Benjamin Willis

Benjamin "Ben" Willis, also known as The Fisherman, is the main antagonist of the I Know What You Did Last Summer trilogy. He is a vengeful serial killer who murders the people who gravely injured him and attempted to cover it up as well as their friends, and later on, becomes a spirit who targets those who cover up another persons death.

He is portrayed by Muse Watson in the first two films, and Don Shanks in the third.

Victims

I Know What You Did Last Summer

• David Egan - Pushed off a cliff by Benjamin "Ben" Willis/The Fisherman and drowned off-screen, mentioned.
• Maxwell "Max" Neurick - Impaled through the throat by Benjamin "Ben" Willis/The Fisherman with a hook.
• Barry Cox - Stabbed to death by Benjamin "Ben" Willis/The Fisherman with a hook.
• Officer David Caporizo - Stabbed in the stomach by Benjamin "Ben" Willis/The Fisherman with a hook.
• Elsa Shivers - Throat slashed by Benjamin "Ben" Willis/The Fisherman with a hook.
• Helen Shivers - Stabbed to death with a hook by Benjamin "Ben" Willis/The Fisherman.
  • Total - 6

I Still Know What You Did Last Summer

• Sarah Willis - Killed and dismembered by Benjamin "Ben" Willis/The Fisherman off-screen, mentioned.
• David "Dave" Strohmenger - Impaled through the throat and jaw pulled out by Benjamin "Ben" Willis/The Fisherman with a hook.
• Darick the Dockhand - Slashed by Benjamin "Ben" Willis/The Fisherman with a hook.
• Olga - Stabbed in the back by Benjamin "Ben" Willis/The Fisherman with a hook.
• Titus Telesco - Hand hooked to a table and impaled through the chest by Benjamin "Ben" Willis/The Fisherman with gardening sheers.
• Jay Brooks - Hacked in the head by Benjamin "Ben" Willis/The Fisherman with a machete off-screen, body shown.
• Tyrell Martin - Impaled through the throat by Benjamin "Ben" Willis/The Fisherman with a hook.
• Nancy - Impaled through the gut by Benjamin "Ben" Willis/The Fisherman with a fire poker.
• William "Will Benson" Willis - Accidentally stabbed in the chest by Benjamin "Ben" Willis/The Fisherman with a hook.
• Julie James - Dragged under her bed and killed by Benjamin "Ben" Willis/The Fisherman off-screen, implied.
• Ray Bronson - Killed by Benjamin "Ben" Willis/The Fisherman off-screen, implied.
• Karla Wilson - Killed by Benjamin "Ben" Willis/The Fisherman off-screen, implied.
  • Total - 12

I'll Always Know What You Did Last Summer

• Roger Pack - Throat sliced open by Benjamin "Ben" Willis/The Fisherman with a hook.
• Zoey "Zoe" Warner - Gutted and dropped off a second story balcony by Benjamin "Ben" Willis/The Fisherman.
• Sheriff Paul Jeremiah Davis Sr. - Stabbed in the shoulder by Benjamin "Ben" Willis/The Fisherman with a hook.
• Colby Patterson - Stabbed in the mouth by Benjamin "Ben" Willis/The Fisherman with a hook
• Deputy John Haffner - Impaled through the back on a forklift by Benjamin "Ben" Willis/The Fisherman.
• Amber Williams - Killed by Benjamin "Ben" Willis/The Fisherman's ghost off-screen.
  • Total - 6

Kill Count

• Total - 24
  • 15 Men
  • 9 Women

Characters Killed by Benjamin "Ben" Willis/The Fisherman

1. David Egan - Pushed off a cliff by Benjamin "Ben" Willis/The Fisherman and drowned off-screen, mentioned.
2. Maxwell "Max" Neurick - Impaled through the throat by Benjamin "Ben" Willis/The Fisherman with a hook.
3. Barry Cox - Stabbed to death by Benjamin "Ben" Willis/The Fisherman with a hook.
4. Officer David Caporizo - Stabbed in the stomach by Benjamin "Ben" Willis/The Fisherman with a hook.
5. Elsa Shivers - Throat slashed by Benjamin "Ben" Willis/The Fisherman with a hook.
6. Helen Shivers - Stabbed to death with a hook by Benjamin "Ben" Willis/The Fisherman.
7. Sarah Willis - Killed and dismembered by Benjamin "Ben" Willis/The Fisherman off-screen, mentioned.
8. David "Dave" Strohmenger - Impaled through the throat and jaw pulled out by Benjamin "Ben" Willis/The Fisherman with a hook.
9. Darick the Dockhand - Slashed by Benjamin "Ben" Willis/The Fisherman with a hook.
10. Olga - Stabbed in the back by Benjamin "Ben" Willis/The Fisherman with a hook.
11. Titus Telesco - Hand hooked to a table and impaled through the chest by Benjamin "Ben" Willis/The Fisherman with gardening sheers.
12. Jay Brooks - Hacked in the head by Benjamin "Ben" Willis/The Fisherman with a machete off-screen, body shown.
13. Tyrell Martin - Impaled through the throat by Benjamin "Ben" Willis/The Fisherman with a hook.
14. Nancy - Impaled through the gut by Benjamin "Ben" Willis/The Fisherman with a fire poker.
15. William "Will Benson" Willis - Accidentally stabbed in the chest by Benjamin "Ben" Willis/The Fisherman with a hook.
16. Julie James - Dragged under her bed and killed by Benjamin "Ben" Willis/The Fisherman off-screen, implied.
17. Ray Bronson - Killed by Benjamin "Ben" Willis/The Fisherman off-screen, implied.
18. Karla Wilson - Killed by Benjamin "Ben" Willis/The Fisherman off-screen, implied.
19. Roger Pack - Throat sliced open by Benjamin "Ben" Willis/The Fisherman with a hook.
20. Zoey "Zoe" Warner - Gutted and dropped off a second story balcony by Benjamin "Ben" Willis/The Fisherman.
21. Sheriff Paul Jeremiah Davis Sr. - Stabbed in the shoulder by Benjamin "Ben" Willis/The Fisherman with a hook.
22. Colby Patterson - Stabbed in the mouth by Benjamin "Ben" Willis/The Fisherman with a hook
23. Deputy John Haffner - Impaled through the back on a forklift by Benjamin "Ben" Willis/The Fisherman.
24. Amber Williams - Killed by Benjamin "Ben" Willis/The Fisherman's ghost off-screen.

Death

I Still Know What You Did Last Summer

• Shot in the chest eight times by Julie James. Revived as a zombie.

I'll Always Know What You Did Last Summer

• Shredded by a snowblower after being pushed into it by Amber Williams. Revived as a ghost.

Gallery

Disguised.

As a zombie/ghost.

Victims

Max Neurick

David Caporizon

Elsa Shivers

Helen Shivers

Barry Cox

Dave

Olga

Titus Telesco & Darick

Jay Brooks

Tyrell Martin

Estes & Nancy

William (Will Benson) Willis

Ben Willis

Julie James

PJ

Roger Pack

Zoe Warner

Sheriff Davis

Colby Patterson

John Haffner

Amber Williams