Arthur Morgan

“

John made it. He's the only one. Rest of us, no. But... I tried. In the end, I did.

”

—Arthur Morgan's last words. (High Honor)

Arthur Morgan is the main protagonist of the video game Red Dead Redemption II. He is one of the co-leaders of the Van der Linde Gang and the player character for the first six chapters of the main story, followed by John Marston.

(1863 - 1899) (36 Years Old)

He is voiced by Roger Clark.

Victims

Main Story Missions

Chapter One: Colter

Outlaws From the West

• Billy (O'Driscoll) - Shot to death by Arthur, Dutch, and Micah. Shared kill.
• Declan (O'Driscoll) - Shot to death by Arthur, Dutch, and Micah. Shared kill.
• Seven Unnamed O'Driscoll Gang Members - Shot to death by Arthur, Dutch, and Micah. Shared kills.
• Unnamed O'Driscoll Gang Member - Strangled to death by Arthur after interrogating him, optional.
• Three O'Driscoll Horses - Shot to death by Arthur Morgan, optional.
  • Total - 13

Enter, Pursued by a Memory

• Three Crows - Shot to death by Arthur Morgan, optional.
• Three Wolves - Shot to death by Arthur to defend John and Javier.
• Four Wolves - Shot to death by either Arthur or Javier. Shared kills.
  • Total - 10

Old Friends

• 16 Unnamed O'Driscoll Gang Members - Shot to death by either Arthur, Dutch, Lenny, Javier, Bill, or Micah. Shared kills. (First Wave)
• 13 Unnamed O'Driscoll Gang Members - Shot to death by either Arthur, Dutch, Lenny, Javier, Bill, or Micah. Shared kills. (Second Wave)
• Three O'Driscoll Horses - Shot to death by Arthur Morgan, optional.
  • Total - 32

The Aftermath of Genesis

• Two Deer - Shot to death by Arthur Morgan with a bow and arrows.
• Deer - Shot by Arthur Morgan with a bow and arrows, optional.
  • Total - 3

Who The Hell Is Leviticus Cornwall?

• Seven Unnamed Cornwall Guards - Shot to death by either Arthur or Lenny to stop the train. Shared kills.
• Unnamed Cornwall Guard - Either shot to death by Arthur Morgan to save Lenny or thrown over the side of the train tracks by Arthur to fall to his death.
• 18 Unnamed Cornwall Guards - Shot to death by either Arthur, Dutch, Bill, Lenny, Micah, Javier, or Charles after the train is stopped. Shared kills.
• Three Unnamed Cornwall Employees - Shot to death by Arthur Morgan, optional.
  • Total - 29

Eastward Bound

• None

Chapter Two: Horseshoe Overlook

Polite Society, Valentine Style

• Jimmy Brooks - Either fell to his death from a cliff after eventually slipping or after his hand was stomped on by Arthur Morgan, optional.
• Horse - Shot to death by Arthur Morgan, optional.
• Unnamed Man - Beaten to death by Arthur Morgan for assaulting Karen, optional.
• Unnamed Man - Shot to death by Arthur Morgan after returning his horse, optional.
  • Total - 4

Americans at Rest

• Nine Unnamed Men - Beaten to death by Arthur, Bill, Charles, and Javier in a bar fight. Shared kills.
  • Total - 9

Who is Not Without Sin

• Eight Sheep - Shot to death by Arthur Morgan, optional.
• Unnamed Man - Killed by Arthur Morgan for beating up Reverend Swanson, optional.
• Unnamed Sheepherder - Killed by Arthur Morgan to prevent reporting either an assault or murder, optional.
  • Total - 10

Exit, Pursued by a Bruised Ego

• Rabbit - Shot to death by Arthur so he and Hosea could eat it.
• Legendary Bear - Shot and stabbed to death by Arthur Morgan, optional.
  • Total - 2

The First Shall Be Last

• Unnamed Ike Skelding's Boys Member - Stabbed in the neck by Arthur Morgan.
• 11 Unnamed Ike Skelding's Boys Members - Shot to death by either Arthur, Charles, or Javier to rescue Sean. Shared kills. (Canyon)
• Two Unnamed Ike Skelding's Boys Members - Shot to death by either Arthur or Javier while rushing to help Charles. Shared kills.
• Unnamed Ike Skelding's Boys Member - Either stabbed to death by Charles Smith with a machete or shot to death by Arthur Morgan to save Charles. Shared kill.
• Ten Unnamed Ike Skelding's Boys Members - Shot to death by either Arthur, Charles, or Javier to rescue Sean. Shared kills. (Camp)
• Two Horses - Shot to death by Arthur Morgan, optional.
  • Total - 27

Paying a Social Call

• Unnamed O'Driscoll Gang Member - Stabbed in the neck by either Arthur or Bill. Shared kill.
• Two Unnamed O'Driscoll Gang Members - Either both stabbed to death by Arthur and Bill or stabbed with knives thrown by Arthur and Bill. Shared kills.
• Unnamed O'Driscoll Gang Member - Stabbed in the neck by either Arthur or John. Shared kill.
• 14 Unnamed O'Driscoll Gang Members - Shot to death by either Arthur, John, or Bill. Shared kills.
• Three Unnamed Women - Shot to death by Arthur Morgan, optional.
  • Total - 21

A Quiet Time

• None

Blessed are the Meek?

• Sheriff Hanley - Shot to death by either Arthur or Micah. Shared kill.
• 22 Unnamed Strawberry Lawmen - Shot to death by either Arthur or Micah. Shared kills. (Strawberry)
• Eight Unnamed Strawberry Lawmen - Shot to death by either Arthur or Micah. Shared kills. (Chase)
• Horse - Shot to death by Arthur Morgan, optional. (Strawberry)
• Eight Horses - Shot to death by Arthur Morgan, optional. (Chase)
  • Total - 9

Good, Honest, Snake Oil

• Benedict Allbright's Horse - Shot to death by Arthur Morgan, optional.
  • Total - 1

We Loved Once and True I

• None

We Loved Once and True II

• None

We Loved Once and True III

• 11 Cows - Shot to death by Arthur Morgan, optional.
• Two Wagon Horses - Shot to death by Arthur Morgan, optional.
• Two Horses - Shot to death by Arthur Morgan, optional.
• Jamie's Horse - Shot to death by Arthur Morgan, optional.
• Unnamed Chelonian Master - Strangled to death by Arthur Morgan, optional.
• Nine Unnamed Men - Shot to death by Arthur Morgan, optional.
  • Total - 26

Money Lending and Other Sins I

• None

Money Lending and Other Sins II

• Cooper - Killed by Arthur Morgan, optional.
• Lilly Millet - Killed by Arthur Morgan, optional.
• Chick Matthews - Killed by Arthur Morgan, optional.
• Chick Matthews' Horse - Shot to death by Arthur Morgan, optional.
• Unnamed Man - Killed by Arthur Morgan for witnessing Cooper's beating, optional.
  • Total - 5

Money Lending and Other Sins III

• None

The Spines of America

• Bob Crawford Sr. - Killed by Arthur Morgan, optional. (Only during the night robbery)
• Bob Crawford Jr. - Killed by Arthur Morgan, optional. (Only during the night robbery)
• Unnamed Man - Killed by Arthur Morgan for witnessing the robbery and possible murders, optional.
  • Total - 3

Pouring Forth Oil I

• None

Pouring Forth Oil II

• Cornwall Guard Dog - Killed by Arthur Morgan, optional. (Oil Refinery)
• Unnamed Cornwall Guard - Shot to death by Arthur Morgan, optional. (Valentine)
  • Total - 2

Pouring Forth Oil III

• None

Pouring Forth Oil IV

• Unnamed Train Guard - Killed by Arthur Morgan, optional.
• Four Unnamed Train Guards - Shot to death by Arthur Morgan to save Sean.
• 12 Unnamed Lawmen - Shot to death by either Arthur, John, Charles, or Sean. Shared kills.
• 25 Horses - Shot to death by Arthur Morgan, optional.
• Unnamed Train Engineer - Killed by Arthur Morgan, optional.
  • Total - 43

A Fisher of Men

• Three Fish - Caught by Arthur Morgan and presumably eaten off-screen, optional.
  • Total - 3

An American Pastoral Scene

• Unnamed Stagecoach Driver - Shot to death by either Arthur or Micah. Shared kill.
• Five Unnamed Stagecoach Guards - Shot to death by either Arthur or Micah. Shared kills.
• 17 Unnamed O'Driscoll Gang Members - Shot to death by either Arthur or Micah. Shared kills.
• Four Stagecoach Guard Horses - Shot to death by Arthur Morgan, optional.
• Two O'Driscoll Horses - Shot to death by Arthur Morgan, optional.
• Two O'Driscoll Wagon Horses - Shot to death by Arthur Morgan, optional.
  • Total - 31

The Sheep and the Goats

• Four Unnamed Cornwall Henchmen - Shot to death by either Arthur or Dutch to save John and Strauss. Shared kills.
• Unnamed Cornwall Henchman - Shot in the head by either Arthur or John to save Strauss. Shared kill. (If the player only kills the guard holding John.)
• 32 Unnamed Valentine Lawmen - Shot to death by either Arthur, John, or Dutch. Shared kills.
• Four Unnamed Valentine Lawmen - Shot to death by Arthur Morgan after rescuing Leopold.
• Three Horses - Shot to death by Arthur Morgan, optional.
• Three Unnamed Ranch Hands - Shot to death by Arthur Morgan, optional.
  • Total - 47

A Strange Kindness

• Six Unknown Gang Members - Shot to death by either Arthur or Charles. Shared kills.
• Three Vultures - Shot to death by Arthur Morgan, optional.
• Two Horses - Shot to death by Arthur Morgan, optional.
  • Total - 5

Chapter Three: Clemens Point

The New South

• At Least Four Fish - Caught by Arthur Morgan and presumably eaten off-screen, optional.
  • Total - 4

Further Questions of Female Suffrage

• Two Unnamed Lemoyne's Raiders Gang Members - Shot to death by either Arthur or Sadie Adler. Shared kills.
• Five Unnamed Lemoyne's Raiders Gang Members - Shot to death by either Arthur or Sadie Adler. Shared kills. (Ambush)
• Five Lemoyne Raiders Horses - Shot to death by Arthur Morgan, optional.
  • Total - 12

Money Lending and Other Sins IV

• White Cougar - Shot to death by Arthur Morgan.
  • Total - 1

American Distillation

• 16 Unnamed Lemoyne Raider Gang Members - Shot to death by either Arthur or Bill. Shared kills.
• Two Lemoyne Raiders Wagon Horses - Shot to death by Arthur Morgan, optional.
  • Total - 18

The Course of True Love I

• None

The Course of True Love II

• None

The Course of True Love III

• None

Advertising, The New American Art

• Ten Unnamed Lemoyne Raider Gang Members - Shot to death by either Arthur or Hosea. Shared kills. (Saloon)
• Unnamed Lemoyne Raider Gang Member - Shot to death by Arthur to save Hosea. (Saloon)
• Two Unnamed Lemoyne Raider Gang Members - Shot to death by Arthur Morgan. (Saloon)
• 13 Unnamed Lemoyne Raider Gang Members - Shot to death by Arthur Morgan. (Chase)
• Two Unnamed Lemoyne Raider Gang Members - Either shot to death by Arthur or blown up after he shot the dynamite filled wagon.
• Ten Lemoyne Raiders Horses - Shot to death by Arthur Morgan, optional. (Chase)
• Two Lemoyne Raiders Wagon Horses - Either shot to death by Arthur Morgan or blown up after shooting the dynamite in the back of the wagon, optional.
• Three Unnamed Men - Shot to death by Arthur Morgan, optional. (Saloon)
  • Total - 43

Horse Flesh for Dinner

• 16 Unnamed Braithwaite Family Guards - Shot to death by either Arthur, John, or Javier. Shared kills. (Manor)
• Three Unnamed Braithwaite Family Guards - Shot to death by either Arthur, John, or Javier. Shared kills. (Chase)
• Four Braithwaite Horses - Shot to death by Arthur Morgan, optional.
• Four Braithwaite Wagon Horses - Shot to death by Arthur Morgan, optional.
• Unnamed Braithwaite Stablehand - Killed by either Arthur, John, or Javier. Shared kill.
  • Total - 28

The Fine Joys of Tobacco

• Hamish - Killed by either Arthur or Sean. Shared kill.
• Unnamed Gray Family Guard - Stabbed to death by either Arthur or Sean. Shared kill.
• 21 Unnamed Gray Family Guards - Shot to death by either Arthur or Sean. Shared kills.
• Two Gray Family Horses - Shot to death by Arthur Morgan, optional.
  • Total - 25

Magicians for Sport

• Jeb - Shot to death by either Arthur or Charles. Shared kill.
• Unnamed Bounty Hunter - Beaten to death by either Arthur or Charles. Shared kill.
• Four Unnamed Bounty Hunters - Shot to death by either Arthur or Charles. Shared kills.
• Unnamed Bounty Hunter - Either stabbed in the chest with a knife thrown by Charles Smith to save Arthur or shot in the head by Arthur to save Charles. Shared kill.
• Jeb's Horse - Shot to death by Arthur Morgan, optional.
• Unnamed Bounty Hunter's Horse - Shot to death by Arthur Morgan, optional.
  • Total - 9

Friends in Very Low Places

• Chester Damsen - Shot to death by Arthur Morgan, optional.
• Unnamed Stagecoach Guard - Shot to death by Arthur Morgan, optional.
• Two Stagecoach Horses - Shot to death by Arthur Morgan, optional.
• Unnamed Stagecoach Driver - Shot to death by Arthur Morgan, optional.
• Unnamed Stagecoach Passenger - Shot to death by Arthur Morgan, optional.
  • Total - 6

An Honest Mistake

• Cooperforth - Shot to death by either Arthur Morgan or Uncle. Shared kill.
• Unnamed Cornwall Guard - Shot to death by Arthur Morgan. (Chase)
• 17 Unnamed Cornwall Guards - Shot to death by either Arthur, Charles, Bill, or Uncle. Shared kills. (Outhouse)
• Unnamed Cornwall Guard - Stabbed to death by Arthur Morgan. (Woods)
• Five Unnamed Cornwall Guards - Shot to death by either Arthur, Charles, Bill, or Uncle. Shared kills. (Woods)
• Two Wagon Horses - Shot to death by Arthur Morgan, optional. (Chase)
• Two Lawmen Horses - Shot to death by Arthur Morgan, optional. (Outhouse)
• Three Lawmen Horses - Shot to death by Arthur Morgan, optional. (Woods)
• Unnamed Man - Shot to death by Arthur Morgan, optional. (Chase)
  • Total - 33

Preaching Forgiveness as he Went

• 16 Unnamed Lemoyne Raiders Gang Members - Shot to death by either Arthur or Lenny. Shared kills. (Plantation)
• Three Unnamed Lemoyne Raiders Gang Members - Shot to death by either Arthur or Lenny. Shared kills. (Chase)
• Two Lemoyne Raiders Wagon Horses - Either shot to death by Arthur Morgan or blown up after shooting the dynamite in the back of the wagon, optional. (Shady Belle)
• Three Lemoyne Raiders Horses - Shot to death by Arthur Morgan, optional. (Ambush)
  • Total - 24

Sodom? Back to Gomorrah

• 15 Unnamed Valentine Lawmen - Shot to death by either Arthur, Bill, Lenny, or Karen Jones. Shared kills. (Valentine)
• Eight Unnamed Valentine Lawmen - Shot to death by either Arthur, Bill, Lenny, or Karen Jones. Shared kills. (Chase)
• Ten Lawmen Horses - Shot to death by Arthur Morgan, optional.
  • Total - 33

Blessed are the Peacemakers

• Unnamed O'Driscoll Gang Member - Neck snapped by Arthur Morgan.
• Six Unnamed O'Driscoll Gang Members - Either stealthily killed or shot to death by Arthur Morgan for kidnapping, shooting, and torturing him. (Camp)
• Eight Unnamed O'Driscoll Gang Members - Shot to death by Arthur Morgan. (Patrolling)
• Seven O'Driscoll Horses - Shot to death by Arthur Morgan, optional. (Camp)
• Five O'Driscoll Horses - Shot to death by Arthur Morgan, optional. (Patrolling)
  • Total - 28

A Short Walk in a Pretty Town

• Sheriff Leigh Gray - Shot in the head by Arthur Morgan to save Bill.
• Deputy Archibald MacGregor - Shot to death by either Arthur or Micah. Shared kill.
• Jock Gray - Shot to death by either Arthur or Micah. Shared kill.
• 31 Unnamed Rhodes Lawmen/Gray Family Hired Guns - Shot to death by either Arthur, Bill, or Micah. Shared kills.
• Unnamed Rhodes Lawman/Gray Family Hired Gun - Shot to death by either Arthur or Micah to save Bill. Shared kill.
• Five Rhodes Lawmen/Gray Family Hired Gun Horses - Shot to death by Arthur Morgan, optional.
  • Total - 40

Blood Feuds, Ancient and Modern

• Gerald Braithwaite - Shot to death by Arthur Morgan.
• Gareth Braithwaite - Shot to death by Arthur Morgan.
• 11 Unnamed Braithwaite Family Guards - Shot to death by either Arthur, John, Dutch, Hosea, Charles, Bill, Lenny, or Javier. Shared kills. (First Wave)
• Unnamed Braithwaite Family Guard - Shot to death by either Arthur or John. (Manor)
• 21 Unnamed Braithwaite Family Guards - Shot to death by either Arthur, John, Charles, Bill, Lenny, or Javier. Shared kills. (Second Wave)
• Three Braithwaite Horses - Shot to death by Arthur Morgan, optional.
• Four Braithwaite Wagon Horses - Shot to death by Arthur Morgan, optional.
  • Total - 42

The Battle of Shady Belle

• Unnamed Lemoyne Raiders Gang Leader - Either shot to death by Arthur Morgan or committed suicide by shooting himself in the head.
• Unnamed Lemoyne Raiders Member - Either shot to death by Arthur or by John as he escaped if Arthur spared him. Shared kill.
• Unnamed Lemoyne Raiders Member - Either shot to death by Arthur Morgan or beaten to death by him on his request.
• Two Unnamed Lemoyne Raider Gang Members - Shot to death by either Arthur or John. Shared kills.
  • Total - 5

Chapter Four: Saint Denis

The Joys of Civilization

• None

Angelo Bronte, A Man of Honor

• Five Unnamed Grave Robbers - Shot to death by either Arthur or John. Shared kills.
• At Least Seven Unnamed Saint Denis Lawmen - Shot to death by either Arthur or John, optional. Shared kills.
  • Total - 12

Money Lending and Other Sins V

• Algie Davison - Shot to death by Arthur Morgan, optional.
• Nate Davison - Shot to death by Arthur Morgan, optional.
  • Total - 2

Help a Brother Out

• Unnamed Human Trafficker - Shot to death by Arthur Morgan, optional.
  • Total - 1

Brothers and Sisters, One and All

• Unnamed Saint Denis Lawman - Shot to death by Arthur, optional.
  • Total - 1

Fatherhood and Other Dreams

• Ashton - Either beaten, strangled, or shot to death by Arthur Morgan, optional.
• Four Wagon Horses - Shot to death by Arthur, optional.
  • Total - 5

No, No, and Thrice, No

• Anthony Foreman - Stabbed in the stomach by Arthur Morgan, optional.
• Two Unnamed Foreman Brothers - Shot to death by Arthur Morgan. (House)
• Two Unnamed Foreman Brothers - Shot to death by either Arthur Morgan or Susan Grimshaw. Shared kills. (Chase)
• Two Foreman Brothers Horses - Shot to death by Arthur, optional.
• Anthony Foreman's Horse - Shot to death by Arthur, optional.
  • Total - 8

The Gilded Cage

• None

A Fine Night of Debauchery

• Unnamed Grand Korrigan Pit Boss - Shot to death by Arthur Morgan in a duel.
• Unnamed Grand Korrigan Guard - Either shot to death by Arthur or hit in the head by Leopold Strauss with a wine bottle. Shared kill. (Poker Room)
• 17 Unnamed Grand Korrigan Guards - Shot to death by either Arthur or Javier. Shared kills. (Poker Room)
  • Total - 19

American Fathers I

• None

American Fathers II

• Danbury - Shot to death by Arthur Morgan, optional.
• 17 Unnamed Cornwall Company Guards - Shot to death by Arthur Morgan. (Refinery)
• Three Unnamed Cornwall Company Guards - Shot to death by either Arthur Morgan or Eagle Flies. (Chase)
• Three Cornwall Horses - Shot to death by Arthur, optional. (Refinery)
• Three Cornwall Horses - Shot to death by Arthur, optional. (Chase)
  • Total - 27

High and Low Finance

• Unnamed Patrolman - Neck snapped by Arthur Morgan.
• At Least Seven Unnamed Rhodes Lawmen - Shot to death by either Arthur or Charles, optional.
• Four Rhodes Lawmen Horses - Shot to death by Arthur, optional. (Chase)
  • Total - 12

Horsemen, Apocalypses

• 36 Unnamed O'Driscoll Gang Members - Shot to death by either Arthur, John, Sadie, Dutch, or Charles. Shared kills.
• Two O'Driscoll Horses - Shot to death by Arthur, optional.
• Two O'Driscoll Wagon Horses - Shot to death by Arthur, optional.
  • Total - 40

Urban Pleasures

• 20 Unnamed Saint Denis Lawmen - Shot to death by either Arthur, Dutch, or Lenny. Shared kills. (Trolley)
• 11 Unnamed Saint Denis Lawmen - Shot to death by either Arthur, Dutch, or Lenny. Shared kills. (Crash Site)
• 20 Unnamed Saint Denis Lawmen - Shot to death by either Arthur, Dutch, or Lenny. Shared kills. (Alleyways/Streets)
• 11 Unnamed Saint Denis Lawmen - Shot to death by either Arthur, Dutch, or Lenny. Shared kills. (Wagon Chase)
• Two of Angel Bronte's Men - Shot to death by Arthur Morgan. (Manor)
• Two Unnamed Saint Denis Lawmen - Either shot to death by Arthur Morgan or blown up with dynamite thrown by Lenny that is shot by Arthur. Shared kills. (Bridge)
• 17 Saint Denis Lawmen Horses - Shot to death by Arthur, optional.
• Four Saint Denis Lawmen Wagon Horses - Shot to death by Arthur, optional.
• Two Horses - Blown up with dynamite thrown by Lenny that is shot by Arthur. Shared kills. (Bridge)
  • Total - 89

Country Pursuits

• None

Revenge is a Dish Best Eaten

• 29 Unnamed Angelo Bronte Henchmen - Shot to death by either Arthur, John, Dutch, Bill, or Lenny. Shared kills.
• 18 Unnamed Saint Denis Lawmen - Shot to death by either Arthur, John, Dutch, Bill, or Lenny. Shared kills.
  • Total - 47

Banking, The Old American Art

• 35 Unnamed Pinkerton Agents - Shot to death by either Arthur, John, Dutch, Bill, Lenny, Javier, Charles, or Micah. Shared kills. (Bank)
• Two Unnamed Pinkerton Agents - Shot to death by Arthur Morgan for killing Lenny. (Rooftops)
• Two Saint Denis Lawmen Horses - Shot to death by Arthur, optional.
• Six Saint Denis Lawmen Wagon Horses - Shot to death by Arthur, optional.
  • Total - 45

Chapter Five: Guarma

Welcome to the New World

• Five Unnamed Guarma Guards - Shot to death by either Arthur or Hercule Fontaine and his rebels. Shared kills. (Beach)
• 11 Unnamed Guarma Guards - Shot to death by either Arthur, Dutch, Bill, Micah, Leon, Hercule, or his rebels. (Rebel Camp)
  • Total - 16

Savagery Unleashed

• Angel - Either stabbed or shot to death by Arthur Morgan after choking him unconscious, optional.
• Unnamed Hangman - Shot to death by Arthur Morgan.
• Seven Unnamed Guarma Guards - Shot to death by Arthur Morgan.
  • Total - 9

A Kind and Benevolent Despot

• Unnamed Guarma Guard - Stabbed in the throat by Arthur Morgan. (Sugar Mill)
• Unnamed Guarma Guard - Stabbed in the back by Artur Morgan. (Sugar Mill)
• 20 Unnamed Guarma Guards - Shot to death by either Arthur or Dutch to save Javier. Shared kills. (Sugar Mill)
• 15 Unnamed Guarma Guards - Shot to death by Arthur Morgan while Dutch escaped with Javier. (Woods)
  • Total - 37

Hell Hath No Fury

• 13 Unnamed Cuban Soldiers - Shot to death by either Arthur, Dutch, Bill, Micah, Hercule, or an unnamed rebel. Shared kills. (Wave One)
• 20 Unnamed Cuban Soldiers - Shot to death by either Arthur, Dutch, or Hercule. Shared kills. (Bridge/Beach)
• At Least 800 Unnamed Cuban Soldiers - Blown up with a cannon fired by Arthur Morgan and Hercule. Shared kills. (Warship)
  • Total - 833

Paradise Mercifully Departed

• Colonel Alberto Fussar - Blown up with a cannon fired by Arthur Morgan.
• Unnamed Cuban Soldier - Stabbed in the neck by Arthur Morgan.
• 24 Unnamed Cuban Soldiers - Shot to death by either Arthur, Dutch, Hercule, or Micah. Shared kills. (Guard Camp)
• 15 Unnamed Cuban Soldiers - Shot to death by either Arthur, Dutch, Hercule, or Micah. Shared kills. (Ruins)
  • Total - 41

Dear Uncle Tacitus

• Agent Bunter - Shot to death by Arthur Morgan, optional.
• Agent Johns - Shot to death by Arthur Morgan, optional.
• Agent Orly - Shot to death by Arthur Morgan, optional.
• Unnamed Pinkerton Agent - Shot to death by Arthur Morgan, optional.
• Four Pinkerton Horses - Shot to death by Arthur Morgan, optional.
  • Total - 8

Fleeting Joy

• 33 Unnamed Pinkerton Agents - Shot to death by either Arthur, Sadie, Dutch, Javier, Bill, Micah, or Charles. Shared kills.
  • Total - 33

A Fork in the Road

• None

That's Murfree Country

• Unnamed Murfree Brood Gang Member - Stealthily killed by Arthur Morgan with any weapon of his choice.
• 18 Unnamed Murfree Brood Gang Members - Shot to death by either Arthur or Charles. Shared kills. (Cave)
  • Total - 19

Chapter Six: Beaver Hollow

Icarus and Friends

• 19 Unnamed O'Driscoll Gang Members - Shot to death by either Arthur or Sadie. Shared kills. (Balloon)
• 20 Unnamed O'Driscoll Gang Members - Shot to death by either Arthur or Sadie. Shared kills. (Crash Site)
• 19 O'Driscoll Horses - Shot to death by Arthur Morgan, optional. (Balloon)
• Seven O'Driscoll Horses - Shot to death by Arthur Morgan, optional. (Crash Site)
  • Total - 65

Visiting Hours

• Milliken - Shot to death by Arthur Morgan, optional.
• Unnamed Sisika Prison Watchtower Guard - Stabbed in the neck by Arthur Morgan.
• Two Unnamed Sisika Prison Guards - Shot to death by Arthur Morgan who were guarding John.
• At Least 27 Unnamed Sisika Prison Guards - Shot to death by either Arthur, John, or Sadie to escape the prison. Shared kills. (Gate/Bridge)
• Seven Unnamed Sisika Prison Guards - Shot to death by either Arthur, John, or Sadie to escape the prison. Shared kills. (Fields)
• Seven Unnamed Sisika Prison Guards - Shot to death by either Arthur, John, or Sadie to escape the prison. Shared kills. (Beach)
• Seven Unnamed Sisika Prison Guards - Shot to death by Arthur Morgan. (Boat)
• 13 Sisika Prison Guard Horses - Shot to death by Arthur Morgan, optional.
  • Total - 65

Just a Social Call

• Three Unnamed Cornwall Guards - Shot to death by either Arthur or Dutch. Shared kills.
• 15 Unnamed Pinkerton Agents - Shot to death by either Arthur or Dutch. Shared kills.
• 23 Unnamed Pinkerton Agents - Shot to death by either Arthur, Dutch, or Micah. Shared kills. (Coal Building)
• 11 Unnamed Pinkerton Agents - Shot to death by either Arthur, Dutch, or Micah. Shared kills. (Chase)
• Stagecoach Horse - Shot to death by Arthur Morgan, optional.
• 11 Pinkerton Horses - Shot to death by Arthur Morgan, optional.
  • Total - 64

Do Not Seek Absolution I

• None

Do Not Seek Absolution II

• None

Of Men and Angels

• None

The Course of True Love IV

• None

The Course of True Love V

• Iain Gray - Shot to death by Arthur Morgan after knocking him out in a fight, optional.
• Scott Gray - Shot to death by Arthur Morgan after knocking him out in a fight, optional.
• Penelope Braithwaite's Second Cousin - Shot to death by Arthur Morgan.
• 11 Unnamed Braithwaite Guards - Shot to death by Arthur Morgan.
• 12 Braithwaite Guard Horses - Shot to death by Arthur Morgan, optional.
  • Total - 26

Money Lending and Other Sins VI

• None

Money Lending and Other Sins VII

• Six Unnamed United States Soldiers - Shot to death by either Arthur or J. John Weathers. Shared kills.
• Three United States Soldier Horses - Shot to death by Arthur Morgan, optional.
• Unnamed Foreman - Shot to death by Arthur Morgan, optional.
  • Total - 10

The Delights of Van Horn

• Five Unnamed Stagecoach Guards - Shot to death by either Arthur or Bill. Shared kills. (Van Horn)
• 12 Unnamed Van Horn Lawmen - Shot to death by Arthur Morgan to defend Bill and the wagon. Shared kills. (Chase)
• Two Stagecoach Horses - Shot to death by Arthur Morgan, optional.
• Four Van Horn Lawmen Horses - Shot to death by Arthur Morgan, optional.
• 12 Pinkerton Horses - Shot to death by Arthur Morgan, optional.
  • Total - 35

The Bridge to Nowhere

• None

A Rage Unleashed

• Pennington - Either shot to death by Arthur Morgan or drowned in the river.
• Six Unnamed United States Soldiers - Shot to death by either Arthur, Dutch, Charles, or Eagle Flies. Shared kills. (Boat)
  • Total - 7

Archeology for Beginners

• Six Unnamed United States Soldiers - Shot to death by Arthur Morgan for robbing Rains Falls and burning down his sacred site, optional.
• Two Wolves - Shot to death by Arthur Morgan, optional.
• Six United States Soldier Horses - Shot to death by Arthur Morgan, optional.
  • Total - 14

Honor, Amongst Thieves

• Two Unnamed United States Soldiers - Shot to death by Arthur Morgan, optional.
• Two United States Wagon Horses - Shot to death by Arthur Morgan, optional.
  • Total - 4

The Fine Art of Conversation

• Jackson - Shot to death by Arthur Morgan, optional. (Later appears in the mission The King's Son if he's spared, but he won't be counted twice)
• Nine Unnamed United States Soldiers - Shot to death by Arthur Morgan. (Army Camp)
• Nine Unnamed United States Soldiers - Shot to death by either Arthur or Charles. Shared kills. (Chase)
• 20 Unnamed United States Soldiers - Shot to death by either Arthur or Charles. Shared kills. (Woods)
• Three Unnamed United States Soldiers - Shot to death by either Arthur or Charles. Shared kills. (Chase #2)
• Nine United States Soldier Horses - Shot to death by Arthur Morgan, optional.
• Two United States Soldier Wagon Horses - Shot to death by Arthur Morgan, optional.
  • Total - 53

Goodbye, Dear Friend

• Paul (O'Driscoll) - Stabbed to death by Arthur Morgan, optional.
• Ten Unnamed O'Driscoll Gang Members - Shot to death by either Arthur, Sadie, Dutch, or Saint Denis lawmen. Shared kills. (Execution Site)
• Five Unnamed Saint Denis Lawmen - Shot to death by either Arthur, Sadie, Dutch, or O'Driscoll gang members. Shared kills. (Execution Site)
  • Total - 16

Mrs. Sadie Adler, Widow I

• None

Mrs. Sadie Adler, Widow II

• Unnamed O'Driscoll Gang Member Sniper - Shot to death by Arthur Morgan.
• 14 Unnamed O'Driscoll Gang Members - Shot to death by either Arthur or Sadie. Shared kills. (Outside)
• Four Unnamed O'Driscoll Gang Members - Shot to death by Arthur Morgan. (Barn)
  • Total - 19

Favored Sons

• Martin - Shot to death by either Arthur, Dutch, Eagle Flies, Paytah, or three unnamed Wapiti Native Americans. Shared kill.
• 11 Unnamed United States Soldiers - Shot to death by either Arthur, Dutch, Eagle Flies, Paytah, or three unnamed Wapiti Native Americans. Shared kills. (Tree trap)
• Eight Unnamed United States Soldiers - Shot to death by either Arthur, Dutch, Eagle Flies, Paytah, or three unnamed Wapiti Native Americans. Shared kills. (Reinforcements)
• Unnamed United States Artilleryman - Shot to death by Arthur Morgan. (Ambush)
• 11 Unnamed United States Soldiers - Shot to death by either Arthur, Dutch, Eagle Flies, Paytah, or one unnamed Wapiti Native American. Shared kills. (Ambush)
• 25 Unnamed United States Soldiers - Shot to death by either Arthur or Dutch. (Chase)
• Five United States Soldier Horses - Shot to death by Arthur Morgan, optional.
  • Total - 62

The King's Son

• Two Unnamed United States Soldiers - Stealthily killed by Arthur Morgan with any weapon of his choice. (Fort Wallace)
• Five Unnamed United States Soldiers - Shot to death by either Arthur Morgan or Charles Smith with bows and arrows. Shared kills. (Fort Wallace)
• Unnamed United States Soldier - Stealthily killed by Arthur Morgan with any weapon of his choice to start a lantern fire. (Fort Wallace)
• 15 Unnamed United States Soldiers - Shot to death by either Arthur or Charles to rescue Eagle Flies. Shared kills. (Fort Wallace)
• 12 Unnamed United States Soldiers - Shot to death by either Arthur or Charles. (Chase)
• 15 Unnamed United States Soldiers - Shot to death by either Arthur or Charles. (Canoes)
• Six United States Soldier Horses - Shot to death by Arthur Morgan, optional. (Fort Wallace)
• 11 United States Soldier Horses - Shot to death by Arthur Morgan, optional. (Chase)
• Seven United States Soldier Horses - Shot to death by Arthur Morgan, optional. (Canoes)
  • Total - 74

My Last Boy

• Colonel Henry Favours - Shot to death by Arthur Morgan.
• 31 Unnamed United States Soldiers - Shot to death by either Arthur, Sadie, Charles, or the six remaining unnamed Wapiti Native Americans. Shared kills. (Wave One)
• Unnamed United States Soldier - Shot to death by either Arthur or Sadie to save Eagle Flies. Shared kill.
• 63 Unnamed United States Soldiers - Shot to death by either Arthur, John, Sadie, Charles, Bill, Javier, Dutch, Eagle Flies, Paytah, or the six remaining unnamed Wapiti Native Americans. Shared kills. (Wave Two)
• Five Unnamed United States Soldiers - Shot to death by either Arthur or Dutch. (Factory)
• Four United States Soldier Horses - Shot to death by Arthur Morgan, optional.
  • Total - 105

Our Best Selves

• 25 Unnamed United States Soldiers - Shot to death by either Arthur or John. Shared kills. (Wave One)
• Unnamed United States Soldier - Shot to death by Arthur Morgan for shooting John.
• 20 Unnamed United States Soldiers - Shot to death by either Arthur, Sadie, Bill, or Cleet. Shared kills. (Minigun)
• 20 United States Soldier Horses - Shot to death by Arthur Morgan, optional.
  • Total - 66

Red Dead Redemption

• Seven Unnamed Pinkerton Agents - Shot to death by either Arthur or Sadie. Shared kills. (Van Horn)
• 19 Unnamed Pinkerton Agents - Shot to death by Arthur Morgan to save Sadie and Abigail. (Van Horn)
• Six Unnamed Pinkerton Agents - Shot to death by either Arthur or Sadie after saving Abigail. Shared kills. (Van Horn)
• Nine Unnamed Pinkerton Agents - Shot to death by Arthur Morgan to defend Sadie and Abigail. (Chase)
• At Least 18 Unnamed Pinkerton Agents - Shot to death by either Arthur or John. Shared kills. (Camp)
• 14 Unnamed Pinkerton Agents - Shot to death by either Arthur or John. Shared kills. (Chase #2)
• 14 Unnamed Pinkerton Agents - Shot to death by Arthur Morgan. (Get The Money)
• 40 Pinkerton Horses - Shot to death by Arthur Morgan, optional.
  • Total - 127

Side Missions

A Bright Bouncing Boy

• "969" - Shot to death by either Arthur or John, optional. Shared kill.
  • Total - 1

A Fine Night For It

• Nine Unnamed Night Folk - Shot to death by either Arthur, John, or an unnamed man. Shared kills.
  • Total - 9

A Fisher of Fish

• Legendary Bluegill - Captured by either Arthur or John on the request of Jeremy Gill. Shared kill.
• Legendary Bullhead Catfish - Captured by either Arthur or John on the request of Jeremy Gill. Shared kill.
• Legendary Chain Pickerel - Captured by either Arthur or John on the request of Jeremy Gill. Shared kill.
• Legendary Lake Sturgeon - Captured by either Arthur or John on the request of Jeremy Gill. Shared kill.
• Legendary Longnose Gar - Captured by either Arthur or John on the request of Jeremy Gill. Shared kill.
• Legendary Muskie - Captured by either Arthur or John on the request of Jeremy Gill. Shared kill.
• Legendary Perch - Captured by either Arthur or John on the request of Jeremy Gill. Shared kill.
• Legendary Smallmouth Bass - Captured by either Arthur or John on the request of Jeremy Gill. Shared kill.
• Legendary Sockeye Salmon - Captured by either Arthur or John on the request of Jeremy Gill. Shared kill.
• Legendary Steelhead Trout - Captured by either Arthur or John on the request of Jeremy Gill. Shared kill.
• Legendary Largemouth Bass - Captured by John Marston on the request of Jeremy Gill.
• Legendary Redfin Pickerel - Captured by John Marston on the request of Jeremy Gill.
• Legendary Rock Bass - Captured by John Marston on the request of Jeremy Gill.
  • Total - 13

A Test of Faith

• None

All that Glitters

• Máximo Cristóbal Valdespino - Shot to death by either Arthur or John, optional.
• Máximo Cristóbal Valdespino's Horse - Shot to death by either Arthur or John, optional.
  • Total - 2

American Dreams

• Edmund Lowry Jr. - Shot to death by either Arthur or John to save Sheriff Malloy or by Sheriff Malloy himself. Shared kill.
  • Total - 1

Arcadia for Amateurs

• Coyote - Shot to death by either Arthur or John, optional. (Encounter #1)
• Five Wolves - Shot to death by either Arthur or John, optional. (Encounter #2)
  • Total - 6

Duchesses and other Animals

• 15 Egrets - Shot to death by either Arthur or John on the request of Algernon Wasp. Shared kills. (Part 2)
• 20 Herons - Shot to death by either Arthur or John on the request of Algernon Wasp. Shared kills. (Part 3)
• 30 Spoonbills - Shot to death by either Arthur or John on the request of Algernon Wasp. Shared kills. (Part 4)
  • Total - 65

Fundraiser

• Unnamed Woman - Shot to death by either Arthur or John, optional.
  • Total - 1

Geology for Beginners

• None

He's British, of Course

• Lion - Shot to death by either Arthur or John.
  • Total - 1

Idealism and Pragmatism for Beginners

• Jean-Marc Mercier - Shot to death by Arthur Morgan on the orders of Henri Lemieux, optional.
  • Total - 1

No Good Deed

• Six Unnamed Gangsters - Shot to death by either Arthur or John. (Camp)
• Three Unnamed Gangsters - Shot to death by either Arthur or John. (Ambush)
• Three Horses - Shot to death by either Arthur or John. (Ambush)
  • Total - 12

Oh, Brother

• None

Smoking and other Hobbies

• None

The American Inferno, Burnt Out

• Deer - Shot to death by either Arthur or John to put it out of it's misery after being caught in a trap, optional.
• Three Unnamed Poachers - Shot to death by either Arthur or John, optional. Shared kills.
  • Total - 4

The Artist's Way

• Unnamed Man - Shot to death by either Arthur or John to save Charles. (Encounter #1)
• Three Unnamed Men - Shot to death by either Arthur or John to save Charles. (Encounter #4)
• Two Unnamed Saint Denis Lawmen - Shot to death by either Arthur or John, optional. (Encounter #4)
  • Total - 6

The Iniquities of History

• Jeremiah Compson - Shot to death by either Arthur or John, optional.
• Two Unnamed Squatters - Shot to death by either Arthur or John.
• Jeremiah Compson's Horse - Shot to death by either Arthur or John, optional.
  • Total - 4

The Mercies of Knowledge

• Four Unnamed Stagecoach Guards - Shot to death by Arthur Morgan. (Bridge)
• Five of McDaniels' Men - Shot to death by Arthur Morgan. (Bridge)
• Three Unnamed Moonshiners - Shot to death by Arthur Morgan. (Ambush)
• Two Stagecoach Guard Horses - Shot to death by Arthur Morgan, optional. (Bridge)
• Three McDaniels' Gang Horses - Shot to death by Arthur Morgan, optional. (Bridge)
• Three Moonshiner Horses - Shot to death by Arthur Morgan, optional. (Ambush)
  • Total - 20

The Noblest of Men, and a Woman

• Gonzalo (Del Lobo) - Shot to death by either Arthur or John. Shared kill.
• Anselmo (Del Lobo) - Shot to death by either Arthur or John. Shared kill.
• Eliso (Del Lobo) - Shot to death by either Arthur or John. Shared kill.
• Flaco Hernández - Shot to death by either Arthur or John. Shared kill.
• Emmet Granger - Shot to death by either Arthur or John. Shared kill.
• Billy Midnight - Either shot to death by either Arthur or John or committed suicide by shooting himself in the head. Shared kill.
• Jim "Boy" Calloway - Shot to death by either Arthur or John. Shared kill.
• Three Unnamed Bounty Hunters - Blown up by either Arthur or John with dynamite on the orders of Black Belle. Shared kills.
• 13 Unnamed Bounty Hunters - Shot to death by either Arthur, John, or Black Belle. Shared kills.
• Two Unnamed Del Lobo Gang Members - Shot to death by either Arthur or John. Shared kills.
• Four Unnamed Gangsters - Shot to death by either Arthur or John to save Jim "Boy" Calloway. Shared kills.
• 16 Horses - Shot to death by either Arthur or John, optional. (Black Belle)
• Four Chickens - Shot to death by either Arthur or John, optional. (Emmet Granger)
• Three Pigs - Shot to death by either Arthur or John, optional. (Emmet Granger)
  • Total - 52

The Smell of the Grease Paint

• None

The Ties That Bind Us

• Unnamed Bounty Hunter's Horse - Shot to death by either Arthur or John, optional.
• Unnamed Elderly Man - Shot to death by either Arthur or John, optional.
• Unnamed Bounty Hunter - Shot to death by either Arthur or John, optional.
  • Total - 3

The Veteran

• Tyrant (Legendary Northern Pike) - Captured by either Arthur or John with the help of Hamish Sinclair. Shared kill.
• Four Wolves - Shot to death by either Arthur, John, or Hamish. Shared kills.
• Alpha Wolf - Shot to death by either Arthur or John. Shared kill.
• Boar - Shot to death by either Arthur or John. Shared kill.
• Buell (Horse) - Shot to death by either Arthur or John, optional. Shared kill.
  • Total - 8

The Wisdom of the Elders

• Two Sick Dogs - Shot to death by either Arthur or John to save a woman's pigs. Shared kills.
• Three Sick Dogs - Shot to death by either Arthur or John to save an unnamed man. Shared kills.
• Two Sick Dogs - Shot to death by either Arthur or John to save Kain. Shared kills.
• Four Sick Dogs - Shot to death by either Arthur or John to protect Butcher Creek.
• "Shaman" - Shot to death by either Arthur or John, optional.
  • Total - 12

To the Ends of the Earth

• William - Shot to death by either Arthur or John, optional.
  • Total - 1

Charlotte Balfour

• Charlotte Balfour - Shot to death by either Arthur or John, optional. Shared kill.
• Rabbit - Shot to death by either Arthur or John. Shared kill. (Encounter #1)
• Two Wolves - Shot to death by either Arthur or John to protect Charlotte. Shared kills. (Encounter #1)
• Rat - Shot to death by Arthur Morgan. (Encounter #2)
  • Total - 5

Companion Activities

Lenny Summers

Five Finger Fillet

• None

Rob a Stagecoach

• Unnamed Stagecoach Guard - Shot to death by either Arthur or Lenny. Shared kill.
• Five Unnamed United States Marshals - Shot to death by either Arthur or Lenny. Shared kills.
• Four Stagecoach Horses - Shot to death by Arthur, optional.
• Three United States Marshal Horses - Shot to death by Arthur, optional.
• Two Unnamed Stagecoach Drivers - Shot to death by either Arthur or Lenny. Shared kills.
  • Total - 15

Charles Smith

Go Hunting

• Unnamed Poacher - Strangled to death by Arthur Morgan, optional.
• Bison - Shot to death by Arthur.
• Five Bison - Shot to death by Arthur, optional.
• Two Poacher Horses - Shot to death by Arthur, optional.
  • Total - 9

Javier Escuella

Rob a Homestead

• Pappy Porter - Shot to death by either Arthur Morgan or Javier Escuella. Shared kill.
• Newt Porter - Shot to death by either Arthur Morgan or Javier Escuella. Shared kill.
• Finney Porter - Shot to death by either Arthur Morgan or Javier Escuella. Shared kill.
• Mal Porter - Shot to death by either Arthur Morgan or Javier Escuella. Shared kill.
• Edie Porter - Shot to death by either Arthur Morgan or Javier Escuella. Shared kill.
• Two Unnamed Porter Family Members - Shot to death by either Arthur Morgan or Javier Escuella. Shared kills.
• Two Horses - Shot to death by Arthur Morgan, optional.
  • Total - 9

Go Fishing

• At Least One Fish - Captured by Arthur Morgan.
  • Total - 1

Micah Bell

Five Finger Fillet

• None

Rob a Stagecoach

• Four Unnamed Boles Overland Stagecoach Guards - Shot to death by either Arthur, Bill, or Micah. Shared kills.
• Four Horses - Blown up with a stick of dynamite planted by Micah Bell that was shot by Arthur Morgan. Shared kills.
• Two Unnamed Stagecoach Drivers - Blown up with a stick of dynamite planted by Micah Bell that was shot by Arthur Morgan. Shared kills.
  • Total - 10

Tilly Jackson

Dominoes

• None

Sean MacGuire

Social Calls with Mr. MacGuire

• Four Unknown Gang Members - Shot to death by either Arthur or Sean. Shared kills.
• Unnamed Gang Member - Shot to death by Arthur Morgan, optional.
  • Total - 5

Rob a Stagecoach

• Laurence - Shot to death by either Arthur or Sean. Shared kill.
• Harry - Shot to death by either Arthur or Sean. Shared kill.
• Four Unnamed Boles Overland Guards - Shot to death by either Arthur or Sean. Shared kills.
  • Total - 6

Kieran Duffy

Go Fishing

• At Least One Fish - Captured by Arthur Morgan and presumably eaten off-screen, optional. (Area One)
• At Least Two Fish - Captured by Arthur Morgan and presumably eaten off-screen, optional. (Area Two)
• Legendary Bluegill - Captured by Arthur Morgan and presumably eaten or stuffed off-screen.
  • Total - 4

Bill Williamson

Rob a Stagecoach

• Six Unnamed Stagecoach Guards - Shot to death by either Arthur or Bill. Shared kills.
  • Total - 6

Simon Pearson

Go Hunting

• Five Crawfish - Captured by Arthur and Pearson. Shared kills.
• Three Alligators - Shot to death by Arthur, optional.
  • Total - 8

Uncle

Go Rustling

• Squears - Shot to death by Arthur Morgan, optional.
• Two Unnamed Cow Rustlers - Shot to death by Arthur Morgan, optional.
  • Total - 3

Bounty Hunts

Ellie Anne Swan

• Unnamed Man - Either shot to death by Arthur or John or stabbed in the throat by Ellie Anne Swan.
  • Total - 1

Joshua Brown

• Four Unnamed Bounty Hunters - Shot to death by either Arthur or John. Shared kills.
• Three Horses - Shot to death by either Arthur or John, optional. Shared kills.
  • Total - 7

Mark Johnson

• Three of Mark Johnson's Friends - Shot to death by either Arthur or John. Shared kills.
• Mark Johnson's Horse - Shot to death by either Arthur or John, optional. Shared kill.
• Three Horses - Shot to death by either Arthur or John, optional. Shared kills.
• Mark Johnson's Wife - Shot to death by either Arthur or John, optional. Shared kill.
  • Total - 8

Camille de Millemont

• Camille de Millemont - Either shot to death by either Arthur or John or eventually hanged by the town of Rhodes. Shared kill.
• Three Unnamed Lemoyne Raiders Gang Members - Shot to death by either Arthur or John. Shared kills. (Camp)
• Three Unnamed Lemoyne Raiders Gang Members - Shot to death by either Arthur or John. Shared kills. (Ambush)
• Seven Lemoyne Raiders Horses - Shot to death by either Arthur or John. Shared kills.
  • Total - 14

Lindsey Wofford

• Lindsey Wofford - Shot to death by either Arthur or John, optional.
• Ten Unnamed Lemoyne Raiders Gang Members - Shot to death by either Arthur or John, optional. (Fort)
• Three Unnamed Bounty Hunters - Shot to death by either Arthur or John. (Ambush)
• Three Bounty Hunter Horses - Shot to death by either Arthur or John, optional. (Ambush)
  • Total - 17

Random Encounters

O'Driscoll Boys

Prison Wagon Break

• Three Unnamed O'Driscoll Gang Members - Shot to death by either Arthur or John. Shared kills.
• Unnamed O'Driscoll Prisoner - Shot to death by either Arthur or John, optional. Shared kill.
• Three O'Driscoll Horses - Shot to death by either Arthur or John, optional. Shared kills.
• Two Unnamed Lawmen - Shot to death by three unnamed O'Driscoll gang members, or optionally killed by either Arthur or John. Shared kill.
  • Total - 9

Stagecoach Robbery

• Two Unnamed O'Driscoll Gang Members - Shot to death by either Arthur or John. Shared kills.
• Four Stagecoach Horses - Shot to death by either Arthur or John, optional. Shared kills.
• Two O'Driscoll Horses - Shot to death by either Arthur or John, optional. Shared kills.
• Unnamed Stagecoach Driver - Shot to death by either Arthur or John, optional. Shared kill.
  • Total - 9

Extortion

• Two Unnamed O'Driscoll Gang Members - Killed by either Arthur or John. Shared kills.
• Two O'Driscoll Horses - Shot to death by either Arthur or John, optional. Shared kills.
• Unnamed Man - Optionally killed by either Arthur or John or beaten to death by two unnamed O'Driscoll gang members if he's not saved by either Arthur or John.
  • Total - 5

Train Robbery

• Three Unnamed O'Driscoll Gang Members - Shot to death by either Arthur or John. Shared kills.
• Three O'Driscoll Horses - Shot to death by either Arthur or John, optional. Shared kills.
• Four Unnamed Train Passengers - Shot to death by either three O'Driscoll gang members if Arthur or John does not save them in time or optionally shot to death by Arthur or John. Shared kills.
  • Total - 10

Road Ambush I

• Four Unnamed O'Driscoll Gang Members - Shot to death by either Arthur or John. Shared kills.
• Four O'Driscoll Horses - Shot to death by either Arthur or John, optional. Shared kills.
  • Total - 8

Road Ambush II

• Three Unnamed O'Driscoll Gang Members - Shot to death by either Arthur or John. Shared kills.
• Two O'Driscoll Stagecoach Horses - Shot to death by either Arthur or John, optional. Shared kills.
  • Total - 5

Bridge Ambush I

• Three Unnamed O'Driscoll Gang Members - Shot to death by either Arthur or John. Shared kills.
• Three O'Driscoll Horses - Shot to death by either Arthur or John, optional. Shared kills.
  • Total - 6

Bridge Ambush II

• Four Unnamed O'Driscoll Gang Members - Shot to death by either Arthur or John. Shared kills.
• Two O'Driscoll Horses - Shot to death by either Arthur or John, optional. Shared kills.
  • Total - 6

Bridge Barricade

• Five Unnamed O'Driscoll Gang Members - Shot to death by either Arthur or John. Shared kills.
• Three O'Driscoll Horses - Shot to death by either Arthur or John, optional. Shared kills.
• Two O'Driscoll Stagecoach Horses - Shot to death by either Arthur or John, optional. Shared kills.
  • Total - 10

Brawl at Keane's Saloon

• Three Unnamed O'Driscoll Gang Members - Shot to death by either Arthur or John. Shared kills.
• Three O'Driscoll Horses - Shot to death by either Arthur or John, optional. Shared kills.
  • Total - 6

Lemoyne Raiders

Cavalry Charge

• 12 Unnamed Lemoyne Raiders Gang Members - Shot to death by either Arthur or John. Shared kills.
• 12 Lemoyne Raiders Horses - Shot to death by either Arthur or John, optional. Shared kills.
  • Total - 24

Gatling Gun Ambush

• Six Unnamed Lemoyne Raiders Gang Members - Shot to death by either Arthur or John. Shared kills.
• Three Lemoyne Raiders Horses - Shot to death by either Arthur or John, optional. Shared kills.
  • Total - 9

Exploding Wagon Ambush

• Five Unnamed Lemoyne Raiders Gang Members - Shot to death by either Arthur or John. Shared kills.
  • Total - 5

Bridge Ambush

• Six Unnamed Lemoyne Raiders Gang Members - Shot to death by either Arthur or John. Shared kills.
• Two Lemoyne Raider Horses - Shot to death by either Arthur or John, optional. Shared kills.
  • Total - 8

Lone Lemoyne Raider

• Unnamed Lemoyne Raider - Shot to death by either Arthur or John. Shared kill.
• Lemoyne Raider's Horse - Shot to death by either Arthur or John, optional. Shared kill.
  • Total - 2

Arson and Vandalism at Saint Denis City Hall

• Three Unnamed Lemoyne Raiders Gang Members - Shot to death by either Arthur or John. Shared kills.
• Three Lemoyne Raiders Horses - Shot to death by either Arthur or John, optional. Shared kills.
  • Total - 6

Abducted Policeman

• Four Unnamed Lemoyne Raiders Gang Members - Shot to death by either Arthur or John. Shared kills.
• Two Lemoyne Raider Horses - Shot to death by either Arthur or John, optional. Shared kills.
• Unnamed Deputy - Either shot to death by an unnamed Lemoyne Raider if he is not saved by either Arthur or John in time, or optionally killed by either Arthur or John. Shared kill.
  • Total - 7

Abducted Tax Collectors I

• Four Unnamed Lemoyne Raiders Gang Members - Shot to death by either Arthur or John. Shared kills.
• Two Lemoyne Raider Horses - Shot to death by either Arthur or John, optional. Shared kills.
• Unnamed Tax Collector - Either stabbed to death by an unnamed Lemoyne Raider if he is not saved by either Arthur or John in time, or optionally killed by either Arthur or John. Shared kill.
  • Total - 7

Abducted Tax Collectors II

• Two Unnamed Lemoyne Raiders Gang Members - Shot to death by either Arthur or John. Shared kills.
• Two Lemoyne Raider Horses - Shot to death by either Arthur or John, optional. Shared kills.
• Unnamed Tax Collector - Either shot in the head by an unnamed Lemoyne Raider if he is not saved by either Arthur or John in time, or optionally killed by either Arthur or John. Shared kill.
  • Total - 5

Prison Wagon Break

• Three Unnamed Lemoyne Raiders Gang Members - Shot to death by either Arthur or John. Shared kills.
• Unnamed Lemoyne Raider Prisoner - Shot to death by either Arthur or John, optional. Shared kill.
• Three Lemoyne Raider Horses - Shot to death by either Arthur or John, optional. Shared kills.
• Two Stagecoach Horses - Shot to death by either Arthur or John, optional. Shared kills.
• Two Unnamed Lawmen - Either shot to death by three Lemoyne Raiders gang members, or optionally killed by either Arthur or John. Shared kill.
  • Total - 11

Brawls at Rhodes Parlour House I

• Two Unnamed Lemoyne Raiders Gang Members - Beaten to death by either Arthur or John inside the bar. Shared kills.
  • Total - 2

Brawls at Rhodes Parlour House II

• Unnamed Lemoyne Raider Gang Member - Beaten to death by either Arthur or John outside the bar. Shared kill.
  • Total - 1

Lemoyne Raiders duo beat man outside Rhodes Parlour House

• Two Unnamed Lemoyne Raiders Gang Members - Beaten to death by either Arthur or John. Shared kills.
• Two Lemoyne Raider Horses - Shot to death by either Arthur or John, optional. Shared kills.
• Unnamed Man - Beaten to death by two Lemoyne Raiders gang members if they are not stopped in time by either Arthur or John, or optionally killed by either Arthur or John. Shared kill.
  • Total - 5

Train Robbery

• Five Unnamed Lemoyne Raiders Gang Members - Shot to death by either Arthur or John. Shared kills.
• Five Lemoyne Raider Horses - Shot to death by either Arthur or John, optional. Shared kills.
• Five Unnamed Men - Shot to death by either five Lemoyne Raiders gang members if Arthur or John does not save them in time or optionally shot to death by Arthur or John. Shared kills.
  • Total - 15

Gun Deal Gone Wrong

• Two Unnamed Lemoyne Raiders Gang Members - Shot to death by either Arthur or John. Shared kills.
• Two Unnamed Gun Smugglers - Shot to death by either Arthur or John, or possibly by two Lemoyne Raiders gang members. Shared kills.
• Two Lemoyne Raiders Horses - Shot to death by either Arthur or John, optional. Shared kills.
• Two Gun Smuggler Horses - Shot to death by either Arthur or John, optional. Shared kills.
  • Total - 8

Successful Gun Deal

• Two Unnamed Lemoyne Raiders Gang Members - Shot to death by either Arthur or John. Shared kills.
• Two Unnamed Gun Smugglers - Shot to death by either Arthur or John.
• Two Lemoyne Raiders Horses - Shot to death by either Arthur or John, optional. Shared kills.
• Two Gun Smuggler Horses - Shot to death by either Arthur or John, optional. Shared kills.
  • Total - 8

Gang Intimidation I

• Three Unnamed Lemoyne Raiders Gang Members - Shot to death by either Arthur or John. Shared kills. (Rhodes)
  • Total - 3

Gang Intimidation II

• Three Unnamed Lemoyne Raiders Gang Members - Shot to death by either Arthur or John. Shared kills. (Scarlett Meadows)
  • Total - 3

Wagon Holdup I

• Two Unnamed Lemoyne Raiders Gang Members - Shot to death by either Arthur or John. Shared kills.
• Two Lemoyne Raiders Horses - Shot to death by either Arthur or John, optional. Shared kills.
• Two Stagecoach Horses - Shot to death by either Arthur or John, optional. Shared kills.
  • Total - 6

Wagon Holdup II

• Three Unnamed Lemoyne Raiders Gang Members - Shot to death by either Arthur or John. Shared kills.
• Stagecoach Horse - Shot to death by either Arthur or John, optional. Shared kill.
• Unnamed Man - Optionally shot to death by either Arthur or John, or possibly by three Lemoyne Raiders gang members. Shared kills.
  • Total - 5

Target Practice

• Three Unnamed Lemoyne Raiders Gang Members - Shot to death by either Arthur or John. Shared kills.
• Three Lemoyne Raider Horses - Shot to death by either Arthur or John, optional. Shared kills.
  • Total - 6

Vengeful Raiders

• Three Unnamed Lemoyne Raiders Gang Members - Shot to death by either Arthur or John. Shared kills.
  • Total - 3

Murfree Brood

Camp Intimidation

• Two Unnamed Murfree Brood Gang Members - Shot to death by either Arthur or John. Shared kills.
• Two Murfree Brood Horses - Shot to death by either Arthur or John, optional. Shared kills.
  • Total - 4

Camp Attack

• Two Unnamed Murfree Brood Gang Members - Shot to death by either Arthur or John. Shared kills.
  • Total - 2

Camp Robbery

• Four Unnamed Murfree Brood Gang Members - Shot to death by either Arthur or John. Shared kills.
  • Total - 4

Road Ambush

• At Least Two Unnamed Murfree Brood Gang Members - Shot to death by either Arthur or John. Shared kills.
  • Total - 2

Burning Wagon Attack

• Five Unnamed Murfree Brood Brood Gang Members - Shot to death by either Arthur or John. Shared kills.
  • Total - 5

Pox Tent Trap

• Unnamed Sick Murfree Brood Gang Member - Shot to death by either Arthur or John. Shared kill.
• Unnamed Murfree Brood Gang Member - Shot to death by either Arthur or John. Shared kill.
  • Total - 2

Man Tied To a Tree

• Two Unnamed Murfree Brood Gang Members - Shot to death by either Arthur or John. Shared kills.
• Unnamed Man - Set on fire by the Murfree Brood gang members if he's not saved in time by either Arthur or John, or optionally killed by either Arthur or John. Shared kill.
  • Total - 3

Pit Trap

• Three Unnamed Murfree Brood Gang Members - Shot to death by either Arthur or John. Shared kills.
  • Total - 3

Kidnapping (Traumatized Victim)

• Two Unnamed Murfree Brood Gang Members - Shot to death by either Arthur or John. Shared kills.
• Stagecoach Horse - Shot to death by either Arthur or John, optional. Shared kill.
• Unnamed Woman - Shot to death by either Arthur or John, optional. Shared kill.
  • Total - 4

Kidnapping (Grateful Victim)

• Two Unnamed Murfree Brood Gang Members - Shot to death by either Arthur or John. Shared kills.
• Two Murfree Brood Horses - Shot to death by either Arthur or John, optional. Shared kills.
• Two Horses - Killed by two Murfree Brood gang members off-screen, bodies shown.
• Unnamed Woman - Killed by the Murfree Brood gang off-screen if Arthur or John choose to not intervene, or optionally killed by either Arthur or John. Shared kill.
  • Total - 7

Murfree Brood dumping bodies from boat into the Elysian Pool

• Three Unnamed Murfree Brood Gang Members - Shot to death by either Arthur or John. Shared kills.
  • Total - 3

Murfree Brood Corpse Trap

• Three Unnamed Murfree Brood Gang Members - Shot to death by either Arthur or John. Shared kills.
  • Total - 3

Night Folk

Night Folk Corpse Trap

• Three Unnamed Male Night Folk - Shot to death by either Arthur or John. Shared kills.
  • Total - 3

Woman in White Trap

• "Woman in White" (Night Folk) - Shot to death by either Arthur or John. Shared kill.
• Three Unnamed Male Night Folk - Shot to death by either Arthur or John. Shared kills.
  • Total - 4

Night Folk Carrying a Corpse

• Two Unnamed Male Night Folk - Shot to death by either Arthur or John. Shared kills.
  • Total - 2

Night Folk Horse Murder Trap (Lure)

• Three Unnamed Male Night Folk - Shot to death by either Arthur or John. Shared kills.
  • Total - 3

Night Folk Horse Murder Trap (Cart)

• Five Unnamed Male Night Folk - Shot to death by either Arthur or John. Shared kills.
  • Total - 5

Angelo Bronte's Mob

Bridge Watch

• Four Unnamed Angelo Bronte Henchmen - Shot to death by Arthur Morgan.
  • Total - 4

Doyle's Tavern Setup

• Three Unnamed Angelo Bronte Henchmen - Beaten to death by Arthur Morgan.
  • Total - 3

Mobsters' Bullying

• Two Unnamed Angel Bronte Henchmen - Shot to death by Arthur Morgan.
  • Total - 2

Ku Klux Klan

KKK Meeting

• Two Unnamed KKK Members - Either optionally shot to death by either Arthur or John or accidentally burned to death when a lit torch touched their robes. Shared kills.
• Two Unnamed KKK Members - Shot to death either Arthur or John. Shared kills. (Player's Choice, Optional)
  • Total - 4

KKK Initiation

• Unnamed KKK Leader - Shot to death either Arthur or John. Shared kill. (Player's Choice, Optional)
• Two Unnamed KKK Members - Either optionally shot to death either Arthur or John or burned to death after setting a giant cross on fire. Shared kills.
• Seven Unnamed KKK Members - Shot to death by either Arthur or John. Shared kills. (Player's Choice, Optional)
• Four KKK Horses - Shot to death either Arthur or John, optional. Shared kills.
  • Total - 14

Cross Accident

• Unnamed KKK Leader - Shot to death by either Arthur or John. Shared kill. (Player's Choice, Optional)
• Two Unnamed KKK Members - Either optionally shot to death by either Arthur or John or accidentally crushed after dropping a giant cross on themselves. Shared kills.
• KKK Leader's Horse - Shot to death by Arthur Morgan. (Player's Choice, Optional)
  • Total - 4

Nature

Man Bitten by Snake I

• Norbert - Bitten on the leg by a snake and succumbed to its venom if either Arthur or John choose to not help, or optionally killed by either Arthur or John. Shared kill.
  • Total - 1

Man Bitten by Snake II

• Unnamed Man - Bitten on the leg by a snake and succumbed to its venom if either Arthur or John choose to not help, or optionally killed by either Arthur or John. Shared kill.
  • Total - 1

Man Poisoned by Plant

• Unnamed Man - Accidentally succumbed to a plant's poison after eating it if he's not saved in time by either Arthur or John, or optionally killed by either Arthur or John. Shared kill.
  • Total - 1

Trapper Steps on a Trap I

• Unnamed Man - Accidentally stepped on a bear trap and bled to death if Arthur or John don't save him in time, or optionally killed by either Arthur or John. Shared kill. (Strawberry)
  • Total - 1

Trapper Steps on a Trap II

• Unnamed Man - Accidentally stepped on a bear trap and bleeds to death if Arthur or John don't save him in time, or optionally killed by either Arthur or John. Shared kill. (Roanoke Ridge)
  • Total - 1

Cougar Attack

• Cougar - Shot to death by either Arthur or John to save an unnamed man. (Player's Choice, Optional)
• Unnamed Man's Horse - Shot to death by either Arthur or John. (Player's Choice, Optional)
• Unnamed Man - Either optionally shot to death by either Arthur or John or mauled to death by a cougar.
  • Total - 3

Wolf Attack I

• Wolf - Shot to death by either Arthur or John. Shared kill.
• Unnamed Man - Either eventually bled to death after being attacked by a wolf or mercifully shot to death by either Arthur or John on his request. Shared kill.
  • Total - 2

Wolf Attack II

• Two Wolves - Shot to death by either Arthur or John. Shared kill.
• Unnamed Man - Either mauled to death by wolves if he's not saved in time or optionally shot to death by either Arthur or John. Shared kill.
  • Total - 3

Prospector I

• Prospector's Horse - Shot to death by either Arthur or John, optional. Shared kill.
• Unnamed Man - Shot to death by either Arthur or John to steal his gold. Shared kill.
  • Total - 2

Prospector II

• Prospector's Horse - Shot to death by either Arthur or John, optional. Shared kill.
• Unnamed Man - Shot to death by either Arthur or John. Shared kill.
  • Total - 2

Shooting Competition I

• Unnamed Man - Shot to death by either Arthur or John. Shared kill. (The Heartlands)
  • Total - 1

Shooting Competition II

• Unnamed Man - Shot to death by either Arthur or John. Shared kill. (Rio Bravo)
  • Total - 1

Shooting Competition III

• Unnamed Man - Shot to death by either Arthur or John. Shared kill. (Big Valley)
  • Total - 1

Shooting Competition IV

• Unnamed Man - Shot to death by either Arthur or John. Shared kill. (Ringneck Creek)
  • Total - 1

Shooting Competition V

• Unnamed Man - Shot to death by either Arthur or John. Shared kill. (Scarlett Meadows)
  • Total - 1

Bear Hunter I

• Bear - Shot to death by either Arthur, John, or the unnamed hunter. Shared kill. (Big Valley)
• Unnamed Man - Either mauled to death by a bear or optionally shot to death by either Arthur or John. Shared kill. (Big Valley)
  • Total - 2

Bear Hunter II

• Bear - Shot to death by either Arthur, John, or the unnamed hunter. Shared kill. (Grizzlies East)
• Unnamed Man - Either mauled to death by a bear or optionally shot to death by either Arthur or John. Shared kill. (Grizzlies East)
  • Total - 2

Coyote Hunter

• Coyote - Shot to death by either Arthur, John, or the unnamed hunter. Shared kill.
• Hunter's Horse - Shot to death by either Arthur or John, optional. Shared kill.
• Unnamed Hunter - Optionally shot to death by either Arthur or John. Shared kill.
  • Total - 3

Hunter Needs Help Looking For His Friend

• Bear - Shot to death by either Arthur, John, or the unnamed man. Shared kill.
• Hunter's Horse - Shot to death by either Arthur or John, optional. Shared kill.
• Unnamed Man - Either mauled to death by a bear or optionally shot to death by either Arthur or John. Shared kill.
  • Total - 3

Herb Collector I

• Herbalist's Horse - Shot to death by either Arthur or John, optional. Shared kill. (New Hanover)
• Unnamed Herbalist - Shot to death by either Arthur or John, optional. Shared kill.
  • Total - 2

Herb Collector II

• Herbalist's Horse - Shot to death by either Arthur or John, optional. Shared kill. (Big Valley)
• Unnamed Herbalist - Shot to death by either Arthur or John, optional. Shared kill.
  • Total - 2

Herb Collector III

• Herbalist's Horse - Shot to death by either Arthur or John, optional. Shared kill. (Scarlett Meadows)
• Unnamed Herbalist - Shot to death by either Arthur or John, optional. Shared kill.
  • Total - 2

Drunk Duelist I

• Unnamed Man - Shot to death by either Arthur or John in a duel. (Valentine)
  • Total - 1

Drunk Duelist II

• Unnamed Man - Shot to death by either Arthur or John in a duel. (Van Horn Trading Post)
  • Total - 1

Duelist Takes on Challenger I

• Unnamed Man - Shot to death by either Arthur or John in a duel.
  • Total - 1

Duelist Takes on Challenger II

• Unnamed Man - Shot to death by either Arthur or John in a duel.
  • Total - 1

Boastful Duelist

• Willy Curlls - Shot to death by either Arthur or John in a duel, optional.
• Willy Curlls' Friend - Shot to death by either Arthur or John, optional.
  • Total - 2

Man Shoots Himself in the Leg I

• Two Unnamed Men - Shot to death by either Arthur or John, optional. Shared kills. (Annesburg)
  • Total - 2

Man Shoots Himself in the Leg II

• Two Unnamed Men - Shot to death by either Arthur or John, optional. Shared kills. (Strawberry)
  • Total - 2

Man Accidentally Shoots and Kills His Friend

• Unnamed Man - Shot to death by either Arthur or John, optional. Shared kill.
  • Total - 1

Horse Race I

• None (Big Valley)

Horse Race II

• Horse - Either shot in the head by its owner for losing the race for a second time or optionally by either Arthur or John. (Big Valley)
• Unnamed Man - Shot to death by either Arthur or John for killing his horse, optional.
  • Total - 2

Horse Race III

• None (Scarlett Meadows)

Horse Race IV

• Horse - Shot to death by either Arthur or John, optional. (Scarlett Meadows)
• Unnamed Woman - Shot to death by either Arthur or John, optional.
  • Total - 2

Horse Race V

• Ariel (Horse) - Shot to death by either Arthur or John, optional. (Grizzlies East)
• Unnamed Man - Shot to death by either Arthur or John, optional.
  • Total - 2

Horse Race VI

• Horse - Shot to death by either Arthur or John, optional. (Ambarino)
• Unnamed Man - Shot to death by either Arthur or John, optional.
  • Total - 2

Horse Race VII

• Horse - Shot to death by either Arthur or John, optional. (Ambarino)
• Unnamed Man - Shot to death by either Arthur or John, optional.
  • Total - 2

Horse Kicks and Kills Its Owner

• Horse - Shot to death by either Arthur or John, optional.
  • Total - 1

Runaway Horse

• Horse - Shot to death by either Arthur or John, optional.
• Unnamed Man - Shot to death by either Arthur or John, optional.
  • Total - 2

Man Falls off Horse

• Horse - Shot to death by either Arthur or John, optional.
  • Total - 1

Woman Trapped Under Her Horse I

• Mildred's Horse - Died of unknown causes off-screen, body shown. (Valentine)
• Unnamed Woman's Husband - Died of unspecified causes off-screen, mentioned.
• Unnamed Woman - Shot to death by either Arthur or John, optional.
  • Total - 3

Woman Trapped Under Her Horse II

• Unnamed Woman - Shot to death by either Arthur or John, optional.
  • Total - 1

Woman Trapped Under Her Horse III

• Unnamed Woman - Shot to death by either Arthur or John, optional.
  • Total - 1

Woman Trapped Under Her Horse IV

• Unnamed Woman - Shot to death by either Arthur or John, optional.
  • Total - 1

Crashed Wagon

• Unnamed Man - Shot to death by either Arthur or John, optional.
  • Total - 1

Lenora View Wagon Crash

• Unnamed Man - Shot to death by either Arthur or John, optional.
  • Total - 1

Crazy Woman Lost in The Woods For Two Days

• Unnamed Woman - Shot to death by either Arthur or John, optional.
  • Total - 1

Peaceful Camper I

• Horse - Shot to death by either Arthur or John, optional.
• Unnamed Man - Shot to death by either Arthur or John, optional.
  • Total - 2

Peaceful Camper II

• Horse - Shot to death by either Arthur or John, optional.
• Unnamed Man - Shot to death by either Arthur or John, optional.
  • Total - 2

Peaceful Camper III

• Horse - Shot to death by either Arthur or John, optional.
• Unnamed Man - Shot to death by either Arthur or John, optional.
  • Total - 2

Peaceful Camper IV

• Horse - Shot to death by either Arthur or John, optional.
• Unnamed Man - Shot to death by either Arthur or John, optional.
  • Total - 2

Peaceful Camper V

• Horse - Shot to death by either Arthur or John, optional.
• Unnamed Man - Shot to death by either Arthur or John, optional.
  • Total - 2

Peaceful Camper VI

• Horse - Shot to death by either Arthur or John, optional.
• Unnamed Man - Shot to death by either Arthur or John, optional.
  • Total - 2

Peaceful Camper VII

• Horse - Shot to death by either Arthur or John, optional.
• Unnamed Woman - Shot to death by either Arthur or John, optional.
  • Total - 2

Perverted Stalker

• Horse - Shot to death by either Arthur or John, optional.
• Unnamed Man - Shot to death by either Arthur or John, optional.
  • Total - 2

Outlaws and Lawmen

Bill Williamson Captured

• Four Unnamed Bounty Hunters - Shot to death by either Arthur or Javier. Shared kills.
• Bounty Hunter Horse - Shot to death by Arthur, optional.
  • Total - 5

Prisoners at Crawdad Willies Shack

• Unnamed Male Prisoner - Shot to death by either Arthur or John, optional.
  • Total - 1

Killer Prostitute

• Unnamed Prostitute - Either hanged by the town of Valentine or optionally killed by either Arthur or John.
  • Total - 1

Outlaw Attack

• Four Horses - Shot to death by either Arthur or John, optional. Shared kills.
• Four Unnamed Men - Shot to death by either Arthur or John. Shared kills.
  • Total - 8

Pickpocket I

• Unnamed Thief - Beaten to death by either Arthur or John. Shared kill.
  • Total - 1

Pickpocket II

• Unnamed Thief - Beaten to death by either Arthur or John. Shared kill.
  • Total - 1

Pickpocket III

• Unnamed Thief - Beaten to death by either Arthur or John. Shared kill.
  • Total - 1

Fugitive Prisoner

• Unnamed Prisoner - Shot to death by either Arthur or John, optional. Shared kill.
  • Total - 1

Chain Gang Escape Attempt

• Two Unnamed Prisoners - Shot to death by either Arthur or John. Shared kills.
• Two Stagecoach Horses - Shot to death by either Arthur or John, optional. Shared kills.
• Two Unnamed Prison Guards - Either stabbed to death by three prisoners or shot to death by either Arthur or John. Shared kills.
• Unnamed Prisoner - Shot to death by either one of the prison guards or by either Arthur or John. Shared kill.
  • Total - 7

Criminal Being Transported by Lawmen I

• Two Stagecoach Horses - Shot to death by either Arthur or John, optional. Shared kills.
• Two Unnamed Lawmen - Shot to death by either Arthur or John, optional. Shared kills.
• Unnamed Female Prisoner - Shot to death by either Arthur or John, optional. Shared kill.
  • Total - 5

Criminal Being Transported by Lawmen II

• Two Stagecoach Horses - Shot to death by either Arthur or John, optional. Shared kills.
• Two Unnamed Lawmen - Shot to death by either Arthur or John, optional. Shared kills.
• Unnamed Male Prisoner - Shot to death by either Arthur or John, optional. Shared kill.
  • Total - 5

Criminal Being Transported by Lawmen III

• Two Stagecoach Horses - Shot to death by either Arthur or John, optional. Shared kills.
• Two Unnamed Lawmen - Shot to death by either Arthur or John, optional. Shared kills.
• Unnamed Male Prisoner - Shot to death by either Arthur or John, optional. Shared kill.
  • Total - 5

Criminal Being Transported by Bounty Hunters I

• Two Unnamed Bounty Hunters - Shot to death by either Arthur or John, optional. Shared kills.
• Two Horses - Shot to death by either Arthur or John, optional. Shared kills.
• Unnamed Man - Shot to death by either Arthur or John, optional. Shared kill.
  • Total - 5

Criminal Being Transported by Bounty Hunters II

• Two Unnamed Bounty Hunters - Shot to death by either Arthur or John, optional. Shared kills.
• Two Horses - Shot to death by either Arthur or John, optional. Shared kills.
• Unnamed Man - Shot to death by either Arthur or John, optional. Shared kill.
  • Total - 5

Kidnapping I

• Unnamed Man - Shot to death by either Arthur or John. Shared kill.
• Horse - Shot to death by either Arthur or John, optional. Shared kill.
• Unnamed Woman - Shot to death by either Arthur or John, optional. Shared kill.
  • Total - 3

Kidnapping II

• Unnamed Man - Shot to death by either Arthur or John. Shared kill.
• Horse - Shot to death by either Arthur or John, optional. Shared kill.
• Unnamed Woman - Shot to death by either Arthur or John, optional. Shared kill.
  • Total - 3

Two Outlaws Trying to Break Open a Safe

• Two Unnamed Men - Either accidentally blown up with dynamite or shot to death by either Arthur or John. Shared kills.
• Two Stagecoach Horses - Shot to death by either Arthur or John, optional. Shared kills.
  • Total - 4

Two Outlaws With a Crashed Wagon

• Unnamed Man - Knocked out by the other outlaw and then optionally shot to death by either Arthur or John. Shared kill.
• Unnamed Man - Shot to death by either Arthur or John, optional. Shared kills.
• Horse - Shot to death by either Arthur or John, optional. Shared kill.
  • Total - 3

Injured Woman Robbery Ambush (Lydie)

• Lydie - Shot to death by either Arthur or John, optional. Shared kill.
• Bobbie - Shot to death by either Arthur or John, optional. Shared kill.
• Earl - Shot to death by either Arthur or John, optional. Shared kill.
• Two Horses - Shot to death by either Arthur or John, optional. Shared kills.
  • Total - 5

Horse Thief I

• Unnamed Man - Shot to death by either Arthur or John for stealing their horse. Shared kill. (New Hanover)
  • Total - 1

Horse Thief II

• Unnamed Man - Shot to death by either Arthur or John for stealing their horse. Shared kill. (Van Horn Trading Post)
  • Total - 1

Robbery

• Unnamed Man - Shot to death by either Arthur or John. Shared kill.
  • Total - 1

Bridge Holdup

• Four Unnamed Men - Shot to death by either Arthur or John. Shared kills.
• Two Horses - Shot to death by either Arthur or John, optional. Shared kills.
  • Total - 6

Uncle's Saloon Debacle II

• Unnamed Man - Shot to death by either Arthur or John for bullying Uncle, optional. (Valentine)
  • Total - 1

Attempted Murder

• Horace - Shot to death by either Arthur or John, optional. Shared kill.
• Two Unnamed Men - Shot to death by either Arthur or John. Shared kills.
• Two Horses - Shot to death by either Arthur or John, optional. Shared kills.
• Horace's Wife - Either stabbed to death by one of the two kidnappers or optionally shot to death by either Arthur or John. Shared kill.
  • Total - 6

Brutal Death

• Horse - Shot to death by either Arthur or John, optional. Shared kill.
  • Total - 1

Random People

"Blind Man" Cassidy

• "Blind Man" Cassidy - Shot to death by either Arthur or John, optional. Shared kill.
  • Total - 1

Nigel (Gavin's Friend)

• Nigel - Shot to death by either Arthur or John, optional. Shared kill.
  • Total - 1

Agnes Dowd

• Agnes Dowd (Ghost) - Stabbed with a tomahawk thrown by either Arthur or John. Shared kill.
  • Total - 1

Mad Preacher

• John/The Mad Preacher - Shot to death by either Arthur or John, optional. Shared kill.
  • Total - 1

Peeping Toms I

• Two Unnamed Men - Shot to death by either Arthur or John, optional. Shared kills.
• Unnamed Man - Shot to death by either Arthur or John, optional. Shared kill.
• Unnamed Woman - Shot to death by either Arthur or John, optional. Shared kill.
  • Total - 4

Peeping Toms II

• Hank - Shot to death by either Arthur or John, optional. Shared kill.
• Two Unnamed Men - Shot to death by either Arthur or John, optional. Shared kills.
• Hank's Wife - Shot to death by either Arthur or John, optional. Shared kill.
  • Total - 4

Peeping Toms III

• Two Unnamed Men - Shot to death by either Arthur or John, optional. Shared kills.
• Unnamed Woman - Shot to death by either Arthur or John, optional. Shared kill.
  • Total - 3

Soothsayer

• Unnamed Woman - Shot to death by either Arthur or John, optional. Shared kill.
  • Total - 1

Lost Dog I

• Dog - Shot to death by either Arthur or John, optional. Shared kill. (Emerald Ranch)
  • Total - 1

Lost Dog II

• Dog - Shot to death by either Arthur or John, optional. Shared kill. (Strawberry)
  • Total - 1

Hayden Russell

• Captain Hayden Russell - Shot to death by either Arthur or John, optional. Shared kill.
  • Total - 1

Poor Joe

• "Poor" Joe/King Joe - Shot to death by either Arthur or John, optional. Shared kill.
  • Total - 1

Lost Tourist

• Unnamed Man - Shot to death by either Arthur or John, optional. Shared kill.
  • Total - 1

Directionally-Challenged Drunk I

• Horse - Shot to death by either Arthur or John, optional. Shared kill.
• Unnamed Man - Either kicked in the head by a horse after spooking it or optionally shot to death by either Arthur or John. Shared kill.
  • Total - 2

Directionally-Challenged Drunk II

• Unnamed Man - Either drowned after walking off a dock into a river or optionally shot to death by either Arthur or John.
  • Total - 1

Mickey

• Mickey - Shot to death by either Arthur or John, optional. Shared kill.
  • Total - 1

Joe Butler

• Joe Butler - Shot to death by either Arthur or John, optional. Shared kill.
  • Total - 1

Drunk Camp Veteran

• Unnamed Man - Shot to death by either Arthur or John, optional. Shared kill.
  • Total - 1

Moonshiner I

• Two Horses - Shot to death by either Arthur or John, optional. Shared kills.
• Two Unnamed Men - Shot to death by either Arthur or John, optional. Shared kills. (Big Valley)
  • Total - 4

Moonshiner II

• Two Horses - Shot to death by either Arthur or John, optional. Shared kills.
• Two Unnamed Men - Shot to death by either Arthur or John, optional. Shared kills. (Southfield Flats)
  • Total - 4

Moonshiner III

• Two Horses - Shot to death by either Arthur or John, optional. Shared kills.
• Two Unnamed Men - Shot to death by either Arthur or John, optional. Shared kills. (Blue Water Marsh)
  • Total - 4

Moonshiners IV

• Unnamed Man - Shot to death by either Arthur or John. Shared kill.
• Two Horses - Shot to death by either Arthur or John, optional. Shared kills.
• Unnamed Man - Either accidentally poisoned when Arthur added Oleander Sage to his moonshine or shot to death by either Arthur or John. Shared kill.
  • Total - 4

Treasure Hunter with High Stakes Treasure Map

• Horse - Shot to death by either Arthur or John. Shared kill.
• Unnamed Man - Shot to death by either Arthur or John. Shared kill.
  • Total - 2

Conman in Hiding in Strawberry

• Unnamed Conman - Either drowned in sewage by an unnamed man or optionally shot to death by either Arthur or John. Shared kill.
• Unnamed Man - Shot to death by either Arthur or John. Shared kill.
  • Total - 2

Braithwaite Trespasses on Caliga Hall

• Two Unnamed Gray Family Guards - Shot to death by Arthur Morgan, optional.
• Unnamed Braithwaite Family Spy - Either executed by one of the Gray Family guards or optionally shot to death by Arthur Morgan.
  • Total - 3

Fistfight Challenge

• Unnamed Man - Knocked out by an unnamed man and then optionally shot to death by either Arthur or John. Shared kill.
• Unnamed Man - Shot to death by either Arthur or John. Shared kill.
  • Total - 2

Reverend Peter Fotheringham

• Reverend Peter Fotheringham - Shot to death by either Arthur or John. Shared kill.
  • Total - 1

Unlucky Man

• Unnamed Man - Either eventually hanged by the city of Saint Denis or optionally shot to death by either Arthur or John. Shared kill.
  • Total - 1

Timothy A. Donahue

• Timothy A. Donahue - Shot to death by either Arthur or John. Shared kill.
  • Total - 1

Norris Forsythe

• Norris Forsythe - Shot to death by either Arthur or John. Shared kill.
  • Total - 1

Skinny Dipper

• Unnamed Man - Shot to death by either Arthur or John. Shared kill.
  • Total - 1

Feral Man

• Three Wolves - Shot to death by either Arthur or John. Shared kills.
• Unnamed Man - Shot to death by either Arthur or John. Shared kill.
  • Total - 4

Captive in the Rhodes Gunsmith Store

• Sammy's Father - Shot to death by either Arthur or John, optional.
• Unnamed Man - Shot to death by either Arthur or John, optional.
  • Total - 2

Manito Glade Hermit

• Unnamed Man - Shot to death by either Arthur or John. Shared kill.
  • Total - 1

Domestic Violence I

• Unnamed Man - Shot to death by either Arthur or John, optional. Shared kill. (Valentine)
• Unnamed Woman - Either drowned by her husband in a water trough or optionally shot to death by either Arthur or John. Shared kill.
  • Total - 2

Domestic Violence II

• Unnamed Man - Shot to death by either Arthur or John, optional. Shared kill. (Rhodes)
• Unnamed Woman - Either drowned by her husband in a water trough or optionally shot to death by either Arthur or John. Shared kill.
  • Total - 2

Sonny the Rapist

• Sonny - Shot to death by either Arthur or John. Shared kill.
  • Total - 1

Saint Denis City Life

Back Alley Mugging I

• Three Unnamed Men - Shot to death by either Arthur or John. Shared kills.
  • Total - 3

Back Alley Mugging II

• Unnamed Man - Shot to death by either Arthur or John. Shared kill.
• Unnamed Man - Either shot to death by an unnamed mugger or optionally shot by either Arthur or John. Shared kill.
  • Total - 2

French Couple Robbed

• Unnamed Man - Shot to death by either Arthur or John. Shared kill.
• Unnamed Woman - Either shot to death by an unnamed mugger or optionally shot by either Arthur or John. Shared kill.
• Unnamed Man - Shot to death by either Arthur or John, optional.
  • Total - 3

Beggar I

• Unnamed Man - Shot to death by either Arthur or John for pretending to be blind, optional.
  • Total - 1

Beggar II

• Unnamed Man - Shot to death by either Arthur or John, optional.
  • Total - 1

Beggar III

• Unnamed Man - Shot to death by either Arthur or John, optional.
  • Total - 1

Street Urchin Ambush

• Three Unnamed Men - Shot to death by either Arthur or John. Shared kills.
  • Total - 3

Doyle's Tavern Rat Infestation

• Doyle - Shot to death by either Arthur or John, optional. Shared kill.
• Seven Rats - Shot to death by either Arthur or John. Shared kills.
  • Total - 8

Police Brutality I

• Unnamed Saint Denis Lawman - Shot to death by either Arthur or John, optional. Shared kill.
• Unnamed Man - Shot to death by either Arthur or John, optional. Shared kill.
  • Total - 2

Police Brutality II

• Unnamed Saint Denis Lawman - Shot to death by either Arthur or John, optional. Shared kill.
• Unnamed Man - Shot to death by either Arthur or John, optional. Shared kill.
  • Total - 2

Jeering Men

• Two Unnamed Men - Shot to death by either Arthur or John, optional. Shared kills.
  • Total - 2

Dorothea Wicklow

• Dorothea Wicklow - Shot to death by either Arthur or John, optional. Shared kill.
  • Total - 1

Man Splashed by Passing Wagon

• Wagon Horse - Shot to death by either Arthur or John, optional. Shared kill.
• Two Unnamed Men - Shot to death by either Arthur or John, optional. Shared kills.
• Unnamed Person - Shot to death by either Arthur or John, optional. Shared kill.
  • Total - 4

An Abrupt End to An Argument

• Two Unnamed Men - Shot to death by either Arthur or John, optional. Shared kills.
• Unnamed Woman - Shot to death by either Arthur or John, optional. Shared kill.
  • Total - 3

Man Splashed By Woman Dumping a Chamberpot

• Unnamed Man - Shot to death by either Arthur or John, optional. Shared kill.
• Unnamed Woman - Shot to death by either Arthur or John, optional. Shared kill.
  • Total - 2

Chelonian Spokesman

• Unnamed Male Chelonia Member - Shot to death by either Arthur or John, optional. Shared kill.
  • Total - 1

Man Recognizes Arthur From "A Fine Night of Debauchery"

• Unnamed Man - Shot to death by Arthur Morgan.
  • Total - 1

Vampire

• Nosferatu/The Saint Denis Vampire - Shot to death by either Arthur or John. Shared kill.
  • Total - 1

Valentine

Smithfield's Saloon Fight

• Unnamed Man - Knocked unconscious during a fight with another man and then optionally killed by either Arthur or John. Shared kill.
• Unnamed Man - Shot to death by either Arthur or John, optional. Shared kill.
  • Total - 2

Man Asks The Protagonist to Help Him Rob His Friend

• Unnamed Man - Shot to death by either Arthur or John, optional. Shared kill.
• Unnamed Female Hotel Worker - Shot to death by either Arthur or John, optional. Shared kill.
• Unnamed Man - Knocked unconscious by either Arthur or John and then optionally killed. Shared kill.
  • Total - 3

Man Confronts Arthur About Beating up Tommy

• Unnamed Man - Shot to death by Arthur Morgan, optional.
  • Total - 1

Public Hanging

• Sheriff Malloy - Shot to death by either Arthur or John, optional. Shared kill.
• Unnamed Man - Either hanged by an unknown person on the orders of Sheriff Malloy or optionally shot to death by either Arthur or John. Shared kill.
• Unnamed Man's Wife - Shot to death by either Arthur or John, optional. Shared kill.
  • Total - 3

Accusatory Widow

• Unnamed Woman's Husband - Murdered by either Arthur or John off-screen, mentioned. Shared kill.
• Unnamed Woman - Shot to death by either Arthur or John, optional. Shared kill.
  • Total - 2

Guarma

Pitfall Trap

• Four Unnamed Cuban Soldiers - Shot to death by Arthur Morgan.
  • Total - 4

Soldiers Pursuing Two Escapees

• Three Unnamed Cuban Soldiers - Shot to death by Arthur Morgan.
• Two Unnamed Guarma Prisoners - Either shot to death by the Cuban soldiers or optionally shot by Arthur Morgan.
  • Total - 5

Appleseed Timber Company

Encounter I

• Unnamed Man - Shot to death by either Arthur or John, optional. Shared kill.
  • Total - 1

Encounter II

• Five Unnamed Men - Shot to death by either Arthur or John, optional. Shared Kills.
  • Total - 5

Encounter III

• Three Wolves - Shot to death by either Arthur or John. Shared kills.
• Four Unnamed Men - Shot to death by either Arthur or John, optional. Shared kills.
  • Total - 7

Castor's Ridge

Encounter I

• None

Encounter II

• Four Unnamed Extortionists - Shot to death by Arthur Morgan.
  • Total - 4

Encounter III

• None

Encounter IV

• Curtis - Shot to death by Arthur Morgan, optional.
• Curtis' Father - Shot to death by Arthur Morgan, optional.
• Curtis' Brother - Shot to death by Arthur Morgan, optional.
• Unnamed Man - Shot to death by Arthur Morgan, optional.
• Unnamed Woman - Shot to death by Arthur Morgan, optional.
  • Total - 5

Central Union Railroad Camp

Encounter I

• Randal - Shot to death by Arthur Morgan, optional.
  • Total - 1

Encounter II

• Unnamed Cornwall Guard - Shot to death by Arthur Morgan.
• Two Unnamed Cornwall Guards - Shot to death by Arthur Morgan, optional.
  • Total - 3

Encounter III

• None

Challenges

Banditry

Rank 1

• Five Unknown People - Shot to death by either Arthur or John after robbing them. Shared kills.
  • Total - 5

Rank 2

• None (Victims are entirely random)

Rank 3

• Four Unknown Shop Owners - Shot to death by either Arthur or John after robbing them. Shared kills.
  • Total - 4

Rank 4

• None (Victims are entirely random)

Rank 5

• None (Murders are not required to receive a bounty and victims are random)

Rank 6

• Five Unknown People - Shot to death by either Arthur or John to steal their horses. Shared kills.
  • Total - 5

Rank 7

• None (The amount of money each person has is too random to count)

Rank 8

• None (Victims are entirely random)

Rank 9

• Three Unknown People - Hogtied and left on the tracks by either Arthur or John to eventually be run over by a train. Shared kills.
  • Total - 3

Rank 10

• None (Victims are entirely random)

Explorer

Rank 1

• None (No Kills Required)

Rank 2

• None (No Kills Required)

Rank 3

• None (No Kills Required)

Rank 4

• None (No Kills Required)

Rank 5

• None (No Kills Required)

Rank 6

• None (No Kills Required)

Rank 7

• None (No Kills Required)

Rank 8

• None (No Kills Required)

Rank 9

• None (No Kills Required)

Rank 10

• None (No Kills Required)

Gambler

Rank 1

• None (Victims are Entirely Random)

Rank 2

• None (Victims are Entirely Random)

Rank 3

• None (Victims are Entirely Random)

Rank 4

• None (Victims are Entirely Random)

Rank 5

• None (Victims are Entirely Random)

Rank 6

• None (Victims are Entirely Random)

Rank 7

• None (Victims are Entirely Random)

Rank 8

• None (Victims are Entirely Random)

Rank 9

• None (Victims are Entirely Random)

Rank 10

• None (Victims are Entirely Random)

Herbalist

Rank 1

• None (No Kills Required)

Rank 2

• None (No Kills Required)

Rank 3

• None (No Kills Required)

Rank 4

• None (No Kills Required)

Rank 5

• None (No Kills Required)

Rank 6

• None (No Kills Required)

Rank 7

• None (No Kills Required)

Rank 8

• None (No Kills Required)

Rank 9

• None (No Kills Required)

Rank 10

• None (No Kills Required)

Horseman

Rank 1

• Five Rabbits - Shot to death by either Arthur or John. Shared kills.
  • Total - 5

Rank 2

• None (No Kills Required)

Rank 3

• None (No Kills Required)

Rank 4

• Unknown Person - Dragged to death by either Arthur or John while riding their horse. Shared kill.
  • Total - 1

Rank 5

• Five Unknown Animals - Ran over by either Arthur or John while riding their horse. Shared kills.
  • Total - 5

Rank 6

• None (No Kills Required)

Rank 7

• Seven Unknown People - Shot to death by either Arthur or John while riding their horse. Shared kills.
  • Total - 7

Rank 8

• Nine Unknown Animals - Shot to death by either Arthur or John while riding their horse. Shared kills.
  • Total - 9

Rank 9

• None (No Kills Required)

Rank 10

• Nine Horses - Shot to death by either Arthur or John after taming them, optional. Shared kills.
  • Total - 9

Master Hunter

Rank 1

• Three Deer - Shot to death by either Arthur or John for their skins. Shared kills.
  • Total - 3

Rank 2

• Three Rabbits - Shot to death by either Arthur or John for their skins. Shared kills.
  • Total - 3

Rank 3

• None (No Kills Required)

Rank 4

• Five Unknown Animals - Shot to death by either Arthur or John. Shared kills.
  • Total - 5

Rank 5

• Three Bears - Shot to death by either Arthur or John for their skins. Shared kills.
  • Total - 3

Rank 6

• Five Cougars - Shot to death by either Arthur or John with a bow and arrows. Shared kills.
  • Total - 5

Rank 7

• Two Unknown Animals - Shot to death by either Arthur or John. Shared kills.
  • Total - 2

Rank 8

• Three Fish - Captured by either Arthur or John. Shared kills.
  • Total - 3

Rank 9

• Opossum - Shot to death by either Arthur or John while it was playing dead. Shared kill.
  • Total - 1

Rank 10

• Giaguaro (Panther) - Shot to death by either Arthur or John. Shared kill.
  • Total - 1

Sharpshooter

Rank 1

• Three Birds - Shot to death by either Arthur or John while they were flying. Shared kills.
  • Total - 3

Rank 2

• Two Unknown Animals - Shot to death by either Arthur or John. Shared kills.
  • Total - 2

Rank 3

• Five Birds - Shot to death by either Arthur or John while they were flying. Shared kills.
  • Total - 5

Rank 4

• Unknown Person - Stabbed with an axe thrown by either Arthur or John. Shared kill.
  • Total - 1

Rank 5

• Six Unknown Animals - Shot to death by either Arthur or John. Shared kills.
  • Total - 6

Rank 6

• Unknown Person - Shot to death by either Arthur or John with a sniper rifle. Shared kill.
  • Total - 1

Rank 7

• Seven Unknown People - Shot in the head by either Arthur or John. Shared kills.
  • Total - 7

Rank 8

• Three Unknown People - Shot to death by either Artur or John after disarming them.
  • Total - 3

Rank 9

• Three Unknown People - Shot to death by either Arthur or John after shooting their hats off their heads.
  • Total - 3

Rank 10

• Three Birds - Shot to death by either Arthur or John with a sniper rifle. Shared kills.
  • Total - 3

Survivalist

Rank 1

• Three Bluegill Fish - Captured by either Arthur or John. Shared kills.
  • Total - 3

Rank 2

• Five Unknown Animals - Shot to death by either Arthur or John. Shared kills.
  • Total - 5

Rank 3

• Five Unknown Animals - Shot to death by either Arthur or John with a varmint rifle. Shared kills.
  • Total - 5

Rank 4

• None (No kills required)

Rank 5

• Fish - Captured by either Arthur or John. Shared kills.
  • Total - 1

Rank 6

• Five Unknown Animals - Shot to death by either Arthur or John. Shared kills.
  • Total - 5

Rank 7

• Eight Unknown Animals - Shot to death by either Arthur or John with a bow and arrows. Shared kills.
  • Total - 8

Rank 8

• None (No kills required)

Rank 9

• Fish - Captured by either Arthur or John. Shared kills.
  • Total - 1

Rank 10

• 15 Fish - Captured by either Arthur or John. Shared kills.
  • Total - 15

Weapons Expert

Rank 1

• Three Unknown People - Stabbed to death by either Arthur or John with a knife. Shared kills.
  • Total - 3

Rank 2

• Three Unknown People - Stabbed with knives thrown by either Arthur or John. Shared kills.
  • Total - 3

Rank 3

• Three Birds - Stabbed with a tomahawk thrown by either Arthur or John. Shared kills.
  • Total - 3

Rank 4

• Ten Unknown People - Shot to death by either Arthur or John with a shotgun. Shared kills.
  • Total - 10

Rank 5

• Five Unknown People - Stabbed with knives thrown by either Arthur or John. Shared kills.
  • Total - 5

Rank 6

• Four Unknown People - Blown up with dynamite thrown by either Arthur or John. Shared kills.
  • Total - 4

Rank 7

• Four Unknown People - Stabbed with a tomahawk thrown by either Arthur or John. Shared kills.
  • Total - 4

Rank 8

• 15 Unknown People - Shot to death by either Arthur or John with a long-barreled sidearm. Shared kills.
  • Total - 15

Rank 9

• Nine Unknown People - Shot to death by either Arthur or John with a bow and arrows. Shared kills.
  • Total - 9

Rank 10

• Bear - Stabbed with knives thrown by either Arthur or John. Shared kills.
  • Total - 1

Points of Interest

Lemoyne

Abandoned Church

• Five Unnamed Lemoyne Raiders Gang Members - Shot to death by either Arthur or John. Shared kills.
  • Total - 5

Ambarino

Meditating Monk

Other

• Unnamed Man - Shot to death by either Arthur or John. Shared kill.
  • Total - 1

Hermit Woman

• Four Dogs - Shot to death by either Arthur or John. Shared kills.
• Unnamed Witch - Shot to death by either Arthur or John. Shared kill.
  • Total - 5

Hidden Tunnel

• Unnamed Man - Shot to death by either Arthur or John. Shared kill.
  • Total - 1

Homesteads

Aberdeen Pig Farm

• Bray Aberdeen - Shot to death by either Arthur or John. Shared kill.
• Tammy Aberdeen - Shot to death by either Arthur or John. Shared kill.
  • Total - 2

Van Horn Mansion

• Two Unnamed Train Robbers - Shot to death by either Arthur or John. Shared kills.
  • Total - 2

Watson's Cabin

• "Mama" Watson - Either shot to death by either Arthur or John or eventually died of old age off-screen. Shared kill.
• Elijah Watson - Shot to death by either Arthur or John. Shared kill.
• Ethan Watson - Shot to death by either Arthur or John. Shared kill.
• Edgar Watson - Shot to death by either Arthur or John. Shared kill.
• Ezra Watson - Shot to death by either Arthur or John. Shared kill.
  • Total - 5

Camp Item Requests

Charles

• Eagle - Shot to death by John Marston on the request of Charles Smith. Shared kill.
  • Total - 1

Pearson

• Rabbit - Shot to death by Arthur Morgan on the request of Simon Pearson. Shared kill.
  • Total - 1

Store Robberies

Saint Denis

• Chu Ling - Shot to death by either Arthur Morgan or John Marston, optional. Shared kill.
• Jim - Shot to death by either Arthur Morgan or John Marston, optional. Shared kill.
• Unnamed Poker Game Guard - Shot to death by either Arthur Morgan or John Marston, optional. Shared kill.
• Three Unnamed Men - Shot to death by either Arthur Morgan or John Marston, optional. Shared kills.
  • Total - 6

Valentine

• Dr. Ben Calloway - Shot to death by either Arthur Morgan or John Marston, optional. Shared kill.
• Three Unnamed O'Driscoll Gang Members - Shot to death by either Arthur Morgan or John Marston. Shared kills.
• Unnamed Woman - Shot to death by either Arthur Morgan or John Marston. Shared kill.
  • Total - 5

Gang Hideouts

Hanging Dog Ranch

• 17 Unnamed O'Driscolls Gang Members - Shot to death by Arthur Morgan. (Before Epilogue)
  • Total - 17

Six Point Cabin

• 12 Unnamed O'Driscolls Gang Members - Shot to death by Arthur Morgan. (Before Epilogue, After "Paying a Social Call")
  • Total - 12

Achievements

Grin and Bear It

• 18 Bears - Killed by either Arthur or John. Shared kills.
  • Total - 18

It was THIS BIG!

• Fish - Captured by either Arthur or John. Shared kill.
  • Total - 1

Skin Deep

• American Alligator - Killed by either Arthur or John for it's skin. Shared kill.
• American Alligator (Small) - Killed by either Arthur or John for it's skin. Shared kill.
• Nine-Banded Armadillo - Killed by either Arthur or John for it's skin. Shared kill.
• American Badger - Killed by either Arthur or John for it's skin. Shared kill.
• American Black Bear - Killed by either Arthur or John for it's skin. Shared kill.
• Grizzly Bear - Killed by either Arthur or John for it's skin. Shared kill.
• North American Beaver - Killed by either Arthur or John for it's skin. Shared kill.
• Wild Boar - Killed by either Arthur or John for it's skin. Shared kill.
• Whitetail Buck - Killed by either Arthur or John for it's skin. Shared kill.
• Whitetail Deer - Killed by either Arthur or John for it's skin. Shared kill.
• American Bison - Killed by either Arthur or John for it's skin. Shared kill.
• Greater Prairie Chicken - Killed by either Arthur or John for it's skin. Shared kill.
• Cougar - Killed by either Arthur or John for it's skin. Shared kill.
• California Valley Coyote - Killed by either Arthur or John for it's skin. Shared kill.
• Mallard Duck - Killed by either Arthur or John for it's skin. Shared kill.
• Pekin Duck - Killed by either Arthur or John for it's skin. Shared kill.
• Reddish Egret - Killed by either Arthur or John for it's skin. Shared kill.
• Little Egret - Killed by either Arthur or John for it's skin. Shared kill.
• Snowy Egret - Killed by either Arthur or John for it's skin. Shared kill.
• Rocky Mountain Bull Elk - Killed by either Arthur or John for it's skin. Shared kill.
• Rocky Mountain Cow Elk - Killed by either Arthur or John for it's skin. Shared kill.
• American Red Fox - Killed by either Arthur or John for it's skin. Shared kill.
• American Gray Fox - Killed by either Arthur or John for it's skin. Shared kill.
• Silver Fox - Killed by either Arthur or John for it's skin. Shared kill.
• Banded Gila Monster - Killed by either Arthur or John for it's skin. Shared kill.
• Canada Goose - Killed by either Arthur or John for it's skin. Shared kill.
• Great Blue Heron - Killed by either Arthur or John for it's skin. Shared kill.
• Tricolored Heron - Killed by either Arthur or John for it's skin. Shared kill.
• Desert Iguana - Killed by either Arthur or John for it's skin. Shared kill.
• Green Iguana - Killed by either Arthur or John for it's skin. Shared kill.
• Collared Peccary - Killed by either Arthur or John for it's skin. Shared kill.
• Common Loon - Killed by either Arthur or John for it's skin. Shared kill.
• Pacific Loon - Killed by either Arthur or John for it's skin. Shared kill.
• Yellow-billed Loon - Killed by either Arthur or John for it's skin. Shared kill.
• Western Bull Moose - Killed by either Arthur or John for it's skin. Shared kill.
• Western Moose - Killed by either Arthur or John for it's skin. Shared kill.
• American Muskrat - Killed by either Arthur or John for it's skin. Shared kill.
• Panther - Killed by either Arthur or John for it's skin. Shared kill.
• Florida Panther - Killed by either Arthur or John for it's skin. Shared kill.
• Ring-necked Pheasant - Killed by either Arthur or John for it's skin. Shared kill.
• Chinese ring-necked Pheasant - Killed by either Arthur or John for it's skin. Shared kill.
• Virginia Possum - Killed by either Arthur or John for it's skin. Shared kill.
• American Pronghorn Buck - Killed by either Arthur or John for it's skin. Shared kill.
• American Pronghorn Doe - Killed by either Arthur or John for it's skin. Shared kill.
• Sonoran Pronghorn Buck - Killed by either Arthur or John for it's skin. Shared kill.
• Sonoran Pronghorn Doe - Killed by either Arthur or John for it's skin. Shared kill.
• Baja California Pronghorn Buck - Killed by either Arthur or John for it's skin. Shared kill.
• Baja California Pronghorn Doe - Killed by either Arthur or John for it's skin. Shared kill.
• Sierra Nevada Bighorn Ram - Killed by either Arthur or John for it's skin. Shared kill.
• Sierra Nevada Bighorn Sheep - Killed by either Arthur or John for it's skin. Shared kill.
• Desert Bighorn Ram - Killed by either Arthur or John for it's skin. Shared kill.
• Desert Bighorn Sheep - Killed by either Arthur or John for it's skin. Shared kill.
• Rocky Mountain Bighorn Ram - Killed by either Arthur or John for it's skin. Shared kill.
• Rocky Mountain Bighorn Sheep - Killed by either Arthur or John for it's skin. Shared kill.
• Black-tailed Jackrabbit - Killed by either Arthur or John for it's skin. Shared kill.
• North American Raccoon - Killed by either Arthur or John for it's skin. Shared kill.
• Roseate Spoonbill - Killed by either Arthur or John for it's skin. Shared kill.
• Striped Skunk - Killed by either Arthur or John for it's skin. Shared kill.
• Diamondback Rattlesnake - Killed by either Arthur or John for it's skin. Shared kill.
• Black-tailed Rattlesnake - Killed by either Arthur or John for it's skin. Shared kill.
• Timber Rattlesnake - Killed by either Arthur or John for it's skin. Shared kill.
• Northern Copperhead Snake - Killed by either Arthur or John for it's skin. Shared kill.
• Southern Copperhead Snake - Killed by either Arthur or John for it's skin. Shared kill.
• Midland Water Snake - Killed by either Arthur or John for it's skin. Shared kill.
• Cottonmouth Snake - Killed by either Arthur or John for it's skin. Shared kill.
• Northern Water Snake - Killed by either Arthur or John for it's skin. Shared kill.
• Eastern Wild Turkey - Killed by either Arthur or John for it's skin. Shared kill.
• Rio Grande Wild Turkey - Killed by either Arthur or John for it's skin. Shared kill.
• Alligator Snapping Turtle - Killed by either Arthur or John for it's skin. Shared kill.
• Gray Wolf - Killed by either Arthur or John for it's skin. Shared kill.
• Timber Wolf - Killed by either Arthur or John for it's skin. Shared kill.
  • Total - 70

Easter Eggs

• Anders Helgerson - Shot to death by either Arthur or John, optional. Shared kill.
• Harville Presley - Shot to death by either Arthur or John, optional. Shared kill.
• "Big" Jon - Shot to death by either Arthur or John, optional. Shared kill.
• Lillian Powell - Shot to death by either Arthur or John, optional. Shared kill.
• Malcolm MacIntosh - Shot to death by either Arthur or John, optional. Shared kill.
• Mayor Nicholas Timmons - Shot to death by either Arthur or John, optional. Shared kill.
• Unnamed Armadillo Town Crier - Shot to death by either Arthur or John, optional. Shared kill.
  • Total - 7

Kill Count

• Total - 4,167
  • Main Story - 2,802 (504 Optional)
    • Chapter 1 - 87 (14 Optional)
    • Chapter 2 - 248 (115 Optional)
    • Chapter 3 - 351 (83 Optional)
    • Chapter 4 - 308 (71 Optional)
    • Chapter 5 - 996 (9 Optional)
    • Chapter 6 - 812 (212 Optional)
  • Side Missions - 227
  • Companion Activities - 76
  • Bounty Hunts - 47
  • Random Encounters - 637
  • Challenges - 218
  • Points of Interest - 13
  • Homesteads - 9
  • Camp Item Requests - 2
  • Store Robberies - 11
  • Gang Hideouts - 29
  • Achievements - 89
  • Easter Eggs - 7

Group Kills

Animals

• Total - 1,061
  • 650 Horses
  • 52 Animals of Unknown Species
  • 32 Unknown Fish
  • 32 Wolves
  • 30 Spoonbills
  • 28 Bears
  • 20 Herons
  • 18 Dogs
  • 15 Egrets
  • 14 Unknown Birds
  • 14 Deer
  • 11 Cows
  • 11 Rabbits
  • 8 Sheep
  • 8 Rats
  • 8 Cougars
  • 8 Snakes
  • 7 Bison
  • 6 Bighorns
  • 5 Crawfish
  • 5 Bluegills
  • 5 Alligators
  • 5 Chickens
  • 4 Pigs
  • 3 Crows
  • 3 Vultures
  • 3 Coyotes
  • 3 Egrets
  • 3 Foxes
  • 3 Loons
  • 3 Panthers
  • 2 Boars
  • 2 Ducks
  • 2 Elk
  • 2 Herons
  • 2 Iguanas
  • 2 Moose
  • 2 Pheasants
  • 2 Opossums
  • 2 Turkeys
  • 1 Bullhead Catfish
  • 1 Chain Pickerel
  • 1 Lake Sturgeon
  • 1 Longnose Gar
  • 1 Muskie
  • 1 Perch
  • 1 Smallmouth Bass
  • 1 Sockeye Salmon
  • 1 Steelhead Trout
  • 1 Largemouth Bass
  • 1 Redfin Pickerel
  • 1 Rock Bass
  • 1 Lion
  • 1 Northern Pike
  • 1 Eagle
  • 1 Armadillo
  • 1 Badger
  • 1 Beaver
  • 1 Gila Monster
  • 1 Goose
  • 1 Muskrat
  • 1 Jackrabbit
  • 1 Raccoon
  • 1 Spoonbill
  • 1 Skunk
  • 1 Turtle

Humans

• Total - 3,125
  • 2,991 Men
  • 94 Victims of Unknown Gender
  • 40 Women

Monsters

• Total - 4
  • 1 Witch
    • All Women
  • 1 Vampire
    • All Men
  • 1 Robot
    • All Men
  • 1 Ghost
    • All Women

Characters Killed by Arthur Morgan

1. Billy (O'Driscoll) - Shot to death by Arthur, Dutch, and Micah. Shared kill.
2. Declan (O'Driscoll) - Shot to death by Arthur, Dutch, and Micah. Shared kill.
3. Jimmy Brooks - Either fell to his death from a cliff after eventually slipping or after his hand was stomped on by Arthur Morgan, optional.
4. Sheriff Hanley - Shot to death by either Arthur or Micah. Shared kill.
5. Cooper - Killed by Arthur Morgan, optional.
6. Lilly Millet - Killed by Arthur Morgan, optional.
7. Chick Matthews - Killed by Arthur Morgan, optional.
8. Bob Crawford Sr. - Killed by Arthur Morgan, optional. (Only during the night robbery)
9. Bob Crawford Jr. - Killed by Arthur Morgan, optional. (Only during the night robbery)
10. Hamish - Killed by either Arthur or Sean. Shared kill.
11. Jeb - Shot to death by either Arthur or Charles. Shared kill.
12. Chester Damsen - Shot to death by Arthur Morgan, optional.
13. Cooperforth - Shot to death by either Arthur Morgan or Uncle. Shared kill.
14. Sheriff Leigh Gray - Shot in the head by Arthur Morgan to save Bill.
15. Deputy Archibald MacGregor - Shot to death by either Arthur or Micah. Shared kill.
16. Jock Gray - Shot to death by either Arthur or Micah. Shared kill.
17. Gerald Braithwaite - Shot to death by Arthur Morgan.
18. Gareth Braithwaite - Shot to death by Arthur Morgan.
19. Algie Davison - Shot to death by Arthur Morgan, optional.
20. Nate Davison - Shot to death by Arthur Morgan, optional.
21. Ashton - Either beaten, strangled, or shot to death by Arthur Morgan, optional.
22. Anthony Foreman - Stabbed in the stomach by Arthur Morgan, optional.
23. Danbury - Shot to death by Arthur Morgan, optional.
24. Angel - Either stabbed or shot to death by Arthur Morgan after choking him unconscious, optional.
25. Colonel Alberto Fussar - Blown up with a cannon fired by Arthur Morgan.
26. Agent Bunter - Shot to death by Arthur Morgan, optional.
27. Agent Johns - Shot to death by Arthur Morgan, optional.
28. Agent Orly - Shot to death by Arthur Morgan, optional.
29. Milliken - Shot to death by Arthur Morgan, optional.
30. Iain Gray - Shot to death by Arthur Morgan after knocking him out in a fight, optional.
31. Scott Gray - Shot to death by Arthur Morgan after knocking him out in a fight, optional.
32. Pennington - Either shot to death by Arthur Morgan or drowned in the river.
33. Jackson - Shot to death by Arthur Morgan, optional. (Later appears in the mission The King's Son if he's spared, but he won't be counted twice)
34. Paul (O'Driscoll) - Stabbed to death by Arthur Morgan, optional.
35. Martin - Shot to death by either Arthur, Dutch, Eagle Flies, Paytah, or three unnamed Wapiti Native Americans. Shared kill.
36. Colonel Henry Favours - Shot to death by Arthur Morgan.
37. "969" - Shot to death by either Arthur or John, optional. Shared kill.
38. Máximo Cristóbal Valdespino - Shot to death by either Arthur or John, optional.
39. Edmund Lowry Jr. - Shot to death by either Arthur or John to save Sheriff Malloy or by Sheriff Malloy himself. Shared kill.
40. Jean-Marc Mercier - Shot to death by Arthur Morgan on the orders of Henri Lemieux, optional.
41. Jeremiah Compson - Shot to death by either Arthur or John, optional.
42. Gonzalo (Del Lobo) - Shot to death by either Arthur or John. Shared kill.
43. Anselmo (Del Lobo) - Shot to death by either Arthur or John. Shared kill.
44. Eliso (Del Lobo) - Shot to death by either Arthur or John. Shared kill.
45. Flaco Hernández - Shot to death by either Arthur or John. Shared kill.
46. Emmet Granger - Shot to death by either Arthur or John. Shared kill.
47. Billy Midnight - Either shot to death by either Arthur or John or committed suicide by shooting himself in the head. Shared kill.
48. Jim "Boy" Calloway - Shot to death by either Arthur or John. Shared kill.
49. Tyrant (Legendary Northern Pike) - Captured by either Arthur or John with the help of Hamish Sinclair. Shared kill.
50. Buell (Horse) - Shot to death by either Arthur or John, optional. Shared kill.
51. "Shaman" - Shot to death by either Arthur or John, optional.
52. William - Shot to death by either Arthur or John, optional.
53. Charlotte Balfour - Shot to death by either Arthur or John, optional. Shared kill.
54. Pappy Porter - Shot to death by either Arthur Morgan or Javier Escuella. Shared kill.
55. Newt Porter - Shot to death by either Arthur Morgan or Javier Escuella. Shared kill.
56. Finney Porter - Shot to death by either Arthur Morgan or Javier Escuella. Shared kill.
57. Mal Porter - Shot to death by either Arthur Morgan or Javier Escuella. Shared kill.
58. Edie Porter - Shot to death by either Arthur Morgan or Javier Escuella. Shared kill.
59. Laurence - Shot to death by either Arthur or Sean. Shared kill.
60. Harry - Shot to death by either Arthur or Sean. Shared kill.
61. Squears - Shot to death by Arthur Morgan, optional.
62. Camille de Millemont - Either shot to death by either Arthur or John or eventually hanged by the town of Rhodes. Shared kill.
63. Lindsey Wofford - Shot to death by either Arthur or John, optional.
64. Giaguaro (Panther) - Shot to death by either Arthur or John. Shared kill.
65. Bray Aberdeen - Shot to death by either Arthur or John. Shared kill.
66. Tammy Aberdeen - Shot to death by either Arthur or John. Shared kill.
67. "Mama" Watson - Either shot to death by either Arthur or John or eventually died of old age off-screen. Shared kill.
68. Elijah Watson - Shot to death by either Arthur or John. Shared kill.
69. Ethan Watson - Shot to death by either Arthur or John. Shared kill.
70. Edgar Watson - Shot to death by either Arthur or John. Shared kill.
71. Ezra Watson - Shot to death by either Arthur or John. Shared kill.
72. Chu Ling - Shot to death by either Arthur Morgan or John Marston, optional. Shared kill.
73. Jim - Shot to death by either Arthur Morgan or John Marston, optional. Shared kill.
74. Dr. Ben Calloway - Shot to death by either Arthur Morgan or John Marston, optional. Shared kill.
75. Anders Helgerson - Shot to death by either Arthur or John, optional. Shared kill.
76. Bob Brownlee - Shot to death by John Marston, optional.
77. Harville Presley - Shot to death by either Arthur or John, optional. Shared kill.
78. "Big" Jon - Shot to death by either Arthur or John, optional. Shared kill.
79. Lillian Powell - Shot to death by either Arthur or John, optional. Shared kill.
80. Malcolm MacIntosh - Shot to death by either Arthur or John, optional. Shared kill.
81. Mayor Nicholas Timmons - Shot to death by either Arthur or John, optional. Shared kill.

Death

• Either succumbed to his tuberculosis or killed by Micah Bell. (Chapter Six: Beaver Hollow - Red Dead Redemption)

Note

• Even if the player were to try to make Arthur Morgan as morally good as possible such as only attacking enemies that attack him first in self defense or helping people as much as possible, there are a few acts which prevent him from being considered pure good, the most notable one being assaulting the deathly sick Thomas Downes with unnecessary violence.