    • 1 Human
      • 1 Man
Public Hanging
Named Characters
  • Sheriff Malloy - Shot to death by either Arthur Morgan or John Marston, optional. Shared kill.
    • Total - 1
Other
  • Three Unknown People - Murdered by an unnamed man off-screen, mentioned.
  • Unnamed Man - Either hanged by an unknown person on the orders of Sheriff Malloy or optionally shot to death by either Arthur Morgan or John Marston. Shared kill.
  • Unnamed Man's Wife - Shot to death by either Arthur Morgan or John Marston, optional. Shared kill.
    • Total - 5
Overall
  • Total - 6
    • 6 Humans
      • 3 Victims of Unknown Gender
      • 2 Men
      • 1 Woman
Accusatory Widow
Other
  • Unnamed Woman's Husband - Murdered by either Arthur Morgan or John Marston off-screen, mentioned. Shared kill.
  • Unnamed Woman - Shot to death by either Arthur Morgan or John Marston, optional. Shared kill.
    • Total - 2
Overall
  • Total - 2
    • 2 Humans
      • 1 Man
      • 1 Woman

Blackwater

Alley Mugging
Enemies
  • Unnamed Man - Shot to death by John Marston.
    • Total - 1
Other
  • Unnamed Man - Shot to death by either a mugger or optionally by John Marston.
    • Total - 1
Overall
  • Total - 2
    • 2 Humans
      • 2 Men
Out of Control Wagon
Animals
  • Wagon Horse - Shot to death by John Marston, optional.
    • Total - 1
Other
  • Unnamed Man - Shot to death by The Skinner Brothers with bows and arrows off-screen, body shown.
    • Total - 1
Overall
  • Total - 2
    • 1 Human
      • 1 Man
    • 1 Animal
      • 1 Horse

Guarma

Pitfall Trap
Enemies
  • Four Unnamed Cuban Soldiers - Shot to death by Arthur Morgan.
    • Total - 4
Overall
  • Total - 4
    • 4 Humans
      • 4 Men
Soldiers Pursuing Two Escapees
Enemies
  • Three Unnamed Cuban Soldiers - Shot to death by Arthur Morgan.
    • Total - 3
Other
  • Two Unnamed Guarma Prisoners - Either shot to death by the Cuban soldiers or optionally shot by Arthur Morgan.
    • Total - 2
Overall
  • Total - 5
    • 5 Humans
      • 5 Men

Armadillo/New Austin

Undertaker Burning Bodies in Coot's Chapel
Other
  • Seven Unknown People - Died of Cholera off-screen, bodies shown in a mass grave.
  • Unnamed Man - Shot to death by John Marston, optional.
    • Total - 8
Overall
  • Total - 8
    • 8 Humans
      • 7 Victims of Unknown Gender
      • 1 Man
Undertaker Exhausted
Animals
  • Wagon Horse - Shot to death by John Marston, optional.
    • Total - 1
Other
  • Three Unnamed Men - Shot to death by John Marston, optional.
  • Two Unknown People - Died of Cholera off-screen, bodies shown in a mass grave.
    • Total - 5
Overall
  • Total - 6
    • 5 Humans
      • 3 Men
      • 2 Victims of Unknown Gender
    • 1 Animal
      • 1 Horse
Town Crier in Armadillo
Other
  • Unnamed Man - Shot to death by John Marston, optional.
    • Total - 1
Overall
  • Total - 1
    • 1 Human
      • 1 Man
Fleeing Family Leaving Armadillo
Animals
  • Two Stagecoach Horses - Shot to death by John Marston, optional.
    • Total - 2
Other
  • Unnamed Man - Shot to death by John Marston, optional.
  • Unnamed Woman - Shot to death by John Marston, optional.
    • Total - 2
Overall
  • Total - 4
    • 2 Humans
      • 1 Man
      • 1 Woman
    • 2 Animals
      • 2 Horses
Exploding House
Other
  • Unnamed Man - Accidentally blown up when his lab exploded.
    • Total - 1
Overall
  • Total - 1
    • 1 Human
      • 1 Man
Tree Hermit
Other
  • Unnamed Man - Fell to his death after John Marston shot the floor of his tree house, optional.
    • Total - 1
Overall
  • Total - 1
    • 1 Human
      • 1 Man

Appleseed Timber Company

Encounter I
Other
  • Unnamed Man - Shot to death by either Arthur Morgan or John Marston, optional. Shared kill.
    • Total - 1
Overall
  • Total - 1
    • 1 Human
      • 1 Man
Encounter II
Other
  • Five Unnamed Men - Shot to death by either Arthur Morgan or John Marston, optional. Shared Kills.
    • Total - 5
Overall
  • Total - 5
    • 5 Humans
      • 5 Men
Encounter III
Animals
  • Three Wolves - Shot to death by either Arthur Morgan or John Marston. Shared kills.
    • Total - 3
Other
  • Four Unnamed Men - Shot to death by either Arthur Morgan or John Marston, optional. Shared kills.
  • Two Unnamed Men - Eaten alive by wolves off-screen, bodies shown.
    • Total - 6
Overall
  • Total - 9
    • 6 Humans
      • 6 Men
    • 3 Animals
      • 3 Wolves

Castor's Ridge

Encounter I
  • None
Encounter II
Enemies
  • Four Unnamed Extortionists - Shot to death by Arthur Morgan.
    • Total - 4
Overall
  • Total - 4
    • 4 Humans
      • 4 Men
Encounter III
  • None
Encounter IV
Named Characters
  • Curtis - Shot to death by Arthur Morgan, optional.
    • Total - 1
Other
  • Curtis' Father - Shot to death by Arthur Morgan, optional.
  • Curtis' Brother - Shot to death by Arthur Morgan, optional.
  • Unnamed Man - Shot to death by Arthur Morgan, optional.
  • Unnamed Woman - Shot to death by Arthur Morgan, optional.
    • Total - 4
Overall
  • Total - 5
    • 5 Humans
      • 4 Men
      • 1 Woman

Central Union Railroad Camp

Encounter I
Named Characters
  • Randal - Shot to death by Arthur Morgan, optional.
    • Total - 1
Overall
  • Total - 1
    • 1 Human
      • 1 Man
Encounter II
Enemies
  • Unnamed Cornwall Guard - Shot to death by Arthur Morgan.
  • Two Unnamed Cornwall Guards - Shot to death by Arthur Morgan, optional.
    • Total - 3
Overall
  • Total - 3
    • 3 Humans
      • 3 Men
Encounter III
  • None

Newspapers

Blackwater Ledger

No. 62
Named Characters
  • Huntington Schrader - Shot to death by two Del Lobo gang members off-screen, mentioned.
  • Isaac Schrader - Shot to death by two Del Lobo gang members off-screen, mentioned.
  • Reverend Alex H. Hughes - Shot to death by Colm O'Driscoll and members of his gang off-screen, mentioned.
    • Total - 3
Animals
  • Cow - Mauled to death by a bear off-screen, mentioned.
    • Total - 1
Other
  • 20 Unknown People - Shot to death by Colm O'Driscoll and members of his gang off-screen, 21 mentioned minus the already counted Reverend Alex H. Holmes.
  • Unnamed Del Lobo Gang Member - Shot to death by Huntington Schrader off-screen, mentioned.
  • Unnamed Man - Mauled to death by a bear off-screen, mentioned.
    • Total - 22
Overall
  • Total - 26
    • 25 Humans
      • 20 Victims of Unknown Gender
      • 5 Men
    • 1 Animal
      • 1 Cow
No. 63
Named Characters
  • Thomas Eberhardt - Accidentally broke his neck after crashing his car and being launched out.
  • Fannie Crenshaw - Poisoned by Benedict Allbright.
    • Total - 2
Other
  • 300 Unnamed United States Soldiers - Killed by unknown people during a war against Guarma off-screen, mentioned.
    • Total - 300
Overall
  • Total - 302
    • 302 Humans
      • 301 Men
      • 1 Woman
No. 64
Other
  • 2,500 Unnamed United States Soldiers - Died of Typhoid fever off-screen, mentioned.
    • Total - 2,500
Overall
  • Total - 2,500
    • 2,500 Humans
      • 2,500 Men
No. 65
Named Characters
  • Officer Henry Jenkins - Shot in the head by one of Angelo Bronte's men on his orders off-screen, mentioned.
  • Bosco Lopez - Accidentally sentenced to death by hanging by the city of Saint Denis thinking he was the Saint Denis Vampire off-screen several years prior, mentioned.
    • Total - 2
Other
  • Four Unknown People - Blood drained by the Saint Denis Vampire off-screen, five mentioned minus one previously counted victim.
    • Total - 4
Overall
  • Total - 6
    • 6 Humans
      • 4 Victims of Unknown Gender
      • 2 Men
No. 66
  • None
No. 67
  • None
No. 68
Named Characters
  • Reverend Benson Floyd - Tortured and then hanged by a lynch mob off-screen, mentioned.
  • Chandler - Murdered by an unknown person off-screen, mentioned.
    • Total - 2
Overall
  • Total - 2
    • 2 Humans
      • 2 Men
No. 69
Named Characters
  • Agnes Henshaw - Killed by The Murfree Brood off-screen, mentioned.
  • Otis Miller Sr. - Shot to death by Charlie Tatum off-screen, mentioned.
    • Total - 2
Other
  • Both of Agnes Henshaw's Sons - Killed by The Murfree Brood off-screen, mentioned.
  • Two Unnamed Women - Killed by The Murfree Brood off-screen, mentioned.
  • Unnamed Male Child - Killed by The Murfree Brood off-screen, mentioned.
    • Total - 5
Overall
  • Total - 7
    • 7 Humans
      • 4 Men
      • 3 Women
No. 70
Other
  • Ten Unnamed Members of the Blackwater Athletics Team - Murdered by Edmund Lowry Jr. off-screen, bodies shown in a mass grave.
    • Total - 10
Overall
  • Total - 10
    • 10 Humans
      • 10 Men
No. 71
Named Characters
  • Flora Lamb - Succumbed to an unspecified illness off-screen, mentioned.
  • Ruby Lamb - Succumbed to an unspecified illness off-screen, mentioned.
    • Total - 2
Overall
  • Total - 2
    • 2 Humans
      • 2 Women
No. 72
Other
  • At Least 1,000,000 Unknown People - Died in a plague of Influenza off-screen sometime before 1899, mentioned.
  • Myrtle Snodgrass' Husband - Died of unspecified causes off-screen, mentioned.
    • Total - 1,000,001
Overall
  • Total - 1,000,001
    • 1,000,001 Humans
      • 1,000,000 Victims of Unknown Gender
      • 1 Woman
No. 73
  • None
No. 74
Named Characters
  • William Bishop - Shot to death by several police officers off-screen, mentioned.
  • Harold Sutton - Shot to death by several police officers off-screen, mentioned.
  • James Shaw - Shot to death by several police officers off-screen, mentioned.
    • Total - 3
Animals
  • Marshall Tidwell's Horse - Shot to death by either Cletus Yarnell or Lawrence Branch off-screen, mentioned.
    • Total - 1
Other
  • 3,000 Unknown People - Killed in an earthquake off-screen, mentioned.
    • Total - 3,000
Overall
  • Total - 3,004
    • 3,003 Humans
      • 3,000 Victims of Unknown Gender
      • 3 Men
    • 1 Animal
      • 1 Horse
No. 75
  • None

Homesteads

Aberdeen Pig Farm

Named Characters
  • Bray Aberdeen - Shot to death by either Arthur Morgan or John Marston. Shared kill.
  • Tammy Aberdeen - Shot to death by either Arthur Morgan or John Marston. Shared kill.
    • Total - 2
Other
  • Both of Bray and Tammy's Parents - Murdered by Bray and Tammy off-screen, mentioned. Shared kills.
  • 14 Unknown People - Murdered by Bray and Tammy off-screen, bodies shown.
    • Total - 16
Overall
  • Total - 18
    • 18 Humans
      • 14 Victims of Unknown Gender
      • 2 Men
      • 2 Women

Van Horn Mansion

Enemies
  • Two Unnamed Train Robbers - Shot to death by either Arthur Morgan or John Marston. Shared kills.
    • Total - 2
Overall
  • Total - 2
    • 2 Humans
      • 2 Men

Watson's Cabin

Named Characters
  • "Mama" Watson - Either shot to death by either Arthur Morgan or John Marston or eventually died of old age off-screen. Shared kill.
  • Elijah Watson - Shot to death by either Arthur Morgan or John Marston. Shared kill.
  • Ethan Watson - Shot to death by either Arthur Morgan or John Marston. Shared kill.
  • Edgar Watson - Shot to death by either Arthur Morgan or John Marston. Shared kill.
  • Ezra Watson - Shot to death by either Arthur Morgan or John Marston. Shared kill.
    • Total - 5
Overall
  • Total - 5
    • 5 Humans
      • 4 Men
      • 1 Woman

Cemeteries

Church of the Holy Blessed Virgin

Named Characters
  1. Caroline E. - Died of unspecified causes off-screen in 1815, grave shown.
Other
  • Seven Unknown People - Died of various unknown causes off-screen several years prior, graves shown.
    • Total - 7
Overall
  • Total - 8
    • All Humans
      • 7 Victims of Unknown Gender
      • 1 Woman

Colter Chapel

Other
  • Seven Unknown People - Died of various unknown causes off-screen several years prior, eight graves shown minus Davey's grave.
    • Total - 7
Overall
  • Total - 7
    • All Humans
      • All Victims of Unknown Gender

Coot's Chapel

Overall
  • None (See Notes)

Emerald Ranch

Named Characters
  1. Joshua Burgess - Shot to death by an unknown person and made to look like an accident off-screen in 1898, grave shown.
Other
  • Nine Unknown People - Died of various unknown causes off-screen several years prior, graves shown.
    • Total - 9
Overall
  • Total - 10
    • All Humans
      • 9 Victims of Unknown Gender
      • 1 Man

Eris Field

Other
  • Nine Unknown People - Died of various unknown causes off-screen several years prior, graves shown.
    • Total - 9
Overall
  • Total - 9
    • All Humans
      • All Victims of Unknown Gender

First Church of Rhodes

Named Characters
  1. Charlie Banks - Died of unknown causes off-screen in 1855, grave shown.
  2. Elsie Feeney - Died of unknown causes off-screen in 1868, grave shown.
  3. Gareth Drury - Accidentally crushed underneath a falling tree off-screen in 1840, grave shown.
  4. George Drury - Died of unknown causes off-screen in 1852, grave shown.
  5. Harvey Feeney - Died of unknown causes off-screen in 1868, grave shown.
  6. Marietta Banks - Died of unknown causes off-screen in 1882, grave shown.
  7. Nettie May Feeney - Died of unknown causes off-screen in 1895, grave shown.
  8. Stephen Banks - Died of unknown causes off-screen in 1888, grave shown.
  9. William "Willie" Bowles - Died of unknown causes off-screen in 1896, grave shown.
Other
  • 24 Unknown People - Died of various unknown causes off-screen, 33 graves shown minus nine marked graves.
    • Total - 24
Overall
  • Total - 33
    • All Humans
      • 24 Victims of Unknown Gender
      • 6 Men
      • 3 Women

First Congregational Church of Tumbleweed

Named Characters
  1. Abe Shackleford - Died of alcoholism off-screen 1881, grave shown.
  2. Estella Blankenship - Died of unknown causes off-screen in 1895, grave shown.
  3. Henrietta Feaney - Died of unknown causes off-screen several years prior, grave shown.
  4. Henry Crenshaw - Died of unknown causes off-screen in 1884, grave shown.
  5. James Jacob Somers - Died of unknown causes off-screen in 1876, grave shown.
  6. Larry Chambers - Died of unknown causes off-screen in 1898, grave shown.
  7. Lucile Riggs - Died of unknown causes off-screen in 1879, grave shown.
  8. Philip J. "Papa" Greenup - Died of unknown causes off-screen in 1866, grave shown.
  9. Samson Forth - Died of unknown causes off-screen in 1897, grave shown.
Overall
  • Total - 9
    • All Humans
      • 6 Men
      • 3 Women

Fort Riggs

Other
  • Unknown Native American - Died of unknown causes off-screen, grave shown.
    • Total - 1
Overall
  • Total - 1
    • All Humans
      • All Victims of Unknown Gender

Mossy Flats Graveyard

Named Characters
  1. Ada F. Williams - Died of unknown causes off-screen in 1851, grave shown.
  2. Charles Philip Landry - Died of unknown causes off-screen in 1838, grave shown.
  3. Ezra Meier - Died of unknown causes off-screen in 1824, grave shown.
  4. George Henry Seymour - Died of unknown causes off-screen in 1841, grave shown.
  5. Marion Landry - Died of unknown causes off-screen in 1839, grave shown.
  6. Mary Jane Hubbard - Died of unknown causes off-screen in 1848, grave shown.
  7. Patrick Edward Reilly - Died of unknown causes off-screen in 1849, grave shown.
  8. Walter David Hubbard - Died of unknown causes off-screen in 1848, grave shown.
Other
  • Two Unknown People - Died of unknown causes off-screen, graves shown.
    • Total - 2
Overall
  • Total - 10
    • All Humans
      • 5 Men
      • 3 Women
      • 2 Victims of Unknown Gender

Odd Fellow's Rest

Overall
  • None (See Notes)

Old Tom's Blind

Other
  • 11 Unknown People - Died of various unknown causes off-screen, graves shown.
    • Total - 11
Overall
  • Total - 11
    • All Humans
      • All Victims of Unknown Gender

Saint Denis Cemetery

Named Characters
  1. Ernest Harris - Died of unknown causes off-screen in 1868, grave shown.
  2. General Quincy T. Harris - Died of unknown causes off-screen in 1888, grave shown.
  3. Hector Fellowes Sr. - Died of unknown causes off-screen in 1884, grave shown.
  4. Ira Harris - Died of unknown causes off-screen in 1872, grave shown.
  5. Mabel Harris - Died of unknown causes off-screen in 1872, grave shown.
  6. Ruth Harris - Died of unknown causes off-screen in 1892, grave shown.
  7. Wanda Fellows - Died of unknown causes off-screen in 1890, grave shown.
Other
  • 820 Unknown People - Died of various unknown causes off-screen, 870 graves shown minus 50 marked graves.
  • Four Unknown Members of the Rousseau Family - Died of unknown causes off-screen several years prior, shared grave shown.
  • Three Unknown Members of the Fortune Family - Died of unknown causes off-screen several years prior, shared grave shown.
  • Three Unknown Members of the Moreau Family - Died of unknown causes off-screen several years prior, shared grave shown.
  • Two Unknown Members of the Delaney Family - Died of unknown causes off-screen several years prior, shared grave shown.
  • Two Unknown Members of the Turner Family - Died of unknown causes off-screen several years prior, shared grave shown.
  • Two Unknown Members of the King Family - Died of unknown causes off-screen several years prior, shared grave shown.
  • Two Unknown Members of the Dupont Family - Died of unknown causes off-screen several years prior, shared grave shown.
  • Two Unknown Members of the Desforges Family - Died of unknown causes off-screen several years prior, shared grave shown.
  • Two Unknown Members of the Famille Family - Died of unknown causes off-screen several years prior, shared grave shown.
  • Two Unknown Members of the Beaumont Family - Died of unknown causes off-screen several years prior, shared grave shown.
  • Two Unknown Members of the Family Family - Died of unknown causes off-screen several years prior, two separate graves shown.
  • Unknown Member of the Jarreau Family - Died of unknown causes off-screen several years prior, grave shown.
  • Unknown Member of the Walters Family - Died of unknown causes off-screen several years prior, grave shown.
  • Unknown Member of the Parker Family - Died of unknown causes off-screen several years prior, grave shown.
  • Unknown Member of the Brewster Family - Died of unknown causes off-screen several years prior, grave shown.
  • Unknown Member of the Wright Family - Died of unknown causes off-screen several years prior, grave shown.
  • Unknown Member of the Elmore Family - Died of unknown causes off-screen several years prior, grave shown.
  • Unknown Member of the Allen Family - Died of unknown causes off-screen several years prior, grave shown.
  • Unknown Member of the Moore Family - Died of unknown causes off-screen several years prior, grave shown.
  • Unknown Member of the Vincent Family - Died of unknown causes off-screen several years prior, grave shown.
  • Unknown Member of the Chapman Family - Died of unknown causes off-screen several years prior, grave shown.
  • Unknown Member of the Carter Family - Died of unknown causes off-screen several years prior, grave shown.
  • Unknown Member of the Faust Family - Died of unknown causes off-screen several years prior, grave shown.
  • Unknown Member of the Blanchard Family - Died of unknown causes off-screen several years prior, grave shown.
  • Unknown Member of the Gardner Family - Died of unknown causes off-screen several years prior, grave shown.
  • Unknown Member of the Schmidt Family - Died of unknown causes off-screen several years prior, grave shown.
  • Unknown Member of the Toole Family - Died of unknown causes off-screen several years prior, grave shown.
  • Unknown Member of the Riviere Family - Died of unknown causes off-screen several years prior, grave shown.
    • Total - 863
Overall
  • Total - 870
    • All Humans
      • 863 Victims of Unknown Gender
      • 4 Women
      • 3 Men

Shady Belle Graveyard

Named Characters
  1. Alex Coutee - Died of unknown causes off-screen in 1862, grave shown.
  2. Archilles Chevelier - Died of unknown causes off-screen in 1896, grave shown.
  3. Coline LeBleu - Died of unknown causes off-screen in 1886, grave shown.
  4. Damita Ravarre - Died of unknown causes off-screen in 1890, grave shown.
  5. Esther Leroux - Died of unknown causes off-screen in 1888, grave shown.
  6. Joseph Charlesworth - Died of unknown causes off-screen in 1864, grave shown.
  7. Louis Breax - Died of unknown causes off-screen in 1888, grave shown.
  8. Michele Jardoin - Died of unknown causes off-screen in 1897, grave shown.
  9. Peter Vidrine - Died of unknown causes off-screen in 1852, grave shown.
Other
  • Two Unknown People - Died of various unknown causes off-screen several years prior, 12 graves shown minus nine marked graves and not including Agnes Dowd's grave.
  • Two Unknown People - Died of various unknown causes off-screen several years prior, coffins shown.
    • Total - 4
Overall
  • Total - 13
    • All Humans
      • 5 Men
      • 4 Victims of Unknown Gender
      • 4 Women

The Blackwater Church of Holy Ascension

Named Characters
  1. Ada Stillman - Choked to death on a fish bone off-screen in 1875, grave shown.
  2. Beatrice Picket - Died of unknown causes off-screen in 1873, grave shown.
  3. Belle Finch - Died of cholera off-screen in 1842, grave shown.
  4. Caroline E. Boardman - Died of unknown causes off-screen in 1815, grave shown.
  5. Clinton Underwood - Died of unknown causes off-screen in 1893, grave shown.
  6. Colonel Thurston Hope - Accidentally committed suicide by shooting himself with his own gun off-screen in 1887, grave shown.
  7. Delilah Gaskell - Died of unknown causes off-screen in 1891, grave shown.
  8. Doris Mosely - Died of unknown causes off-screen in 1874, grave shown.
  9. Eldon Crabb - Died of unknown causes off-screen in 1889, grave shown.
  10. Elijah Liggons - Shot to death by an unknown person off-screen in 1885, grave shown.
  11. Emma Crawford - Died of unknown causes off-screen in 1880, grave shown.
  12. Esther Sinclair - Died of unknown causes off-screen in 1864, grave shown.
  13. Freda Dunbar - Died of unknown causes off-screen in 1906, grave shown.
  14. Georgia Dobbs - Died when an unspecified object fell on her off-screen in 1866, grave shown.
  15. Gertrude Barber - Died of unknown causes off-screen in 1898, grave shown.
  16. Matilda Brines - Died of unknown causes off-screen in 1885, grave shown.
  17. Maxwell Laskey - Died in an unspecified battle off-screen several years prior, grave shown.
  18. Minerva Pratt - Died of an unspecified illness off-screen in 1883, grave shown.
  19. Myra Leathers - Died of unknown causes off-screen in 1890, grave shown.
  20. Niles Carruthers - Shot to death by an unknown Native American with a bow and arrow off-screen in 1843, grave shown.
  21. Olive Shipley - Died of unknown causes off-screen in 1865, grave shown.
  22. Pearl Palemer - Died of unknown causes off-screen in 1887, grave shown.
  23. Phylis Shodlow - Died of unknown causes off-screen in 1886, grave shown.
  24. Rose Beasley - Died of unknown causes off-screen in 1899, grave shown.
  25. Samuel Makepeace - Died of unknown causes off-screen in 1879, grave shown.
  26. Seth Trice - Died of unknown causes off-screen in 1847, grave shown.
  27. Stanley Pollard - Died of unknown causes off-screen in 1873, grave shown.
  28. Willie Swenson - Died of unknown causes off-screen in 1893, grave shown.
Animals
  • Fish - Captured by an unknown person and cooked off-screen in 1875, mentioned on Ada's grave.
    • Total - 1
Other
  • Unknown Outlaw - Died of unknown causes off-screen in 1893, grave shown.
  • Unnamed African American Man - Died of unknown causes off-screen in 1891, grave shown.
    • Total - 2
Overall
  • Total - 31
    • 30 Humans
      • 18 Women
      • 11 Men
      • 1 Victim of Unknown Gender
    • 1 Animal
      • All Fish

Valentine Church

Named Characters
  1. Albert Calloway - Died of unknown causes off-screen in 1889, grave shown.
  2. Bridget Dunn - Died of unknown causes off-screen in 1886, grave shown.
  3. Catherine Calloway - Died of unknown causes off-screen in 1875, grave shown.
  4. Eugene Dunn - Died of unknown causes off-screen in 1886, grave shown.
  5. Lucy Dunn - Died of unknown causes off-screen in 1895, grave shown.
  6. Magdalene Dalton - Died of unknown causes off-screen in 1867, grave shown.
  7. Maggie Calloway - Died of unknown causes off-screen in 1876, grave shown.
  8. Marry Dunn - Died of unknown causes off-screen in 1886, grave shown.
  9. Simon Dalton - Died of unknown causes off-screen in 1875, grave shown.
  10. Thomas Dunn - Died of unknown causes off-screen in 1862, grave shown.
Other
  • 59 Unknown People - Died of various unknown causes off-screen several years prior, graves shown.
    • Total - 59
Overall
  • Total - 69
    • All Humans
      • 59 Victims of Unknown Gender
      • 6 Women
      • 4 Men

Van Horn Graveyard

Other
  • 19 Unknown People - Died of various unknown causes off-screen several years prior, graves shown.
  • Two Unnamed Men - Died of various unknown causes off-screen several years prior, graves shown.
    • Total - 21
Overall
  • Total - 21
    • All Humans
      • 19 Victims of Unknown Gender
      • 2 Men

Camp Item Requests

Abigail

  • None

Bill

  • None

Charles

Animals
  • Eagle - Shot to death by John Marston on the request of Charles Smith. Shared kill.
    • Total - 1
Overall
  • Total - 1
    • 1 Animal
      • 1 Bird

Dutch

  • None

Hosea

  • None

Jack

  • None

Javier

  • None

Kieran

  • None

Lenny

  • None

Mary-Beth

  • None

Molly

  • None

Pearson

Animals
  • Rabbit - Shot to death by Arthur Morgan on the request of Simon Pearson. Shared kill.
    • Total - 1
Overall
  • Total - 1
    • 1 Animal
      • 1 Rabbit

Sadie

  • None

Sean

  • None

Susan

  • None

Tilly

  • None

Uncle

  • None

Store Robberies

Saint Denis

Named Characters
  1. Chu Ling - Shot to death by either Arthur Morgan or John Marston, optional. Shared kill.
  2. Jim - Shot to death by either Arthur Morgan or John Marston, optional. Shared kill.
Enemies
  • Unnamed Poker Game Guard - Shot to death by either Arthur Morgan or John Marston, optional. Shared kill.
    • Total - 1
Other
  • Three Unnamed Men - Shot to death by either Arthur Morgan or John Marston, optional. Shared kills.
    • Total - 3
Overall
  • Total - 6
    • All Humans
      • All Men

Strawberry

Named Characters
  1. Chip Cooper - Shot to death by John Marston, optional.
Overall
  • Total - 1
    • All Humans
      • All Men

Valentine

Named Characters
  1. Dr. Ben Calloway - Shot to death by either Arthur Morgan or John Marston, optional. Shared kill.
Enemies
  • Three Unnamed O'Driscoll Gang Members - Shot to death by either Arthur Morgan or John Marston. Shared kills.
  • Unnamed Woman - Shot to death by either Arthur Morgan or John Marston. Shared kill.
    • Total - 4
Overall
  • Total - 5
    • All Humans
      • 4 Men
      • 1 Woman

Gang Hideouts

Beaver Hollow

Enemies
  • 20 Unnamed Murfree Brood Gang Members - Shot to death by John Marston.
    • Total - 20
Animals
  • At Least 11 Horses - Killed by the Murfree Brood off-screen, remains shown.
  • Deer - Killed by the Murfree Brood off-screen, skull shown.
    • Total - 12
Other
  • At Least 29 Unknown People - Tortured to death by the Murfree Brood off-screen, remains shown.
    • Total - 29
Overall
  • Total - 61
    • 49 Humans
      • 29 Victims of Unknown Gender
      • 20 Men
    • 12 Animals
      • 11 Horses
      • 1 Deer

Fort Mercer

Enemies
  • 17 Unnamed Del Lobo Gang Members - Shot to death by John Marston.
    • Total - 17
Overall
  • Total - 17
    • All Humans
      • All Men

Gaptooth Breach

Enemies
  • 23 Unnamed Del Lobo Gang Members - Shot to death by John Marston.
    • Total - 23
Overall
  • Total - 23
    • All Humans
      • All Men

Hanging Dog Ranch

Enemies
  • 17 Unnamed O'Driscolls Gang Members - Shot to death by Arthur Morgan. (Before Epilogue)
    • Total - 17
Overall
  • Total - 17
    • All Humans
      • All Men

Shady Belle

Enemies
  • 16 Unnamed Lemoyne Raiders - Shot to death by John Marston. (After Epilogue)
    • Total - 16
Overall
  • Total - 16
    • All Humans
      • All Men

Six Point Cabin

Enemies
  • 12 Unnamed O'Driscolls Gang Members - Shot to death by Arthur Morgan. (Before Epilogue, After "Paying a Social Call")
    • Total - 12
Overall
  • Total - 12
    • All Humans
      • All Men

Solomon's Folly

Enemies
  • 17 Unnamed Del Lobo Gang Members - Shot to death by John Marston.
    • Total - 17
Overall
  • Total - 17
    • All Humans
      • All Men

Thieves' Landing

Enemies
  • 16 Unnamed Del Lobo Gang Members - Shot to death by John Marston.
    • Total - 16
Overall
  • Total - 16
    • All Humans
      • All Men

Twin Rocks

Enemies
  • 11 Unnamed Del Lobo Gang Members - Shot to death by John Marston.
    • Total - 11
Overall
  • Total - 11
    • All Humans
      • All Men

Documents

Letters

Named Characters
  • Elijah - Died of unknown causes off-screen sometime between 1861 and 1899, body shown. (Letter to Uncle Lewis from Elijah)
  • Corporal Garfield - Stabbed in the chest by an unknown person with a bayonet off-screen during the Civil War, skeleton shown. (Letter to Martha from Garfield)
  • Cardinal Blanco - Died of unknown causes off-screen sometime between 1797 and 1899, implied. (Letter to Brother Rodolfo)
  • Robert Elliot Patchen - Committed suicide by jumping off of a waterfall off-screen sometime before 1899. (Letter from Robert Elliot Patchen)
  • Claude - Stabbed to death by Annette with a machete off-screen, body shown. (Letter to Annette from Claude)
  • Harriot - Stabbed to death by Annette with a machete off-screen, body shown. (Letter to Annette from Claude)
  • Annette - Committed suicide by slashing her wrists and then shooting herself in the head off-screen, body shown. (Letter to Annette from Claude)
  • Lucille Braithwaite - Died of unknown causes off-screen sometime between 1806 and 1899. (Faded Letter)
  • Douglas Gray - Died of unknown causes off-screen sometime between 1806 and 1899. (Faded Letter)
  • Zhou Yi - Died of unknown causes off-screen sometime before 1899, body shown. (Letter to Zhou Yi from Zhou Wei)
    • Total - 10
Other
  • Henrietta Douglas' Husband - Burned alive in a fire off-screen sometime before 1899. (Letter to Henrietta Douglas)
  • 11 Unknown People - Committed suicide in an unknown manner off-screen sometime before 1899, skeletons shown. (Mysterious Sermon)
    • Total - 12
Overall
  • Total - 22
    • 22 Humans
      • 11 Victims of Unknown Gender
      • 8 Men
      • 3 Women

Notes

Named Characters
  • First Lieutenant Ronald Alger - Executed by Confederate soldiers off-screen during the Civil War. (Civil War Report)
    • Total - 1
Overall
  • Total - 1
    • 1 Human
      • 1 Man

Books

Other
  • Unknown Person - Murdered by Jesse Murray off-screen. (Jail Ledger)
    • Total - 1
Overall
  • Total - 1
    • 1 Human
      • 1 Victim of Unknown Gender

Handbills

  • None

Drawings

  • None

Business Cards

  • None

Newspaper Scraps

Named Characters
  • Roscoe Briggs - Hanged by Micah Bell II and Micah Bell III off-screen in 1877. Shared kill. (Micah Newspaper Scrap)
  • Jean Briggs - Hanged by Micah Bell II and Micah Bell III off-screen in 1877. Shared kill. (Micah Newspaper Scrap)
  • Gideon Bennett - Murdered by either Ira or Earl Bennett off-screen in 1896. Shared kill. (Bennett Brothers Newspaper Scrap)
  • Ira Bennett - Murdered by either Gideon Bennett or Earl Bennett off-screen in 1896. Shared kill. (Bennett Brothers Newspaper Scrap)
  • Earl Bennett - Murdered by either Gideon or Ira Bennett off-screen in 1896. Shared kill. (Bennett Brothers Newspaper Scrap)
  • Darragh MacGuire - Shot to death by Lawmen off-screen in 1889. (Former Fenian Raider Killed In Gun Battle)
    • Total - 6
Other
  • Eight Unknown People - Murdered by Darragh MacGuire off-screen sometime before 1889. (Former Fenian Raider Killed In Gun Battle)
  • Unnamed Man - Beaten and stabbed to death by an unknown person off-screen sometime before 1899. (Norwegian Newspaper Scrap)
  • Unnamed Woman - Beaten and stabbed to death by an unknown person off-screen sometime before 1899. (Norwegian Newspaper Scrap)
  • Unknown Child - Beaten and stabbed to death by an unknown person off-screen sometime before 1899. (Norwegian Newspaper Scrap)
    • Total - 11
Overall
  • Total - 17
    • 17 Humans
      • 9 Victims of Unknown Gender
      • 7 Men
      • 1 Woman

Photographs

  • None

Bounty Posters

  • None

Maps

  • None

Treasure Maps

Other
  • Unnamed Man - Either committed suicide by hanging himself or hanged by another person off-screen, body shown. (The Elemental Trail)
  • Two Unnamed Men - Died of unknown causes off-screen, bodies shown. (Le Tresor des Morts)
    • Total - 3
Overall
  • Total - 3
    • 3 Humans
      • 3 Men

Invitations

  • None

Achievements

Grin and Bear It

Animals
  • 18 Bears - Killed by either Arthur Morgan or John Marston. Shared kills.
    • Total - 18
Overall
  • Total - 18
    • 18 Animals
      • 18 Bears

It was THIS BIG!

Animals
  • Fish - Captured by either Arthur Morgan or John Marston. Shared kill.
    • Total - 1
Overall
  • Total - 1
    • 1 Animal
      • 1 Fish

Skin Deep

Animals
  • American Alligator - Killed by either Arthur Morgan or John Marston for it's skin. Shared kill.
  • American Alligator (Small) - Killed by either Arthur Morgan or John Marston for it's skin. Shared kill.
  • Nine-Banded Armadillo - Killed by either Arthur Morgan or John Marston for it's skin. Shared kill.
  • American Badger - Killed by either Arthur Morgan or John Marston for it's skin. Shared kill.
  • American Black Bear - Killed by either Arthur Morgan or John Marston for it's skin. Shared kill.
  • Grizzly Bear - Killed by either Arthur Morgan or John Marston for it's skin. Shared kill.
  • North American Beaver - Killed by either Arthur Morgan or John Marston for it's skin. Shared kill.
  • Wild Boar - Killed by either Arthur Morgan or John Marston for it's skin. Shared kill.
  • Whitetail Buck - Killed by either Arthur Morgan or John Marston for it's skin. Shared kill.
  • Whitetail Deer - Killed by either Arthur Morgan or John Marston for it's skin. Shared kill.
  • American Bison - Killed by either Arthur Morgan or John Marston for it's skin. Shared kill.
  • Greater Prairie Chicken - Killed by either Arthur Morgan or John Marston for it's skin. Shared kill.
  • Cougar - Killed by either Arthur Morgan or John Marston for it's skin. Shared kill.
  • California Valley Coyote - Killed by either Arthur Morgan or John Marston for it's skin. Shared kill.
  • Mallard Duck - Killed by either Arthur Morgan or John Marston for it's skin. Shared kill.
  • Pekin Duck - Killed by either Arthur Morgan or John Marston for it's skin. Shared kill.
  • Reddish Egret - Killed by either Arthur Morgan or John Marston for it's skin. Shared kill.
  • Little Egret - Killed by either Arthur Morgan or John Marston for it's skin. Shared kill.
  • Snowy Egret - Killed by either Arthur Morgan or John Marston for it's skin. Shared kill.
  • Rocky Mountain Bull Elk - Killed by either Arthur Morgan or John Marston for it's skin. Shared kill.
  • Rocky Mountain Cow Elk - Killed by either Arthur Morgan or John Marston for it's skin. Shared kill.
  • American Red Fox - Killed by either Arthur Morgan or John Marston for it's skin. Shared kill.
  • American Gray Fox - Killed by either Arthur Morgan or John Marston for it's skin. Shared kill.
  • Silver Fox - Killed by either Arthur Morgan or John Marston for it's skin. Shared kill.
  • Banded Gila Monster - Killed by either Arthur Morgan or John Marston for it's skin. Shared kill.
  • Canada Goose - Killed by either Arthur Morgan or John Marston for it's skin. Shared kill.
  • Great Blue Heron - Killed by either Arthur Morgan or John Marston for it's skin. Shared kill.
  • Tricolored Heron - Killed by either Arthur Morgan or John Marston for it's skin. Shared kill.
  • Desert Iguana - Killed by either Arthur Morgan or John Marston for it's skin. Shared kill.
  • Green Iguana - Killed by either Arthur Morgan or John Marston for it's skin. Shared kill.
  • Collared Peccary - Killed by either Arthur Morgan or John Marston for it's skin. Shared kill.
  • Common Loon - Killed by either Arthur Morgan or John Marston for it's skin. Shared kill.
  • Pacific Loon - Killed by either Arthur Morgan or John Marston for it's skin. Shared kill.
  • Yellow-billed Loon - Killed by either Arthur Morgan or John Marston for it's skin. Shared kill.
  • Western Bull Moose - Killed by either Arthur Morgan or John Marston for it's skin. Shared kill.
  • Western Moose - Killed by either Arthur Morgan or John Marston for it's skin. Shared kill.
  • American Muskrat - Killed by either Arthur Morgan or John Marston for it's skin. Shared kill.
  • Panther - Killed by either Arthur Morgan or John Marston for it's skin. Shared kill.
  • Florida Panther - Killed by either Arthur Morgan or John Marston for it's skin. Shared kill.
  • Ring-necked Pheasant - Killed by either Arthur Morgan or John Marston for it's skin. Shared kill.
  • Chinese ring-necked Pheasant - Killed by either Arthur Morgan or John Marston for it's skin. Shared kill.
  • Virginia Possum - Killed by either Arthur Morgan or John Marston for it's skin. Shared kill.
  • American Pronghorn Buck - Killed by either Arthur Morgan or John Marston for it's skin. Shared kill.
  • American Pronghorn Doe - Killed by either Arthur Morgan or John Marston for it's skin. Shared kill.
  • Sonoran Pronghorn Buck - Killed by either Arthur Morgan or John Marston for it's skin. Shared kill.
  • Sonoran Pronghorn Doe - Killed by either Arthur Morgan or John Marston for it's skin. Shared kill.
  • Baja California Pronghorn Buck - Killed by either Arthur Morgan or John Marston for it's skin. Shared kill.
  • Baja California Pronghorn Doe - Killed by either Arthur Morgan or John Marston for it's skin. Shared kill.
  • Sierra Nevada Bighorn Ram - Killed by either Arthur Morgan or John Marston for it's skin. Shared kill.
  • Sierra Nevada Bighorn Sheep - Killed by either Arthur Morgan or John Marston for it's skin. Shared kill.
  • Desert Bighorn Ram - Killed by either Arthur Morgan or John Marston for it's skin. Shared kill.
  • Desert Bighorn Sheep - Killed by either Arthur Morgan or John Marston for it's skin. Shared kill.
  • Rocky Mountain Bighorn Ram - Killed by either Arthur Morgan or John Marston for it's skin. Shared kill.
  • Rocky Mountain Bighorn Sheep - Killed by either Arthur Morgan or John Marston for it's skin. Shared kill.
  • Black-tailed Jackrabbit - Killed by either Arthur Morgan or John Marston for it's skin. Shared kill.
  • North American Raccoon - Killed by either Arthur Morgan or John Marston for it's skin. Shared kill.
  • Roseate Spoonbill - Killed by either Arthur Morgan or John Marston for it's skin. Shared kill.
  • Striped Skunk - Killed by either Arthur Morgan or John Marston for it's skin. Shared kill.
  • Diamondback Rattlesnake - Killed by either Arthur Morgan or John Marston for it's skin. Shared kill.
  • Black-tailed Rattlesnake - Killed by either Arthur Morgan or John Marston for it's skin. Shared kill.
  • Timber Rattlesnake - Killed by either Arthur Morgan or John Marston for it's skin. Shared kill.
  • Northern Copperhead Snake - Killed by either Arthur Morgan or John Marston for it's skin. Shared kill.
  • Southern Copperhead Snake - Killed by either Arthur Morgan or John Marston for it's skin. Shared kill.
  • Midland Water Snake - Killed by either Arthur Morgan or John Marston for it's skin. Shared kill.
  • Cottonmouth Snake - Killed by either Arthur Morgan or John Marston for it's skin. Shared kill.
  • Northern Water Snake - Killed by either Arthur Morgan or John Marston for it's skin. Shared kill.
  • Eastern Wild Turkey - Killed by either Arthur Morgan or John Marston for it's skin. Shared kill.
  • Rio Grande Wild Turkey - Killed by either Arthur Morgan or John Marston for it's skin. Shared kill.
  • Alligator Snapping Turtle - Killed by either Arthur Morgan or John Marston for it's skin. Shared kill.
  • Gray Wolf - Killed by either Arthur Morgan or John Marston for it's skin. Shared kill.
  • Timber Wolf - Killed by either Arthur Morgan or John Marston for it's skin. Shared kill.
    • Total - 70
Overall
  • Total - 70
    • 70 Animals
      • 15 Birds
      • 8 Snakes
      • 8 Deer
      • 7 Sheep
      • 3 Foxes
      • 2 Alligators
      • 2 Bears
      • 2 Elk
      • 2 Iguana
      • 2 Moose
      • 2 Panthers
      • 2 Wolves
      • 2 Pigs
      • 1 Armadillo
      • 1 Badger
      • 1 Beaver
      • 1 Bison
      • 1 Cougar
      • 1 Coyote
      • 1 Gila Monster
      • 1 Muskrat
      • 1 Possum
      • 1 Rabbit
      • 1 Raccoon
      • 1 Skunk
      • 1 Turtle

Easter Eggs

Named Characters

  • Anders Helgerson - Shot to death by either Arthur Morgan or John Marston, optional. Shared kill.
  • "Blind Man" Cassidy - Shot to death by either Arthur Morgan or John Marston, optional. Shared kill.
  • Bob Brownlee - Shot to death by John Marston, optional.
  • Dorothea Wicklow - Shot to death by either Arthur Morgan or John Marston, optional. Shared kill.
  • Harville Presley - Shot to death by either Arthur Morgan or John Marston, optional. Shared kill.
  • "Big" Jon - Shot to death by either Arthur Morgan or John Marston, optional. Shared kill.
  • Lillian Powell - Shot to death by either Arthur Morgan or John Marston, optional. Shared kill.
  • Malcolm MacIntosh - Shot to death by either Arthur Morgan or John Marston, optional. Shared kill.
  • Mayor Nicholas Timmons - Shot to death by either Arthur Morgan or John Marston, optional. Shared kill.
  • Reverend Peter Fotheringham - Shot to death by either Arthur Morgan or John Marston, optional. Shared kill.
  • Timothy A. Donahue - Shot to death by either Arthur Morgan or John Marston, optional. Shared kill.
    • Total - 11

Animals

  • Horse - Disemboweled by an unknown animal off-screen, body shown. (Frozen Couple)
  • Gorilla - Killed by an unknown person off-screen, taxidermized body shown.
    • Total - 2

Other

  • Four Unknown Soldiers - Died of unknown causes off-screen during the Civil War, skeletons shown. (Civil War Field Hospital)
  • Unnamed Man - Froze to death in the snow off-screen, body shown. (Frozen Couple)
  • Unnamed Woman - Froze to death in the snow off-screen, body shown. (Frozen Couple)
  • Unnamed Armadillo Town Crier - Shot to death by either Arthur Morgan or John Marston, optional. Shared kill.
    • Total - 7

Overall

  • Total - 20
    • 18 Humans
      • 15 Men
      • 3 Women
    • 2 Animals
      • 1 Horse
      • 1 Gorilla

Dialogue

Named Characters

  • Cain (Dog) - Murdered by Micah Bell III in an unknown manner off-screen, mentioned.
  • Micah Bell I - Died of unknown causes off-screen sometime before 1899, mentioned.
  • Micah Bell II - Died of unknown causes off-screen sometime before 1899, mentioned.
    • Total - 3

Animals

  • Rabbit - Died of unknown causes off-screen, body shown. (Sean and Jack)
    • Total - 1

Other

  • At Least Five Unknown People - Murdered by Micah Bell II off-screen in five counties, mentioned.
    • Total - 5

Overall

  • Total - 9
    • 7 Humans
      • 5 Victims of Unknown Gender
      • 2 Men
    • 2 Animals
      • 1 Dog
      • 1 Rabbit

Deaths

  • Total - 1,022,297
    • Main Story - 3,303
      • Chapter 1 - 95
      • Chapter 2 - 302
      • Chapter 3 - 393
      • Chapter 4 - 329
      • Chapter 5 - 1,015
      • Chapter 6 - 883
      • Epilogue Part 1 - 35
      • Epilogue Part 2 - 251
    • Side Quests - 10,347
    • Companion Activities - 91
      • Lenny Summers - 18
      • Charles Smith - 16
      • Javier Escuella - 11
      • Micah Bell - 11
      • Tilly Jackson - None
      • Sean MacGuire - 12
      • Kieran Duffy - 6
      • Bill Williamson - 6
      • Simon Person - 8
      • Uncle - 3
    • Bounty Hunts - 116
    • Random Encounters - 840
      • Rival Gangs - 429
        • O'Driscolls - 81
        • Del Lobo - 79
        • Laramie - 32
        • Lemoyne Raiders - 154
        • Murfree Brood - 50
        • Skinner Brothers - 27
        • Night Folk - 22
        • Angelo Bronte's Mob - 9
        • Guido Martelli's Mob - 2
        • Ku Klux Klan - 22
      • Nature - 108
      • Outlaws and Lawmen - 92
      • Random People - 93
      • Locations - 118
        • Saint Denis - 42
        • Valentine - 14
        • Black Water - 4
        • Guarma - 9
        • Armadillo/New Austin - 21
        • Appleseed Timber Company - 15
        • Castor's Ridge - 9
        • Central Union Railroad Camp - 4
    • Challenges - 218
      • Banditry - 17
      • Explorer - None
      • Gambler - None
      • Herbalist - None
      • Horseman - 36
      • Master Hunter - 26
      • Sharpshooter - 34
      • Survivalist - 48
      • Weapons Expert - 57
    • Points of Interest - 55
      • Lemoyne - 22
      • New Hanover - 10
      • Ambarino - 6
      • West Elizabeth - 14
      • New Austin - 3
    • Newspapers - 1,005,834
    • Homesteads - 25
    • Cemeteries - 1,102
    • Camp Item Requests - 2
    • Store Robberies - 12
    • Gang Hideouts - 190
    • Documents - 44
      • Letters - 22
      • Notes - 1
      • Books - 1
      • Handbills - None
      • Drawings - None
      • Business Cards - None
      • Newspaper Scraps - 17
      • Photographs - None
      • Bounty Posters - None
      • Maps - None
      • Treasure Maps - 3
      • Invitations - None
    • Dialogue - 9
    • Achievements - 89
    • Easter Eggs - 20

Group Deaths

Animals

  • Total - 11,256
    • 10,006 Alligators
    • 757 Horses
    • 117 Birds
    • 73 Fish
    • 57 Animals of Unknown Species
    • 33 Wolves
    • 29 Bears
    • 24 Dogs
    • 24 Deer
    • 16 Rabbits
    • 15 Sheep
    • 14 Cows
    • 12 Bison
    • 11 Pigs
    • 10 Rats
    • 9 Snakes
    • 8 Cougars
    • 3 Foxes
    • 3 Panthers
    • 3 Coyotes
    • 2 Iguana
    • 2 Moose
    • 2 Whales
    • 2 Frogs
    • 2 Opossum
    • 2 Skunks
    • 2 Beavers
    • 1 Armadillo
    • 1 Badger
    • 1 Bison
    • 1 Gila Monster
    • 1 Muskrat
    • 1 Possum
    • 1 Raccoon
    • 1 Turtle
    • 1 Mammoth
    • 1 Lion
    • 1 Squirrel
    • 1 Chipmunk
    • 1 Bat
    • 1 Gorilla

Humans

  • Total - 1,011,113
    • 1,004,310 Victims of Unknown Gender
    • 6,660 Men
    • 145 Women

Monsters

  • Total - 5
    • 1 Vampire
      • All Men
    • 1 Giant
      • All Victims of Unknown Gender
    • 1 Witch
      • All Women
    • 1 Robot
      • All Men
    • 1 Ghost
      • All Women

Kill Counts

  1. Arthur Morgan - 4,167 (Deceased)
  2. John Marston/Jim Milton - 2,195 (Alive)
  3. Hercule Fontaine - 890 (Alive)
  4. Dutch Van der Linde - 642 (Alive)
  5. Charles Smith - 495 (Alive)
  6. Sadie Adler - 427 (Alive)
  7. Marion "Bill" Williamson - 390 (Alive)
  8. Micah Bell III - 337 (Deceased)
  9. Javier Escuella - 300 (Alive)
  10. Leonard "Lenny" Summers - 287 (Deceased)
  11. Eagle Flies - 106 (Deceased)
  12. Paytah (Wapiti Tribe) - 94 (Alive)
  13. Algernon Wasp - 65 (Alive)
  14. Edmund Lowry Jr. - 51 (Deceased)
  15. Sean MacGuire - 49 (Deceased)
  16. Colm O'Driscoll - 25 (Deceased)
  17. Uncle - 24 (Alive)
  18. Hosea Matthews - 24 (Deceased)
  19. Karen Jones - 23 (Unknown)
  20. Cleet (Micah's Gang) - 22 (Deceased)
  21. Maybelle Elizabeth Colter/Black Belle - 21 (Alive)
  22. Ms. L. Hobbs - 19 (Alive)
  23. Tom Dickens - 18 (Alive)
  24. Abe (Pronghorn Ranch) - 18 (Alive)
  25. Elias Green - 15 (Deceased)
  26. Jim "Boy" Calloway - 15 (Deceased)
  27. Mr. Devon (The Tool Box) - 14 (Alive)
  28. Jeremy Gill - 13 (Deceased)
  29. Leon Fuentes - 12 (Alive)
  30. Darragh MacGuire - 8 (Deceased)
  31. Simon Pearson - 7 (Alive)
  32. Micah Bell II - 7 (Deceased)
  33. J. John Weathers - 6 (Alive)
  34. Ellie Anne Swan/The Black Widow - 6 (Imprisoned)
  35. Nosferatu/Saint Denis Vampire - 5 (Determinant)
  36. Hamish Sinclair - 5 (Deceased)
  37. Benedict Allbright - 4 (Imprisoned)
  38. Susan Grimshaw - 4 (Deceased)
  39. Thomas (Country Pursuits) - 3 (Alive)
  40. Sheriff Samuel "Sam" Freeman - 3 (Alive)
  41. Sheriff Malloy - 2 (Alive)
  42. Agnes Dowd - 2 (Deceased)
  43. Annette (Robard Farm) - 2 (Deceased)
  44. Ira Bennett - 2 (Deceased)
  45. Gideon Bennett - 2 (Deceased)
  46. Earl Bennett - 2 (Deceased)
  47. Agent Andrew Milton - 2 (Deceased)
  48. Abigail Roberts-Marston - 1 (Alive)
  49. Chief Rains Fall - 1 (Alive)
  50. John "Jack" Marston Jr. - 1 (Alive)
  51. Matilda "Tilly" Jackson/Tilly Pierre - 1 (Alive)
  52. Stripey (Cougar) - 1 (Alive)
  53. Charlie Tatum - 1 (Alive)
  54. Mayor Henri Lemieux - 1 (Alive)
  55. Jesse Murray - 1 (Imprisoned)
  56. Cletus Yarnell - 1 (Imprisoned)
  57. Lawrence Branch - 1 (Imprisoned)
  58. "969" (Robot) - (Determinant)
  59. Angel (Guarma) - 1 (Determinant)
  60. Willy Curlls - 1 (Determinant)
  61. Kieran Duffy - 1 (Deceased)
  62. Leopold Strauss - 1 (Deceased)
  63. Otis Skinner - 1 (Deceased)
  64. Shane Finley - 1 (Deceased)
  65. Professor Marko Dragic - 1 (Deceased)
  66. Camille de Millemont - 1 (Deceased)
  67. Colonel Henry Favours - 1 (Deceased)
  68. State Marshall Slim Grant - 1 (Deceased)
  69. Billy (O'Driscoll) - 1 (Deceased)
  70. Declan (O'Driscoll) - 1 (Deceased)
  71. Tom (O'Driscoll) - 1 (Deceased)
  72. Joaquín Arroyo - 1 (Deceased)
  73. Professor Andrew Bell III - 1 (Deceased)
  74. Wilson J. McDaniels - 1 (Deceased)
  75. Huntington Schrader - 1 (Deceased)
  76. Billy Midnight - 1 (Deceased)
  77. Angelo Bronte - 1 (Deceased)

Notes

General

  • Used this page for the chronological order of the main story missions in RDR2.
  • This page only includes deaths that are scripted, whether or not they occur every time. For example, this means that animals hunted or people killed by the player at random in towns or in the wild are not counted, but those in missions and other events are counted since they appear every time.
  • While NPCS that are simply unconscious (such as from a fight) are marked on the map with the same "X" symbol as those who are dead, only those who are dead are covered on the map's index, so only they will be counted.

Main Story

  • In the mission "The Aftermath of Genesis", a bear will appear after hunting two deer that Arthur Morgan can attack, however it is literally impossible to kill no matter how many times it is shot so it won't be counted.
  • In the mission "Eastward Bound", Hosea Matthews mentions several Native Americans being killed for their land, but does not specify how many.
  • In the mission "Good, Honest, Snake Oil", while it's never mentioned how many deaths Benedict Allbright is responsible for, it is mentioned he's "killed more than Landon Ricketts" who before the events of RDR2 had killed at least two known people, so Benedict is responsible for at least three people dying making him a serial killer and warranting a bounty.
  • In the mission "We Love Once and True III", while Arthur Morgan can strangle the Chelonian Master and the map indicates he died, he can show up again later during the epilogue, so he won't be counted.
  • In the mission "Pouring Forth Oil II", no matter how many guards Arthur Morgan kills, more will always spawn infinitely at random numbers, so none will be counted. However, there is always only one guard dog, so it will be counted.
  • In the mission "The New South", if Arthur Morgan decides to go fishing, Dutch and Hosea Matthews will either throw their fish back into the water or keep them at random, so they won't be counted.
    • Hosea also mentions a dog by the name of Copper who ate several of the salmon that were caught earlier, but does not say how many there were.
  • In the mission "Money Lending and Other Sins IV", Winton Holmes mentions that his father and him have hunted many cougars in the past, but does not say how many.
    • In the White Cougar's cave, the remains of several animals can be found, but it's impossible to know how many there are.
  • In the mission "The Gilded Cage", it's mentioned that guns are banned at social parties in Saint Denis due to an "incident" the previous year, but it's not mentioned if it was because someone was shot or even died.
  • In the mission "Banking, The Old American Art", Hosea Matthews and Abigail Marston cause a distraction for the heist by setting off a massive explosion. It is entirely unknown if this explosion killed anyone at all.
  • In the mission "Welcome To the New World", after Javier Escuella is shot in the leg, he's marked as dead on the map for an unknown reason. Obviously, he won't be counted here as he appears in later missions.
  • In the mission "Hell Hath no Fury", during the second part of the mission, the warship fires on the bridge and kills several soldiers, but the amount they kill is entirely random and it's possible for Arthur Morgan, Dutch, and Hercule to kill all of them before the shell hits.
    • Using this battle for Cuban warships in the 1890s, the ship that closest resembles the warship destroyed by Arthur Morgan and Hercule appears to be the real life ship the Vizcaya which is an armored cruiser. According to Britannica, armored cruisers have a crew population of 600 to 800 men, so the maximum will be used.
  • In the mission "That's Murfree Country", Charles Smith mentions the Murfree Brood killing an entire stagecoach full of people, but does not say how many.
  • In the mission "Visiting Hours", Sadie Adler apparently knocks out four guards while John Marston is holding Milliken hostage, but the index displays them as dead. In this case, it'll be assumed these knock out blows were fatal.
  • In the mission "Favored Sons", 15 soldiers will spawn to try and arrest Arthur Morgan and Dutch before they jump from the cliff into a river, but trying to kill them instead of jumping will result in an instant death from an invisible and immortal sniper. In this case, they won't be counted.
  • In the mission "Red Dead Redemption", for simplicities sake, only the route that has the most amount of deaths will be added: Going back for the money after Arthur Morgan and John's Horses are killed.
  • In the mission "The Tool Box", Charles Smith mentions that a few weeks prior, the Skinner Brothers massacred an entire caravan of "men, women, and children" but does specify how many.
  • In the mission "A Really Big Bastard", Sadie Adler mentions that Micah had killed an entire family except for a little girl, but does not say how many people this was.

Side Missions

  • In the fourth part of "Arcadia for Beginners", Albert mentions that "90 percent" of the alligators around Saint Denis have been killed off, but it's unknown how many this could have been. Only those confirmed by Albert will be counted.
  • In the mission "The Mercies of Knowledge", Arthur Morgan mentions "one dozen" cattle being struck by lightning, but it's most likely he was only saying this to scare McDaniels.
  • In the mission "A Bright Bouncing Boy", the toy boat's missiles will sometimes kill fish in the pond, but this is entirely random so they will not be counted.
  • In the mission "A Better World, A New Friend", Ms. L. Hobbs mentions she attempted to perform taxidermy on Humans who died of Cholera, but doesn't specify how many.
  • In the mission "A Test of Faith", no dinosaurs will be counted since it's unknown how many dinosaurs the bones belonged to exactly and not all of the bones belonged to dinosaurs.

Companion Activities

  • Much like Dutch Van der Linde and Hosea Matthews, Kieran Duffy in the fishing companion activity will either keep or toss back the fish he catches at random, so they won't be counted.
  • In the fishing mission for Javier Escuella, he mentions that a stagecoach in Nevada was robbed by the O'Driscoll gang and they killed several women and children, but he doesn't say how many of either, so none will be counted.

Bounty Hunts

  • Because Anthony Foreman can be killed during the mission "No, No, and Thrice No", he will not be counted again in his bounty mission.

Random Encounters

  • None of the animals in the five shooting competitions will be counted since there's always a random amount of them, the goal is to just shoot more than your opponent.
  • In the sixth "Friendly Camper" encounter, the man who tells either Arthur Morgan or John Marston about Red Harlow will mention he was a bounty hunter in the past, but he does not say how many people he killed if any.
  • In the "Killer Prostitute" encounter, it's mentioned that she has killed several men before meeting Arthur Morgan or John Marston, but it's not said how many.
  • The drunken veteran mentions in his story that he and several other soldiers killed many Native Americans and left others to starve to death at Fort Riggs, but does not mention how many.
  • In the random encounters set in Blackwater, Arthur Morgan doesn't get any of the kills there since he's wanted in Blackwater for the entire game and even going near the town causes lawmen and bounty hunters to chase him nonstop.
  • In the random encounters set in Guarma, John Marston doesn't get any of the kills there since he never goes to Guarma during the main story and there's no way to return during or after the epilogue.
  • In the random encounters set in Armadillo and New Austin, Arthur Morgan doesn't get any of the kills for the same reason he's not allowed in Blackwater due to being wanted during the main story.

Points of Interest

  • At the abandoned church, one of the Lemoyne raiders mentions that the church was destroyed when one raider accidentally dropped a lit match on stored gunpowder. It's not mentioned how many were in the building at the time, so only the one raider will be counted for the minimum.
  • At Bolger Glade, it's mentioned that all of Major Wilkinson, Major Smith, and Captain Fisher's men were killed during a battle during the Civil War but does not say how many there were, so they won't be counted.

Newspapers

  • None of the deaths from story missions mentioned in any of the issues will be counted.
  • Despite there being 42 newspapers in the game, there's actually only 14 original issues as the three newspapers in the game reprint all of the same stories. Because of this, only the original stories will be counted.
  • General Francisco Ramirez Torres is mentioned to have stopped a "bloody coup" in 1876, but it's not mentioned how many were killed during it.
  • Several soldiers are mentioned to have succumbed to the bubonic plague, but a specific amount is never mentioned.
  • A war between the United States and the Philippines is mentioned, but it's unknown how many are killed, if any.
  • In a war between the United States and Guarma, it's mentioned that "thousands" of Guarma soldiers were killed in the process, but does not say how many there were.
  • Several O'Driscoll gang members are mentioned to have been killed by a group of four other gangsters, but it's not said how many there were.
  • The submarine known as the H.T. Abernathy is mentioned to have had two crews who have drowned in the past, but it's unknown how many were in each crew.
  • In the article that mentions The Murfree Brood kidnapping a stagecoach filled with five people (One man, two women, Meredith Buckley, and a young boy), it's most likely that one of the two men killed by the Murfree Brood during the mission "That's Murfree Country" though it's unknown if it's the one that can be saved or the one that can't. Either way, they will not be counted twice just in case.
  • The Tallulah Getty gang is mentioned to have killed several people, but it is not mentioned how many.
  • The "two-dozen men" killed by Micah mentioned in the newspaper after his death will not be counted since they've already been covered.

Homestead Robberies

  • Catfish Jacksons can be robbed during the mission for "Money Lending and Other Sins V", so it won't be counted twice.
  • Willard's Rest is actually the same set of missions for Charlotte Balfour, who will not be counted twice.

Cemeteries

In General

  • The only graves counted in the game are marked ones that only appear during the events of RDR2, as many of the same exact graves also appear in the original RDR and unmarked graves could be ones that later appear in 1911.

By Cemetery

  • At Odd Fellow's Rest, the grave of Peter Turner won't be counted since he was previously mentioned in Red Dead Redemption during the mission "Let No Man Put Asunder". There are also a total of 23 graves, though more than three unmarked graves, so it will be assumed some graves were marked later on before the events of RDR and none will be counted.
  • At Coot's Chapel, there are a total of 26 graves and much like the previously mentioned cemetery, there are more unmarked graves in RDR2 than there is in the original RDR meaning more are labeled later, and none will be counted.
  • At The Blackwater Church of Holy Ascension, there are are a total of 56 graves and 23 of them are unmarked.
  • At the Saint Denis Cemetery, there is a single mausoleum with no graves inside at all, so it will be assumed this is a pre-bought lot.
  • At the Shady Belle graveyard, Agnes Dowd's grave will not be counted since it was previously covered in the random encounters section.

Store Robberies

  • Because Chip Cooper in Strawberry canonically survives to 1907, he will only be counted as a potential kill for John Marston since the robbery can be done after the mission "The Wheel".

Documents

  • The letters that are entirely random to obtain will not be counted.
  • The fiction books, such as The Lady of The Manor, will not be counted since they're not real in-universe.

Dialogue

  • During one of the campfire stories, Simon Pearson will talk about how he once saw a 300 pound man eaten alive by Sardines and a Portuguese wrestler crushed by a fishing net because of them, but it's more than likely this never happened as Pearson was clearly lying.

Easter Eggs

  • "Big" Jon claims to have killed and eaten several Native Americans and Buffalo in the past, but it's more than likely he's exaggerating, so nothing he says will be counted.

Navigation

           

Video Games
Canon
Red Dead Revolver | Red Dead Redemption II | Red Dead Redemption
Non-Canon
Red Dead Redemption: Gunslingers | Undead Nightmare

Characters
Van der Linde Gang
Arthur Morgan | Bessie Matthews | Charles Smith | Davey Callander | Hosea Matthews | Jenny Kirk | Karen Jones
Kieran Duffy | Lenny Summers | Leopold Strauss | Mac Callander | Micah Bell | Molly O'Shea | Sadie Adler
Sean MacGuire | Simon Pearson | Susan Grimshaw | Tilly Jackson
Civilians
Agnes Dowd | Eliza | Hamish Sinclair | Isaac Morgan | Jeremiah Compson | Mr. Devon | Thomas Downes
Criminals
Angelo Bronte | Edmund Lowry Jr. | Micah Bell I | Micah Bell II | Norman Deek
Guarma Rebellion
Hercule Fontaine | Leon Fuentes
Law Enforcement
Sam Freeman
Micah Bell's Gang
Cleet | Joe
Military Personnel
Henry Favours
Monsters
"969" | Saint Denis Vampire
O'Driscoll Boys Gang
Colm O'Driscoll | Tom
Skinner Brothers
Otis Skinner
The Pinkertons
Andrew Milton
Wapiti Indians
Chief Rains Fall | Eagle Flies | Paytah

Events
Battle of Bolger Glade | Battle of Fort Brennand | Battle of Shady Belle | Blackwater Massacre
Braithwaite Family Massacre | Butcher Creek Dig Site Accident | Guarma Slave Rebellion
Hani's Bethel Mass Suicide | Influenza | Massacre of Alligators | New Hanover Meteorite
Pleasance Town Massacre | Saint Denis Bank Heist | Typhoid Fever

Groups
Cuban Military | Ku Klux Klan | Micah Bell's Gang
O'Driscoll Boys Gang | The Murfree Brood | The Pinkertons
United States Army | Van der Linde Gang

           

Video Games
Grand Theft Auto
London 1961 | London 1969 | Vice City Stories | Vice City | San Andreas | Grand Theft Auto | Liberty City Stories
Grand Theft Auto II | Advance | Grand Theft Auto III | Grand Theft Auto IV | The Ballad of Gay Tony
The Lost and Damned | Chinatown Wars | Grand Theft Auto V
Grand Theft Online ( Liberty City Stories • Vice City Stories • GTA IV • GTA V )
Red Dead
Red Dead Revolver | Red Dead Redemption II | Red Dead Redemption | Undead Nightmare
Max Payne
Max Payne | Max Payne 2: The Fall of Max Payne | Max Payne 3
Manhunt
Manhunt | Manhunt 2
Other Games
Bully

Films
Grand Theft Auto
GTA 2: The Movie

Trailers
Grand Theft Auto
Grand Theft Auto VI (Trailer 1)

Characters
Grand Theft Auto
Main Protagonists
Claude Speed | Claude | Franklin Clinton | Johnny Klebitz | Luis Fernando Lopez | Michael De Santa | Mike | Niko Bellic | Tommy Vercetti | Toni Cipriani | Trevor Philips
The Online Protagonist
Vice City Stories
Antagonists
"Roman's Kidnapper" | Abigail Winthrop | Brad Snider | Brock Thompson | Colby Wright | David Richards | Devin Weston
Dimitri Rascalov | Donald Love | Eddie Low | El Rubio | Eugene Reaper | Fred Quincy | Hans Nemesis | Harold "Stretch" Joseph
Jimmy Pegorino | Jock Cranley | Josh Bernstein | Keyla | LJ Ha
Los Santos Slasher | Mark Fostenburg | Marquel Green
Merle Abrahams | Mr. Trenchcoat | Peter Dreyfuss | Ray Bulgarin | Simeon Yeterian | Steve Haines | The Gooch | The Yeti | Tommy
Radio Hosts
Jack Howitzer
Animals
El Rubio's Black Panther
Other Characters
"Chef" | "Flyboy" | Felipe | Dr. Dre | Floyd Hebert | Imani
Little Jacob | Maude Eccles | King Tiny | Vernon | P | Jamal Amir
Jolene Cranley-Evans
Red Dead
Main Protagonists
Arthur Morgan
Van Der Linde Gang
Charles Smith | Hosea Matthews | Karen Jones | Kieran Duffy
Lenny Summers | Leopold Strauss | Molly O'Shea | Sadie Adler
Sean MacGuire | Simon Pearson | Susan Grimshaw | Tilly Jackson
Protagonists
Chief Rains Fall | Eagle Flies | Hercule Fontaine
Antagonists
Andrew Milton | Angelo Bronte | Cleet | Colm O'Driscoll
Edmund Lowry Jr. | Henry Favours | Jeremiah Compson | Joe
Micah Bell | Micah Bell I | Micah Bell II | Otis Skinner | Tom
Other Characters
"969" | Bessie Matthews | Davey Callander | Eliza | Hamish Sinclair | Isaac Morgan | Jenny Kirk | Mac Callander | Sam Freeman | Thomas Downes
Manhunt
Protagonists
James Earl Cash | Daniel Lamb
Antagonists
Barry | Leo Kasper | Piggsy | Ramirez
Max Payne
Protagonists
Detective Max Payne | Mona Sax | Raul Passos
Antagonists
Nicole Horne | Victor Branco

Groups
Grand Theft Auto
Bobcat Security | Epsilon | Michael Townley's Crew | North Yankton State Patrol | The Lost MC | Vice City Police Department
Red Dead
Cuban Military | Ku Klux Klan | Micah Bell's Gang
O'Driscoll Boys Gang | The Murfree Brood | The Pinkertons
Van der Linde Gang
Manhunt
Hoods

Events
Grand Theft Auto
Bobcat Security Depot Heist | Cayo Perico Island Massacre
Chinatown Bank of Liberty Branch Heist | Cluckin' Bell Farm Raid | Destruction of Fort Staunton | Kortz Center Shootout
O'Neil Family Massacre | The Diamond Deal | The Lost MC Massacres | The Tsunami of Nabidneku
Red Dead
Battle of Bolger Glade | Battle of Fort Brennand | Battle of Shady Belle | Blackwater Massacre | Braithwaite Family Massacre | Butcher Creek Dig Site Accident | Guarma Slave Rebellion | Hani's Bethel Mass Suicide | Influenza | Massacre of Alligators | New Hanover Meteorite | Pleasance Town Massacre
Saint Denis Bank Heist | Typhoid Fever

Locations
Grand Theft Auto
Cluckin' Bell | North Yankton

Community content is available under CC-BY-SA unless otherwise noted.